Behind Giuliani Daughter Alleged Shoplifting

(CBS)  Rudy Giuliani and his family were in the public eye for years, first during his high-profile career as New York City mayor and then a presidential candidate.

Now they're back in the spotlight, after Wednesday's arrest of his daughter on shoplifting charges.

The Real Reasons Some Young People Shoplift
Pictures: Winona Ryder
Pictures: Celebrity Shoplifters

Security cameras caught Caroline Giuliani, a Harvard theater major, allegedly stealing five products worth more than $100 from a Sephora makeup store on New York's Upper East Side.

After being led away in handcuffs, Giuliani spent five hours in New York's 19th precinct lock-up. She was later released to her mother, Donna Hanover and a family attorney.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg told reporters, "When you're kids get in trouble, you do what's natural you try to protect them, and I think this is a private matter the Giuliani's have to work through."

Rudy Giuliani's office issued a brief statement, saying, "This is a personal matter and Mayor Giuliani asks the media to respect the privacy of his daughter at this time."

It's widely believed the 20-year-old is estranged from her famous father since her parents divorced in 2002.

Caroline Giuliani faces petty larceny charges and is due in court August 31st, but the charges will likely be dropped because the store is refusing to press charges.

But how do young well-to-do people find themselves in this situation at all?

Child and Adolescent Psychologist Dr. Jennifer Hartstein, an "Early Show" contributor, said shoplifting happens for a lot of reasons. However, according to the National Association for Shoplifting Prevention, about a third of people who shoplift have depression.

She added entitlement may also be a factor.

"There's this sense of, 'Well, I just deserve, it I'm going to take it, I'm going to do that and keep moving forward."

As for the two-thirds who don't have depression, Hartstein said some people may be using shoplifting as a substitute for a loss.

"Something happens and then they feel like they need to replace it, so they go and take things," Hartstein said.

She added justified payback is another factor, which could be at play in Giuliani's case.

Hartstein said, "Justified payback is something we could be talking about with Caroline Giuliani, which is getting back at a parent, getting back at someone who does something to hurt you and getting back at them by trying to embarrass them."

Shoplifting for others may be a relief mechanism.

"It's to relieve some anxiety or negative sense of self, some negative feelings, similarly to someone who might drink, someone who might self-injure," Hartstein said. "It helps decrease a real sense of emotional disregulation and makes them feel better."

She continued, "It gives them a rush, it might give them the boost they need to make themselves feel more regulated and feel better."

So how can you help your child avoid a situation like this? Click on the video below for Hartstein's tips for parents.

[thebob-bob]

Old 'tough on crime' Giuliani should read his old statements about how 'tough love' is the only way. Book her!!!!!!!!!!

[cktirumalai]

A famous father and a divorced one does not automatically lead a daughter to shoplifting but, as your commentator explains, they are not unrelated.
I would not be surprised if Caroline Giuliani's lawyer used a "psychological" defence. Not everyone will be convinced or moved, however.
Candadai Tirumalai

[ladyang]

My daddy isn't paying me any attention!

[SuperWittySmitty]

"When you're kids get in trouble" ?? Who ever wrote this sentence should get an editor. You're setting a bad example when you cannot use the English language properly.

And please, Giuliani fixed this city? I think the people of New York had a lot more to do with it than he did. Any real new Yorker knows this. It's the suburbanites who are confused.

[manhattanmale]

Amazing to see the nit-wit anti Giuliani people out there. Bottom line, he cleaned up the cesspool city scum in the 1990's and did an outstanding job of leading the city during 9/11.

The only negative thing I will say about the mayor is that he didn't do enough smiling and pandering towards the "minorities" in our City, which explains why a majority of them hate him with such vengeance.

Get past the hate and stop attacking his family because you might disagree with his "hard-nosed" politics.

Compared to Dinkins or Abe Beame, he was like a night in shining armor!

[NexusAndroid]

I wonder how many people Sephora HAS pressed charges against. Must be nice to be the daughter of somebody famous.

[Justiceserved]

Stealing does/may have something to do with upbringing and it is not physiological help, it is psychological help! The prior post must be a Palin supporter. Coming from a screwed up background where you father is unfaithful & then marries person he has the affair with more than once, one whose father is estranged from his own son, and has very questionable moral code vs. real world actions can definately lead to confusion/acting out/estrangement. Lord knows what really went on behind closed doors!!!

[noanobamalemming]

Being a kleptomaniac has nothing to do with upbringing. She obvoiusly needs physiological help.