Alleged Cancun Sand Thieves Raided

(AP)  Surprised tourists found their little piece of Cancun beach paradise ringed by crime-scene tape and gun-toting sailors on Thursday.

Environmental enforcement officers backed by Mexican navy personnel closed off hundreds of feet (dozens of meters) of powder-white coastline in front of a hotel accused of illegally accumulating sand on its beach.

Patricio Patron, Mexico's attorney general for environmental protection, said five people were detained in a raid for allegedly using pumps to move sand from the sea floor onto the beach in front of the Gran Caribe Real Hotel. The hotel is also suspected of illegally building a breakwater that impeded the natural flow of sand onto other hotels' beaches, he said.

Mexico spent $19 million to replace Cancun beaches washed away by Hurricane Wilma in 2005. But much of the sand pumped from the sea floor has since washed away, leading some property owners to build breakwaters in a bid to retain sand. The practice often merely shifts sand loss to beaches below the breakwaters.

"Today we made the decision to close this stretch of ill-gotten, illegally accumulated sand," said Patron. "This hotel was telling its tourists: 'Come here, I have sand ... the other hotels don't, because I stole it.'"

An employee of the hotel's marketing office said nobody was available to comment on the allegations. Authorities said the hotel owner ignored previous orders to remove the breakwater.

A knot of angry tourists gathered around the closed beach.

Some were irked by the sight of police tape and "Closed" signs.

Maria Bachino, a travel agent from Rocha, Uruguay, said by telephone that she had booked a beachfront room in Cancun, only to find herself cut off from the clear, bathtub-temperature waters that lure millions to Cancun each year.

"They promised us a beach," said Bachino. "This is very unpleasant, we feel bad. This is intimidating," she said of the armed navy personnel who participated in the raid.

Patron said he regretted any inconvenience for tourists, but said the government is planning projects to restore beaches throughout Cancun in an orderly, environmentally responsible way.

"I apologize to the tourists for this problem, but it is a question of enforcing the law," Patron said.

[vuenbelvue]

I always remember the tremendous rip tides along the beaches in Cancun. Definitely worst I have encountered and worst than Panama City Beach, Fla. No wonder the sand doesn't stay around. It's suck out to sea.

[brianbwb-2009]

In Bali, some of the beaches are beautiful indeed, but unusable because the volcanic sand is black, and can cause blisters, as it gets extremely hot in the tropical sun.

The price of white sand is very high, because most of the available sand from the Riau islands is bought by Singapore for sea reclamation, creating a shortage of available sand for Indonesians who wish to replace the black sand with white sand.

Sand for upscale resorts is indeed a dirty, multi-million dollar business, full of smugglers, thieves, pirates, and results in destruction of entire islands and ecosystems in an uncontrolled fashion. The corruption goes all the way up the government, and perhaps the only way to combat it is with the Chinese "zero tolerance" method, two in the brain of the government officials who take the bribes to look the other way.

[jtdev1]

That would NEVER happen in the USA...

They would NEVER close a business no matter how ILLEGAL the act was...

[MiddleClassWorker]

Are they sure that the "powder-white coastline" is really just sand? I mean, this is Mexico.