Mystery Lincoln Memo Turns Up In Hawaii

Researchers Want To Know How Civil War-Era Document Ended Up On Islands That Were Not Part Of U.S. At Time

(AP)  Documents bearing signatures of U.S. presidents have turned up in a lot of unexpected places: Attics, libraries, even thrift stores.

But how did an innocuous Civil War-era memo bearing Abraham Lincoln's signature end up in the state archives of Hawaii, which was not part of the United States at the time? State researchers are trying to find out.

The memo dated Sept. 22, 1862, orders the secretary of state at the time to affix the U.S. seal to a separate piece of paper, a proclamation dated the same day.

That proclamation was the Preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln's official warning to rebellious Southern states to return to the Union within three months or face military emancipation of their slaves.

Hawaii records indicate they've had the memo - but not the proclamation - for at least 74 years.

"We knew we had it," said Luella Kurkjian, chief of the archives' historical records branch. "Quite frankly, we didn't know what it was. There was no documentation with it."

Hawaii's archives also contain one letter each from Lincoln to King Kamehameha IV and to his brother, King Kamehameha V, and a note from Lincoln appointing a new U.S. consul, Alfred Caldwell, to the Kingdom of Hawaii.

The Kingdom of Hawaii was overthrown by mostly American residents in 1893 and annexed to the United States in 1898. It became America's 50th state in 1959.

"Those three all make sense to be in the Hawaii State Archives," said Daniel Stowell, director of the Papers of Abraham Lincoln, a part of the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum in Springfield, Illinois.

"This one is a fish out of water," Stowell said of the 1862 memo. "I mean, it doesn't fit. Why is it here?"

Officials are following a couple of clues.

Back in the 1920s and '30s, the archives received several donations from a collector named Bruce Cartwright Jr., grandson of Alexander Joy Cartwright, considered by sports historians to be the inventor of baseball.

One of those donated items was the Lincoln-signed note announcing Caldwell's appointment, Kurkjian said.

"It's my guess that (Cartwright) is the donor" of the proclamation memo "and for whatever reason it wasn't properly documented," she said.

"I can't prove it. I've been trying," she said.

"Its an interesting mystery," Stowell said.

[Dgunner]

Stealing the land and committing genocide on the redman wasn't enough they had to get into boats and go murder and steal a kingdom from yet another unconquered people.Oh the tyranny !

[tmittelstaed]

Bruce Cartwright was born in 1853 and there's recorded evidence that he was in Hawaii at least through the 1880's, however, his father Alexander Cartwright also had another son, Alexander III, who eventually moved to San Francisco and had several children, among them Mary Muriel who donated her grandfathers Gold Rush diary to the Bishop Museum in Hawaii. I suspect there's many donations to Hawaiian museums and the archives from that family over the years as the Cartwrights were close to the Hawaiian Royal Family and were involved with them, so it would be an easy guess to say they donated it.

[koko98-2009]

During the 19th century Hawaii was in the American sphere of influence. It was dominated by the missionaries and the planters. It should not be unusual to find a civil war era artifact in the islands.

[rlsutter]

Hey, maybe Lincoln was really born in Hawaii!