September 8, 2009 10:34 AM

NATO Confirms Civilians Died in Airstrike

(AP)  The NATO-led force acknowledged for the first time Tuesday that Afghan civilians were killed in a German-ordered airstrike last week on two stolen fuel tankers, and the top commander appointed a team to investigate.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel said Tuesday that her government won't accept "premature judgments" about the incident. Germany's military has been criticized for calling in Friday's strike by a U.S. jet on two hijacked tanker trucks in Kunduz province and for initially insisting that it appeared only militants were killed. Local officials have said civilians were among more than 50 killed, but there have been conflicting claims over how many.

A statement from the NATO-led force said Tuesday that commanders originally believed the tankers were surrounded only by Taliban insurgents, but that a subsequent review showed "civilians also were killed and injured in the strike." Previously, officials had said only that civilians may have been wounded.

The top U.S. and NATO commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, appointed a Canadian major general to lead the investigation. A U.S. Air Force officer and a German officer are also on the investigating team, the NATO-led force announced. The make-up of the investigative team is important because the incident involved both German and U.S. forces.

Taliban militants have used attacks like the one Friday in northern Kunduz province to rally support among villagers angry at international forces.

McChrystal has said military officials could see about 120 people around the tankers when the airstrikes were launched. German officials have said they believed all were militants, but the decision to launch airstrikes appeared to run counter to directives from McChrystal to draw back from conflicts rather than risk civilian deaths.

Read related Afghanistan coverage on CBSNews.com:

Karzai Has 54% of Fraud-Riddled Vote
For Obama, A Pivotal Moment in Afghanistan
Car Bomb Attack Targets NATO in Kabul

Merkel acknowledged the possibility that civilians were harmed and that "we will not gloss over anything" when results of the investigation are clear. But she told parliament that the identities of those hit were still unclear because of contradictory reports.

"We will not accept premature judgments," she said. "I say this very clearly after what I have experienced in the last few days: I will not tolerate that from whoever it may be, at home as well as abroad."

She told parliament weeks before national elections that she regrets deeply if any civilians were harmed.

However, she also delivered a robust defense of a military mission that is unpopular at home.

The NATO announcement came the same day .

The blast killed at least three civilians, Afghan officials said.

No foreign forces were killed in the attack, U.S. military spokeswoman Capt. Elizabeth Mathias said.

(AP Photo/Manish Swarup)
The Taliban claimed responsibility for the blast, the third major attack by insurgents in the capital in four weeks. The Belgian Defense Ministry said one Belgian soldier was seriously wounded and that three others were lightly wounded.

The chief of Kabul's criminal investigation department, Abdul Ghafar Sayadzada, said three Afghan civilians were killed and six wounded.

Taliban spokesman Zabiullah Mujahid said a suicide car bomber rammed into a NATO convoy and destroyed three Land Cruisers.

The early morning blast rattled windows more than a mile away and flames continued to shoot out from burning vehicles more than an hour later. Small blasts could be heard, likely from ammunition exploding inside the vehicles.

A witness said he saw the car ram into a line of SUVs.

"I saw three or four Land Cruisers for the foreigners just in front of the gate ... then there was a car and it hit them then blew up," said Humayun, who watched the attack from his nearby shop.

U.S. forces spokesman Lt. Col. Todd Vician confirmed an explosion south of the airport, but said he did not have details. The military airport used by U.S. and other international forces is right next to Kabul's civilian airport, but they have separate entrances.

Insurgent attacks, often deadly, occur in Kabul despite tight security and blast walls. Suicide bombers have hit government buildings and gunmen have overrun ministries.

In the run-up to the Aug. 20 presidential election, a suicide attack near the main gate of NATO headquarters killed seven people and injured scores and gunmen briefly took over a bank in the city. Also insurgents fired on the presidential palace on the same day that they unleashed a suicide car bombers on a NATO convoy.

The violence in the capital comes amid growing uncertainty over the vote. A U.N.-backed commission investigating the vote said Tuesday it had found "clear and convincing evidence of fraud" and that it was .

Widespread allegations of ballot-box stuffing and suspicious tallies are threatening the legitimacy of the election as the country awaits final results. More than 720 major fraud charges have been lodged with the Electoral Complaints Commission.

Meanwhile, Taliban insurgents ambushed a police convoy in the village of Dahna Ghori in Baghlan province Monday evening, Gov. Mohammad Akbar Barakzai said Tuesday, and police killed 12 Taliban in the resulting firefight.

Police suffered no casualties in the ambush, Barakzai said. But he said as the convoy was returning to Pul-e-Khumri, the provincial capital, it was hit by a bomb.

Barakzai said one policeman was killed and 17 were wounded in the explosion, two of them seriously.
By Associated Press Writers Rahim Faiez and Amir Shah

© 2009 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Add a Comment
by underdogus09 September 8, 2009 12:09 PM EDT
BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) A spate of roadside bombings in Iraq killed four U.S. troops and a civilian...
Thank you obama for keeping your "promise"
Reply to this comment
by Sloughfoot September 8, 2009 11:15 AM EDT
People die in a war zone. You go running to bad guy congregation for freebies-boom you dead. No sorrow no remorse.
Reply to this comment
by blitzder September 8, 2009 11:05 AM EDT
According to Cheney he made the US safe...... by killing thousands od civilians. YEAH EIGHT!.

How can they have been so stupid, Cheney spawned more terrorists by his kill,kill policies and made the US more of a target for revenge seekers. Go figure.
Reply to this comment
by mysteriousjz September 8, 2009 10:26 AM EDT
Where is the outrage for these confirmed 120 people burned alive?
Reply to this comment
by jefleshman September 9, 2009 2:40 AM EDT
Mysteriousjz

wow do we have to go through a lesson again? You are making a bold assumption that all 120 are indeed non combatants. Were you there? Could you outright determine each and everyone there was an innocent victum? Again. No you can not.

The loss of life is tragic. Indeed and sad for both. War is not pretty and so clear cut. I would hope you would understand that now based on dialogue from yesterday. I guess not.
by casionova September 8, 2009 10:11 AM EDT
Other news media have highlighted the time difference between the calling in of the air strike and the actual dropping of the bombs, citing that as the reason the civilians were hit and not the Taliban.
Reply to this comment
by casionova September 8, 2009 11:25 AM EDT
Further to this, from the NY times: "the German commander on the ground, to minimize damage, ordered the warplanes to use 500-pound bombs rather than the 2,000-pound bombs suggested by the pilots".

They wanted to drop 2,000-pound bombs on a crowd of people and they claim they want to avoid civilian casualties.
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook