Mama Grizzly Euthanized After Fatal Attack

(CBS/ AP)  Wildlife officials say a grizzly bear has been euthanized after tests determined it was responsible for a triple mauling in a Montana campground.

Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks spokesman Ron Aasheim said Friday DNA tests determined the sow killed a Michigan man and injured two others in unprovoked attacks in a campground overnight Wednesday.

The bear was euthanized after wildlife officials captured the sow and her three cubs at the Soda Butte Campground five miles from Yellowstone National Park.

Aasheim says the cubs will likely be placed in a zoo. Jackie Worstell, executive director of ZooMontana in Billings, says state officials have asked if her zoo could take the cubs.

A final decision is expected Friday or Saturday.

A sow and two of her three cubs were trapped by Thursday, with a year-old cub found in a trap early Friday. The bears - crying and scratching at the steel sides of traps - were taken from the Soda Butte campground in a three-truck convoy.

Their departure brought relief among residents and visitors in Cooke City, an old mining town just outside Yellowstone National Park that was jolted by the Wednesday attacks on three people as they slept in separate tents.

"They captured them? All of them?" asked Linda Olson. The 60-year-old nurse from Minnesota let out a sigh when she learned the answer was yes.

The cubs will likely go to a zoo, said Chris Servheen, a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service grizzly bear recovery coordinator. The sow was killed so officials can conduct an autopsy to determine if any physical ailments or conditions caused her to attack the campers.

Authorities said the bear family, under the tutelage of the mother, specifically targeted campers - a sharp departure from the usual behavior of grizzlies attacking only when threatened or surprised.

Evidence indicated all three cubs likely participated in what Warden Capt. Sam Sheppard called a sustained attack on Kevin Kammer of Grand Rapids, Mich. He was pulled from his tent and dragged 25 feet. At least one of the bears fed on his body.

Despite the unusual nature of the attacks, there also was a realization in
Cooke City that bear run-ins would continue. Three million tourists a year visit the remote and wild Yellowstone region of Montana and Wyoming, which has an estimated 600 grizzlies.

"It's a great spot, but you have to realize we're in their home. We're part of the food chain," Pat Froelich, 75, said as she watched the trucks haul the grizzlies from town as she ate breakfast at the Bear Claw Bakery.

Fibers from a tent or sleeping bag were in the droppings of the captured bears, and a tooth fragment found in a tent appears to match a chipped tooth on the sow that weighs more than 300 pounds.

"Everything points to it being the offending bear," said Ron Aasheim, a spokesman for Fish, Wildlife and Parks.

The two other victims, Deb Freele of London, Ontario, and Ronald Singer of Alamosa, Colo., were initially hospitalized in Cody, Wyo. Singer, 21, was treated and released. Freele was scheduled to have surgery Friday for bite wounds and a broken bone in her arm, her husband Bill Freele said.

He expected her to be released from the hospital sometime this weekend.
Freele said his wife had wanted to carry on with their trip but reconsidered after having nightmares about the attack.

"Right now, she just wants to see the kids," he said.

Deb Freele is a native of Michigan and knew Kammer but did not realize he was in the same campground or that he was the victim until she saw his picture with a story about the maulings, her husband said.

Freele said she couldn't understand why the bear attacked her, because she posed no threat.

"If it was something that I had done - if I had walked into a female with cubs, and startled her, and she attacked me - I can understand that," she said. "She was hunting us, with the intention of killing us and eating us."
Freele said she woke up just before the bear bit her arm.

"Next thing I know, this bear is chewing on my arm. I screamed. He bit harder. I screamed harder," she told "Early Show" co-anchor Erica Hill Thursday from a Cody, Wyoming hospital.

"I told myself, play dead," she said. "I went totally limp. As soon as I went limp, I could feel his jaws get loose and then he let me go."

Bear Mauling Victim: Playing Dead Saved My Life

Bill Freele was in Cooke City on Friday retrieving the couple's camping equipment. He believes the mother bear should be killed "because it tasted humans."

He was fine with placing the cubs in a zoo. "Just don't tell me where it is," he added.

Messages left Thursday for Kammer's mother-in-law and brother-in-law in Michigan were not returned.

Singer and his mother Luron Singer did not immediately return e-mail messages from The Associated Press seeking comment. Luron Singer told The Denver Post that her son, a former high school wrestler, had been camping with his girlfriend.

He started punching the bear when he felt it biting his leg, she said. His girlfriend screamed, and the bear ran away.

"He is doing fine," Luron Singer told the newspaper. "He went fishing today."
Freele said she couldn't understand why the bear attacked her, because she posed no threat.

"If it was something that I had done - if I had walked into a female with cubs, and startled her, and she attacked me - I can understand that," she said. "She was hunting us, with the intention of killing us and eating us."

All the victims did the right thing, and there was no telling why the bear picked out those three tents, Sheppard said.

About 600 grizzly bears and hundreds of less-aggressive black bears live in the Yellowstone area. The grizzlies are listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act.

[PackAlarm]

When will campers learn to use my PackAlarm to protect their campsites? I worked for years around Alaskan bears developing my PackAlarm so people would be forewarned of attacks, and this tragedy could have been totally prevented. See www.packalarm.net and camp safely.

[erasmus111]

Either the bear was sick, or the people had food in their tent. Or their hands and clothes were dirty from handling food.

[Anne-Kare]

I was saddened to hear the results of this story. Does anyone believe we, the smarter, educated humans of our planet, actually BROUGHT INSIGHT to this situation? Maybe so. Maybe other alternatives to euthanasia were truly considered...however, it would seem not judging from the speed of the actions taken. The Mother Bear lost everything...as did her cubs (no disrespect intended to the zoo who will care for them). At the very least, those in decision-making authority, please pledge to re-visit this issue in light of all the evidence and circumstances which those of us commenting admittedly are not privy to. Once done, are YOU satisfied with the outcomes as they unfolded? If so, case closed. If not, what could be done differently the next time...and the time after that...???

[Hitman4700]

Sick puppy? For believing that animal murder is wrong? No, you are if you believe that this is justice. I'd like to see them feast on your entrails.

[OmegaWolf747]

The more we encroach into wild habitat, the more animals will be driven into parks, the more this kind of thing will happen. It's time for humans to stop reproducing and stop developing every inch of green land.

[Anne-Kare]

Comment earlier today never made it; trying again. Killing the Mother Bear, sending her cubs to a zoo (no disrespect to any zoo) did absolutely nothing to eliminate or assuage the human loss and suffering. Were alternative options--re-location of the little bear family--seriously considered, only to be quickly disregarded by perhaps the expense of such a plan? Might there have been some one or ones with the desire and ability to financially assist? Was there time allotted for such an option? We will most likely never know. What of future incidents...is it logical to infer that euthanasia is our #1 solution? For sure, each animal-human incident carries unique circumstances, so realistically no one solution could or should be applied across the board. Seems that rule of thumb should apply to euthanasia as well. My hope is that people at decision-level authority at our parks will give every aspect of this whole episode their utmost consideration--the sort from which the maxim "hindsight is 100%" is derived. You as our representatives are the keepers of the parks and all that lie within them, so it seems "we" (only through you) have no choice but to trust that lives who can't speak for themselves are given due consideration of their options. Yes, among them is euthanasia...not to be confused with "automatic euthanasia" as it appears to have happened here, no information provided to the contrary. In sum, we are looking to you to evidence this trust back to us in matters such as these.

[williampoiri]

you live near Bears the expect to die by a bear,you cannot go,live near wildlife and not expect the worse the mauling was because,and that is the reason, just like a car accident there is that accident and that is that,
the officials just kill the animals and no lawyers come for the defendant Bears, A Grizzly is a vicious animal anyone venturing into there geographic
area risk that why not just relocate the bear to a more friendly neighborhood like we do to sexual predatory criminals just released from jail, or just close Yellow stone completely to humans

[ouchitatom]

Old father ? What is it you want Tallturtle? Old father what happened to the great red bear you tell me about in your stories? Look up ther in the stars , he is there next to the puma and the eagle. Do you see them? Yes old father. Old father? Yes tallturtle ? Old father were there many of them when you were a cub? Yes there were many and we lived together and we lived wide.Come tallturtle let us go and fish now. They too will be gone soon and they are as many as the stars but we must hurry!

[choiceshaveconsequences]

Personally, I think these mama grizzlies just got tired of being painted as Republicans.

[tswepsto]

The bear should not have been put down. If you inhabit their territory, it is their right to protect it. Mother nature is called mother nature as much as the christian god is called "God". I'm in tears. I know that humans think they rule everything, but please, look at the big picture. I know life isn't fair, but it's much less fair to introduce an event that is not called for. This is one of those events - clearly unethical by all means. Let the claimed die, and save those who get away. Mother nature has her way of collecting those who do not observe and consider. I feel sorry for that poor family labeled as bears. Think of this as a murder. If someone shot my mother in front of me, that would be considered murder, right? Tears to you all. This is horrible. It's not justice.