December 14, 2009 1:02 PM

Clinton Jabs Iran over U.S. Hikers

(AP)  Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said Monday that Iranian charges against three detained Americans are "totally unfounded" and appealed anew to authorities in Iran to release them.

Clinton said the three were in no way involved in any questionable activity and were simply hiking near the Iraq-Iran border when they allegedly crossed an unmarked border. Her comments came after Iran's foreign minister said the three had "suspicious aims" and would stand trial. Iranian officials have said earlier the trio is suspected of espionage.

"We consider this a totally unfounded charge," Clinton told reporters. "There is no basis for it. The three young people who were detained by the Iranians have absolutely no connection with any kind of action against the Iranian state or government."

"In fact, they were out hiking and unfortunately, apparently, allegedly, walked across an umarked boundary," she said. "We appeal to the Iranian leadership to release these three young people and free them as soon as possible."

The Americans - Shane Bauer, 27, Sarah Shourd, 31, and Josh Fattal, 27 - were detained after crossing the border from Iraq on July 31. The three graduates of the University of California at Berkeley had been trekking in Iraq's northern Kurdistan region, their relatives say.

They have been held in Tehran's Evin prison, where Swiss diplomats who represent U.S. interests in Iran have visited them twice.

Earlier Monday, Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki said the three would be tried but would not say when proceedings would begin.

"They will be tried by Iran's judiciary system and verdicts will be issued," Mottaki told a news conference in Tehran, without elaborating. He said the three were still being interrogated.

© 2009 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Add a Comment See all 11 Comments
by muslimpoxbyebye December 16, 2009 1:45 AM EST
Memorize this:
?Islam is an absurd theology of an immoral Bedouin, a rotting corpse which poisons our lives." - Kemal Ataturk? the Turkish genius , himself a muslim.
A MUSLIM WILL SHOOT THE AMERICAN AND SMALL BRITAIN'S GENERALS IN A MARCHPAST .... EGYPT ALL OVER AGAIN IN AMERICA and SMALL BRITAIN .... WHEN THE CHILREN AND GRAND-CHILDREN OF THE JUDGES WHO SET ALL THESE MUSLIM IDIOTS FREE IN THE US AND THE EUROPEAN UNION ARE HUNTED DOWN BY THE VERY MUSLIMS THAT THEY THEMSELVES FREED ... SOME SENSE WILL COME TO THEM. THE MUSLIM POX IS WORSE THAN SMALL POX.... GET READY .... IT'S AMONGST ALL OF US ....WE'RE ALL SCREWED ... AND OUR CHILDREN TOO.... THE MUSLIMS SHOULD HUNT FOR THE JUDGES ...HOWLING AALAAAHUUU AKKKKHHBAAR....WHICH BY THE WAY MEANS ALLAH (THE IDIOT :) IS GREATER....ONLY THEN THE CHANGE WILL COME ...
FIRST THINGS FIRST .... THE KORAN IS NOT A HOLY BOOK....IT IS THE MOST EVIL AND RACIST AND SEXIST BOOK EVER WRITTEN. IT IS A SLUR TO THE WRITTEN WORD. IT IS AN INSULT TO HUMAN INTELLIGENCE. HAVE NO DOUBT. READ IT TO DISBELIEVE IT . ALL MUSLIMS SHOULD BE TRYING TO GET OUT OF ISLAM'S CLUTCHES . ALL MUSLIMS SHOULD BE TRYING TO GET OUT OF ISLAM'S CLUTCHES NOT ONLY FOR THEIR SAKE AND THEIR CHILDREN'S SAKE BUT FOR THE SAKE OF THEIR FOREFATHERS AND FOREMOTHERS WHO WERE CONVERTED TO THIS EVIL AND VILE CULT BY THE SWORD AND FRIGHT. FORGET CHRISTIANITY IF IT?S SUCH A BIG ISSUE ?MUSLIMS NEED TO MOVE OUT EN MASSE TO SOMETHING LIKE BUDDHISM.



MUSLIMS SHOULD START REALISING THAT THEIR FOREFATHERS WERE FORCED INTO THIS BLOOD THIRSTY CULT BY BLOOD AND SWORD.THEY BECAME MUSLIMS OUT OF FEAR NOT BECAUSE THEY LOVED ISLAM. THE NEW GENERATION SHOULD SET THEIR FOREFATHERS' MISTAKES RIGHT BY GETTING OUT OF ISLAM EN MASSE (IN BIG GROUPS) AND RETURNING TO THEIR OLD PEACEFULL RELIGIONS OF THEIR GREAT GREAT GRAND PARENTS BEFORE THE MUSLIMS CAME AND TURNED THEIR LIVES AND MORALS UPSIDE DOWN. WHATEVER IS PREACHED IN THAT CULT IS THE EXACT OPPOSITE OF WHAT GOOD PEOPLE AND CITIZENS SHOULD BE. START THE CHANGE NOW. ONLY THE MUSLIMS CAN HELP THEMSELVES SMASH THIS EVIL CULT THAT HAS GOT THEM AND THEIR WOMEN AND CHILDREN BY THE THROATS.

THE WEST SHOULD BE HELPING MUSLIMS WITH A FREE SERVICE OR A NOMINAL CHARGED SERVICE WHICH COULD TRACE EACH OF THEIR ANCESTRAL ROOTS OR RELIGION PRACTICED BEFORE THEY HAD TO BOW TO ALLAH OR DIE HORRIBLY. THEN THE CHOICE WOULD BE THEIRS TO CONTINUE IN THIS EVIL CULT OR OPT OUT TO WHAT WAS THEIR LIFESTYLE OR RELIGION BEFORE THE MADNESS CAME. THE SERVICE COULD BE CALLED ?BEFORE THE MADNESS?. THE EDUCATED WEST HAS TO HELP THESE BARBARIC PEOPLE SEE THE LIGHT OF PEACE AND LAUGHTER SO THEIR CHILDREN AND WOMEN MAY APPRECIATE THE SUNLIGHT WHICH IS OUR PLANET?S BIRTHRIGHT.
Reply to this comment
by mrjustice1 December 15, 2009 9:43 PM EST
WSJ: Iran, Venezuela Share a Nuclear Dream
[see article and photo under above Dec 15 2009 CBSNEWS.COM heading]

THIS RATHER DISTURBING ITEM AND PHOTO HAS FAR MORE SERIOUS IMPLICATIONS
THAN MANY OF US CAN IMAGINE FOR AMERICA, AS WELL AS FOR THE ENTIRE WORLD!

We have two oil-and-gas-rich countries with leader-psychopaths who hate, and WANT TO DESTROY America. In fact both Achmadinejad and Chavez have openly stated such intentions.

Since both of their nations, Venezuela and Iran, do NOT need nuclear technology for energy, what conclusions should be drawn?

Obama's passive policies of burying our heads in the sand, have only emboldened America's sworn enemies to advance their aggressive military and other avenues against us.

It appears that we better reassess U.S. policy toward such nations, and toward those who plan to do harm to us.

There are times when we must resort to major and thorough military action in order to prevent a much worse scenario at a later moment in our history.

This is one of those times that the consequences of our inaction today, will very, very likely cost us dearly later. And reference is not being made to our enemies' building amusement parks!
Reply to this comment
by vietnamwar December 14, 2009 8:40 PM EST
ok, if this is 3 girls...call Bill Clinton but if this is a guys....forget it.....
Reply to this comment
by newsterl December 14, 2009 7:42 PM EST
Clinton said the three were in no way involved in any questionable activity and were simply hiking near the Iraq-Iran border when they allegedly crossed an unmarked border."

And how would SHE know this as a fact? was she there? No, so no one but the 3 know what they were REALLY doing over there.
And claiming to cross an "unmarked" border in the face of maps and GPS is BS, this isn't 1850 here with hand drawn maps on notepads!
Reply to this comment
by mrjustice1 December 14, 2009 7:31 PM EST
HOW TO TREAT ENEMY-NATION-TO-MANKIND IRAN,
AND IT'S PLANNED 'USHERING IN' OF THE MAHDI

The current Iranian regime's intentions and its Islamofascist agenda, is viewed by many responsible and experienced world leaders as a major threat to all mankind. These major world leaders of large and powerful countries as well as leaders of smaller and less powerful countries have by now recognized the fact that Iran's export and support of terrorism, and Iran's export of Islamofascist ideology is not working in the interests of the peoples and nations of the world. In fact, they know that the current Islamofascist Iranian regime is working HEAVILY AGAINST the peoples and nations of the world.

Since the current Islamofascist Iranian regime has visions(delusional and dangerous visions of power, domination and conquest) specifically for precipitating The Apocalypse
- nuclear 'white heat flashes' included -
that will pave the way for the Mahdi's return...


...NO FURTHER EXPLANATION OR APOLOGIES ARE NEEDED

ALL necessary action to render Iran's military harmless and reduce Iran's nuclear capabilities to rubble MUST BE taken, since the current Islamofascist Iranian regime continues to deceive the world and stall for time to develop its nuclear weapons.

In the meantime, we must all learn and understand not only about the return of The 12th Imam, or Mahdi, which is the Islamic version of Messiah or Savior, but we must also understand what Achmadinejad and his 'religiously delusional' Ayatollahs who lead Iran plan to do to accommodate and precipitate said Mahdi's arrival.


THE CURRENT DECEPTIVE ISLAMOFASCIST IRANIAN REGIME CANNOT BE TRUSTED

It is based on strict religious laws and rules, primitive hate, punishment and revenge. In its view, Islam must be imposed and followed or all others must suffer the consequences 'for being infidels'.

LEARN ABOUT AND RESEARCH THE MAHDI, AND ABOUT ACHMADINEJAD'S AND THE CURRENT ISLAMOFASCIST IRANIAN REGIME'S RELIGIOUSLY DELUSIONAL VISIONS AND PLANS FOR YOUR FUTURE

Reference is being made to required action in order to spare all mankind from the darkest era since Hitler and the Nazis in the 1930s and 1940s!
Reply to this comment
by NowBeWithThat December 14, 2009 5:23 PM EST
Hillary is trying hard to be a big player in the international arena, but she just comes off as a dowdy matron with a stink attitude.
Reply to this comment
by myeyedea December 14, 2009 3:57 PM EST
If you're going to go on holiday to an active warzone then you deserve any and all consequences that come of it. I don't know if anyone remembers the story about the FL teenager, Farris Hasaan, that decided to see for himself just what war in Iraq looked like and stole over to the Middle East to have a look around. He said he wanted to do his homework and see for himself just what things were like in Iraq and going the "extra couple thousand miles" into an active war would be the ultimate way to show how sorry he is for being a priveledged, sheltered American. All the news agencies that reported on his secret trip over there laughed and thought it was just a funny little story of poor judgement by a naive young man. That's beyond poor judgement. That's 100% American arrogance. He got out totally unharmed, and as far as I'm concerned, that was too good an outcome for him. These hikers are showing the exact same thing, 100% American arrogance and entitlement. Nothing but a pure narcissitic idiot would think it's ok to go traipsing about a country in the midst of fighting for its own identity, and one that is split so many ways over its feelings about Americans an abacus is needed to keep up with all of it. And not only did the hikers go to a country the US government has one of the highest travel warnings on, they chose to go walking near the border of a country that's just downright opposed to just about all things American. It doesn't matter if the border was unmarked or not, they were close enough to be in questionable territory, just like those reporters that ventured over into North Korea. I don't have a lick of sympathy for any of them; I can't say I hope they get killed because I surely do not, but if that's what comes of their escapade then they took that consequence on themselves when they made plans to go into the fire.
Reply to this comment
by mjlewis6 December 14, 2009 1:28 PM EST
Iran is also holding another chip that I notice is missing from this article: The disappearance of one of their nuclear scientists who went on a Haijj to Saudi Arabia. Iran is claiming the US is holding him. No admission from Iran that this person holds confidential nuclear secrets about the Iranian nuclear program either.

Expect a standoff over the situation.
Reply to this comment
by yermamma December 14, 2009 1:10 PM EST
The charges against the hikers may be unfounded, but why were they hiking there in the first place? If 3 Iranians had illegally crossed the US boarder, what would we do? Would we assume them to be terrorists? Spies? Would we slap them on the hand and send them right home? We've been pushing our "Do as we say not as we do" foreign policy for so long that we don't know anything else. It's like 3 teens playing with a loaded gun and we blame the maker of the gun if something happens. I hope they are returned but they had no business being there.
Reply to this comment
by kikamybutt December 14, 2009 1:10 PM EST
I say send Carter's delegation,he works so well with Iran.
Reply to this comment
See all 11 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook