The Nation/ February 18, 2010, 8:59 AM

How does Senator Mellencamp Sound?

The guy who put populist politics on the charts with a song title "Pink Houses" John Mellencamp performed at the White House last week, as part of a program titled: "In Performance at the White House: A Celebration of Music from the Civil Rights Movement."

The Rock-and-Roll Hall of Fame member sang the song "Jim Crow" with veteran folkie Joan Baez -- as well as a terrific song version of "Keep Your Eyes on the Prize" -- on a night that also featured performances by Smokey Robinson, Natalie Cole, Yolanda Adams, the Five Blind Boys from Alabama and Bob Dylan, among others.

That was powerful company, but Mellencamp was up to it.

For the past quarter century, he has been penning and performing smart, often very political songs -- focusing on the farm crisis, economic hard times and race relations. He's been a key organizer of Farm Aid and other fund-raising events for good causes, and he's been a steady presence on the campaign trail in recent years, appearing at the side of numerous Democratic presidential candidates, including Barack Obama.

So, could Mellencamp perform in the U.S. Senate?

Could he be the right replacement for retiring Senator Evan Bayh, D-Indiana?

Forget the blah-blah-blah about celebrities in politics. We crossed that bridge decades ago.

The question is whether this celebrity makes the right connections with this state.

Mellencamp certainly has the home-state credibility. Few rockers have been so closely associated with a state as Mellencamp with Indiana.

Mellencamp has a history of issue-oriented political engagement that is the rival of any of the Democratic politicians who are being considered as possible Bayh replacements.

And Mellencamp has something else. He has a record of standing up for disenfranchised and disenchanted working-class families in places like his hometown of Seymour, Indiana.

In other words, he's worthy of the consideration that has led to talk of a "Draft John Mellencamp" movement. In fact, he might be just enough of an outlier to energize base votes and to make independent voters look again at the Democratic column.
Mellencamp's not making any campaign moves.

He's a savvy player who has been around power politics for a long time -- he counts Bill Clinton as a pal -- and he's smart enough (and humble enough) to know that the leap from rock star to senate candidate is a long one.

But John Hall, the songwriter and leader of the band Orleans, is now a two-term Democratic congressman from New York.

And the Republicans have run more than a few actors for jobs like senator, governor and even president.

Notably, President Ronald Reagan's 1984 reelection campaign wanted to use the song "Pink Houses" at campaign events. And John McCain's 2008 presidential campaign did indeed use it, even as Mellencamp explained that the Arizona senator might not fully "get" the point of the song about working families living on the backroads of America.

So Mellencamp has already crossed some partisan and ideological lines.

That's more than can be said for most Senate prospects -- be they Democrats or Republicans.



By John Nichols:
Reprinted with permission from The Nation
The Nation
47 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
jda1952 says:
shut up and sing!
reply
suenaustin replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
"shut up & sing?" Last I checked Mellencamp can speak just as freely as you can -- except people are more interested in him than in you and your efforts to suppress his opinions.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
sl3_007 says:
Mellencamp is not what we need. Isn't there a good accountant in Indiana that could run?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
DasaniDude5 says:
Wow, talking about a guy thats just too full of himself! Wow.,

Jess
www.anonymous-tools.se.tc
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ludvig1-2009 says:
Let's see. A comedian, a nude model, and a musician all in the Senate. Somehow, I don't think this is what the founding father's envisioned.
reply
hopper21 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Actually, you're wrong.

They wanted wealthy white male landowners, which describes Franken, Brown, and Mellencamp.

That being said, Go John Go!

Mellencamp for Senate!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
noloyalisti says:
The GOP ruined the economy of the US with their corporate welfare and entitlement programs. They have been wrong about everything for the last 30 years and are no longer wanted in America. The wreckage of the Republicans are knee deep all around us.

You even have dirtbag right wing terrorists flying planes into buildings. The idiot voted to cut taxes on the rich and then doesn't want to live to see what he has done. Typical tea bagger moron.
reply
widollar replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Your comments are right on the money! The GOP misfits are all train wrecks for America! No good plans of their own, only attacking all Democratic ideas to stop Obama! Sickening actually!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rightbehind says:
Who controlled Congress during the Clinton years? Gee let me see, They tried to impeach him. They controlled the congress and senate. Republicans!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rightbehind says:
Ain't that America. You and me. Ain't that America. Land of the free!

John is a bring the jobs back or we'll shut the door behind you kind of man!

OH YAH! John would be the Greatest contribution to the Senate that Indiana could send!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
krzeaz says:
Mellencamp sounds like a dirtbag if he's a democrat.
reply
suenaustin replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
@krzeaz:
And what would he sound like if he was a Republican? Sweet music to your ears?
linkicon reporticon emailicon
91786 says:
Mellonhead is a petty person. He demanded that the GOP not use his music after is was published. When music is published, anyone can use it as long as they pay the fee. Mellonhead shows he is a petty, spiteful, small-thinking piece of dirt. He obviously cares less about the law.
reply
rightbehind replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
John is real common folk. Not the phony baloney drive an old truck pretend to be common folk. He would be a bring the US jobs back or we'll shut the door behind you kind of representative. He has helped many farming communities. I wish he was my representative.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
91786 says:
Mellonhead is a knee-jerk liberal that can not think on his own.
reply
suenaustin replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
@91786:
Mellancamp can't think on his own? That's funny -- why is it that Republicans are always stealing songs to play that were created by liberals?
See all 47 Comments
Scroll Left Scroll Right