Devices To Help You Ditch Cable TV

In Tough Economy, CNET Looks At Alternatives To Expensive Cable Service

(CNET)  The economy is in the toilet, and I know I'm not the only person in America who is looking for ways to cut costs. Top on my list in 2009 is finding a way to eliminate my $100 a month cable TV bill.

Up until very recently, the idea of cutting off subscription TV would have meant skimping on a whole lot of good quality entertainment. I must admit, I don't watch a lot of TV. But I watch enough that I would be very sad if I had to give up HBO's "Flight of the Conchords" or NBC's "30 Rock."

But thanks to that wonderful communications network known as the Internet and the fact that big Hollywood studios and TV networks have finally realized that digital distribution is actually a good thing, cable cord cutters, like me, won't have to sacrifice that much or anything at all, depending on what movies and TV programs we like to watch.

Thanks to services like Netflix, iTunes, and Amazon On Demand, consumers can simply stream or download movies or previous seasons of TV shows directly from the Web anytime they want. And for those viewers looking for current seasons of TV shows, they can turn to Web sites, such as Hulu.com or TV.com, which have aggregated some of the most popular TV shows for on-demand viewing over the Net. (Disclosure: CNET and TV.com are properties of CBS Interactive.)

However, even though it's nice to be able to watch "The Dark Night" or "The Office" on your PC or laptop, many people would prefer to kick back on their couches and view it on that big flat-screen TV in their living rooms. So how do you get all the cool video content from your PC to the TV?

Well, there are plenty of options available today and more are coming. LG and Samsung already offer Blu-ray players that can stream Netflix movies; both companies are upping the ante in 2009 with Netflix-friendly home theater systems, HDTVs--and more Blu-ray players. Panasonic's 2009 VieraCast-compatible plasmas will offer support for Amazon Video On Demand. Meanwhile, a new company called ZillionTV is also working with broadband providers, movie studios, TV networks, and advertisers to create an entirely new business model to give consumers yet another easy and cheap way to view on-demand movies and TV shows using their Internet connections.

But if buying a new TV or Blu-ray player isn't in your budget for 2009, here's a look at some alternatives. A number of companies are making inexpensive, purpose-built boxes to provide movies and TV shows over the Net. And if you're a gamer, console makers such as Microsoft and Sony already have Internet-based video functionality.

For those tech-savvy TV viewers out there who aren't afraid of going the extra mile, there's also the option of simply hooking up a computer to your TV and using that 40-inch flat-screen as your PC monitor to locate and view online video.

I've done a little digging through the CNET Reviews archives to highlight the top 10 boxes/computers for accessing video-on-demand content via the Web. Here's a brief summary of each, in no particular order. You can see at a glance what makes each one cool and what makes it not so cool. And you'll get a general idea of how much each one costs.

I'm sorry to say that I haven't found a box that offers me everything from all the top movies and TV shows to the best local and live TV programming. But the market is still evolving. And I promise you that the landscape could look very different in another 18 months, so stay tuned.

Roku Digital Video Player - $99

Roku CNET review

What makes it cool? At $99, the Roku box is a cheap and simple way to stream movies and TV shows from the Internet to your TV. Users can subscribe to Netflix's Watch Now on-demand video service for as little as $9 a month and watch as many of Netflix's 12,000 streaming movie and TV titles as they like. Roku also recently added even more titles to its service through Amazon's pay-per-view Video on Demand service. For as little as $2 to $4 a pop, viewers can rent movies or TV episodes.
The CNET Reviews team gives this device a high score for being simple to set up with built-in wired and 802.11g Wi-Fi networking. It works with all TVs. And the firmware is upgradeable, so as Roku adds more services and options like advertising-supported programming from the big networks like ABC, NBC, CBS, and Fox -- an option that the company is currently exploring -- users can grow with the service.

What makes it not so cool? Roku needs more content. Currently, Netflix's streaming library is only a fraction of its DVD-by-mail offering, especially when it comes to popular recent releases. There's no browser to access Hulu.com or other sites offering other programming online. The CNET Reviews team notes that the video quality for non-HD titles is not DVD quality, especially when viewed on large TVs. There's also no surround sound (yet), and the Netflix queue still has to be managed from a PC.

---

Apple TV - $215 to $329

AppleTV CNET review

What makes it cool? Apple TV offers a variety of free and premium media content over the Net directly to your TV. Using Apple's popular iTunes Store, users can rent movies and TV shows, buy and listen to music, view photos, and access podcasts. The AppleTV also allows people to stream media from networked Mac or Windows PCs (assuming that it's already been imported into iTunes). Apple has struck deals with all the major movie studios, and some of the titles are in HD. It offers surround sound on some titles as well. The CNET Reviews team also like Apple's "sleek external design and elegant user interface." The setup is simple and it comes equipped with 802.11n wireless networking.

Pricing for movie rentals and purchases vary depending on whether they are in standard definition or high definition and depending on whether they are a new release or an older movie. But prices to rent movies are between about $1.99 and $4.99. And movies can be bought for about $15 a pop. The box currently comes in two versions: 40GB and 160GB.

What makes it not so cool? AppleTV doesn't work with older, non-widescreen TVs. And once again, the device doesn't come with a browser to access content that's available for free on the Web such as Hulu.com or TV.com. Basically, if it's not something you can get in iTunes, you won't be able to watch it on Apple TV.

---

Vudu - $125 to $150

Vudu CNET review

What makes it cool? Like Apple TV and Roku, Vudu is a dedicated set-top box for playing Internet-delivered video content. But what sets it apart from these other players is that the video resolution is much better at a full 1080p HD resolution. It also offers surround sound. As for content, Vudu offers a selection of movies from all the major studios as well as TV shows. It also offers adult content. And for the budget-conscious viewers, it added a bargain channel to the service that offers a rotating list of 99 movies for just $0.99 a pop.
What makes it not so cool? For one, its video library pales in comparison to Netflix or Amazon, which offer 12,000 and 40,000 titles, respectively. What's more, the best-quality HD content requires download queuing before viewing. It can't stream media from other networked PCs, and it lacks Wi-Fi.

---

2Wire MediaPoint Digital Media Player - $99 with included 25-movie download credit

2Wire MediaPoint Digital Media Player CNET review

What makes it cool? This box is very similar to the Roku, AppleTV, and Vudu devices. The single-purpose box, which costs $99, is essentially free since it comes with a 25-movie credit. It streams Blockbuster OnDemand video titles to your TV. There's no monthly fee, and it has built-in Ethernet and 802.11g Wi-Fi for easy networking. Blockbuster OnDemand offers more, newer titles than Netflix. And the device allows for progressive downloading, which means movies can be downloaded and then viewed on slower connections.

What makes it not so cool? The CNET Reviews team doesn't recommend this device. They say the remote is tiny and cluttered. There is no HD viewing, and it offers a small selection of movie and TV titles. And like other boxes built for streaming alone, it has no Web browser for accessing free online video content.

---

Microsoft Xbox 360 - $180 to $400

Microsoft Xbox 360 CNET review

What makes it cool? The Xbox 360 is primarily a gaming console, but it also offers an on-demand movie rental service from Netflix as well as from its own Xbox Video Marketplace. According to the CNET Reviews team, it has a superior selection of games and excellent online gaming and communications via Xbox Live. The box also doubles as a digital media hub and Windows Media Center extender. And it plays DVDs.

What's not so cool? The system is big and noisy. There's no built-in wireless networking. And like the purpose-built video streaming boxes, it doesn't have a browser for accessing other free online video content. And at around $300 (for the 60GB version), it's on the expensive side if all you'd like to do is stream movies and TV from the Web. (You also need to have a $50 a year Xbox Live Gold subscription to access the Netflix feature.) But if you're looking for a gaming console, DVD player, and Netflix-capable media center too, this might be a box to consider.

---

Sony PlayStation 3 - $400

Sony PlayStaton 3 CNET review

What makes it cool? Like the Xbox 360, the Sony PS3 is primarily a gaming console that also happens to offer online movie and TV viewing on your TV. Movies can be bought, or they can be rented for 24 hours from the online Sony PlayStation Store. Movies are available from most major Hollywood studios and TV networks. Unlike the Xbox 360 and the other online video appliances, the PS3 also has a built-in Web browser that allows users to find and view any Web content on their TV. The console has built-in Wi-Fi as well. And in addition to games and online videos, it also plays standard DVD movies and HD Blu-ray movies.

What makes it not so cool? The biggest knock against this device with respect to movie watching is the fact that the media and commerce options are not nearly as developed as Xbox Live, according to CNET Reviews.

---

TiVo HD/Series3 - $250 to $300

TiVo HD/Series3 CNET review

What makes it cool? Like the gaming consoles, the TiVo HD/Series3 is much more than an appliance for watching TV over your broadband connection. It's also a digital video recorder that can record two HD programs simultaneously while playing back a third, previously recorded one. But in addition to being a pretty cool DVR, it also offers on-demand movies over the Internet from Netflix, Amazon, CinemaNow, and Jaman.

What makes it not so cool? The biggest issue with TiVo is the price. While the up-front cost is a reasonable $300, it also requires a monthly subscription fee for the DVR function, which can add up over time. And if you are trying to replace your subscription TV service, it seems like you wouldn't need a DVR to record shows, because you'd be able to get them on-demand whenever you wanted to watch something. And like other devices mentioned here, the TiVo does not come with full Internet browsing to get already available video online.

---

SlingCatcher - $200 to $300

SlingCatcher CNET review

What makes it cool? SlingMedia's SlingCatcher lets owners of the companion Slingbox product place-shift viewing from one room to another (say, from the living room to bedroom), so you can watch live TV, or stuff that's recorded on your DVR, for example. But the SlingCatcher also includes SlingProjector software (Windows only, for now) that streams any video playing on your PC to your TV. That includes video from Web sites like Hulu.com, TV.com, and YouTube on your TV. Viewers can also use the SlingCatcher to view movies downloaded on their PCs from services such as Amazon or iTunes. Basically, anything you can play on your PC can be viewed on your TV via the SlingCatcher.

What makes it not so cool? The Web video viewing is a bit kludgy. You pretty much need to keep a laptop or desktop on to access the TV shows and online video content you want. That means navigating to new videos and sites needs to be done from the PC--not from through the SlingCatcher's remote.

---

Mac Mini - $599 to $799

Mac Mini CNET review

What makes it cool? The Mac Mini is a tiny computer with a cute and slick design that easily fits in a home entertainment center. And because the Mac Mini is a full-blown computer using Apple's OS, it can easily surf the Web and play video from any Web site offering video. This includes Hulu.com, TV.com, and all the major TV networks offering video on their Web sites as well as user-generated sites such as YouTube. Viewers could also download movies from Amazon or iTunes and watch them on the big screen via the Mac Mini. The Mac Mini comes in two configurations: a 2GHz Core 2 Duo processor, 1GB of RAM, and a 120GB hard drive; or 2GHz Core 2 Duo chip, 2GB of RAM, and a 320GB hard drive.

What makes it not so cool? The Mac Mini is expensive. The low-end version costs $599, and the high-end version costs $799. And because it's a computer, users will need to get a wireless mouse and keyboard to navigate and search for content.

---

Acer Aspire X1700 - $479

Acer Aspire X1700 CNET review

What makes it cool?This desktop PC is compact and includes an HDMI video and digital audio output, making it a good pick for a low-cost, compact PC to stream online videos to the TV. Like the Mac Mini, the fact that the Acer Aspire is a full computer means that viewers can surf the Net and watch video from any Web site. This includes sites that offer free TV shows like Hulu.com or they can download movies from Amazon or iTunes and watch them on the big screen. Of course, users could also use the computer to view movies from BitTorrent and other sites that offer movies via peer-to-peer services.

What makes it not so hot? This particular PC is not as fast as the competition, notes the CNET Reviews staff. And just like with the Mac Mini, the fact that the Acer is a computer means that users will have to use a mouse and keyboard to navigate and search for content.

[Samuel-HiLL]

@brianbwb-2009

I think you misunderstood part of my post. While the tuner in my vid card is indeed an analog receiver, it isn't connected to or receiving anything. All the vid card does is provide an HDMI output. All video is streamed over the internet and it will continue to stream just fine in a couple of months.

Your points about the PIII are well taken but not exactly accurate. Replacement parts are actually dirt cheap. For example, I purchased two spare PIII CPU on eBay for $20 and a box with 20 sticks of RAM for $5. If the mobo, northbridge/southbridge go belly up, I can buy another entire machine for next to nothing. There are zillions of them out there.

Of course you are right that upgrading to an AMD box with built in HDMI and 7.1 audio would be a wise improvment. Being an AMD fan, thats probably the route I will go when I build the next media box. I just happened to have the PIII sitting around so I put it to good use.

In fact, I have a bunch of so called obsolete computers that do my bidding for me. Right now Im using a machine built with an old server board sporting 2 1.7 GHZ Athlons, 2 gigs of RAM, and 320 GBs of storage, running 2 19 inch LCD monitors. You wouldnt believe me if I told you how cheap it was to build.

The point is, you can easily put together an adequet system without the limitations of the devices mentioned in the article, without breaking the bank. Sure, its not the latest greatest hardware, but it doesnt have to be.

If anyone wants to know more: samhill at myrealbox dot com

[brianbwb-2009]

" What makes it not so hot? Hmmmm cant think of anything right off the bat." Posted by Samuel-HiLL

What makes it not so hot is that in a couple of monthas you will still need a converter box to decode the new digital signals, your setup is basically an analog receiver, what you will soon need is a digital receiver, and those are much more than $50. Try $300+.

Also because your machine is a PIII, if anything should go wrong with any of the components, (ram, mainboard, cpu, north-and-south bridges, for example) your best option is a total upgrade, as the replacement parts for your machine are now more expensive than they are worth.

The idea is good, just letting you know to be prepared, perhaps start upgrading your machine now (AMD quad-cores are cheap now, as is ddr 800 ram, and mainboards now have on-board HDMI out, and 7.1 sound built in. You can ditch that blaster for a far better solution at no extra cost.

Then when the changeover is official, only put in the digital decoder card, (or usb dongle) and you're good to go.

[brianbwb-2009]

" We have a tv that uses a rabbit ears antenna and no converter box...haven't lost any stations as of yet." Posted by httpwwwnews

"As of yet" being important words, because when the changeover date comes, (it has been pushed back because in the current economy no one is buying the boxes) you will suddenly lose all of your channels at once.

Then it is buy a new digital-ready TV, or an expensive converter box/ cable decoder, and pay monthly fees, which they will say are for the cable channels, but you will soon find that even the free to air channels you now watch won't be viewable unless the box is activated, which means you will be paying a TV tax directly to the cable companies.

[heliocracy]

I spent way too much on my TV to watch highly compressed, less-than-1080p video on it for a $1 per episode. If I had to pay a dollar per episode for the TV shows I watch now on cable, my bill would be a thousand dollars per month. Also, there's a lot out there I didn't know I wanted to watch until I did...when everyone has to go online and pick and choose what they want to see, no one will ever watch anything they've never heard of before, especially if they have to pay in advance for it. I think I'll just stick with a system that doesn't compress the video, provides at least 5.1 audio, and lets me channel surf without a lot of preplanning and research. That's cable.

[httpwwwnews]

First, none of this works unless you have a fast connection for your computer or whatever else you connect it to. You can't watch Netflix on Demand on dial up. Too slow! So you're still going to have to pay for that speed/connectivity.

We have a tv that uses a rabbit ears antenna and no converter box...haven't lost any stations as of yet.

[Samuel-HiLL]

It doesn't take the latest whiz bang computer to stream video. I have an old Pentium III that does a great job. All it takes is a video card upgrade (if it doesnt already have HDMI) and a cheap soundblaster card for surround capability. I have a $50 video card with built in tuner that came with a remote, so I can keep the wireless keyboard and mouse out of site until I need them. I have the processor speed turned down and you cant even hear the fan running. To top it off I have $14 USB wireless adapter that connects it all to an unsecured wireless network. I have less than $200 in the whole shebang and my monthly cost is $0.

What makes it not so hot? Hmmmm cant think of anything right off the bat.

[brianbwb-2009]

Seems I am the only one who noticed the scam, cable made its debut as a subscription service that promised commercial-free viewing for the fee, but to prevent it from becoming a de facto tv tax, it was seperated from the non-fee free stations, ABC,CBS, and NBC, as well as the local channels.

Now they all have to go thru the box, which is exactly what we were promised wouldn't happen, noiw you pay to watch also the previously non-cable channels, because the box won't work until you pay the fee.

Not only has it become the de facto tax, but also this tax goes directly to corporate coffers, without any requirements to use any of it for public services.

Also, whatever happened to "commercial-free"?

[hsudul]

I never got the promised coupon for converter box,,,, And learning to live without TV
isn't so ad. I get some of the news on the intemet
REality shows have merely shown how people were do anything for money and
foolishly classify this as entertanment is ludicrious. America needs to get a life.Ride
a bike throw a FRisbee and do volunteer work .It's difficult to laugh when half of the
world is struggling.