Sweat Lodge Victim Was in "Top Shape"

Woman, 38, Had No Pre-Existing Conditions; Autopsies Performed on 2 Dead From Spiritual Cleansing Ceremony

(AP)  A 38-year-old New York woman who died after sitting in a sauna-like sweat lodge at a scenic Arizona resort was an avid surfer and hiker who was "in top shape," took self-improvement seriously and had a passion for art, a family spokesman said.

Kirby Brown of Westtown, N.Y., was one of two people who died Thursday evening after being overcome in the crudely built hut during a spiritual cleansing ceremony. Authorities on Saturday identified the other victim as 40-year-old James Shore of Milwaukee, who served as director of business development at an Internet marketing company in his hometown.

Nineteen other people were taken to hospitals, suffering from burns, dehydration, respiratory arrest, kidney failure or elevated body temperature. Most were soon released, but one remained in critical condition Saturday.

Brown had no pre-existing health conditions that would have kept her from participating in an otherwise safe activity, said cousin and family spokesman Tom McFeeley. That two people died and 19 others became ill at the Angel Valley Retreat Center indicates that "something went horribly wrong."

"Our only thought is shock, sadness and surprise," McFeeley said. "There will be plenty of time to react to the truth of what happened here, but we believe it is pointless to be angry or to place blame or to make assumptions before we understand what occurred here."

Matt Collins, who knew Shore since seventh grade, described his friend as a wonderful husband and father whose life revolved around his three kids. "Everybody who got to know him absolutely loved him," Collins told The Associated Press.

Collins said he was stunned to hear of Shore's death, and the family remained in shock.

"Right now we're trying to focus on making sure that his wife, his children are comforted during this time," he said.

Autopsies on Brown and Shore were conducted Friday, but the results weren't disclosed pending additional tests. Authorities have ruled out carbon monoxide poising as the cause.

Yavapai County Sheriff Steve Waugh said Saturday that his detectives were focusing on self-help expert and author James Arthur Ray and his staff as they try to determine if criminal negligence played a role. Waugh said Ray refused to speak with authorities and has since left the state.

"We will continue this investigation down every road that is possible to find out if there is culpability on anybody relative to the deaths of these individuals," Waugh said. He said it could be three to four weeks before they knew if criminal charges would be filed.

Ray's recent postings on his Twitter account said he was "shocked and saddened" by the tragedy.

"My deep heartfelt condolences to family and friends of those who lost their lives," he wrote. "I am spending the weekend in prayer and meditation for all involved in this difficult time; and I ask you to join me in doing the same."

Ray's company, James Ray International, is based in Carlsbad, Calif. Ray's publicist, Howard Bragman, expressed condolences in a statement Friday but declined to speak about the deaths. Bragman didn't return a call for additional comment Saturday.

The Angel Valley Retreat Center is owned by Michael and Amayra Hamilton, who rented it to Ray for a five-day "Spiritual Warrior" retreat that promised to "absolutely change your life."

On Saturday, Amayra Hamilton said Ray has held the event at the resort for seven years, and there never have been any problems.

Hamilton said the resort remains closed to the public. The sweat lodge has been dismantled and a ceremony was conducted for those affected by Thursday's incident.

"The whole situation is very traumatizing for everybody," she said.

The people at Ray's retreat, whose ages ranged from 30 to the 60s, paid between $9,000 and $10,000 to attend.

Ray and his staff constructed the temporary sweat lodge with a wood frame and covered it with layers of tarps and blankets, Waugh said. The sweat lodge - a structure commonly used by American Indian tribes to cleanse the body and prepare for hunts, ceremonies and other events - was 53 inches high at the center and about 30 inches high around the outer edges.

Between 55 and 65 people were crowded into the 415-square-foot space during a two-hour period that included various spiritual exercises led by Ray, Waugh said. Every 15 minutes, a flap was raised to allow more volcanic rocks the size of cantaloupes to be brought inside.

Authorities said participants were highly encouraged but not forced to remain in the sweat lodge for the entire time.

Joseph Bruchac, author of "The Native American Sweat Lodge: History and Legends," called the number of participants in the lodge "appalling."

"If you put people in a restrictive, airtight structure, you are going to use up all oxygen," he said by phone Saturday from his home in Saratoga Springs, N.Y. "And if you're doing a sweat, you're going to use it up that much faster."

American Indian sweat lodges typically hold about 12 people and are covered with blankets made of natural materials, such as cotton or wool, and the air flow isn't restricted, he said.

"I don't see how the person running that lodge could have been aware of the health and well-being of that many people," he said.

The participants had fasted for 36 hours as part of a personal and spiritual quest in the wilderness, then ate a breakfast buffet Thursday morning. After various seminars, they entered the sweat lodge lightly dressed at 3 p.m.

Two hours later, a woman dialed 911 to say that two people, whom Waugh identified as Brown and Shore, did not have a pulse and weren't breathing.

A nurse hired by Ray was directing rescue efforts including CPR when emergency crews arrived, Waugh said. Shore and Brown were pronounced dead when they arrived at a hospital.

Sheriff's Lt. David Rhodes said authorities were checking whether there was a lag time between the first signs of medical distress and the emergency call.

McFeeley said Brown had attended similar retreats, although he wasn't certain whether any were hosted by Ray. He said Brown, who grew up in Brooklyn and Westtown and spent time in Mexico, saw the outing as a chance to continue on a positive path in life.

Brown, a graduate of the State University of New York at Geneseo, had two sisters who recently got married, two new nephews and a focus on "making the world more beautiful for someone, not only with her art but with her heart," McFeeley said. Although the family is saddened by her death, he said Brown created a roadmap by which others should live.

"She was the least selfish, kindest person I knew," he said.

[Ahaseheset]

It was with great sadness that I read about the people who died in AZ in a sweat lodge run by an individual who was charging a fair amount of money to his victims.
No charges have been filed against this person. He should be charged. Perhaps then, he and others like him, will no longer be able to hurt someone for their own financial gain.

The trouble is he was stealing what is a sacred Native American ceremony. Now people have suffered for his lack of respect of Native traditions.
He was selling those traditions as if they were some sort of of commodity.

I wonder if he also offered Holy Communion and Confession complete with Rosary and the prescribed numbers of Hail Marys?? For these traditions and ceremonies must also be for sale, in his eyes.

About five years ago, Arvol Looking Horse, a bundle keeper for the Lakota people and several other medicine people, elders and bundle keepers for many nations decreed that Native American ceremony is for NATIVE AMERICANS.
You may be invited to attend, but the ceremony is to be conducted by NATIVE AMERICANS who are trained. They came to this conclusion after a similar tragedy happened in Redding, CA.

I absolutely agree with this decree by the Plains Nations elders.

STOP STEALING TRADITIONS! STOP SELLING TRADITIONS!!

[LittleBirdNDN]

Thank you

[hungry1968-16]

Once again, the psychosis known as "organized religion", claims MORE lives.

Nothing new to see here folks.....

Move along......

Pretend it never happened.......

[mecanik-2009]

Ok, Ok, Now the next time we go to the sweat lodge guys, I'M tending to the fire. And no, we can't throw the can of gas into it anymore. Yah yah, I know it looks cool but we need to tone it down a bit.

[bubbadubba]

I too am in shock that a person could actually die from heat stroke as that has never happened before in human history.
I am in shock I tell ya!

[rwsmith29456]

If so many had burns, something was very wrong with the mechanism used to produce heat/steam. I don't blame the navel gazers. They can do what they want with thier money but this resorts makeshift spa hurt and killed people.

[timincal]

The term used to describe these new age charlatans is "Plastic Shaman".

They use Native American concepts and ideology to sucker fools out of their money.

[John_Merritt]

" Nineteen other people were taken to hospitals, suffering from burns, dehydration, respiratory arrest, kidney failure or elevated body temperature. Most were soon released, but one remained in critical condition Saturday."

No matter how physically fit we are, they fasted for days prior and so they were naturally depleted of vital minerals and nutrients require especially in the heat of the Arizona desert. Than they climb into a sweat box and there body took a dump real fast.

Our bodies are capable of many things but it was never intended that we should be microwaved. That is exactly what happened because they died from inside out. Place people in extreme conditions, including freezing temperatures and death is emminent. My sympathies to all those who lost.