June 25, 2009 2:05 PM

Attorney General Urges New Hate Crimes Law

(CBS/AP)  Attorney General Eric Holder said Tuesday that recent killings show the need for a tougher U.S. hate crimes law to stop "violence masquerading as political activism."

"Over the last several weeks, we have witnessed brazen acts of violence, committed in places that many would have considered unthinkable," Holder told the Washington Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs.

He cited separate attacks over a two-week period that killed a young soldier, an abortion provider and a guard at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum.

Federal agents and prosecutors are already involved in the local investigations of each attack.

The violence, he said, "reminds us of the potential threat posed by violent extremists and the tragedy that ensues when reasoned discourse is replaced by armed confrontation."

In order to stop that violence, he said, Congress should past an updated version of hate crimes legislation, in order to more effectively prosecute those who commit violent attacks based on gender, disability, or sexual orientation.

The growing number of hate crimes against Hispanics also shows the need for tougher laws, Holder said.

"We will not tolerate murder, or the threat of violence, masquerading as political activism," Holder said. "So let me be clear, the Justice Department will use every tool at its disposal to protect the rights ensured under our Constitution."

Earlier, a leading civil rights coalition says there has been an increase in white supremacist activity since the election of the first African-American president.

The Leadership Conference on Civil Rights Education Fund reported Tuesday that the economic downturn and fear of immigrants also contributed to the increase.

The report comes a week after a white supremacist killed a security guard at the U.S. Holocaust Museum.

The coalition reported the U.S. now averages a hate crime nearly every hour of every day. A special concern is the rising number of hate crimes committed against Hispanics and gays.

Separately, a national advocacy group says the number of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people killed in bias-motivated incidents increased by 28 percent in 2008 compared to 2007.

The National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs released its report Tuesday. It says last year's 29 killings is the highest it has recorded since 1999. It documented the same number of slayings then.

The New York-based coalition says the overall number of victims who reported gay bias violence in 2008 increased by 2 percent.

The coalition says its figures are more accurate than those from law enforcement agencies. As an example, the group says the FBI doesn't record bias crimes against transgender people because gender identity isn't covered by federal hate-crime law.

Last week, CBS News correspondent Bob Orr reported that in the past eight years, the number of hate groups in America has exploded - up 50 percent - from 602 in 2000 to 926 last year.

© 2009 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 72 Comments
by blog_fever2 June 19, 2009 10:37 AM EDT
This is good. I think there should be a hate crimes law and it should apply to all people. You do not have to like everyone, but we do have to get along. To commit a crime against someone for no reason other than hate is ridiculous. This is 2009 people. Let's grow up.
Reply to this comment
by endurorob June 17, 2009 7:53 AM EDT
by woeisme1 June 17, 2009 4:21 AM PDT
What you people do not seem to understand is there IS a difference between the guy who would cut my throat because I may be gay and the guy who cuts my throat for $20.00.

The guy who robs me wants MY $20. He is a robber, a thief. The guy who wants to cut ALL gays throats hates EVERYONE in that group. His hate endangers far more people and is not random like a petty thief, but organized and deliberate as opposed to a crime of opportunity like a petty thief.

This really is'nt too hard to understand.


Thats just ignorant. There are many more people murdered for money or other items than are murdered because of race or sexual orientation.... Just because you are gay or a minority does not make your life more valuable.
Reply to this comment
by woeisme1 June 17, 2009 10:50 AM EDT
Theres nothing ignorant about my post at all. Let me repeat this as simply as I can for all you right wing radicals who struggle with logic.

Hate crimes are designed for those who would kill on a mass scale if they could. A robber will rob only when he needs. A racists or a fascists will kill based on an ideology that ALL people in a segment of society deserve to be killed, and he/she will continue to kill. Is a serial killer worse than someone who commits manslaughter? Of course! That is why the person committing the hate crime is more a threat to more people. And that is why we need hate crime laws.

You right wing radicals are very paranoid of this...why? I am suspicious of you guys. I hope the FBI, SS, CIA and everyone is keeping a close eye on you people. You're weird.
by lloydbest1 June 18, 2009 12:06 AM EDT
"Thats just ignorant. There are many more people murdered for money or other items than are murdered because of race or sexual orientation.... Just because you are gay or a minority does not make your life more valuable."

It's not about the money. It's not about catching someone in bed with your wife. It's not about vehicular homocide or any of the almost limitless ways we can kill each other through malice.
We are talking about IDEOLOGICAL crimes. These are the very worst sort. Bobby Cutts, a black ex-police officer, was sentenced to prison for killing his white girlfriend. What he did was unconscionable and he deserved worse than he got. But the point here is he went after only one white. And that one was an intimate. As far as I know he doesn't hate whites in general enough to slaughter them at random or en masse.
There's your difference between "ordinary" crime and hate motivated crime the has the same end result. The criminal motivated by hate wants to kill ALL (or as many as he can) Whites, Blacks, Christians, Gays, Cops - whatever BECAUSE of those characteristics. That is what makes an ideological crime; a hate crime so much more reprehensible.
No, "Just because you are gay or a minority does not make your life more valuable" but it doesn't make it less so, either. And that is what the hate criminal believes.
by gunownerdan June 17, 2009 6:55 AM EDT
Please learn about the hateful and racist roots of gun control in America.
Watch "NO GUNS FOR NEGROES" for free at......
JPFO.org

"Free people can own guns, slaves can not."
Reply to this comment
by woeisme1 June 17, 2009 7:28 AM EDT
What on earth do guns and slaves have to do with this thread at all? I think you're the one with hateful and racist roots.
by endurorob June 17, 2009 6:44 AM EDT
So ley me get this straight. If someone cuts your throat because you are gay they should get harsher punishment than if they cut your throat because they want the $20 in your wallet? Is that correct?
Reply to this comment
by woeisme1 June 17, 2009 7:21 AM EDT
What you people do not seem to understand is there IS a difference between the guy who would cut my throat because I may be gay and the guy who cuts my throat for $20.00.

The guy who robs me wants MY $20. He is a robber, a thief. The guy who wants to cut ALL gays throats hates EVERYONE in that group. His hate endangers far more people and is not random like a petty thief, but organized and deliberate as opposed to a crime of opportunity like a petty thief.

This really is'nt too hard to understand.
by endurorob June 17, 2009 6:41 AM EDT
mnbrant June 16, 2009 8:49 PM PDT
California violent crimes
REPORTED TOTAL MURDER=2,503 RAPE=9,392 ROBBERY=63,622 ASSAULT=114,661

United States violent crimes
REPORTED TOTAL MURDER=16,692 RAPE=93,934 ROBBERY=417,122 ASSAULT=862,947

Percentage of violent crime committed in the good ole state of California.
Murder=12.51% RAPE=10% ROBBERY=66% ASSAULT=25%

Does this mean we build a wall around California to save ourselves? At the risk of sounding radical I say NO. Even though they won't pass tax increases to pay their own way and expect govt to give them a bailout

First off a couple of your numbers are wrong. For robbery Cal accounts for about 15% and for assault they account for about 13%. Now considering California accoutns for more thatn 12% of the population the numbers are not a surprise.
Reply to this comment
by pensacola8-2009 June 17, 2009 12:43 AM EDT
I applaud Attorney General Eric Holder for his initiative to fill in the critical missing piece to providing domestic security.

It has been very clear that several radical groups have infected communities with violence under the umbrella of 501C3 (Non Profit Groups).

It has been very clear that gang violence has a competitor with organized crime coming from radical religoius (501C3) groups.

I had dinner in a restaurant just this evening and learned about a church in Tennessee that was actually a front and serving organized crime by performing money laundering services.

The country side in the south is littered with numerous phony churches who evade tax payment and contribute to organized crime.
Reply to this comment
by mnbrant June 17, 2009 12:48 AM EDT
Huh? You talking about Bennie Hinn and Creflo Dollar?
by mnbrant June 16, 2009 11:49 PM EDT
California violent crimes
REPORTED TOTAL MURDER=2,503 RAPE=9,392 ROBBERY=63,622 ASSAULT=114,661

United States violent crimes
REPORTED TOTAL MURDER=16,692 RAPE=93,934 ROBBERY=417,122 ASSAULT=862,947

Percentage of violent crime committed in the good ole state of California.
Murder=12.51% RAPE=10% ROBBERY=66% ASSAULT=25%

Does this mean we build a wall around California to save ourselves? At the risk of sounding radical I say NO. Even though they won't pass tax increases to pay their own way and expect govt to give them a bailout

28 deaths due to hate crimes unspecified. lets look at the percentages compared to California. I don't know how to add but I think its .0018% correct me if I am wrong. Other crimes unspecified oh well.

To make a long story short Ruby Ridge and other acts the intelligence community and govt perpetrated on these guys made the Dems lose and propelled me to become right wing for a number of years. All you CIA types and Community activist Stasi type people mass blogging this blog. Ask yourself this what you ban. A college group promoting white culture and ideas accepting people of all races who have an interest to come, and who as a group have commited no crime, or a group of players from the basketball team who commit gang rape. If your CIA or Stasi I know what you will answer will be. As far as I know there are no precogs out there who can predict who will commit a violent crime. Except me heh.
Reply to this comment
by billpl-2009 June 16, 2009 11:22 PM EDT
a crime is a crime and all are created equal

if there's a pattern or a specific group causing it, fine, let law enforcement investigate it
that's why we have them

if the crime is more serious or has special circumstances, fine, let the jury weigh in and stiffen the sentence
that's why we have them

to have a bunch of old crows sitting around a conference table on the government time clock, telling us what's wrong and right, is a waste
that's why we don't need them
Reply to this comment
by fred-mertz June 16, 2009 10:58 PM EDT
"Terrorists and other violent extremists will always prefer unarmed and defenseless victims." - gunownerdan

No, dan. GUN OWNERS, cowards that they all are, will always prefer unarmed and defenseless victims! See, a gun won't do you any good at all if someone else comes to kill you and they have a gun and it's armed and aimed and the safety is off. They shoot first... you die. Your gun is useless.

Furthermore, no one is "defenseless" simply because they don't carry a gun. The best defense is to NOT MAKE ENEMIES. The second best defense is to NOT BE THERE WHEN YOUR ENEMY ARRIVES. A gun doesn't even make the list of possible "defenses". A gun is WORTHLESS for defense. A gun is designed to do ONE thing, and only one thing: to KILL. That's NOT a "defensive act". It is the violently agressive act of a coward.

But there's GOOD NEWS: the number 1 fatal use of guns in this country is NOT killing criminals to "defend yourself", it is NOT being killed by criminals, it is NOT anything the NRA will tell you about. The number 1 fatal use of guns by gun owners is SUICIDE. That's what guns are REALLY GOOD FOR, to kill yourself. Next to that, they're also great for killing your kids or your wife or her new "friend" or your neighbors-- you know, the kinds of things CRIMINALS AND CRAZY PEOPLE DO. Why, guns are just GREAT at killing people, no matter who those people happen to be, whether they are criminals, passersby, or your intimate family members! So, go ahead, dan. We're waiting for YOU to become the next statistic. There's no doubt, that's where you're headed.
Reply to this comment
by johninpennsyl June 16, 2009 10:20 PM EDT
Remember,people-only Whitey can hate.
If you happen to be killed or mugged by a minority....don't take it personal.
Reply to this comment
by Rebel_Rebel June 16, 2009 10:54 PM EDT
That is ridiculous!
See all 72 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook