July 12, 2010 1:34 AM

Doctors Threaten to Pull Out of Texas Medicaid

(AP)  Cuts to the reimbursements given to doctors who treat patients covered by the state's low-income health care program are raising fears that already declining physician participation will fall even further, according to a published report.

The health care and insurance industries fear that a 1 percent cut in Medicaid fees scheduled to take effect Sept. 1 will be the first in a series of cuts as state agencies are asked to trim their two-year budgets by 10 percent to help cover an expected $18 billion revenue shortfall, The Dallas Morning News reported Sunday.

About 3.3 million poor and disabled Texans depend on Medicaid for health care, but less than a third of the state's 48,700 practicing doctors accept patients covered by the federal program, according to Texas Health and Human Services Commission. And some doctors who do participate in the program limit the number and kind of patients they accept.

The commission, which administers the program in Texas, is among the state agencies that state leaders expect to cut spending. Thomas Suehs, the commission's top executive, said he realizes the bind that physicians find themselves in.

"No one ever wants to cut Medicaid," commission spokeswoman Stephanie Goodman said. But, she noted, "it's 75 percent of our budget. So when you start to identify places to reduce our budget, it gets very hard to skip Medicaid."

Dr. Lou Montanaro, a suburban Dallas obstetrician, said he wanted to stay in the Medicaid program, but low reimbursement levels have prompted him to restrict the Medicaid cases he takes. He accepts pregnant patients, but not women seeking gynecological care.

Montanaro believes that reimbursement levels will continue to decline, which will prompt more doctors to decide to restrict or stop taking Medicaid patients.

"They're going to try to expand the rolls of Medicaid ... and at the same time they want to reduce the reimbursement to doctors," he said. "With the (pay) trend going downwards, I don't see additional physicians signing up. It's just not going to happen."

A survey by the Texas Medical Association, the state's largest physicians interest group, showed that 45 percent of its members who responded said they would limit how many Medicaid patients they would treat if the Medicaid fees were cut by 1 or 2 percent, while another 24 percent said they would stop accepting any Medicaid patients.

The issue is one of financial survival, said Tom Banning, the association's lobbyist. He said Medicaid pays about 70 percent of what Medicare, a federal insurance program for people age 65 or older, pays for the same service. Commercial insurers are also lowering their rates, he said.

In planning their business survival strategies, doctors "have tended to look at what is the lowest-paying part of the market, which is Medicaid. It's not a hard economic decision," Banning said.

© 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Add a Comment See all 56 Comments
by MadJayhawk July 13, 2010 8:38 PM EDT
Rationing is coming. When you have doctors quiting or not accepting patients and millions of more people coming into the system for free healthcare rationing is the only solution. Who decides who gets treatment and who doesn't? On what basis will they make the decision of who gets care and who doesn't? The youngest and most healthiest? Or the old and less likely to survive? Which group are you in? Which group is your parents in? Are you going to be able to keep your Doctor as the Democrats and Obama promised?
Reply to this comment
by Pats1 July 12, 2010 7:10 PM EDT
30-50% profit?! Where did you get that BS figure, the Huffington Post or perhaps at a Comrade Obama rally? Insurance companies make around a 6-8% profit per year which is far less than most companies. You can find all kinds of stories on this, here is just one: http://newsbusters.org/blogs/tom-blumer/2009/10/26/aps-woodward-fact-checks-health-insurance-company-profits-finds-them-ane
Reply to this comment
by Brokennews July 12, 2010 10:42 AM EDT
Jesus spent most of his time healing the sick. Never once did he ask about health insurance.

by msimamaji July 12, 2010 10:06 AM EDT





Well, just in case you missed the sunday school stories, Jesus didn't really have much overhead & expenses to deal with. All he had to do has touch someone & bang! They were healed! I don't recall any bible stories of Jesus hauling around MRI machines, X-ray machines, emergency room equipment & directing patients to the pharmacy. Now if you can think of a way to bestow the healing powers of Jesus upon today's Doctors then yeah, then Doctors shouldn't be as concerned with getting paid, until then using the "Jesus would have done it for free" doesn't really hold any water!!
Reply to this comment
by Brokennews July 12, 2010 10:15 AM EDT
It doesn't take a genius to figure out that you can't provide medical services to anyone for long if the hospital's or clinic's balance sheets are running in the negative.
But for some reason there are people out there that think you can?!?!
Wierd!
Reply to this comment
by SquezeBox July 12, 2010 12:49 PM EDT
It does take a Genious to actually figure out that 10 of million have no insurance and my never have it. But they still work and contribute to the country. The reason hospitals hurt is because the overhead for healthcare is astronomical but even then I have worked in plenty of hospital which does not take medicaid or medicare except in limited quantities. First patients to go home are the medicare patients as long as they are stable they are out the door.

Our biggest problem is to many bakers are steering the pot, not including the religions right.
by tsigili July 12, 2010 9:37 AM EDT
We have no one to blame for that.....but Obama himself!
Reply to this comment
by msimamaji July 12, 2010 10:06 AM EDT
Wrong. Texas has Governor Perry. Remember the health care reform permits states to set up their own health care system, as long as it meets the guidelines of HHS, namely that no one is denied medical care.
Texas is oozing with oil, so why can't they paid Medicaid doctors more? The answer is simple. They want to kill of Medcaid patients. In addition, I wonder how many Medicaid patients got sick because of pollution or because of industrial accidents? (The oil industry in Texas has a lousy safety record.) Shouldn't the rich people of Texas be required to help the people they have injured? And, aren't we a Christian coutry, and isn't Texas a Christian state?
Jesus spent most of his time healing the sick. Never once did he ask about health insurance. Why is providing health care for everyone such a problem for a supposedly Christian country like the USA?
by 44wonder July 12, 2010 10:20 AM EDT
msimamaji No you are wrong.Back up your post with some facts!!You are just rambling!!
by antiglobal5 July 12, 2010 9:04 AM EDT
what did people think was going to happen. This is still America and we are still a largely capitalist system.
The govt' cannot dictate to a doctor or any other highly trained professional in the private sector telling them they have to work in a cretain place for a certain amount of money.
Once it is no longer profitable for a doctor to practice somewhere they can get up and move. You will see medical practices in low income areas closing left and right.
Also most doctors are wealthy. If the govt' tries to bully them they can just buy a few vacation homes and retire
Reply to this comment
by SquezeBox July 12, 2010 12:52 PM EDT
Your right, who cares about American, look at those fools in the military if they are poor and dumb enough to follow order they deserve also what they get. Doctors are the smarter part of society, they figure a good way to make money off sick fools and they are going to milk it as much as they can.

I see no difference from CPA or Lawyer. I for one see no problem not caring about your fellow American after all we are a Capitalist country.
by antiglobal5 July 12, 2010 8:59 AM EDT
what did people think would happen? This is still America and we are still a largely capitalist system.
You cannot dictate to doctors or anyone else in a highly skilled profession that they have to work in certain places and that they have to do it for less money.
Once it is no longer profitable for a doctor to practive somewhere they can get up and move somewhere else.
also most doctors are wealthy so if the govt' starts making demands they can just buy a few vacation homes and retire.
Reply to this comment
by kyleminli July 12, 2010 10:35 AM EDT
Many doctors won't even go into certain areas of medicine because of the cost of malpractice insurance. Obama's wonderful idea that nobody--NOBODY--wanted is making what was a bad situation worse. Recall Obama and get someone--Democrat/Republican/Independent--who actually knows how to make economic sense. Even Clinton has to apologize for this guy these days. Recently he was asked why Americans don't feel Obama empathizes with us. His answer was that as long as the economy is bad Americans won't be happy with Obama. Do you get it, Obama? You put the health care cart before the economic horse. The moment you became president and began focusing on health care, I was thinking, "What's wrong with this guy?" Why is he taking up health care before he makes the economy strong. His timing at passing health care was one of the worst decisions I've seen any president (of any party) make? That's why the American people have no faith in him anymore. Yes, we don't believe. Not anymore.
by smitvict July 12, 2010 8:54 AM EDT
This is just the beginning. Wait until Obama realizes you can't give everyone free medical care and ends up really cutting reimbursements.

Long waits, long lines for the few physicians that remain. But fear not, it will be free.
Reply to this comment
by X2670 July 12, 2010 6:58 AM EDT
Medicaid could probably raise it's reimbursement rate if we for example, cut somewhere else, like, 15,000 Marines in Okinawa, 60,000 Soldiers in Germany fighting who? Iraq, Af-cannotwin-istan? Lots of places in Defense to cut to make up for shortcomings elsewhere. CUT DEFENSE NOW!
Reply to this comment
by revmrbill July 12, 2010 7:44 AM EDT
"But maybe we should do something about our insurance paying out $30 for a single tylenol."

You hit the nail right on the head. This is however more of a practice in hospitals than it is with individual doctors. It would be a great travesty for those unfortunate people who would have no health coverage at all if their doctor were to stop taking Medicaid or they could not find a doctor to accept them in the first place. That would be the case with my 89 year old mother. She can barely pay her bills and buy food. Many would find themselves in the same boat, and this is not their fault. They are simply very poor people. Family helps out when they can, but they have to support their families too. At the same time I feel sorry for the doctors. The amount they were imbursed is already critically low. They actually lose money. These days it is not unusual for an RN or a nurse practioner to make more money than the doctors.
by Sannybeth July 12, 2010 4:45 AM EDT
Well correct me if I'm wrong but this is due to cut backs not the healthcare reform. But maybe we should do something about our insurance paying out $30 for a single tylenol.
Reply to this comment
by smitvict July 12, 2010 8:58 AM EDT
The $30 tylenol subsidizes the illegal aliens getting free health care in the U.S. You and I are paying for the services they receive. Nothing is truely free.
by CHReed July 12, 2010 9:38 AM EDT
smitvict - Lets add the fact that it also subsidizes all the uninsured poor and not so poor Americans in this country. And some of those uninsured are uninsured because they choose to be, knowing full well taht the rest of us will be forced to pick up their tab. Oh wouldn't it be so nice if we could just blame all our problems on one group of people. Then we could just arrest them and haul their butts off to some interment camp and then poof! all our problems would all disappear.
See all 56 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
Better Information. Better Health.
CBS News on Facebook