AP/ July 9, 2010, 2:14 PM

Europeans Back Veil Ban, but Americans Oppose

While most Americans oppose banning face-covering Islamic veils, most western Europeans questioned in a new global poll say the garments should be forbidden - especially in France, where a ban may soon be a reality.

A survey by the Pew Global Attitudes Project found that an overwhelming 82 percent of French respondents support a ban. The poll found 71 percent support in Germany, 62 percent in Britain and 59 percent in Spain.

In the United States, 28 percent of those questioned said they would approve a ban.

Several European countries have been considering bans on such veils, with special attention on France, home to western Europe's largest Muslim community and a strongly secular government.

The lower house of France's parliament is expected to approve a divisive bill Tuesday that would make it illegal to wear full-face veils in public. The government says such veils oppress women. Only a very small minority of French Muslim women wear veils such as the niqab or burqa, and many French Muslims fear a ban would stigmatize the whole Islamic community.

French Parliament Debates Ban on Islamic Veils
Barcelona Bans Burqas From City Hall

The pollsters questioned more than 4,000 people by telephone in the five countries as part of a larger poll on global attitudes conducted in April and May. The margin of error was plus or minus 4 or 5 percentage points for the countries asked about the veil. The study was released Thursday.

In the United States and Europe, respondents to the poll who were over 55 were more likely to support a ban than those age 18 to 34.

Those on the political right were more likely to support a ban than those on the left, except in Spain.

The pollsters said there was no variation along gender lines in any of the five countries and little variation depending on income and education levels.

The French government's proposed veil ban is widely expected to become law after Tuesday's lower house vote and a vote in the Senate in September.

The government has insisted that the bill is not about religion but has called it a way to promote equality between the sexes, to protect oppressed women or to ensure security in public places.

While the proposed legislation is colloquially referred to as the "anti-burqa law," it is officially called "the bill to forbid covering one's face in public." Part of the bill is aimed at husbands and fathers who impose such veils on female family members.

Citing security reasons, Belgium's lower house has enacted a ban on the face-covering veil, though it must be ratified by the upper chamber. Calling them an affront to human dignity, Spain's government has said it favors barring the use of burqas in government buildings.

Germany's interior minister, however, has said he sees no need for a debate on whether to ban full-body veils in Germany.
© 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
8 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nabi18 says:
for the islamic perspective on all of this check out http://www.islamicsolutions.com/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
barbaram99 says:
I have met a woman in Seattle that was covered and the face as well. I think the face should be seen. Deaf people use sign or finger spelling. For the fully sighted they can read their face expressions. For us legally blind, we go by the persons' voice.Deafblind spell in the hand. They can dress modest.If the ladies want to wear head covering that is fine.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
armyoftwelve says:
I'm sure the number of Americans opposed will change once the first suicide bomber in a burqa blows up in Disneyland.

I have a sister who still lives in Jordan and the last time I saw her her HUSBAND made her wear the full veil. She wasn't exactly thrilled with it but really--WHAT CHOICE DID SHE HAVE!??

Of course, I haven't seen her in over a decade because I became a Catholic and I don't trust her husband.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
markamichaud says:
I live in Quebec and we have a large muslim population and in the Montreal area women with the hijab which covers the entire face. They refuse to remove them when applying for a driver`s licence and other government functions. This spring Quebec passed a law which made it illegal to wear the hijab in government buildings. We believe that it is a security issue as how do we know who is under the garment. Many muslims here in Quebec also support the ban as they say it has nothing to do with islam. I believe that if people saw this more regularly in their daily lives then they would change their opinions. I am sorry but in this day and age I do not want someone covered from head to toe coming into my building. I want to know that the person is not some fanatic.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jsf14 says:
I'd like it broken down by people who have seen a totally swathed woman and those who have not. Seeing in person a figure with only eyes visible, or with not even eyes visible because a mesh covers the eyes -- that's different from seeing a picture and is likely to shake you. Now if that hidden woman talks to you, you might find out she's nice, but you don't talk with most people you see. You see this outfit more often in parts of Europe than in most of the US.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
OnTheRoad01 says:
I want to see who I am talking to.
I want to see who is walking beside me.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tsigili says:
This American favors the European sensibilities. There is absolutely no justification for any kind of "dress" code for a religion, and certainly not one that conceals a person's true identity.

The "trappings" of religion are just a simple, and clear indicator, of how humans have twisted religion into something that is not true.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
antoniof123 says:
I never got asked and I am deaf so I like the idea because that way I can see what they are saying.
reply