January 6, 2011 10:52 AM
- Text
Edited "Huckleberry Finn" Stirring Heated Debate
ATLANTA - Mark Twain defined a classic as "a book which people praise and don't read." These days a lot of schools are not reading one of his classics, "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn," because it contains offensive language.
CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann reports a new sanitized version is coming out. It may not solve the problem.
Twain's classic book still navigates America's river of race relations. The book uses racial slurs, words customary for Twain's time. Today those words are radioactive.
On one page of "Huck Finn," Twain wrote the n-word six times. Should each use be edited out and replaced with the word "slave"?
Version of "Huckleberry Finn" to Remove "N" Word
Allan Gribben says yes. Gribben is a Twain scholar at Auburn University at Montgomery and will publish a new edition of Twain's classic without the n-word.
"Seems to me I'm doing something constructive by simply eliminating a word that's a clear barrier for many people," says Gribben.
In the entire book, Twain uses the n-word 219 times, deliberately, to spotlight 19th century racism.
"That word meant something. That word means something," says Morehouse College's David Wall Rice. He says Twain's slurs actually help Americans face the issue of racism.
"We have to have the discussion about it," says Rice. "We can't skate over it."
As a book, "Hucklberry Finn" was controversial right from its first printing in 1885. it was too coarse, critics said. But its racial stereotypes and language are what eat at some critics today with repeated recent attempts to ban the book.
On Twitter Wednesday, reaction to editing Twain's text was overwhelmingly negative. Take out the n-word, one person wrote, and "...you have to take the holocaust out of Anne Frank, and the adultery out of 'The Scarlet Letter.'"
Rice says the n-word makes people uncomfortable which helps teach.
"If you're going to move forward there's going to be some agitation, right?" says Rice. "You want to make sure that going to disturb the equilibrium, at least a little bit, or there's not going to be any growth."
Mark Twain started this debate. He'd probably like the last word.
As Huck says in a film version of the novel, "I don't give a damn what the whole world says."
Copyright 2011 CBS. All rights reserved. CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann reports a new sanitized version is coming out. It may not solve the problem.
Twain's classic book still navigates America's river of race relations. The book uses racial slurs, words customary for Twain's time. Today those words are radioactive.
On one page of "Huck Finn," Twain wrote the n-word six times. Should each use be edited out and replaced with the word "slave"?
Version of "Huckleberry Finn" to Remove "N" Word
Allan Gribben says yes. Gribben is a Twain scholar at Auburn University at Montgomery and will publish a new edition of Twain's classic without the n-word.
"Seems to me I'm doing something constructive by simply eliminating a word that's a clear barrier for many people," says Gribben.
In the entire book, Twain uses the n-word 219 times, deliberately, to spotlight 19th century racism.
"That word meant something. That word means something," says Morehouse College's David Wall Rice. He says Twain's slurs actually help Americans face the issue of racism.
"We have to have the discussion about it," says Rice. "We can't skate over it."
As a book, "Hucklberry Finn" was controversial right from its first printing in 1885. it was too coarse, critics said. But its racial stereotypes and language are what eat at some critics today with repeated recent attempts to ban the book.
On Twitter Wednesday, reaction to editing Twain's text was overwhelmingly negative. Take out the n-word, one person wrote, and "...you have to take the holocaust out of Anne Frank, and the adultery out of 'The Scarlet Letter.'"
Rice says the n-word makes people uncomfortable which helps teach.
"If you're going to move forward there's going to be some agitation, right?" says Rice. "You want to make sure that going to disturb the equilibrium, at least a little bit, or there's not going to be any growth."
Mark Twain started this debate. He'd probably like the last word.
As Huck says in a film version of the novel, "I don't give a damn what the whole world says."
134 Comments +
Popular Now in CBS Evening News
- U.S. Catholic nuns go about work after rebuke
- Romney gives Obama an "F" across the board
- 5/30: Stock market plummets, handling Syrian crisis
- "Super-agers": What it takes to live beyond 100
- 5/31: John Edwards mistrial, NYC soda ban
- Edwards verdict: Why the gov't case fell apart
- 5/29: World responds to Syria massacre, Romney to clinch GOP nomination
- Michael Bloomberg defends soft drink restrictions
- In Syrian town of Houla, a "vigil of despair"
- Presidents add humor to presidential portrait unveiling
- U.K. royal family's home movies, 1957
- Vatican scandal could further grow
- Vatican reprimands "radical" U.S. nuns
- Catholic nuns in America focus on God's work
- 6-year-old tries out for National Spelling Bee
- Romney: I give Obama an "F" on foreign policy
