"Smart Choices" Food Label Misleading?

(CBS)  A new food-labeling campaign called Experts Say Industry Food Labels DeceptiveRegistered dietician Keri Glassman said on "The Early Show" Monday that to qualify for the Smart Choices Program nutrition symbol, products must meet specific nutritional benchmarks. For example, foods cannot exceed "nutrients to limit" including: total fat, saturated fat, trans fat, cholesterol, added sugars and sodium. Additionally, products must include one or more "nutrients to encourage," such as vitamin C, or provide at least a one-half serving from at least one "food group to encourage," such as vegetables.

---

Get a complete look at specific nutrient requirements in each "Smart Choices" Program food category.

---

However, different foods have different qualifications. Glassman explained the foods are categorized into 19 different categories and have different standards. Snacks, for example, have a different standard than cereals.

The program, originally devised by The Keystone Center, a nonprofit organization, was designed to help remove customers' confusion about different claims or call-outs on packages, and to help lead consumers to healthier choices. Scientists, consumer organizations and the food industry all had a say in the program. However, Glassman said, Smart Choices was then handed off to the American Society for Nutrition to administer. And then, guidelines were derived from the Dietary Guidelines of America and other sources, such as the Institute of Medicine.

"Early Show" substitute co-anchor Jeff Glor remarked that the program has gotten confusing along the way. He added the Smart Choices Program has come under fire for giving checkmarks to some sugary products. Kellogg's Froot Loops, Cocoa Krispies, Frosted Flakes and Keebler Cookie Crunch, which contain roughly 40 percent of calories from sugar, qualified for the checkmark, Glassman said, because an exception was made.

Glassman explained foods in most product categories cannot qualify for a check if more than 25 percent of their calories come as added sugars, but the exception was made to include these cereals because they are the lesser of dietary evils. For people who reach for even more sugary breakfast options, such as donuts, Glassman said, these cereals are a better choice.

"But we know, obviously, there are much better choices out there," she said. "... If this check mark guides you to the box, you can't take any shortcuts, you still need to read the nutrition, read the ingredients list and remember the best foods out there - whole foods -- don't come in packages -- so you won't see the green check mark -- so don't forget those foods."

Several companies, including Kraft Foods, Unilever, Kellogg Company, ConAgra Foods, Tyson Foods, PepsiCo and General Mills, have joined the program.

[jsf14]

VERY misleading. I would have asked how anyone could think Frootloops a smart choice. But it seems that not only the green checkmark people but also the moms who note the mark are able think it is. Are there really parents who wonder what's better than a donut? And would a donut get a smarcheck if it had vitamin C sprayed on it? Probably. Every packaged food is better than eating only sugar and butter. And eating sugar and butter is better than eading dog poop.

[displeased]

This program is ridiculous and needs to be shut down. I can't believe they have chewing gum listed as a product. And Cheese Nips? If they can justify labeling something as healthy because there are worse choices, couldn't they label just about everything in the grocery store?

[koko98-2009]

Saw this story in LAST Sunday's New York Times. Fruit Loops is a healthy choice because it is healthier than a donut. I love people who are able to regulate themselves.