HAGERSTOWN, Md., July 15, 2009

Teen Guilty of Soliciting Father's Murder

Girl, 16, Faces Life in Prison for Having Father Stabbed on Halloween Outside Md. Home

  • This undated photo submitted as state's evidence provided by the Washington County Circuit Court shows Danielle Black, then 15. Black was convicted July 15, 2009 of soliciting the first-degree murder of her father last Halloween. (AP Photo/Washington County Circuit Court)

    This undated photo submitted as state's evidence provided by the Washington County Circuit Court shows Danielle Black, then 15. Black was convicted July 15, 2009 of soliciting the first-degree murder of her father last Halloween. (AP Photo/Washington County Circuit Court)  (AP Photo/Washington County Court)

  • Interactive Crime Beat

    Statistics and specifics on crime in America.

(AP)  A jury in Hagerstown has convicted a 16-year-old girl of soliciting the murder of her late father.

The panel deliberated about 90 minutes Wednesday before finding Danielle Black guilty of solicitation of first-degree murder.

She faces up to life imprisonment at her sentencing, which has not been scheduled.

Danielle's father, 47-year-old Billy Lee Black, was stabbed to death outside the family's Hagerstown home on Halloween. The man charged with killing him is not the same friend Danielle was convicted of approaching on a school bus a few days before the slaying.

In closing arguments on Wednesday, the prosecutor portrayed Danielle Black as a girl obsessed with her father's death and her twisted hatred of him.

But the defense said Danielle, and the boy on a school bus she allegedly approached, were just teenagers saying things they didn't mean.

The state rested Wednesday after presenting its star witnesses - two teenagers who were little help in proving that Danielle Black asked a friend on a school bus to kill her father.

Defense attorneys said they would rest after an afternoon recess. Black declined to testify.

The 18-year-old who allegedly received the request testified that Black asked him to "take care of" her father, not kill him. A 14-year-old prosecution witness testified that she overheard Black discuss a murder plan, but she said the conversation happened Oct. 31, at least five hours after Billy Lee Black was killed.

Her testimony contradicted the timeline she gave to police.

© MMIX The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 32 Comments
by lakelizardholmes July 19, 2009 11:06 PM EDT
THIS is why the passing of Walter Cronkite should be noted with significantly more public concern than that of, say, Michael Jackson. While our society should certainly mourn the accompanying death of journalistic integrity, this story clearly indicates that we need also mourn the death of journalistic competence. CBS: My how the mighty have fallen.
Reply to this comment
by Illuminated1 July 16, 2009 3:01 PM EDT
This case is just entering another phase that will in the end exonerate her since the evidence wouldn't stand 10 minutes in appeal.
Reply to this comment
by american-german July 16, 2009 2:54 PM EDT
I see a big problem with any jury convicting someone of first degree murder after only 90 minutes of deliberation. These small town courts scare the hell out of me.
Reply to this comment
by pierson98 July 16, 2009 2:50 PM EDT
I'd hit it.
Reply to this comment
by eewrites July 16, 2009 1:41 PM EDT
The editor of this website should look seriously at the fact that several readers felt the need to go find relevant information on the internet and post it. This article left a myriad of obvious questions unanswered. This does not speak well about the quality of writing or reporting on this site.
I find the new format somewhat confusing and, as indicated above, the reporting substandard. I hope CBS news takes a good long look at themselves.
Reply to this comment
by lakelizardholmes July 19, 2009 11:33 PM EDT
Recipient of the "Nail on the Head Award"! The story becomes secondary to the poor job done in its reporting.
(The Nail on the Head Award is randomly given to posters on news sites who manage against all odds to logically focus on the central issue of a given news story without resorting to name-calling, political or religious partisanship, or celebrity worship)
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 12:10 PM EDT
Morality doesn't require religion. Start with a definition of Man as a reasoning animal, define Good as whatever allows his reason, define Evil as whatever prevents his reason. Define sustaining his own life as Good, define involuntary sacrifice for others' lives as Evil (the use of force). Define productive effort as Good, define slavery as Evil (you don't get paid or you don't get to own what you buy).

From these definitions, republics are Good, dictatorships are Evil. Supporting dictatorships is also Evil, which means we have a lot of Evil people on the CBS blog without any reference to their religion.
Reply to this comment
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 1:28 PM EDT
How so?
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 3:59 PM EDT
But it follows that a Man who endorses Evil, as previously defined, is Evil himself. It doesn't matter what religious persuasion he also endorses (and as religion often denies the use of Reason, it is Evil to that extent as well).
by pubsnomore July 16, 2009 12:08 PM EDT
I heard that gang sign is gonna be the new Mitt Romney campaign symbol.
Reply to this comment
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 12:11 PM EDT
But your gang sign was both hands in the air?
by crazycwp July 16, 2009 10:29 AM EDT
Who knows what her dad did to her to make her feel that way. Maybe something, maybe nothing, maybe he raised her the way most kids are being raised, outside the church. That would explain the lack of gratitude,graciousness and humility that we should see in kids today.Fact remains tho, dad's dead and the young woman gonna spend the rest of probably most of her life in prison learning more about being a criminal. Sad all the way around.
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat4000 July 16, 2009 10:51 AM EDT
Yes, that's what our youth need, more religion.

LMAO!!!
by blog_fever2 July 16, 2009 11:10 AM EDT
"Train up a child the way they should go and when they get old the will not depart from it." - Holy Bible
************************************
We need to go back to the basics with our children. This generation is worse of than we ever were.
by Samuel-HiLL July 16, 2009 11:35 AM EDT
Just how does that "explain the lack of gratitude,graciousness and humility that we should see in kids today"?

While this is tragic, what is truly "sad all the way around", is that Christians somehow think they have a monopoly on morals. Just about every moral teaching in the bible can be traced back to Pagan beliefs. Even the ten (or so) commandments, for the most part, were borrowed from existing laws and beliefs, and didn't require the wisdom of an omnscient/omnipotent being.
by lakelizardholmes July 19, 2009 11:21 PM EDT
Gratitude, graciousness, and humility are far from the character traits I have noted most often in over half of century of observing the antics of the Christian church. Condemnation, hypocrisy, and close-mindedness are FAR more common. Christianity has been divided and sub-divided into so many schisms that Jesus himself could not help but be confused ... and mortified. The real threat to American freedom is NOT from Islam; it is from "agree with me or die" Christians who have empirically proven that they cannot even agree with themselves!
# 1 Apostolic/Catholic

* 1.1 Anglican Communion
* 1.2 Assyrian Church of the East
* 1.3 Eastern Orthodox Church
* 1.4 Oriental Orthodox Church
* 1.5 Roman Catholic Church
o 1.5.1 Latin Rite
o 1.5.2 Eastern Catholic Churches
* 1.6 Other Churches that call themselves Catholic
o 1.6.1 Roman
o 1.6.2 (Continuing and Independent) Anglican
o 1.6.3 Orthodox
+ 1.6.3.1 Byzantine
+ 1.6.3.2 Oriental
+ 1.6.3.3 Western-Rite

# 2 Protestantism

* 2.1 Pre-Lutheran Protestants
* 2.2 Lutheranism
* 2.3 Reformed Churches
* 2.4 Presbyterianism
* 2.5 Congregationalist Churches
* 2.6 Anabaptists
* 2.7 Brethren
* 2.8 Methodists
* 2.9 Pietists and Holiness Churches
* 2.10 Baptists
o 2.10.1 Spiritual Baptists
* 2.11 Apostolic Churches - Irvingites
* 2.12 Pentecostalism
* 2.13 Charismatics
o 2.13.1 Neo-Charismatic Churches
* 2.14 African Initiated Churches
* 2.15 United and uniting churches
* 2.16 Religious Society of Friends (Quakers)
* 2.17 Restorationism: Stone-Campbell Movement
* 2.18 Southcottites
* 2.19 Millerites and Comparable groups
o 2.19.1 Sabbath Keeping Churches, Adventist
o 2.19.2 Sabbath-Keeping Churches, Non-Adventist
o 2.19.3 Sunday Adventists
o 2.19.4 Sacred Name Groups
o 2.19.5 Bible Student Groups
* 2.20 Anglo-Israelism
* 2.21 Miscellaneous/Other

# 3 Latter Day Saints

* 3.1 "Prairie Saint" denominations
* 3.2 Rocky Mountains denominations
* 3.3 Other denominations

# 4 Nontrinitarian groups

* 4.1 Oneness Pentecostalism
* 4.2 Unitarianism and Universalism
* 4.3 Swedenborgianism
* 4.4 Other non-Trinitarians

# 5 Messianic Judaism
# 6 New Thought
# 7 New religious movements

* 7.1 Ethnic or syncretic religions incorporating elements of Christianity
* 7.2 New Age movements
* 7.3 Religions associated with the Yoruba

# 8 Esoteric Christianity
by stillwaters6 July 16, 2009 10:00 AM EDT
WHAT IN THE WORLD???
Reply to this comment
by pubsnomore July 16, 2009 9:55 AM EDT
Story says she's part of the RePubs, not the bloods.
Reply to this comment
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 10:19 AM EDT
But you didn't say 'CON' and so you have failed. Try again and again.
by Questionews July 16, 2009 10:34 AM EDT
How's your arm? After that reach it must be dislocated.
(You're usually wittier than that:)
by YuSoWrong July 16, 2009 10:59 AM EDT
Thanks for noticing.
by John_Merritt July 16, 2009 8:47 AM EDT
As per usual, I just wish these news channels could give us a story we could all post decent comments about instead of just filler. Thanks CBS, solid work.
Reply to this comment
by pubsnomore July 16, 2009 8:39 AM EDT
You can see in the background that she was drinking RED KOOL-AID probably by the container! The psychosis must have been too much for her.
Reply to this comment
by sean58z July 16, 2009 6:39 AM EDT
The Police should provide a motive for the killing of Billy Lee. Why did he die on Halloween?
Reply to this comment
by common2cents July 16, 2009 3:50 AM EDT
This article kind of sucks. She was convicted for having her father killed because she asked someone who didn't kill her father to kill him? Legacy asks valid questions that the article should have touched on, also things like what nailed the conviction if the star witnesses apparently sucked would be good to know.

I checked it out on google and apparently a friend of hers had confessed to the murder and said he did it because he believed her father was abusing her, and she wanted the guy to take care of it (and asked him to kill the dad)
Reply to this comment
by legacyabq July 16, 2009 1:26 AM EDT
Strange. The latter part of the article said that the pros. witnesses were "little help"

Obviously thats not the case. They got their conviction didnt they?

What about the person who actually killed the man?

Has he been tried yet?
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat4000 July 16, 2009 10:48 AM EDT
"crappy defence attorney"?

Her attorney," these were just teenagers, saying things that they did not mean".

Ya think?
by ICStoopidPeople July 16, 2009 12:45 AM EDT
I feel really sorry for stoopid people, they always manage to get caught doing really stoopid things. I wonder what her father did to her to make her want him dead. Possibly care for her? Maybe give her a roof over her head or food to eat? God help us all...
Reply to this comment
by arthlop1 July 15, 2009 10:51 PM EDT
She is one fugly chick. They need to send her to Prison and throw away the key.
Reply to this comment
by punchbees July 15, 2009 10:01 PM EDT
yes it says blood, as in the Bloods
Reply to this comment
by timping1 July 15, 2009 9:31 PM EDT
It seems to be some type of hideously debilitating palsy. Looks like it might be related to "Pursed-Lip Palsy". Serious stuff.
Reply to this comment
by John_Merritt July 16, 2009 8:46 AM EDT
Call me naive, but I think it maybe a sign of a local gang or group of friends.
See all 32 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Mike Huckabee on GOP "rock stars," 2012, health care reform and more. Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: