Photo Finish: Debts Close In on Leibovitz

Famed Photographer Faces Giving Up Rights To Every Picture She Has Ever Taken to Pay Back $24M Loan

(AP)  Annie Leibovitz's artsy, provocative portraits of celebrities regularly grace the covers of Vanity Fair and Vogue, images that have made her as famous as her subjects and earned her millions.

Now Leibovitz risks losing the copyright to the images - and her entire life's work - if she doesn't pay back a $24 million loan by Tuesday. Art Capital Group, a New York company that issues short-term loans against fine and decorative arts and real estate, sued her in late July for breach of contract.

"We have clear contractual rights and will protect them in any scenario," said ACG spokesman Montieth Illingworth on Friday. "Our preference is for this to be resolved."

Some experts say filing for bankruptcy reorganization could be the best option for Leibovitz, 59, who has put up as collateral her three historic Greenwich Village townhouses, an upstate property and work. She bought two of the townhouses in 2002, embarking on extensive renovations to combine them into one property. That spurred protests from historic preservationists and a $15 million lawsuit by a neighbor.

"Based on the magnitude of her obligations and the facts as they are publicly known, that would be the best option," said art lawyer Peter Stern.

Leibovitz's images of musicians, presidents and Hollywood glitterati are cultural touchstones. One of her earliest photos is of John Lennon curled up naked in a fetal position with Yoko Ono, taken just hours before he was assassinated in 1980.

So to many, her decision to gamble the rights to her work seems inexplicable. "Jaw-dropping," Stern said.

Her editorial agent, Contact Press Images, has declined to comment on the case, saying it is a private matter.

Her spokesman, Matthew Hiltzik, has accused ACG of harassment.

"There has been tension and dispute since the beginning ... For now, her attention remains on her photography and on continuing to organize her finances," Hiltzik said.

A reorganization filing would suspend all litigation against Leibovitz and place her finances under the protection of a federal judge, said bankruptcy lawyer Paul Silverman, who works with Stern. Neither attorney is involved in the case.

Last year, Leibovitz put up her homes and the copyright to every picture she has ever taken - or will take - as collateral to secure the loan to pay off her mounting debt: unpaid bills, mortgage payments and tax liens, ACG said.

While no one has suggested publicly how Leibovitz got into such desperate financial straits, the mortgage debt on all her properties - including the townhouses in Greenwich Village and a sprawling estate in Rhinebeck, New York - totaled about $15 million. This includes the $1.2 million loan she took out on two of the townhouses, and another $2.2 million three years later, according to New York magazine.

In addition to her mortgages, court records show that she piled up years of federal, state and city liens and judgments from vendors for unpaid bills - all presumably now satisfied with the $24 million she borrowed. Federal records show that Leibovitz owed a total of $2.1 million in unpaid taxes for tax years 2004, 2006 and 2007. She also had New York state tax liens of $247,980 for six years, including $135,915 in 2007. And she owed New York City several thousand dollars for three years.

In 2008, a design firm that did work on one of her Greenwich Village properties claimed that she owed it $51,000. Leibovitz was also accused that year of refusing to pay $386,000 to a photo stylist during a 2007 shoot Leibovitz did for the Disney Company in 2007.

Her spokesman, Hiltzik, declined Thursday to discuss her finances.

"Annie is working to resolve the situation so it would be inappropriate to comment," Hiltzik said.

Art Capital Group, which consolidated all her loans in September 2008, charged in its lawsuit that Leibovitz breached the contract by refusing to allow real estate experts into her homes to appraise their value and by blocking ACG from selling her photographs.

ACG has estimated the value of the Leibovitz portfolio at $40 million; real estate brokers say her New York properties are worth about $40 million.

Manhattan luxury real estate broker Leonard Steinberg of Prudential Douglas Elliman estimated the two Greenwich Village townhouses would be worth $14 million to $18 million in today's market. Steinberg is not the broker on the property.

Leibovitz also owned an apartment in Paris, which she bought for her longtime companion, writer and feminist Susan Sontag.

Leibovitz gave birth at the age of 51 to her daughter Sara in 2001, and has twins, who were born to a surrogate in 2005.

ACG, with art gallery-like offices on Madison Avenue, is in effect a high-end pawn shop and - just like pawn shops - is just as happy to see a default, according to art and money experts.

Under the sales agreement with Leibovitz, Illingworth said, the company would get 10 percent commission on the sale of Leibovitz' real estate and 15 percent on the sale of her portfolio. Leibovitz would get the remainder after paying off the $24 million loan, interest and other fees, he said. If she defaults, the company would get a net 12 percent commission, after paying approximately 13 percent for costs and fees.

Leibovitz, 6 feet tall with long blond tresses, joined Vanity Fair in 1983. Over the years, her lens has captured the rich and famous: Barack Obama, Queen Elizabeth II and Bruce Springsteen among them. She gave the world its first glimpse of baby Suri, newborn daughter of Hollywood's superstar couple Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes, on the cover of Vanity Fair.

Her Vanity Fair salary has been reported to be about $2 million, according to New York magazine. She also has done work for Louis Vuitton and American Express; she charges $100,000 for private portraits.

A meticulous and demanding artist designated a "Living Legend" by the Library of Congress, Leibovitz makes her photo shoots lavish, sometimes theatrical affairs. For a portrait of Kristin Dunst as Marie Antoinette, she flew the actress and a crew to Paris for a shoot at the Versailles. She put Whoopi Goldberg in a bathtub of warm milk. Many of her images are provocative and controversial, including those last year of 15-year-old Miley Cyrus exposing bare shoulders and back, and a portrait of a very pregnant and nude Demi Moore in 1991.

Her financial problems escalated in 2003, during the renovation of her Greenwich Village townhouses. A neighbor sued her for $15 million after a common wall between their buildings was damaged. Leibovitz eventually settled by buying the neighbor's property for $1.9 million.

Silverman, a past president of the New York State Bar Association bankruptcy committee, is not familiar with Leibovitz's case. But he said a bankruptcy reorganization filing would give her control of what assets need to be sold and which to keep.

"It would allow her to decide the manner and method of the disposition," he said.


For more info:
Vanity fair archives

[heresmy2cent]

Not only is she a genius at personal finances, she's really good looking, too. She has the "Garth of Wayne's World" look down to a science.

[formrusmcsgt]

The woman buys three swanky houses and will have to declare bunkruptcy as a result.

She has a good eye, but no brains.....

[longtree-2009]

another idiot who cannot live within her means, her earnings. for being so stupid, she should lose every thing and start all over again. lesson learned.

[cattiej]

Another story about the rich not paying but taking. I don't feel sorry for her or her girl-friend. Anyone who owes 24 million, when most of the American people are losing there jobs, their homes and their health insurace, makes me ill. These rich that have so many homes, cars, etc...Our country is just one step away from a depression. If Obama gives any more money away, and doesn't stop the war, we WILL be in a Depression by December...my advice, stop using the credit cards, the interest is way to high. We cut up ours and breathed a sigh of relief. We own, free and clear, 2 American made cars ( a 1996 & 1997 ) We buy American products most of the time. We do get upset when we find out that most of our medications are made in other countries. Ask your pharmacist where your medications were made..even most of the tooth paste in made in Mexico. Ford makes cars in Mexico, don't buy a car made in a foreign country. Buy American made cars made by an American company.

[platteman]

Another tax cheat. Bet she voted for Obama and his merry band of men.
Too bad, she can't have it all. She has to make choices. I don't feel sorry for her. She had it all, tried to live way too high. She is just like the federal government.

[spiritwalk]

Considering the number of people I see on the street who do not have a home, I cannot get up a lot of sympathy for someone afaid of losing their HOMES!

And who lent her $24 million in the first place...and why did she need it?

I wonder if some of these rich celebs like Liebowitz and Michael Jackson could have been much better adjusted if they had to spend a little time on food stamps and assistance after borrowing themselves into debt to have a half dozen homes and a cupboard full of caviar.

[1notrub11]

Sorry, but I have serious problems with: A) someone that well off, who cannot manage their own finances, B) the ability to declare bankruptcy, in the presence of apparent assets that could cover the debt (and assets which, if missing, will not interfere with daily living moving forward), and C) who has not paid taxes (which the majority of us seem to do) due on income earned.
If I can cope with my personal responsibilities for over 45 years, then so can she.

[marc5006]

Why are we writing about more stupid millionaires who can't pay their bills? I think it an absolute shame they are allowed to file for bankruptcy for being stupid with their finances while the rest of us who can't afford a night out have to pay for it with higher interest rates? More well fare for the rich please

[random_radar]

The lesson is clear--stay out of debt. Debt is slavery.