April 20, 2010 8:33 AM

Are School Lunches Weapons of Mass Destruction?

By
CBSNews
(AP)  School lunches have been called many things, but a group of retired military officers is giving them a new label: national security threat.

That's not a reference to the mystery meat served up in the cafeteria line either. The retired officers are saying that school lunches have helped make the nation's young people so fat that fewer of them can meet the military's physical fitness standards, and recruitment is in jeopardy.

A new report being released Tuesday says more than 9 million young adults, or 27 percent of all Americans ages 17 to 24, are too overweight to join the military. Now, the officers are advocating for passage of a wide-ranging nutrition bill that aims to make the nation's school lunches healthier.

The officers' group, Mission: Readiness, was appearing on Capitol Hill on Tuesday with Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., and Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack.

The military group acknowledges that other things keep young adults out of the armed services, such as a criminal record or the lack of a high school diploma. But weight problems that have worsened over the past 15 years are now the leading medical reason that recruits are rejected.

Although all branches of the military now meet or exceed recruitment goals, retired Navy Rear Adm. James Barnett Jr., a member of the officers group, says the obesity trend could affect that.

"When over a quarter of young adults are too fat to fight, we need to take notice," Barnett said. He noted that national security in the year 2030 is "absolutely dependent" on reversing child obesity rates.

Recruitment isn't the only problem posed by obesity. According to the report, the government spends tens of millions of dollars every year to train replacements for service members discharged because of weight problems.

Lunch Ladies Wage Food Fight
Will Calorie Labels Kill Cheeseburgers?
Kids Spurn Jamie Oliver's Healthy Food

This isn't the first time the military has gotten involved in the debate over school lunches. During World War II, military leaders had the opposite problem, reporting that many recruits were rejected because of stunted growth and inadequate nutrition. After the war, military leaders pushed Congress to establish the national school lunch program so children would grow up healthier.

The program was established in 1946, "as a measure of national security," according to the original bill language.

Today, the group is urging Congress to eliminate junk food and high-calorie beverages from schools, put more money into the school lunch program and develop new strategies that help children develop healthier habits.

The school lunch bill, currently awaiting a Senate vote, would establish healthier options for all foods in schools, including vending machine items. The legislation would spend $4.5 billion more over 10 years for nutrition programs.

The Army is already doing its part to catch the problem earlier, working with high schoolers and interested recruits to lose weight before they are eligible for service, says U.S. Army Recruiting Command's Mark Howell. He added that he had to lose 10 pounds himself before he joined the military.

"This is the future of our Army we are looking at when we talk about these 17- to 24-year-olds," Howell said. "The sad thing is a lot of them want to join but can't."

AP
Add a Comment See all 39 Comments
by barbaram99 April 21, 2010 1:51 PM EDT
i live in Seattle and I price the food and yes the bell pepper is 3 dollars..I broght to my room mate's attn..BS or not..the healthy stuff is sky high..I am appalled at the prices..I am going to buy the cheapest. Why are the healthy foods costly...They add the cost of growing,gas trucked, taxes etc..I wanted that bell pepper but I ain't paying 3 dollars for it..We ***** about the hot lunch at school being junk..I really don't know..They need to pull the pop/candy machines from the schools lunch rooms.
Can't they write things with all that darn war talk,,War on this/that.. Battle this/that..It turns me off..I don't the young to die in useless wars. I don't want to pay for the fat cat military..That money is wasted..I have vets in my family.. I live with a vet..Military personnel should stay out the schools..The military is whinning about the children's school lunch.. I never served..Thank goodness..I did look into it years ago..I am sp needs person..It is sad that the military want every abled bodied to fight..Now women..It is not the lunchse served at school..The lack of money ..The lack of recess/phy ed..I see no need for ipods..Just about every young person has one..I was 51 when I got a computer.
Reply to this comment
by barbaram99 April 20, 2010 10:36 PM EDT
I know what the healthy foods are..Have ye people ever priced them.. 3 dollars for a bell pepper. To eat right ye all preach and yet they are the very foods that go sky high..It it any wonder why the over wt..I would rather buy a dinner I can heat as a sp needs person I can safely do that..i can't cook. The military is whining again..
Reply to this comment
by Nate650 April 20, 2010 6:22 PM EDT
Typical school lunch quality is on par with fast/industrial food, which means it's loaded with preservatives, chemicals, and highly processed corn derivatives. Parents should demand wholesome meals or provide it themselves until the food system gets massively overhauled.
Reply to this comment
by Nate650 April 20, 2010 6:20 PM EDT
Typical school lunch quality is on par with fast/industrial food, which means it's loaded with preservatives, chemicals, and highly processed corn derivatives. Parents should demand wholesome meals or provide it themselves until the food system gets massively overhauled.
Reply to this comment
by barbaram99 April 20, 2010 5:25 PM EDT
Why are not the parents
Barring sweets,candy, pop in the home. I am poor and always been so..I have seen them chat shows on TV where babies/tops weigh more than I..The parents are the ones that never learnt NO growing up. When I was a student there was one student overweight,,A medical issue..He would also grab food off our trays..I could not see him reach for mine..He had to sit at the teacher's table..Ye parents are the ones buying the eats for the family table. Ye are the ones too scared to let them play outdoors..My mother wanted a grandchild and asked me if I would give her such..I was in my 20s. I told her no. I am a sp needs person from birth. I am a single person as well. The military wants ....I want the troops home..My late father was a military vet.. I hate wars..Why is it always America that trains the people in other nation only to later fight the forces America trained
Why is America the world's cop.
Thers is more money spent on wars..My late father gave me the right to my say..An America that belong to the American Indians..An America whinning She has Fat children..Who made them FAT..Not I..Ye set a plate of cake,candy and pop in their faces..Ye barred them from playing..The car made them lazy..If I want to go places I have to walk.
Reply to this comment
by tmittelstaed April 20, 2010 4:30 PM EDT
Most adults are very hipocritical when it comes to fitness. Posters on here whine about how kids are so fat but when it comes to their own fitness I don't see them running around on an intermural field in the rain and mud. Instead I see them all on the treadmills over at the health club, watching TV while they run.

We live in a modern society here. Our sports are played in well lit stadiums that are covered from the cold and wet and hot sun and are astroturfed. Adults exercise in a modern fitness facilities that are warm, sheltered, with tv sets and radios to listen to while they run in place. But when it comes to our children exercising in school we turn the clock back 50 years. They get a field that is either a sea of mud or a sea of dust to run in, in the cold and rain or burning sun. Why do you think that they don't want to take PE in school? Wouldn't you rather be inside where a bathroom and a refrigerator are a few steps away and a stereo and big screen TV set are right there to keep you entertained? Of course you would, that's why you do your exercising down at the health club.

If schools want to have physically fit students then they need to replace their gymnasiums with exercise equipment rooms and put in the same amenities that a typical health club has in it. Then the kids would be beating down the door to get in.
Reply to this comment
by cdimice April 20, 2010 2:27 PM EDT
U.S. children eat may be 2 meals a day at school, IF they eat what they are served at all.. MOST throw their food in the trash...they aren't in the cafeteria long enough to sit around eat and get fat.... check their backpacks and lockers for forbidden foods... yep, you'll find 'em.....and they typically brought them from home... or the corner store...
Reality is These kids spend MORE TIME sitting on their BUTTS at HOME cramming chips, and who knows what all down their throats and swilling down sodas... that is stuff they don't/can't get at most schools....
They are NOT getting fat eating at school, they are coming into their school years already FAT, kindergarten and first graders, already over weight... NOT THE SCHOOLS FAULT...... their MOMMAS are making them fat...
Reply to this comment
by FauxNews April 20, 2010 3:49 PM EDT
I totally agree, it's not the school lunch that is the problem, it's the "extras", pop and candy, which is even sold at cafeteria, causing the problem.
by cdimice April 20, 2010 4:56 PM EDT
by FauxNews April 20, 2010 3:49 PM EDT
I totally agree, it's not the school lunch that is the problem, it's the "extras", pop and candy, which is even sold at cafeteria, causing the problem.

FauxNews.... I was in school food service for 20 years here in El Paso, Texas and WE DON'T sell the EXTRAS...and we no longer serve FRIED foods ... The kids bring those EXTRAS in from 'outside' sources... no candy, sodas or unbaked chips sold on our campus...THEY ARE getting FAT at home... like respect and discipline, IT STARTS AT HOME... They are not born and raised in school cafeterias... the process begins at home....
by barbaram99 April 20, 2010 1:53 PM EDT
I member lunch in the schoul in the 60s/70s..I got free lunch as a foster child. As a legally blind I helpped in the lunchroom during the lunch period. .They were better,,Here is the kicker the military are overlooking..We had recess/Phy Ed..I was skinny..I could not gain weight til menopause at 37..
Food was cheaper to buy years ago..The healthy food is there but is so dang costly..I never had children..I am 55.They are whining that the children are fat..Why..Look in to the medications they use to control. In my day, that was unheard of..We did not watch TV..The govt ,the parents,the school, church are the blame..The bloody dollar is the blame as well.
Reply to this comment
by livvy500 April 20, 2010 1:46 PM EDT
We know already how many American children live below or not that far above the poverty line. They are raised by parents that work to survive (no more Moms at home planning those meals from Woman's Day magazine these days) Carbohydrates and processed foods are cheap and easy to prepare. On top of all that everything we buy anymore has chemicals. Our meat supply is pumped full of steroids so that animals grow quicker to butcher faster meaning more profit. Who knows what all this is doing to young bodies?

Schools are in a bind. They contract out for cheap food. In many poorer homes the meals at school are their basic source of nutrition and we should be able to do better. In a world where they are laying off teachers because they can't even afford to pay them to teach food choices get a pretty low priority. As a society the adults like to all sit around and say "back in my day blah blah blah" rather than solve anything in THIS day.

We can pay for it later when this generation grows up to have health problems that probably come from bad nutrition when they are young.
That is what we do with most all our problems with kids. No money for counseling - lets pay for prison! Same principle.
Reply to this comment
by dwilson59 April 20, 2010 1:33 PM EDT
I can solve the problem:

When I was young and I wanted to see if Ric was home I got on my bike to ride. Now kids sit in the house and just text. When I was a kid you stayed out till dark (7pm) then you went home from playing. When I was a kid we packed a lunch 2 cold cut sandwiches, chips, 2 apples, a cupcake and 1$ for milk.

What I am trying to say is kids sit at home and play video games all day long. Video games are fun entertainment but when they take up your entire day this will happen.

So put down the Video Games pick up a basketball and start playing.
Reply to this comment
by Nate650 April 20, 2010 7:34 PM EDT
Exercise isn't the answer for everything. Eating habits are far more important. The body can't "burn off" trans fats or chemicals.
See all 39 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
Better Information. Better Health.
CBS News on Facebook