November 15, 2009 9:57 AM

"Wild Things": A Real Dream

By
CBSNews
(CBS)  I hold in my hand a rare thing, a perfect work: "Where the Wild Things Are." My copy!

I've read it to my daughters so many times, acted it out, too! It's about a boy's tantrum and his fed-up mother's rejection - bed without supper - and the dream that transports him in his wolf pajamas to a land of monsters that crown him king and help him act out all his rowdy, infantile impulses.

The Wild Things are on the border between cuddly and mythically grotesque.

In Sendak's work, fantasies can set you free . . . but if you're not careful, they'll eat you up!

Now there's a film, directed by Spike Jonze. He embellished the book, and with a work so compact, to expand is in some ways to diminish. Still, what a fabulous voyage!

The setting is real - the coast of Australia, a burned forest, a desert; the creatures are unreal, giant puppets, furry, feathered. Most animated movies bombard you with computer illusions. Here you bring your imagination to the party.

Max is played by a kid with an apt name: Max Records. A sweet face, but edgy. He doesn't ingratiate himself, which is why, I think, you end up loving him.

Same with the Wild Things. They're now personalities. They quarrel, they smash things, they wait for someone - even a boy in wolf pajamas - to tell them what to do.

"Let the wild rumpus start!"

The voices of the Wild Things are sublime. James Gandolfini is Carol, a needy lummox with no trace of New Jersey gangster.

Carol and Max bond over kids' fears like few kids in movies.

Some critics have griped there isn't much plot - I think there's enough exactly, (Sometimes, kids just sit around and break things.)

Others worry the monsters are too scary. I agree with Sendak, who told a press conference, "Let 'em wet their pants!" He knows kids like to be scared, especially when the story ends happily, when they emerge laughing (or even crying but safe) from that rumpus room that's every kid's fantasy life.

Most modern kids' movies are synthetic, processed. "Where the Wild Things Are" is the real dream.


David Edelstein Also Endorses:
  • "A Serious Man" by Joel and Ethan Coen: "Is it a comedy? A tragedy? It's right on the border, a broad Jewish joke that morphs into a jeremiad, a tale of woe - that keeps you wondering if the punch line, when it comes, will make you laugh or want to kill yourself, or both."
  • The micro-budget horror picture "Paranormal Activity": "I've never seen a movie that so cunningly exploits our anticipation."
  • Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
    Add a Comment
    by kenodenis October 18, 2009 8:12 PM EDT
    My husband and I took our 3 and 6 year old grandchildren to see this movie today. We both found this movie to be ecologically unfriendly, the "things" ruining trees by either ripping them out of the earth or punching huge holes in their trunks, then shooting down two owls in mid-air with huge rocks, ripping the wing off the chicken.... One moment we have Max telling a "thing" that the sun is dying, but it goes no further. THe only thing that goes further are displays of violence either amongst the things, or what they do to the trees and the owls. This movie sends the wrong messages. This movie is a one star, don't waste your money.
    Reply to this comment
    by frogger581 October 19, 2009 12:46 AM EDT
    The film is based on a fantasy story where the boy goes to a world IN HIS IMAGINATION where he can act out all he wants and not get punished... I don't know how many children have fantasy lands where they recycle everything and conserve water... You want to ruin Santa Clause too? Just watch the movie!!!
    by mnbrant October 18, 2009 7:36 PM EDT
    Yeah I noticed the lack of digitized animations right away when I saw the previews and was very impressed by what I saw. I really want to see this movie despite they fact that I am a 46 year old man with no kids. I felt the same about Harry Potter movies, and when I went to see the last one the theater was filled with 50 year old women. Not a kid in sight.
    Reply to this comment
    .
    Scroll Left
    Scroll Right More »
    CBS News on Facebook