Nov. 3, 2009
Sarah Palin's Brutal Education
CBSNews.com Exclusive: An Excerpt from "Sarah From Alaska" -- a New Book Telling the Inside Story of Palin's Campaign for VP
-
Play CBS Video Video Behind McCain-Palin 'Civil War' Harry Smith spoke with co-authors Scott Conroy and Shushannah Walshe about the "civil war" going on behind the scenes of the McCain-Palin campaign.
-
(CBS)
-
Photo Essay Sarah Palin Alaska's youngest and first female governor tabbed to be McCain's running mate.
The authors share new insights and bring to light illuminating stories from Palin's governorship and vice presidential campaign. Read the excerpt below, which includes a prescient remark that Palin made to senior campaign aides after her debate with Joe Biden and revealing emails that demonstrate how she worked behind the scenes to try to convince the campaign's top strategists not to give up on winning the state of Michigan, much to their annoyance.
Scott Conroy is a digital journalist for CBS News, and Shushannah Walshe was formerly a reporter and producer with Fox News. "Sarah From Alaska: The Sudden Rise and Brutal Education of a New Conservative Superstar" is available now in bookstores.
THE OVERPOWERING SMELL OF cheeseburgers and French fries saturated the candidate's suite at the Philadelphia Westin Hotel. About a dozen staffers shuffled around the table set up in the middle of the room where hundreds upon hundreds of five-by-seven-inch note cards were spread out in two-foot-high stacks. Palin had been locked in there for hours, cramming for her debate against Joe Biden. The biggest test of the campaign was less than a week away.
On the heels of the first round of Katie Couric interviews, her margin for error was nonexistent. Joe Lieberman, a veteran of a previous vice presidential debate, had been brought in to give Palin an idea of what to expect. The stifling air shortened everyone's patience, and tensions were running especially high between debate prep coordinator Mark Wallace and foreign policy adviser Randy Scheunemann. It was the note cards that had first led to the longstanding feud between Wallace and Scheunemann a couple of weeks earlier. One of the aides wanted Palin to memorize them, while the other thought it better for her to learn conceptually. The spat made it all the way up the chain to Steve Schmidt, who told Scheunemann in no uncertain terms that he did not have the time for bickering between staffers and that they needed to sort it out. But the two men were still fuming at one another, and negative vibes permeated the room along with the smell of greasy food.
At the end of one cram session, Palin asked her advisers to run through the various trade agreements, including "who's in NAFTA, who's in CAFTA," and so forth. It seemed an unremarkable request at the time. The advisers knew that the governor was, in fact, aware that the NAFTA treaty included the United States, Canada, and Mexico. But someone in the room with a penchant for whispering to reporters was taking mental notes. Come November, the anonymous source would pass Palin's words along as part of a concerted effort to advance the exaggerated narrative that her handlers had been stymied in their heroic, yet futile, efforts to educate an ignoramus.
Steve Schmidt, Rick Davis, and domestic policy adviser Becky Tallent arrived in Philadelphia by train on Sunday, September 28. It was clear by the time they set foot in the suffocating hotel suite on the third full day of debate prep that a dramatic change was needed. Schmidt and Davis had already spoken to John McCain, who agreed to offer up his sprawling Sedona ranch. It did not take much persuasion to convince Palin of the benefits of moving the operation to the desert compound, where she could work in her shorts and T-shirt with her family by her side. Schmidt realized that the candidate would benefit from having a more condensed circle of aides to brief her, so he sent some of the staffers who had been with her in Philadelphia ahead to the debate site at St. Louis. Others who did travel to Sedona were barred from McCain's compound and had to remain at the hotel.
Palin and her downsized contingent of advisers arrived in Arizona the next afternoon. On the first evening of their stay, one of her aides spoke privately to the governor about the importance of speaking in her own voice, rather than regurgitating talking points handed down from the Washington insiders who ran the campaign, all of whom were white males. It was one piece of advice that Palin took to heart.
The preparations were kept informal except for two timed reenactments in which debate conditions were replicated, including the exact distance between the podiums. Randy Scheunemann had flown in to play Joe Biden, an acting role that the archconservative seemed born to play. Scheunemann had sat through years of Biden's speeches during his time working for two Republicans on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and he knew the Delaware senator's mannerisms well. Palin struggled to keep a straight face as Scheunemann peppered his performance with "God love ya"s and "literally"s and shifted between long-winded discourses on everything from the war in Iraq to his own mother. A former National Rifle Association lobbyist, Scheunemann as Biden delivered a passionate screed on banning assault rifles. When he waxed poetic on the issue of gay marriage, some of the aides looking on from the sidelines gave up on trying to maintain decorum and burst out laughing. At the end of the ninety-minute session, they broke out into spontaneous applause. Palin's keen memory for detail had manifested itself in her very first formal rehearsal, and she had done even better than they had hoped she would.
Watch Conroy and Walshe Talk About Their Book on "The Early Show"
Palin Jumps into N.J., Virginia Races
Palin Snubs Republican Candidate in House Race
Steve Schmidt: Palin "Catastrophic" for 2012, Good for 2008
Palin Finishes Memoir, Called "Going Rogue"
The next day, the group decided to move the debate operation outdoors so that they could take full advantage of the beautiful Sedona weather. The new environment continued to have a calming effect on Palin and everyone around her. Gone were the endless stacks of note cards and claustrophobic atmosphere that plagued the operation in Philadelphia. Palin looked refreshed as she stood behind her podium in a baseball cap and T-shirt. As evening shadows crept across the well-manicured grass, Cindy McCain came out from the house to address the group. She insisted that all toil must end at an appointed hour of 5 P.M., when everyone was to convene for wine and cheese. There were no arguments.
When Palin nailed a second ninety-minute mock debate, everyone was optimistic about the real thing, which was coming up the next day. By the time she and her aides left the ranch for St. Louis, their confidence was high enough that the hottest topic under discussion was whether the governor should wear blue or black. In the end, she went with black. The background, after all, would be blue.
Just minutes before the candidates shook hands on stage in St. Louis, Palin collected her thoughts in a room as she was joined by three top McCain advisers and her longtime Alaska aide Kris Perry. "Be still in the presence of the Lord!" Perry called out, as Palin bowed her head and prayed.
Palin would give her own version of this event several months later in a speech at a Republican Party dinner in Alaska. "So, I'm looking around for somebody to pray with. I just need maybe a little help, maybe a little extra," she said. "And the McCain campaign, love 'em, you know-there are a lot of people around me, but nobody I could find that I wanted to hold hands with and pray."
© MMIX, CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
More From Politics
Add a Comment See all 176 Comments
- Sarah is a quitbull with lipstick.....
- Reply to this comment
- by democracy1 November 6, 2009 7:52 AM EST
2nd rate universities, sorry. And hiring someone to balance your checkbook is not necessarily the same as allowing them ACCESS to your accounts. But all that is beside the main point I made which referred to the ability to engage in critical analysis in thinking and logic. Which, apparently, you lack. Have a lovely day. ;-)
That's just your opinion! There are many, including myself, who disagree with you! And when you hire someone to balance your checkbook you are giving them your account number and the nine or ten digit number located to the left of your account number on your checks. If they get those numbers they can order checks in your name and write checks on your account and forge your name to them. By the time you find out about it they can be long gone with your money! And another thing, I am very capable of engaging in critical analysis in thinking and logic but you don't think so because I disagree with you! You think that everyone who disagrees with you is uneducated and stupid! Hopefully before you leave this world you will accept that not everyone is going to agree with you! - Reply to this comment
- by democracy1 November 5, 2009 7:51 AM EST
by JV1970 November 5, 2009 4:06 AM EST
"some of the best universities in the country are located in the republican red state south"
*********
Oh really? Such as? And as to the "balancing checkbook" examples that you use, there are many more who have less education who do the same, so maybe that's just a human thing. I would rather know someone who is capable of critical analysis of logic than someone who regularly balances their checkbook. You can hire someone to balance the checkbook. The critical analysis you have to do on your own.
Oh just Auburn, Duke, Baylor, the University of Mississippi (Ole Miss), and Vanderbilt to name a few. There are many more. And another thing, it is NOT so smart to hire someone to balance your checkbook or manage your money in any way! Remember Bernie Madoff? Many so called "smart" people trusted him with their money and look where it got them! Really smart people balance their own checkbooks and manage their own money! They trust their checking accounts and their money to NO ONE but themselves! - Reply to this comment
-
- 2nd rate universities, sorry. And hiring someone to balance your checkbook is not necessarily the same as allowing them ACCESS to your accounts. But all that is beside the main point I made which referred to the ability to engage in critical analysis in thinking and logic. Which, apparently, you lack. Have a lovely day. ;-)
- Overall, it seems like a fair treatment, this article.
If Sarah wrote an article about someone, it would be full of half-truths and slanders and out-right lies. She prides herself in the "Mean Girl" 10th grade posture and isn't going to give it up, it gives her adrenalin. Anytime she is on the attack, she just hums like a snow-machine, or better yet a machine gun...rat a tat...take that you winning opponent. (and they always will be) Sarah Hannity. - Reply to this comment
- by laurelann11 November 4, 2009 9:57 AM EST
Since natural gas produces a carbon output, it is NOT "clean energy". Educate yourself before criticizing others! - Reply to this comment
- I think that it's being kind and diplomatic to say that Sarah Palin is not particularly bright.
- Reply to this comment
- As long as there are people out there who believe that Palin is their ticket to the White House she will continue to be a news item. This woman really needs to go back to Alaska and start taking care of her family and forget trying to fool us into thinking that she actually has what it takes to be the leader of the free world. There are many people around the world who do not share the evangelical beliefs that Palin subscribes to and she would not relate well. We need the support of the rest of the world and Obama has the ability to pull people together in a way that will be beneficial to America. Actually I hope she does get the republican nomination because that would assure another four more years for Obama. I will admit that when it comes to sex appeal Palin is loaded with it. But I would not really want to have to listen to her for any length of time. Pretty packages are sometimes disappointing.
- Reply to this comment
-
- Between her speech patterns and her lack of attention to facts, she would be an even worse President than GW, if that's possible. Think of it, she'd bomb Iran, get Roe v. Wade repealed, make her religion THE only one, because she does not tolerate any ideas except her own, and she wouldn't worry about the economy because it's much too complex when your economy doesn't run on the backs of the oil and gas companies.And forget about universal health care...not even on her radar that people in her own state are dying. I doubt she even understands that there are really poor people in this country, and they deserve help. Even FauxNoise called her out on her clain that Obama moved "In God We Trust" on the new dollar coins. A teeny bit of fact checking (or common sense?) would have told her that coins are not designed and stamped the next day, but are years in the making and that REPUBLICANS approved this change. But she doesn't care, because it gave her drooling supporters another reason to distrust this administration. Pitiful.
- by hockeymom441 November 4, 2009 1:40 PM EST
"...If she were Democrat, but otherwise the same person, you'd hate her.
Some repubs are so blinded by their devotion to the party that they cannot see straight."
*********
BINGO!!!!!!!!!!! - Reply to this comment
- I guess with the election of George W. Bush began the era of Republicans worshipping stupid people.
"Ignorant, and Proud of It!" GOP - Reply to this comment
- i don't have time to read this right now, but wonder if it details of just when it was that she had the epiphany that the united states was such a wonderful country after all that she should now run for vice-president of it? that in reference to belonging to a group that supports secession from the union?
when was that?
it seems it was when she got offered the job.
and what does that fact show?
that she is a self-serving politician and would sell out her beliefs for getting elected to office.
is that the sort of person the republicans want speaking for them? - Reply to this comment
- Peace Corps volunteers go thru a grueling application process, and are required, or at least encouraged to speak a foreign language. Civil servants in foreign embassies are required to know American local and foreign politics before being allowed to serve. Those who campaign for the country's decision-making posts are not held to these standards. That is how and why the Bush administration allowed 9/11 and lied about Iraq. This is why Americans fear people because they live in another country, which is complete stupidity. This woman couldn't even give the title of a single newspaper, magazine, or foreign news source online. Wake up, America! Only this woman's dangerous level of ignorance is newsworthy.
- Reply to this comment
- Would the Republicans keep giving her this much attention if she looked like Golda Meir? She is proof that even the prettiest wrapped presents can be a huge dissappointment when you open 'em.
- Reply to this comment
-
- by cidaia November 5, 2009 11:07 AM EST
Yes, but Republicans like that she's pretty.
And they really really like that Democrats don't.
********
So you agree that Republicans like pretty, vacuous nonsense and that Democrats prefer intelligence, integrity and character instead.
- by cidaia November 5, 2009 11:07 AM EST
- Gee, the News Media keeps telling us how out-of-the-running Palin is. If she were, why would they need to?
- Reply to this comment
- That is one of the things I find most endearing about Sarah. Every time she gets beat down by someone, including her own mishaps, she gets right back up for more. I like that in any person, 'no quittin' in the little girl from Alaska. I guess they know how to grow their women up there? I hope she succeeds in whatever she does, I believe she may be pushing a little too hard now, even though it remains to be seen.
- Reply to this comment
-
- No quittin'? She quit as mayor, she quit her post on the Oil and Gas Commission, she quit as Governor, and she'll quit whatever job she takes next. And she never admits that she makes any "mishaps," let alone that she lies, repeatedly. Everything is always someone else's fault. If you admire that in a person, she's your gal. I prefer a human being.
- Sarah Palin...pretty and stupid.
- Reply to this comment
- CBS and these authors are just using Sarah to make money. As someone from Alaska, I wish she would just go away. I live in Ketchikan (the bridge to nowhere city) and know firsthand what a hypocrite she is. She came here in favor of that ridiculously expensive bridge (you could take that amount of money and use it to buy each resident here a small boat) and when the story broke in the national media she lied and said that she had always been against it. She's just a big joke.
- Reply to this comment
- hey have ya'll seen that poster of Sara in a bikini holding a rifle??
Thats awesome..I never heard of her before I saw that!
lol - Reply to this comment
- I just love the animosity that Sarah Palin brings out in liberals :-) They try to bad mouth everything about her... very, very little of which is true. The truth is that even though she might not be perfect, she is a very good person!
If it would have been Palin-McCain instead of McCain-Palin, she would be president right now... At least she loves this country, which is a lot more than I can say for B.O.
----------------------------------------
You sound like one of those delirious Tea-baggers .....
one of those morons who is apparently not getting enough oxygen .... - Reply to this comment
-
- I'm not a Tea-bagger and I have a IQ of 129. I'm not a genius but I'm certainly NOT a moron and I'm a Palin supporter, too, and I agree with this person whoeever they are. And another thing, I live in an area where the air is clean and clear. I get plenty of oxygen!
- JV, don't bother trying to defend yourself against what amounts to a circle. If you don't agree with them, you're stupid, an ignorant bigot. How do they know? Because only a stupid, ignorant bigot would not agree with them. DUH!
Just remember: the Democrats ran out of policies years ago - they ran out of hope a decade after that. Now all they are running on is rage masquerading as superiority - they apparently experience it as something like a sense of "at least I'm not white trash."
They have everything they've got invested in their sense of superiority. They not only really think they're smarter...they really NEED to feel smarter....
- I just love the animosity that Sarah Palin brings out in liberals :-) They try to bad mouth everything about her... very, very little of which is true. The truth is that even though she might not be perfect, she is a very good person!
If it would have been Palin-McCain instead of McCain-Palin, she would be president right now... At least she loves this country, which is a lot more than I can say for B.O. - Reply to this comment
-
- Liberal or conservative, who cares? You can be conservative and dislike Sarah Palin and her politics. Perhaps she is a good person; there are many good people in this country, that doesn't mean they should be President or Vice President.
- If the ticket had been Palin-McCain, she would be POTUS right now???!!!!!
BWAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! What are YOU smoking?!
- LOL you have it very backwards - If it wasn't for Sarah Palin, John McCainn would be POTUS right now.
- by jayrh November 4, 2009 5:13 PM EST
I just love the animosity that Sarah Palin brings out in liberals :-) They try to bad mouth everything about her... very, very little of which is true. The truth is that even though she might not be perfect, she is a very good person!
If it would have been Palin-McCain instead of McCain-Palin, she would be president right now... At least she loves this country,
==========
yes you are right about that. she loved this country so much she was a member of a group wanting to secede from it.
then she gets an offer to further herself politically and threw that out and now she loves the untied states?
what a laugh!
- by hockeymom441 November 4, 2009 1:40 PM EST
I'm not a huge Couric fan, but what exactly do you admire Palin for... quitting her job as Governor, or is the ethics violations, perhaps the excessive spending on clothing... no wait, let me guess, her ability to raise a respectable teenage daughter w/ good conservative morale values... no, not that!?! Ok, it must be her reading and speaking ability. Come on, she's just terrible and what's scarier, is that people like you have been duped.
She's an embarassment to women, she's an embassment to the party, and worse of all, she's an embarassment to this country, as she travels around the world fattening her wallet trashing our own gov't.
If she were Democrat, but otherwise the same person, you'd hate her.
Some repubs are so blinded by their devotion to the party that they cannot see straight.by hockeymom441 November 4, 2009 1:40 PM EST
I guess you haven't heard about the latest book that was written about her. It's called Sarah From Alaska. I don't know who wrote it but in it a couple of RNC aides finally come clean and tell the truth about those clothes. They said that Sarah knew nothing about the cost of the clothes and she didn't order them or shop for them. They said that they cut the tags off the clothing before Sarah even saw the clothing. They said that they were ordered by John McCain and the RNC to buy the clothing. They said that they deliberately kept the cost of the clothing from Sarah because they knew that she wouldn't accept or wear the clothes if she knew the cost or where it came from. The truth is out about it. I suggest you read the book. It's time to stop accusing Sarah of something she didn't do. - Reply to this comment
Mike Huckabee on GOP "rock stars," 2012, health care reform and more.
