February 6, 2010 10:19 PM

Whaler, Activist Ship Clash in Antarctic

(AP)  The anti-whaling ship the Bob Barker and a Japanese harpoon boat collided Saturday in the icy waters off Antarctica - the second major clash this year in the increasingly aggressive confrontations between conservationists and the whaling fleet.

No one was injured in the latest smash-up, for which each side blamed the other.

The U.S.-based activist group Sea Shepherd, which sends vessels to confront the Japanese fleet each year, said the Japanese ship deliberately rammed the Bob Barker - named after the U.S. game show host who donated millions to buy it for the anti-whaling group.

However, Japan's Fisheries Agency said the activist boat caused the collision by suddenly approaching the harpoon vessel No. 3 Yushin Maru to throw bottles containing butyric acid in an attempted attack on the Japanese ship.

The Japanese agency accused Sea Shepherd of "committing an act of sabotage" on the Japanese expedition, noting that it is allowed under world whaling restrictions as a scientific expedition. Conservationists call the annual hunt a cover for commercial whaling.

"We will not tolerate the dangerous activity that threatens Japanese whaling ships and endangers the lives of their crew members," it said in a statement late Saturday.

Neither side's account could be verified. Video shot from the Bob Barker and released by Sea Shepherd shows the two ships side by side moving quickly through the water. The ships come closer together and the Japanese ship then appears to turn away, but its stern swings sharply toward the Bob Barker. The collision is obscured by spray, but a loud clanging noise can be heard before the vessels separate.

Saturday's collision was the second this year between a Sea Shepherd boat and the Japanese fleet.

On Jan. 6, a Japanese whaler Ady Gil and sheared off its nose. The Bob Barker then came to rescue the crew of the Ady Gil, which sank a day later.

Sea Shepherd and the whalers have faced off in Antarctic waters for the past few years over Japan's annual whale hunt, with each side .

Sea Shepherd activists try to block the whalers from firing harpoons, and they dangle ropes in the water to try to snarl the Japanese ships' propellers. They also hurl packets of stinking rancid butter at their rivals. The whalers have responded by firing water cannons and sonar devices meant to disorient the activists. Collisions have occurred occasionally.

Japan aims to take hundreds of whales each year - mainly minke whales, which are not endangered - under a program that is allowed despite the international moratorium on killing whales because it is done in the name of science. Critics say the scientific program is a front for commercial whaling, and much of the meat is eaten.

On Saturday, the Bob Barker found the whaling fleet for the first time since the time of the Ady Gil clash, Watson said.

Sea Shepherd founder Captain Paul Watson said by satellite telephone on Saturday that the Bob Barker took up a position behind the Nisshin Maru - the Japanese factory ship where dead whales are hauled aboard and butchered - so the four harpoon vessels could not reach it, he said.

"The harpoon ships started circling like sharks," Watson told The Associated Press from his ship, the Steve Irwin. "They were making near passes to the stern and the bow of the Bob Barker, then the Yushin Maru 3 intentionally rammed the Bob Barker."

The Bob Barker sustained a 3-ft. long, 4-inch wide gash in its hull. Welders aboard the ship were already working on patching the hole, and the Bob Barker would resume its pursuit of the whalers, Watson said.

Watson said the Yushin Maru 3 appeared to stop moving after the collision and had not been seen by the Bob Barker's crew to have moved since, suggesting it also may have been damaged.

The Japanese fisheries statement said the Bob Barker caused the collision by coming in too close to throw butyric acid - smelly, rancid butter that spoils whale meat - onto the Japanese vessel. "The No. 3 Yushin Maru immediately moved away to avert a collision, but it was grazed in its tail area," the Fisheries Agency statement said.

The clash caused No. 3 Yushin Maru minor damage - its railing was slightly bent - but involved no injuries among crewmembers, the agency said.

The governments of Australia and New Zealand, which have responsibility for maritime rescue in the area where the hunt is usually conducted, say the fight between the two sides is becoming increasingly dangerous and have repeatedly urged them to tone it down.


On the Web:
Sea Shepherd video: http://www.seashepherd.org/matilda/video.html
Institute of Cetacean Research: http://www.icrwhale.org/eng-index.htm

© 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Add a Comment See all 31 Comments
by likeitbe February 8, 2010 12:58 AM EST
The fact that the Sea Shepherd group was in the area with no obvious purpose than to interfere with the Whalers clearly shows that they initiated the whole encounter. Clearly, the Whalers would be well within their rights to sink these jerks.

Were any harm to come to the Whaling vessels, the courts should see to it that Sea Shepherd bears the cost.
Reply to this comment
by vietnamwar February 7, 2010 9:58 PM EST
SINK THE GREEN PEACE....
Reply to this comment
by ianlou February 7, 2010 3:19 PM EST
Nuke a Gay Whale for Christ.

That about covers it.
Reply to this comment
by Dgunner February 7, 2010 11:04 AM EST
By the time the whale is extinct and the whales they hunt are plentiful. Most posting here will be dead and long gone. The absence of a speceices will be part of the new frontier built by future generations. in other words acceptable losses.Thw whiteman slaughtered and starved and murdered with viruses the native american of all tribes .We as a nation put under acceptable losses.Acceptable to whom ? You might ask. I can't give you the answer but to slaughter anything to extinction is wrong but is part of the make up of man.History records it and future generations learn from past history. What we leave them to compare to and embrace thier future with is a deadly foundation of ideas and technology.
Reply to this comment
by libftw February 7, 2010 4:36 PM EST
Seriously, go back to cut and paste. I know English can be tricky, but even your logic patterns are chaotic.
by cidaia February 7, 2010 5:39 PM EST
If you don't like the way the law of the jungle works, then figure out a better way.

Waiting for the strong to stop eating the weak just isn't working. Predators just don't CARE about the opinions of rabbits.
by dontknowitall February 7, 2010 9:31 AM EST
"Research vessel"? Sea Shepherd Conservationists should be treated like the terrorist organization that they are. The Japanese whalers should be allowed to protect themselves on the High Seas at all costs.
Reply to this comment
by prajaowain February 7, 2010 3:21 AM EST
Hey all free thinkers! Beware edgy44 works for Uncle Sam.
Reply to this comment
by prajaowain February 7, 2010 3:16 AM EST
Where is the bacon edgy44? You parasite henchman.
Reply to this comment
by emmaliza1 February 7, 2010 1:48 AM EST
I don't see any difference between Greenpeace and the Taliban, both using terror and 'war' to punish 'non-believers'. It's interesting to see how many comments subscribe to these methods. Courts of law exist to prove your case against another; to use violence to gain your ends is barbarian.
Reply to this comment
by Ceres6 February 7, 2010 2:40 AM EST
It seems the japanese believe they have the right to exterminate all the whales from face of the earth. Long life to the Conservationists for protecting the whales, a magnificent species that belong to all mankind, not just to the selfish and greedy japanese.
by cidaia February 7, 2010 5:42 PM EST
Yes, some people think terrorism becomes justifiable if they happen to hate the group targeted.

Some people confuse "saving" things with scapegoating. I never understood how villifying lumberjacks would save our forests, and I don't understand how villifying whalers is going to save any whales. In both cases, the real problem isn't the guy who is paid to do his job. It is a problem that has its roots in the fact that we are running out of planetary resources, and we aren't finding ways to solve the problems, so instead we just scapegoat some guy for being the one who harvests whatever it is we ourselves are probably going to consume later.

How many liberals have bamboo flooring in their mcmansions? No, no, oak is so much prettier!
by prajaowain February 6, 2010 9:01 PM EST
Do the Japanese realize how selfish it is for them to stuff their fat faces with whale meat at the expense of the such graceful and magestic creatures? How evil and selfish can one be? They behave like serial killers of the high seas. The U.S should sink those ships.
Reply to this comment
by cidaia February 7, 2010 5:49 PM EST
wow, they're evil and selfish for wanting to eat?

That's a real solution. Why don't we just persuade the Japanese to not want to "stuff their fat faces"? Hey, maybe if you just call them NAMES they'll agree to eat nothing but CARROTS!
by prajaowain February 6, 2010 8:52 PM EST
We should sink those *** ships for murdering our brothers the whales. Whales are highly evolved mammals like us humans and their lives are of equal importance.
Reply to this comment
by prajaowain February 7, 2010 3:13 AM EST
Only a power pig like you would say that.
by prajaowain February 7, 2010 3:15 AM EST
Where is the bacon?
See all 31 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook