Alternatives to Mammograms

(CBS)  As health experts and women continue to debate when a woman should get their mammograms, what about the other options? Who should get an MRI? What's the difference between an ultrasound and a mammogram?

Critics Still Outraged on Mammogram Ruling
Mammography Debate Puzzles Many
New Mammogram Advice Sparks Concerns

"Early Show" contributor and WCBS-TV's Dr. Holly Phillips discussed on the broadcast the different screening measures for breast cancer -- and which may be best for you.

METHODS:

Home breast exam plus a clinical exam (least invasive)
Phillips said she still encourages women to perform breast exams at home, regardless of the guidelines. She said a large number of women find their own breast tumors -- they just discover them on their own.

Ultrasound
Ultrasound, Phillips said, is better for younger women. She explained breasts among young women are often denser, which makes mammograms less accurate.

Phillips said ultrasound is not yet widely proven to be as accurate as a mammogram or MRI. She said currently ultrasound is used alongside mammogram screening.

And for women 30 to 39, ultrasound is a very sensitive screening tool for breast cancer that has no radiation, Phillips said.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
Phillips said MRI is most expensive, yet most accurate breast cancer screening method.

Often utilized among very at-risk women, Phillips said the screening method may, at times, be overly accurate, finding things that may not be necessary. She added that MRI, also, has no radiation.

[olson4]

Why isn't anyone researching and discussing thermography? In many cases it can detect physiological changes that will justify a biopsy or mri of which none of these 3 options has radiation. thermography is a screening tool and I am glad they are admitting that mammography is not the perfect or only screening tool.

[darkferious]

Finally, more talk about options! MRI is more accurate and does not involve radiation, I wish that this method got more press and more support from insurers!