April 30, 2010 4:56 PM

11 Somalis in U.S. Court on Piracy Charges

By
CBSNews
(AP)  Eleven suspected Somali pirates accused in separate attacks on two Navy ships off the coast of Africa were indicted in U.S. federal court Friday.

There was heavy security at the courthouse when the men appeared wearing handcuffs and either bright orange or olive drab prison outfits. One used crutches and had a bandage wrapped around his head. Another used a wheelchair, with his leg covered in bandages because it had been amputated below the knee.

The government said the injuries were the result of the men's alleged battle with the Navy.

The defendants did not enter pleas. An interpreter read them the charges of piracy, attacks to plunder a vessel, assault with a dangerous weapon, and use of a firearm during a crime of violence. Piracy carries a mandatory life sentence; the other charges carry penalties of 10 to 35 years.

The men, appearing weary and impassive, sat in the jury box during the 90-minute hearing. They did not make any statements other than to say they understood the court proceeding.

U.S. Magistrate Tommy Miller scheduled a detention hearing Wednesday and ordered the men kept in custody until then. They have no listed assets, so they will be assigned defense attorneys.

Five of the men were captured March 31, after the frigate USS Nicholas exchanged fire with a suspected pirate vessel west of the Seychelles.

The other six were captured after they allegedly began shooting at the amphibious dock landing ship USS Ashland on April 10 about 380 miles off Djibouti, a small nation facing Yemen across the mouth of the Red Sea.

U.S. Attorney Neil H. MacBride said the Defense Department has pushed for the U.S. prosecution because the Navy was the victim and believed the piracy charges could be proved in federal court.

"Piracy threatens human lives and disrupts international commerce," MacBride said. "When pirates attack U.S. vessels by force, they must face severe consequences."

The trial, which could be scheduled within two months, would be held in a court that has a strong reputation for maritime law. Naval Station Norfolk, the world's largest naval base, is within 10 miles of the courtroom. Both ships in the attacks are part of the Atlantic Fleet based in the Hampton Roads, Va., area.

The 11 had been held on U.S. ships for weeks off Somalia's pirate-infested coast as officials worked to determine whether and where they could be prosecuted and prepare legal charges against them.

The transfer of the case to a U.S. court comes amid discussions about setting up an international court to prosecute piracy suspects. Some nations have been reluctant to do that because of difficulties transporting suspects, fears they may claim asylum and thorny jurisdiction issues.

The Somali mission to the United Nations said it is attempting to sort out the latter.

"We prefer those kids to be tried in Somalia," said Omar Jamal, first secretary for the mission. "The Somali government is against piracy and its practice, and asks the international community's support to stop it."

U.S. warships are part of an international flotilla protecting shipping in the region.

Kenya, south of Somalia, has taken some to its courts but now says pirates are putting too much strain on the country's court system. Some pirates have been released after capture because no nation could be found to try them.

Related:

Pirate Attack Foiled Off Somalia Coast




AP
Add a Comment See all 24 Comments
by msjb1 April 24, 2010 2:05 PM EDT
DEATH TO THE PIRATES set a plank up on the empire state building and make them walk it now that sounds like fun
Reply to this comment
by trillion1 April 24, 2010 10:33 AM EDT
Waste of time and money. Should have just left them in the water.
Reply to this comment
by wheear April 23, 2010 11:30 PM EDT
Don't ask don't tell Just shoot.
Reply to this comment
by TomColt April 23, 2010 10:02 PM EDT
We should pay the court and detention costs in a neighboring country (Ethiopia or Kenya), under the proviso that IF Somalia ever becomes a functioning country again, they would return the prisoners to Somali custody.

We could even build the confinement facility in one of those countries, help train their guards in international custody standards, and provide for the costs to keep these pirates from preying on the public for decades - at much less cost than bringing them back to the USA.

Once we bring them to the USA, they become our wards indefinitely...
Reply to this comment
by rock0223 April 23, 2010 9:23 PM EDT
This is kid-glove treatment. Just breeds more pirates, so I think. And it engenders disrespect amongst American taxpayers.
Reply to this comment
by myopinionpal April 23, 2010 6:34 PM EDT
I'm not being mean when I say this the Navy could of handled this out at sea by making shark food out of them.
Reply to this comment
by dwilson59 April 23, 2010 5:51 PM EDT
What will this cost?

Trial in NY 100k x 11 is 1.1 million.

Lets say 20 years each in prison. Which is better living conditions then what they are in now.

At $57,000 per a year times 11 is $627,000.00 per a year x 20 years $12,540,000.00 plus the trial.

Total $13,640,000.00
Reply to this comment
by dwilson59 April 23, 2010 5:46 PM EDT
I will help I will donate 11 rounds of .45 for the cause.
Reply to this comment
by m95foru April 24, 2010 3:27 AM EDT
Under Muslim law,...they would have their hands removed....but yeah,..did the Navy just not have any yardarms high enough or something.The whole lot of them should swing....
by dwilson59 April 23, 2010 5:10 PM EDT
If they were caught firing on a Military ship cant we just shoot them dead. We could save so much money.
Reply to this comment
by DocD--2008 April 23, 2010 5:05 PM EDT
"We prefer those kids to be tried in Somalia," said Omar Jamal, first secretary for the mission. "The Somali government is against piracy and its practice, and asks the international community's support to stop it."

I guess this guy doesn't know that Somali has not had an effective national government for nearly three decades... That and they have just released many of them.. The priates that attack (other than US Warships as that in itself is an act of war) need to be going to The Hague for trial as it is an international incident covered by the UN......
Reply to this comment
See all 24 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook