November 19, 2009 3:47 PM

Gates Unveils Pentagon Probe of Fort Hood

By
CBSNews
(CBS/ AP)  Updated at 2:55 p.m. EST

Defense Secretary Robert Gates is putting former Army Secretary Togo West and former Navy chief Vernon Clark in charge of a broad Pentagon review of the circumstances surrounding the Fort Hood shootings.

"The most important thing for us now is to find out what actually happened, put all the facts together and figure out a way where we can do everything possible so that nothing like this ever happens again," Gates told reporters during press conference Thursday with Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the joint chiefs.

Gates said the 45-day review will look into gaps in how the military identifies service members who might be a threat to others.

"The shootings at Fort Hood raise a number of troubling questions that demand complete but prompt answers," Gates said. He said the review would seek to ensure the health and safety of military members and their families.

The review also will look at personnel and medical programs, and at how well U.S. bases are able to respond to mass casualty incidents.

"All of the services potentially have some of the same problems that the Army's trying to deal with," Gates said. "I have every confidence in the army's ability to do this. But I think it's important that we look at it from a departmental-wide perspective."

Mullen told reporters that members of the country's armed services wouldn't have to be told to look for possible potential threats within their units.

"It doesn't take this kind of direction to have leaders recognize the challenges that are associated with this," Mullen said. "Every base, every unit literally, leaders have, I think, immediately grabbed this to look within, to kind of see where they are and to look at whether there's potential or not."

Both officials were asked what military families in Fort Hood or at other bases across the country should be watching for.

"No one should draw any rapid conclusions," Mullen said. "We need to ensure that we treat everybody fairly."

Mullen specifically was asked what he would do if was in charge of a sailor making radical statements.

"My expectation is for any commander to certainly to be aware of those kinds of things and then to take appropriate action, to certainly not sit idly by but to address it and there are a lot of simple ways to address it and a single proclamation isn't determinate," Mullen said.

Gates told reporters that the review will benefit the way the military handles service personnel overcome with stress.

"You go to the hospitals and you talk to the nurses and the doctors and those who care for these grievously wounded young men and women, and I can't imagine the burden on them of doing that all day, every day," Gates said. "One of the things, for their own benefit, if nothing else, is for us to take a look at how are we helping them deal with stress, given the circumstances that they face."

West was Army secretary in the mid-1990s and later became secretary of veterans affairs. Clark was the chief of naval operations from 2000 to 2005.

The review will go well beyond the specific case of Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, the Army psychiatrist accused of killing 13 people and wounding more than 30 in the shootings at the Texas military post on Nov. 5.

CBSNews.com Special Report: Tragedy at Fort Hood

President Obama already has ordered a review of all intelligence related to Hasan, including his contacts with a radical Islamic cleric overseas and concerns about the major voiced by some medical colleagues, and whether the information was properly shared and acted upon within government agencies.

At a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing Wednesday, Attorney General Eric Holder said he was disturbed to learn that the Hasan had communicated the radical Islamic cleric.

Giuliani: Political Correctness to Blame for Fort Hood Rampage

Gates told reporters he agreed with the attorney general's assessment.

"Yes, it's disturbing," Gates said. "But before I draw any conclusions about it, I want to find out all the facts."

Investigators have said e-mails between Hasan and the imam, Anwar al-Awlaki, did not advocate or threaten violence. After the shootings, al-Awlaki's Web site praised Hasan as a hero. Holder said investigators still were gathering evidence in the case.

At the hearing, Holder was asked what he would do to prevent such an occurrence in the future.

"I think what we have to do is understand exactly what happened that led to that tragedy," Holder said. "Were their flags that were missed? Were there miscommunications or was there a lack of communication? And once we have a handle on that, I think that we can propose and work with this committee on ways in which we can prevent such a tragedy from occurring again."

"I will say that on the basis of what I know so far, it is disturbing to know that there was this interaction between Hasan and - and other people that is, I find, disturbing," Holder said.

As Congress prepared to open oversight hearings into the massacre, Rep. James Langevin, D-R.I., said Wednesday there was no suggestion that Hasan was working with others. "All the information we have is that this is a lone wolf," Langevin, a member of the House Armed Services Committee, said after a closed-door briefing on the Fort Hood investigation.

Sens. Susan Collins, R-Maine, and Joe Lieberman, a Connecticut independent, are investigating whether a breakdown in communications or poor judgment calls contributed to the shootings, considered the deadliest attack on a military base in the U.S. The Senate Homeland Security Committee that Collins and Lieberman sit on was expected to open hearings in the case Thursday.

A joint terrorism task force overseen by the FBI learned late last year of Hasan's repeated contact with the cleric, who encouraged Muslims to kill U.S. troops in Iraq. The FBI said the task force did not refer early information about Hasan to superiors because it concluded he wasn't linked to terrorism.

"The Fort Hood massacre also raises questions about whether there are unnecessary restrictions on information sharing and whether those restrictions resulted in a failure to trigger a further inquiry," Collins said.

Hasan's psychiatry supervisors at Walter Reed Army Medical Center had expressed concerns in May 2007 about what they described as Hasan's "pattern of poor judgment and lack of professionalism." The Associated Press had previously reported that doctors there discussed concerns about Hasan's overly zealous religious views and strange behavior months before the attack, but National Public Radio on Wednesday published an evaluation letter signed by the department's psychiatry residency program director, Maj. Scott Moran.

Moran concluded that Hasan still could graduate and did not deserve even probation because Hasan was able to improve his behavior once confronted by supervisors. About a year after Moran's memo was written, Hasan was selected for promotion from captain to major, a position that would give him increased pay and responsibilities. He would formally become a major in May 2009 and by July he was on his way to Fort Hood.

Rep. Tom Rooney, R-Fla., said any "telltale signs that he was a disgruntled major were not as apparent as the rumors you've heard." Rooney spoke to reporters after he left Wednesday's classified briefing.

Rooney, a member of the House Armed Services personnel subcommittee and a former Army lawyer, also said Hasan was qualified to be promoted but was in "more toward the bottom third of his class."

CBS/ AP
Add a Comment See all 37 Comments
by gangesdak November 20, 2009 7:12 AM EST
by ffsdafaifd November 20, 2009 5:58 AM EST

Is there a way CBS can stop such commercials in this space? Or, will CBS act the same way Pentagon and Gateas are going to act on Hasan investigation?
Reply to this comment
by 2012EOD November 20, 2009 6:43 AM EST
How many here saw this on the CBS site?

I will give you the answer - None, they would never post this.

President Obama, our troops are not a photo op. I also like the pay increase, good "PR".

Obama arrived on the base 3:19 p.m. local time (1 a.m. Eastern Standard Time) and received a rousing welcome from 1,500 troops in camouflage uniforms, many holding cameras or pointing cellphones to snap pictures.

"You guys make a pretty good photo op," the president said.

Standing on a riser wearing a blue suit and red tie, with a cluster of troops and a large American flag behind him, Obama expressed "the gratitude of the American public" and said his meetings in four countries over eight days in Asia will help deliver a "safer, more prosperous world for all of us."

He got a huge cheer when he told them he was increasing military pay. "That's what you call an applause line," he said, before boarding his jet and taking off at 4:11 p.m.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/19/AR2009111900904_pf.html
Reply to this comment
by pensacola8-2009 November 20, 2009 6:15 AM EST
We will see what Gates feeds to the media when the time comes.

It is a Lose Lose situation for Gates either way he spins the results to the public.

Trusting the Pentagon to probe this crime? Come on! That's like trusting a food company to inspect and report its' own health violations after a dozen people died of e.coli poisoning from eating their food.
Reply to this comment
by nnez4321 November 20, 2009 12:49 AM EST
Great! I hope they remember to give everyone at the Pentagon a crash course in what Islam and what Muhammed taught so they COMPLETELY understand ITS GOAL and what its followers are TAUGHT TO DO:

Islam means to "Submit." They want everyone in the world to "Submit" to them. That IS what it IS. It is not "extreme" believers who believe this...it is simply what ISLAM TEACHES.

When someone tells you they are a "muslim," they are saying this is what they believe!

You are such a bigot!

Go read a book! Islam translates to Submit in Arabic. This means to submit to God. A Muslim, one who practices Islam, submits to the will of God, i.e. Muslim means, One who submits.

Therefore the principles (5 pillars) of Islam are: The confession of faith, There is no god but God, and Muhammad is his prophet. Pray Five Times A Day. Be Generous to the Poor. Make The Hajj (Pilgrimage to Mecca) once in your lifetime.

No only that but, Allah literally means "the God" Arab Christians and Jews refer to God as Allah as well as Muslims. They worship the same God as Christians and Jews...this is a fact, go read.

Stop spreading your bigotry and ignorance!
Reply to this comment
by nnez4321 November 20, 2009 12:49 AM EST
Great! I hope they remember to give everyone at the Pentagon a crash course in what Islam and what Muhammed taught so they COMPLETELY understand ITS GOAL and what its followers are TAUGHT TO DO:

Islam means to "Submit." They want everyone in the world to "Submit" to them. That IS what it IS. It is not "extreme" believers who believe this...it is simply what ISLAM TEACHES.

When someone tells you they are a "muslim," they are saying this is what they believe!

You are such a bigot!

Go read a book! Islam translates to Submit in Arabic. This means to submit to God. A Muslim, one who practices Islam, submits to the will of God, i.e. Muslim means, One who submits.

Therefore the principles (5 pillars) of Islam are: The confession of faith, There is no god but God, and Muhammad is his prophet. Pray Five Times A Day. Be Generous to the Poor. Make The Hajj (Pilgrimage to Mecca) once in your lifetime.

No only that but, Allah literally means "the God" Arab Christians and Jews refer to God as Allah as well as Muslims. They worship the same God as Christians and Jews...this is a fact, go read.

Stop spreading your bigotry and ignorance!
Reply to this comment
by wdh3007 November 19, 2009 9:22 PM EST
Gates needs to man up & say that this was a terrorist incident instead of saying that he is not going to go there. This guy is a joke and should be the secretary of the postal service instead of the Secretay of Defense!
Reply to this comment
by fedup12 November 19, 2009 7:49 PM EST
Does anyone else see the contradiction here? A muslim psychiatrist.

No religion that regularly blows themselves up should be in charge of mental health.
Reply to this comment
by dontknowitall November 19, 2009 6:53 PM EST
Most people prefer to mind their own business. It's certainly apparent to those that have "gone out on a limb". To report issues against a co-worker for instance, the whistle blower is the one that ends up on the wrong end of the stick. No longer trusted by management and their peers. Careers are at stake here and reporting wrong doing in the military is a losing proposition. When the person reporting an issue isn't held in contempt more people will get involved. The only problem there is that there will be those that will start yelling Gestapo and KGB tactics. And you know who you are.
Reply to this comment
by 6591Hou November 19, 2009 6:35 PM EST
The man was screwed up, counseled for exceeding the Army's body fat percentage, counseled for actively seeking to convert his patients to Islam, counseled for tardiness, absenteeism, reported for all sorts of comments (not to mention his PowerPoint presentation)- and then they promoted him and shipped him out to Fort Hood.

We had an E-3 working on our security detail, at an ammunition storage facility, whose roommate came forward and alleged that the young man was talking about committing suicide. So we found out where he was, got him to psychiatric care for a screening, and he ended up being admitted indefinitely to a VA mental hospital (never saw him again).

It turned out that the four guard shifts had all had this individual on their shift where he engaged in various bizarre behaviors, and was ultimately reassigned from shift to shift. The NCOs in charge of each shift didn't tell the guard commander what was going on, they just made changes to the roster and went with it.

According to his doctor his suicidal thoughts were based upon the scenario that he wanted to kill everyone on his detail, but to avoid punishment for doing this he would have to kill himself.

The only reason we did not have a tragic outcome was because his roommate paid attention to what he was saying and reported it. When we received the report we acted.

The people who kept quietly reassigning him, rather than addressing the issue, were derelict in their duties and were disciplined for that, as was the guard commander for not being in control of the assignments in his security force.

Major Hasan apparently had a lot of issues going on, his approach to his religion being a chief factor but not the only one (i.e. out of shape, tardiness, lack of professionalism etc.). His behavior was reported, but not appropriately addressed, therefore his immediate superiors and anyone who received the reports of his activities are culpable.
Reply to this comment
by Lickedy November 19, 2009 6:29 PM EST
Yeah, just be nice to Hasan, he was just a little mentally disturbed and suffered under a lot of stress. Oh my, better take him over to the strip club so he can unwind, we wouldn't want anyone else to suffer with such stress, now would we ?
Reply to this comment
See all 37 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook