Tech Innovations Great but Lacking Quality

From left, Knighthawk, April Hanson and her husband Harley Hanson, members of the International Keystone Knights Realm of Georgia, perform a traditional Klan salute along the portion of highway they want to adopt allowing them to put up a sign and do litter removal near Blairsville, Ga., Sunday, June 10, 2012. The Ku Klux Klan group wants to join Georgia's "Adopt-A-Highway" program for litter removal, which could force state officials to make difficult decisions on the application. (AP Photo/The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Curtis Compton) / Curtis Compton

I appreciate all the great technological advances of the last 25 years or so but I sometimes question whether it's all for the good.

Don't get me wrong - I love my big-screen TV, my cell phone and my digital music player, and I wouldn't dream of giving up my personal computer. But as I use all of these modern devices, I sometimes miss what they've replaced. For many devices, we're opting for convenience and portability while sacrificing quality.

The cell phone is an obvious example. Sure, it's great to be able to talk from anywhere, but there's a reason we can all relate to those ubiquitous "Can you hear me now?" Verizon commercials. Who among us hasn't experienced dropped calls or difficulty hearing or understanding someone talking on a cell phone?

I don't recall having those problems with the land line I grew up with. Sure, that wired phone in my parents' living room couldn't go with me when I left the house, but that wasn't entirely bad. At least I never had to worry about losing it and it never had to be charged. Even now, in addition to our cell phones and Internet lines, we still have one old-fashioned "POTS" line (stands for Plain Old Telephone Service) at our house with a couple of old-fashioned corded phones that work even if the power fails.
I always know where they are, and those are the phones I always use when sound quality counts. Speaking of quality sound and corded phones, am I the only one who misses pay phones? Because of my work with CBS, I need to go on the radio every day and, for quality reasons, prefer using a land line. Trouble is, finding a working pay phone when I travel - even at an airport or hotel lobby - is increasingly difficult.

I also miss my old typewriter. I feel certain nostalgia for the clicking sound it made when I banged the keys. Writing felt somehow more deliberate in those days. But what I miss most is how easy it was to fill out forms. Have you ever tried filling in the blanks on a PDF file? Unless it's one of the few that are designed for that purpose (hats off to the IRS for using interactive PDF forms on its site), it's really hard to do, even if you have a PDF editor. I don't, however, miss having to use buckets of Wite-Out and wasting reams of crumpled-up paper.

My biggest complaint is what we're settling for when it comes to music. These days, most young people listen to virtually all their recorded music through those little white earbuds connected to an iPod or some other digital player. IPods are great and those white earbuds are fine as far as they go, but listening to a highly compressed MP3 file through earbuds is not the same as listening to a well-mastered LP record or CD through good speakers or good headphones.


Even if you connect your iPod to a good audio system, you're still suffering from a narrower harmonic range - there is simply less information in the file.

I did make sound compromises in the '70s and '80s when I would make cassette tapes of my favorite LPs (and later CDs) to listen to in the car or at my office. I had to put up with hiss and other imperfections, but I still owned that original LP or CD, which I could put on when I wanted to get the best possible sound. That may still be the case if you rip your own MP3 files from CDs. But if you buy your music on iTunes or any other download service, you don't even have the CD to fall back on.

Apple and some other download services now offer higher-quality files. Apple says its iTunes tracks, which are encoded as 256 kbps AAC files, are "virtually indistinguishable from the original recordings." But "virtually" isn't the same as "exactly," which is always the goal for serious audiophiles.

In the old days, when I wanted to kick back and really enjoy my tunes or impress a friend, I would carefully remove an LP from its album cover, gently place it on the turntable and run a cleaning cloth over it before carefully placing the needle on the record.

And it wasn't just about sound. Many of those LPs had wonderful album covers with great images on the front, plenty to read on the back and often printed liner notes with even more information. Apple is trying to bring that back with its new iTunes LP feature. Admittedly, it can offer video and other media that those old record producers could only dream of, but that doesn't completely make up for the aesthetics of those old printed LP albums.

Before you write me off as a Luddite or just a grumpy old man, Google the term "vinyl comeback." You'll find articles from Time, Rolling Stone and other sources about how college and even high school kids are now collecting vinyl records because of the warmer sound as well as the covers and liner notes.

I'm still waiting for land lines and typewriters to become hip again.

This column originally appeared in the San Jose Mercury News

[eyedreamer]

I think this article was very nostalgic, but doesn't quite meet the right qualities for this website, or perhaps the target audience is much older than me and I couldn't see a worthy substance in it.

[rwsmith29456]

I think that there is both good and bad in the progress. I wouldn't want an old typewriter after word processing. And the quality of copies is much better than it was years ago. I do agree on the music however. The music companies have us paying $$ for bits and bytes (no substance) in a lossy compressed format so we can play it on our ipods.

[barbaram99]

I found the article interesting. Mind ye, I don't have a ipod thing. I would not use it. I do love my Notebook. I do member the old days of 45s,33s,cassettes. I don't miss them. I do like CDs as they are legally blind friendly. No flipping them over or trying to put a needle on a record. I hate droopped calls. I do carry a cell . Have a phone at home and DSL as we need the voice line. I don't have 50 cents to use one.

[texanforlogi]

I still have all my albums, although I no longer have a turntable. (Hopefully, Santa will come through this year--I miss playing my albums.)

It seems as if all this technology is promoting acceptance of mediocrity.

People tolerate dropped cell phone calls and even laugh them off, but must have the cell because they must stay in touch. I haven't had a dropped call on my landline in 35 years. I don't have to charge it, it always works--no worries about how many bars or roaming, and I pay around $30 per month.

MP3 players don't offer nearly the music quality but folks accept the mediocrity because of the convenience.

[Yes_ABWH_Fan]

I miss knobs the most, particularly on my car-audio player. Sometimes the hassle involved in "toggling" or making sure you don't "overshoot" a frequency or CD #, can cause enough distraction to create accidents. With a knob, you can twirl it, get exactly the result you expected, and not even look away from the road.

[willow013]

Ah yes.....Isn't it nice to kick back and relax in this hectic world sometimes? Its nice to get away from the technology of always being available through one device or another.....Gives us a chance to stop and smell the roses, instead of waking up and smelling the coffee all of the time.....

[thesevenveils]

I'm with you on this one. There are just times when you want to slow down and not just listen to, but Hear the music.

The announcement of satellite radio made me ecstatic. But after listening to it long enough to discover the sample rate is so low it makes its sound so annoyingly choppy that even with the windows rolled down at highway speeds, FM music has better sound depth and quality. So I gave it away. And so it goes as you have said so well.

Yes sir, there is nothing finer than the ritual of dusting a vinyl record, watching it turn while the needle drops, and then melting into a comfy chair in front of real speakers. Speaking words of wisdom, Let it Be...

[brianbwb-2009]

Now you're finally learning, Mr. Magid. Too bad it is too late.

On more than one occasion I called you to task, after reading one of your articles gushing about about the latest gadget (the iPod comes to mind) and how you can do this, or that, or what bells and whistles it possessed, while completely ignoring rather important drawbacks about the devices.

By accepting your salary to write what was little more than an advertisement for these gadgets, you helped promote the diminishing quality of the primary function of such devices. Sure they play music, sure you can store hundreds of songs on one small device, but what about the amazingly poor sonic quality of the music from the devices?

Nary a word.

Also the fact that you were paying a lot of money to hear very-reduced-quality music was something else missing from your articles. Even as much as I hated them, a dolby-equipped Walkman cassette player sounds better than the garbage mp3 players out there today.

From a producer's standpoint, it is somewhat frustrating to use my years of experience to make a music work, to make sure my sound was mastered to the highest possible standards, only to hear a barely-tolerable representation of it on an mp3 player.

So the next time you feel that irritating twinge of something missing from your music experience, because vinyl is no longer sold, and CD's and DVDs are also losing the battle to the now-ubiquitous mp3 downloader-player, just remember that your unquestioning, uncritical, unabashed cheerleading of such gadgets with the power of CBS distribution behind you, contributed much to the loss of that which you now lament.