CBS/AP/ March 5, 2010, 7:57 PM

6 Dead in Fatal Arizona Bus Crash

Updated at 5:01 p.m. ET

The bus company involved in a deadly accident on the interstate south of Phoenix Friday has been operating without insurance for nearly a year, and its buses should not have been on the road, CBS News Affiliate KPHO-TV reports.

The carrier, Tierra Santa Inc., lost its authorization to operate on April 1, 2009, KPHO-TV found while checking the company against the Web site of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.

A phone message left by The Associated Press with Tierra Santa was not immediately returned.

KPHO-TV also reports the company, which operates in the United States out of Van Nuys, Calif., has a history of violations, including one failed bus inspection resulting in the bus being taken out of service. Two of the company's drivers had also lost their authorization to drive. In the last two years, the company has been involved in one other crash.

Six people were ejected from one of Tierra Santa's buses and killed Friday when the vehicle hit a pickup and rolled over on the interstate south of Phoenix, state police said.

The six were thrown about 10 yards in the accident about 5:30 a.m. on the Gila River Indian Reservation near the community of Sacaton, according to the Arizona Department of Public Safety. Their bodies were covered with blue tarps midmorning Friday, and police said there may be another victim under the bus.

The roof of the bus was crushed and all the windows were knocked out, with one thrown as far as 25 yards.

DPS spokesman Bart Graves said two men and four women, all aboard the bus, were killed. The bus, traveling from central Mexico to Los Angeles, was carrying at least 22 passengers, and the surviving 16 passengers were all injured. Police said the rollover triggered a second accident when another pickup slowed and was hit by a sedan. One person from the sedan was taken to a hospital.

Eight of the injured were taken to Maricopa Medical Center in Phoenix, where six were in critical condition with life-threatening injuries ranging from broken spines and pelvises to head injuries, hospital spokesman Michael Murphy said.

He said an 11-year-old boy and the bus driver were among the patients at the hospital, and that the two were in guarded condition with non-life-threatening injuries.

Alex Porras said his sister, 25-year-old Jasmine Porras, was coming back from a two-week vacation in Mexico when the bus crashed Friday morning. She was critically injured.

"I was shocked when I got the call," a red-eyed Porras told The Associated Press at Maricopa Medical Center. "We're really worried."

Alex Porras, 28, said his sister, who is married, had just graduated from Arizona State University with a nursing degree and was hoping to start working soon so she could help others.

Four patients, two in critical condition and two in good condition, were taken to Scottsdale Healthcare Osborn hospital. Three patients, one in critical condition and two in good condition, were taken to St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix. Two others were at Banner Good Samaritan Medical Center in Phoenix, but the hospital did not release their conditions.

Early reports said the bus hit a semi, but Graves said later a semi was not involved in the crash.

Police said the bus hit the pickup, veered into the central median, then overcorrected and rolled once before landing on its wheels.

The accident scene quickly became a mass of police and rescue personnel as ambulances arrived and medics set up a triage area in the middle of the normally busy interstate, preparing the injured for transport.

Emergency crews needed to break the bus' windows to remove everyone from the vehicle, KPHO-TV reports. A triage area was set up in the middle of the interstate.

Medical helicopters landed on the freeway to airlift the most critically injured to area hospitals.

The bus originated in central Mexico near Durango, Graves said. It entered the United States at El Paso, Texas, and was traveling westbound on I-10.

Two drivers were onboard, the main driver and a relief driver. The plan was to switch drivers in Phoenix, Graves said.

Graves said the investigation will include whether the driver was fatigued as well as the maintenance history of the bus.

Both westbound lanes of I-10 were closed at milepost 173, and traffic was being rerouted onto State Route 587 until further notice.

The accident scene, about 25 miles south of downtown Phoenix, remained under investigation.
© 2010 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
19 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
sunday42 says:
Minority owned and allowed to operate without insurance and violating the same laws the rest of us have to follow.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
the48thronin says:
As we now know, the bus company was operating outside the laws, without authority and without insurance. That is the real story here, that a person can decide to ignore the laws and still this buss was running regularly scheduled runs across the border into and back from Mexico and NO ONE STOPPED IT.... The owner was taken to court and told again to stop but was he arrested... NOT YET! That is why there are people ignoring the laws, there is no punishment even when their actions result in dead people scattered across the hiway and ruined families scattered across 2 or more countries...
reply
sunday42 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Minority owned and operated.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nickjacket says:
The driver is in as deep legal trouble as the company that owns the bus.
When the bus was "pre-tripped" lacking the insurance statement papers, the bus would have normally been un-drivable.

Seatbelts on buses sound like a great idea but to get the paying public to wear them is not. If this bus had been maintained so that evasive maneuvers could be controlled there might have been a different outcome. From the picture it looks like an old Greyhound bus that's been painted over. This bus could have been 15 years old when it was bought used. Also, this generation of bus would not have had an effective braking retarder system to "haul it down" if the driver needed it.
The stretch of I-10 where this happened is a long 15 mile downhill slope to the Gila River bridge. Braking effectiveness would have been a challenge especially if the bus driver thought that they could "keep up" with the other yo-yo's that regularly do 10-20mph over the limit along that stretch of road.

In better economic times Arizona has a greater presence of roving commercial driver enforcement vehicles checking plates and the general condition of a bus like this. Now that 30+ years of low taxes with per capita deficient enforcement is showing the seams of red thread, the true cost of safety comes out when we're shown pictures of tarps covering corpses.

The name of the Indian Reservation town (Sacaton) is pronounced as
Sack-Ah-Tone.
reply
the48thronin replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
As can plainly be seen in the video, this was not an old repainted greyhound bus, but was in fact a modern Marcopolo model... are you always wrong?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
wheresmycountry says:
Seatbelt laws for private vehicles, and no seatbelts available on buses.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
danny13760 says:
It is such a shame to see one bus crash after another. I wish there was more reporting so to help raise the standards that bus companys operate. I am a bus driver and companys can make their drivers work up to 15 hours a day with 10 hrs driving time. Lets say there is a three hour layover between or before the return to home terminal, well the driver just worked 18 hours.but the federal government allows companys to make their driver log that time as off duty so not to go over the 15 hour rule. I work 60-70 hrs a week not counting the 1 to 4 hours a day off duty.
reply
stychokiller replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I'll bet you get really cranky if you don't get your full 8 minutes of sleep then!
aliceazure replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I believe you need to read your DOT regulations. Rules have changed in last few years. One rule: you can drive 11 hours vice the 10; also the off duty rules have changed. If your still driving bus, you need to put yourself "out of service" until you bring yourself up to speed.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
CompletelyFrustrated says:
"the vehicle hit a pickup" nothing like accurate reporting! Yeah right!

The bus hit a tractor-trailer and flipped over the video has the wrecked truck still in the road!!
reply
the48thronin replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Actually, in another video I have posted on my facebook from ma different news source you can plainly see the tractor that stopped while the driver tried to help people is unscratched and parked in the roadway which was still shut down, the white pickup with its' damaged rear end is also shown plainly... Are you always wrong?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
pragmatist1 says:
A real tragedy and one that was probably preventable. I've seen car drivers deliberately put on their brakes if they feel a vehicle behind them is getting too close, whether that's another car, a semi, van or bus. When drivers do this, they're just asking for a rear-end collision and often cause serious accidents. Other factors might include a distracted or sleepy bus (or car) driver, or a poorly maintained bus with malfunctioning brakes, etc. Very sad.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
averjane says:
The driver must have been driving to close to rear end the car. What a shame. I hope it's not because the car pulled in front of it, but either way, it's a tragic thing to happen. I pray for the families of those killed due to such negligence.
reply
Rovels1 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
does anybody know if I10 is open now? going to Phoenix
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Bob Fitz says:
That IS I-10. Here in Tucson the local stations were warning that traffic was stopped between here and Phx on the interstate as early as 615am local time. Fifteen mins. ago they were reporting the same.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
wtcmedicdidntforget says:
being a bus driver can be rough. odd hours, groups pushing you to drive without a stop. by law can can drive for 10 hours at a stretch. in your own auto you can nap if tired, in a bus the driver has no choice but to try and stay awake.
reply
See all 19 Comments