December 3, 2009 12:14 PM
- Text
Mammogram Guidelines Explained
(CBS)
Last month, a government-appointed panel recommended that most women start getting mammograms at age 50, rather than 40, and have follow-up screenings every two years, instead of every year.
After a nationwide uproar, members of the task force were questioned about the changes at a congressional hearing on Wednesday.
Critics Still Outraged on Mammogram Ruling
Mammography Debate Puzzles Many
New Mammogram Advice Sparks Concerns
Alternatives to Mammograms
Read more about Healthy Living
CBS News medical correspondent Dr. Jennifer Ashton explained on "The Early Show" that the panel hasn't changed any of their policy, guidelines, or recommendations.
"They simply repackaged the way in which it was stated," Ashton said. "To be clear, those guidelines were significant as much for what they found as for what they didn't find, specifically this task force acknowledges that mammograms do save lives, even for women in their 40s."
Mammograms are not a perfect screening test, Ashton said. Mammograms can potentially miss cancers -- resulting in a false negative -- and can find things in the breast that are not cancerous -- a false positive.
"In their opinion, it does more harm than good (to do mammograms), so they're leaving it up to the women and their doctors to make individual choices," Ashton said.
The government panel, Ashton pointed out, did not contain a medical oncologist or cancer specialist, radiologist or other expert in imaging tests, or doctor who works with women on an everyday basis, such as a gynecologist.
Ashton said, "Women need to be their own health advocate and discuss any confusion, any concerns, as well as screenings, with their doctors."
As for the panel finding that self-breast exams are not viable or valuable, Ashton said she thinks women should continue to perform self-breast examinations and know their own bodies.
After a nationwide uproar, members of the task force were questioned about the changes at a congressional hearing on Wednesday.
Critics Still Outraged on Mammogram Ruling
Mammography Debate Puzzles Many
New Mammogram Advice Sparks Concerns
Alternatives to Mammograms
Read more about Healthy Living
CBS News medical correspondent Dr. Jennifer Ashton explained on "The Early Show" that the panel hasn't changed any of their policy, guidelines, or recommendations.
"They simply repackaged the way in which it was stated," Ashton said. "To be clear, those guidelines were significant as much for what they found as for what they didn't find, specifically this task force acknowledges that mammograms do save lives, even for women in their 40s."
Mammograms are not a perfect screening test, Ashton said. Mammograms can potentially miss cancers -- resulting in a false negative -- and can find things in the breast that are not cancerous -- a false positive.
"In their opinion, it does more harm than good (to do mammograms), so they're leaving it up to the women and their doctors to make individual choices," Ashton said.
The government panel, Ashton pointed out, did not contain a medical oncologist or cancer specialist, radiologist or other expert in imaging tests, or doctor who works with women on an everyday basis, such as a gynecologist.
Ashton said, "Women need to be their own health advocate and discuss any confusion, any concerns, as well as screenings, with their doctors."
As for the panel finding that self-breast exams are not viable or valuable, Ashton said she thinks women should continue to perform self-breast examinations and know their own bodies.
Popular Now in CBS News
- Teen's Facebook Sex Scam
- The Best Pregnancy Tests
- Pom-Pom Mom Goes To Extreme
- Eight Delicious Foods That Help Fight Belly Fat
- Cyberbullying Continued After Teen's Death
- Which Yogurts Are Healthiest?
- Perks of Five-Hour Energy Put to Test
- How Long Foods Stay Fresh In Fridge
- "Designer Babies" Ethical?
- Ten Healthiest Fast Food Chains
- Could Protein Shakes Harm Your Health?
- Best Low-Tech Cell Phones Suitable for Seniors
- Electronic Cigarettes: Are They Safe?
- Can Exercise Make You Gain Weight?
- How to Stop a Cold Before It Takes Hold
- Best Sleep Positions To Rid Aches, Pains
- Countertop Makeover In A Paint Can
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- Hacker claims porn site users compromised
- Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood wants government sacked
- Jordan holds ex-intelligence chief in graft probe
- Palestinian prisoner on 55th day of hunger strike
on Facebook
- Adele sings a cappella for Anderson Cooper
- Beyonce and Jay-Z post first photos of Blue Ivy Carter
- Adele sings a cappella for Anderson Cooper
on CBS News





