February 11, 2010 7:34 AM

Baptists' Lawyer: They Had Paperwork

By
CBSNews
(CBS/ AP)  The new lawyer for 10 American Baptists charged with child kidnapping said Monday he believes they had paperwork to take 33 children out of the country after Haiti's devastating earthquake.

Attorney Aviol Fleurant's remarks came as investigators questioned the Baptist group's leader, Laura Silsby, who insisted she is innocent of any wrongdoing.

"I am trusting in God to reveal all truths and that we will be released and exonerated of charges," Silsby, of Meridian, Idaho, told reporters as she left a courthouse in Port-au-Prince. "We are just waiting for the Haitian legal process to be completed."

The rest of the group's members will be questioned this week over allegations they tried to take the children to the neighboring Dominican Republic without proper documents. The Americans said they were on a humanitarian mission to rescue orphans after Haiti's catastrophic Jan. 12 quake.

Who is Laura Silsby?
Haiti Earthquake - Latest Coverage
Haiti Relief: How You Can Help

Their Dominican lawyer, Jorge Puello, said at a news conference that the Haitian court was going to drop all charges against his clients Wednesday. Puello would not say where that information came from. Last week, he claimed nine of the 10 were about to be released.

"The judge will rule on Wednesday on whether or not to take the case or free them, and we already have assurances that they will drop the case," Puello told The Associated Press.

At least 20 of the 33 children had living parents. Some of those parents told The Associated Press they gave the kids to the group because the missionaries promised to educate them at an orphanage in the Dominican Republic and said they would allow parents to visit.

"Many of the parents who had the opportunity to speak out declared, in good faith, to have given their children to the Americans," Fleurant said.

"I also believe, really believe and I don't want to break the gag order from the court - that the Americans have a document, from somebody, an authorization to take the children with them."

It wasn't immediately clear who could have given the authorization.

CBS News went back to the tiny mountain village, home to 20 of the 33 children. Their parents refute almost all of Silsby's claims and said they never signed any papers.

"Lots of the kids had parents," Lelly Laruentus told CBS News correspondent Bill Whitaker, speaking in French. "I told Laura that."

Puello, retained by relatives of the 10 missionaries after their Feb. 1 arrest, said over the weekend that he fired their first Haitian lawyer - Edwin Coq - after Coq allegedly tried to bribe the missionaries out of jail. He had hired Coq to represent the detainees at Haitian legal proceedings.

Coq denied the allegation. He said the $60,000 he requested from the Americans' families was his fee.

Bernard Saint-Vil, the investigating magistrate, is in charge of finding out what happened in late January, in the days leading up to the arrest of Silsby and the others at the Dominican border.

The Dominican consul in Haiti, Carlos Castillo, has said he warned Silsby that she lacked the required papers and risked being arrested at the border for child trafficking.

The case has tapped into fears in Haiti that traffickers would take advantage of the chaos immediately after the quake to abduct children.

Amid those fears - and before the Baptists were detained - Prime Minister Jean-Max Bellerive announced that all foreign adoptions would need his personal approval.

At the same time, Bellerive has rushed to approve legal foreign adoptions that were already in the pipeline, said Jeanne Bernard Pierre, an adoptions official at the Haitian Ministry of Social Affairs.

Pierre did not have exact statistics. In terms of the United States, more than 650 orphans have gone to live there since the quake - compared to 330 for all of 2009 and 302 in 2008, U.S. Embassy spokeswoman Elizabeth E. Detmeister said.

Until Bellerive speeded up the process, it could take up to two years to complete all the formalities necessary for a foreign adoption, Pierre said.

Every day, prospective parents crowd outside the U.S. Embassy, waiting to apply for visas for the children they want to adopt.

Until last year, France was the country that adopted the most Haitian children, Pierre said. She said French parents adopted nearly half of the 1,000 children taken in by foreigners in 2008. It was the last official figure Pierre could remember; most records are buried in the rubble of government buildings in Port-au-Prince.

Thousands more Haitian children, orphaned and not, leave the country illicitly each year, according to the U.N. Children's Fund. They are forced into domestic or agricultural labor, used as sex slaves, or sold on the clandestine market for adoption.

CBS/ AP
Add a Comment
by kyleminli February 9, 2010 12:14 PM EST
Someone said the lawyers' charges were for bribery. Guess what, folks, bribery is a kind of tax that many people around the world pay to get things done. Don't tell me you're going to break the on-the-book laws of another country and then claim that the informal ways of a country--including bribery--are going to be out of the question for getting these people released. In many countries, you can't even get a driver's license without being extorted. Now you're going to say that getting people freed from jail isn't going to involve extortion? You can complain to high heaven all you want, but if you want these people freed you have to stop applying American law--both when you break other countries' laws and when you try to get Americans freed after they've broken those laws. We have to stop acting so naive as to apply American law overseas; it's completely naive! The only American laws that do apply overseas (in most cases) is American tax law--to Americans and American Green Card Holders (PRs) who work and earn money overseas. If you are either of these, you'll need to be in compliance with American law. Anyway, those who do the most basic research about going to another country would know that you don't start spouting off American law in Haiti or any other country. If you do, you'll only make enemies and won't have any friends in the country that has welcomed you. You are guests in the country. Stop breaking their laws and then blaming their legal system after the fact. Yes, I am an American who has lived overseas. Many years in Singapore and numerous visits to Malaysia. I wasn't arrested once during my time there. How is it that this group managed to get arrested in less than a week in Haiti? Easy. They didn't know the laws, but acted like they work experts on Haiti. Big mistake.
Reply to this comment
by Farver4girls February 9, 2010 12:32 AM EST
Fired or not, Attorney Coq should be paid the services he provided. But $60,000 for 4 days of work is out of the ball park. Many American attorneys charge about $200 per hour. The Baptists should pay Attorney Coq $200 per hour for his services.
Reply to this comment
by ffoulkes-2009 February 9, 2010 4:40 AM EST
First...the guy was court appointed...means paid by the Haitian government. Second...the money was obviously for bribery.
by formrusmcsgt February 8, 2010 9:42 PM EST
It wasn't immediately clear who could have given the authorization.
---
Jesus, most likely....
Reply to this comment
by ToolMangler1 February 8, 2010 11:04 PM EST
Don't worry... The Media doesn't want them released, They are getting more sales while they are covering the story of "Evil American Child Molesters" That will be prosecuted and provide even more fodder for the anti American sentiment in Latin America and the mideast. The media is not patriotic merely capitalistic backstabbers that will play any angle to sell a story. Walter Cronkite is dead and the industry is free to make its own news..
by obbbl February 8, 2010 8:30 PM EST
If the US government would just cut off the aid to the country, our citizens would be returned to us in a flash. I don't believe for one minute that this lawyer thought his fee was $60,000. It was obviously for the corrupt Haitian government.
Reply to this comment
by cidaia February 8, 2010 9:11 PM EST
Maybe some of us don't WANT those particular citizens back.

They're an embarrassment to our country.

Christians would be smart to disown them, not defend them. They're a disgrace to those doers of good works who are genuinely trying to help. (I assume there ARE Christians who are genuinely interested in helping, rather than just using crisis as an opportunity to exploit....)
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook