
WASHINGTON, Jan. 12, 2009
Where Did The Bailout Billions Really Go?
CBS Evening News Exclusive: Were Bank Bailout Winners And Losers Cherry-Picked?
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Bailout Money Trail
Congress is wary of how President-elect Obama plans to spend TARP funds as Bush bailout billions went to buy other banks and not to free up credit, reports Sharyl Attkisson.
-
Video
Bailout Bait And Switch?
The financial industry bailout was supposed to help troubled mortgage holders and free up credit lending. So why have the firms used the money to buy up smaller banks? Sharyl Attkisson reports.
-
Photo
Panelists testify at a Senate Banking Committee hearing Nov. 13, 2008. (CBS)
-
Timeline
Stopgap Measures
A look at the series of government moves to try and stem the financial meltdown.
-
Timeline
Financial Meltdown
Track major events that lead to one of the most tumultuous times in Wall Street's history.

• Murtha's Defense Earmarks Questioned
• Bailout Banks Hike Up Charges
• Student Loan Charity Under Fire
• Bailout Money To Tax Havens
• Big Bank's Bailout Spending Spree
• The Impossible-To-Track Bailout
• Where Did The Bailout Billions Really Go?
• Pension System A Runaway Train
• Parking Garage To Nowhere
• Did D.C. Bribery Cost Troop Lives?
• Teach For America Gets Schooled
• USDA Jobs A Day At The Beach?
• From Lawmaker To Lobbyist
• Flying The Empty Skies
• Fishing For Tax $$
• Millions In Pills, Flushed
But once the bill became law on October 3, Henry Paulson's Treasury Department moved quickly on an entirely different front: Give bailout money to select banks to help them buy competitors. It was largely under the public radar, with only anonymous government officials acknowledging the strategy, CBS News investigative correspondent Sharyl Attkisson reports.
During the hearing on Nov. 13, Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn., called it "confounding to me."
Rep. Dennis Kucinich, D-Ohio, said it "breaks with congressional intent."
But CBS News has learned the banking industry was clued-in from the start.
Listen to what BB&T Bank's chief executive told analysts in a conference call shortly after the bailout passed. He's not talking about using bailout funds to help with mortgages or consumer credit - but to buy other banks.
"This is a relatively inexpensive way to raise capital for acquisition opportunities," said John Allison, CEO of BB&T.
A month later, they got $3 billion in bailout money.
Just look at all the banks we found that have gotten taxpayer bailout funds, and are gobbling up the competition:
Nobody from the Treasury Department would respond to CBS News' questions. But some analysts say the idea is to strengthen the banking industry by giving strong banks the means to take over weak ones.
It's not necessarily working out that way.
Some banks judged by federal regulators as "strong," like Merrill Lynch and Provident Bancshares, are the very ones getting bought out.
And some in Congress are upset that the Treasury Secretary is hand-picking winners and losers.
In a November 14 hearing, Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Calif., said: "Hank Paulson gets to decide who lives and who dies? Who buys whom?"Read more at Couric & Co. Blog: Bailout "Bait And Switch?"
Take PNC Bank and National City. Both wanted bailout money but only PNC got it: Then, it bought National City.
Rep. Kucinich is from Cleveland, where National City was based. He grilled the Treasury official in charge of the bailout, Neel Kashkari, saying in the Nov. 14 hearing: "You picked a winner, PNC, and you picked a loser, National City Bank."
Kashkari responded: "With deep respect, it is not appropriate for me to speak about an individual institution, but I can talk generally about …"
"Well, with deep respect, you know, you put 4,000 people out of work in the city of Cleveland," Kucinich said. "You're, you know … are you taking a Fifth Amendment here?"
"No, sir," Kashkari said. "I don't think it's a good use of taxpayer money to put taxpayer capital into a financial institution that's going to fail."
"Boy, you know that statement that you just made you will hear about for the rest of your career," Kucinich said.
With billions going to banks and so far not helping with the mortgage crisis, congressional leaders this week said no further bailout money will be given to Treasury without much stricter conditions.
© MMIX, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News
- Latest in CBS Evening News
- The Story Behind the Skating Babies
- Sagging Sales, Even in a Beach Paradise
- Grief, Outrage over Grave Desecrations
Read more at Couric & Co. Blog: Bailout "Bait And Switch?"



- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- next
See all 163 Commentsthis whole mess is their fault and Barny Frank should be impeached
Posted by stinginrich at 07:34 PM : Jan 12, 2009
Paulson is NOT a Jew.
But then, Paulson is not the head of the Fed.
What religion is Barny Frank again? I forgot already.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08
Hey - Another International conspiracy by Jewish Bankers. What nonsense. You guys never give up.
Posted by stinginrich at 07:34 PM : Jan 12, 2009
Paulson is NOT a Jew.
But then, Paulson is not the head of the Fed.
What religion is Barny Frank again? I forgot already.
------------------------
----------------------------------------
----------------
Posted by repo_man_08
Hey - Some of you make rotten decisions, get yourself into financial trouble, spend the equity in your homes, don''t save anything for emergencies and retirement, and max out your credir cards. Then you lose your job. After all of your stupidity, you blame the bankers and belive you are vitims of an international Jewish conspiracy. What losers.
+ report abuse
Posted by rhs648 at 07:51 PM : Jan 12, 2009
report abuse
Please get your GED''s, Wingnuts....
Fed Refuses to Disclose Recipients of $2 Trillion
Mark Pittam - Bloomberg News
Friday 12 December 2008
The Federal Reserve refused a request by Bloomberg News to disclose the recipients of more than $2 trillion of emergency loans from U.S. taxpayers and the assets the central bank is accepting as collateral.
Bloomberg filed suit Nov. 7 under the U.S. Freedom of Information Act requesting details about the terms of 11 Fed lending programs, most created during the deepest financial crisis since the Great Depression.
The Fed responded Dec. 8, saying it''s allowed to withhold internal memos as well as information about trade secrets and commercial information. The institution confirmed that a records search found 231 pages of documents pertaining to some of the requests.
Obama and his people should make it clear to Congress that they (Congress) already have all the leverage they need to discover where past TARP monies have gone - regardless of what is stated by the NYT, Pols, or the pundits on Cable that it is not %u2018tracked%u2019 or even traceable (that by itself is laughable). No one can be that stupid. Of course it can be tracked, but the financial institutions themselves must be given an incentive to do so. So give it to them %u2013 "no more money until we have a full and complete accounting (to the penny)." Of course, once they understand they''ll do so, but it will also mean more work for the SEC/AG. With time, hopefully, the public will see the accountability that they/we so richly deserve, that is, in the form of a lot more suicides and jail-time. In my opinion, it will take about 300 or so suicides or jailbirds before the public finds the "confidence" that everyone talks about. Otherwise, the public will itself exact punishment on the ruling class and wealthy by holding out even longer. If money has been sitting in a vault, terrific... "now use it according to the latest requirements and mandates"; the monies were "diverted"... hmmm - jail anyone? The point is that the apple is rotten to the core, smells corrupt, is corrupt, and too many deals have been made; the question is, and it must be answered "this time", by whom? Let''s pray and hope Obama isn''t in on it too (and has the courage of his convictions). Anyway, just my two cents..
TIME AND TIME AGAIN, the U.S. government USES the emotional state brought by some crisis or another to implement terrible legislation that directly benefits the friends of whoever happens to be in power, or their agendas.
This bailout has been a joke, it''s really unbelievable that they can pull a SCAM like this RIGHT IN FRONT OF US, and we remain powerless, utterly powerless to do anything..
After 911, we got war and the PATRIOT act because of emotional reactionism. After this supposed "crisis" in the banking industry, the biggest banks in the world get free and open access to the US Treasury, and what do they do with the money??????
Make themselves bigger!! Richer!! Grow grow grow the bottom line boys!!
This is wholesale theft! This is fascism! Rule by the corporate elite! There is no distinction anymore between the corporations of the world and the U.S. Federal government! From the military, to the money system, corporations ARE the u.s. government..
What a wonderful world!
Posted by rhs648,
Yeah, everyone could be more responsible when it comes to these decisions. Given the nature of your post I can see that you are one to hold others accountable for thier decisions.
Remembering that do you care to comment on how well the Bush adminstration has run the country, managed foreign policy, Iraq and the public debt?
Considering his job performance you must be ready to go postal on him!
Take it easy, not everyone is as responsible as you are.
Thus, Paulsons demand to handle the $700 billion without oversight---that alone was suspect and still no oversight from our government---they ALL ought to go to jail!
The worldwide economic downturn called the Great Depression, which persisted from 1929 until about 1939, was the longest and worst depression ever experienced by the industrialized Western World. While originating in the U.S., it ended up causing drastic declines in output, severe unemployment, and acute deflation in virtually every country on earth. According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, "the Great Depression ranks second only to the Civil War as the gravest crisis in American history".
What exactly caused this economic tsunami that devastated the U.S. and much of the world??
In "A Monetary History of the United States", Nobel Prize-winning economist Milton Friedman along with coauthor Anna J. Schwartz lay the mega-catastrophe of the Great Depression squarely at the feet of the Federal Reserve.
Bernanke:
"Let me end my talk by abusing slightly my status as an official representative of the Federal Reserve. I would like to say to Milton and Anna, regarding the Great Depression, you''re right, we did it. We''re very sorry. But thanks to you, we won''t do it again...
(Oh, we believe you, Benny)......LOL
After all of your stupidity, you blame the bankers and belive you are vitims of an international Jewish conspiracy. What losers.
What is he a vitim of ? I belive so !
Not only was there no intent to use the money for what it was supposedly intended, but there was going to be the usual "Oversight? What Oversight?" mentality that has been a hallmark of the Bush era for the past 8 years!
So, the Congress and the American public have been "stung" once again by the "3 stooges of Finance" who will walk away from all this secure in the knowledge that the Great Emperor Obama will look "FORWARD, NOT BACKWARD", and patting themselves on the back for a huge, sucessful, well-done "CON JOB"!
SIG HEIL, MY FAVORITE MOVIE IS "THE STING"!!!, BUSH!!!
In this way the Federal Reserve System violates the letter and spirit of the United States Constitution. There, in Article I, Section 8, Clause 5, we read that the Congress shall have the power "to coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin, and fix the standard of weights and measures".
Kennedy was murdered shortly after signing Executive Order #11110, returning to the Government the power to create and issue it''s own currency without going through the FED.
1.) War (Viet Nam)
2.) The creation of money by a Privately Owned Central Bank. His efforts to have all U.S. troops out of Vietnam by 1965 combined with Executive Order #11110, would have destroyed the profits and control of the private Federal Reserve Bank.
Executive Order #11110 has never been rescinded....
The banks were not "given" money.
The US government bought preferred stock from the banks at some interest rate. The US government has made about $6B so far from what I have read on that preferred stock purchase.
The same deal was done by Buffet with GE. He bought preferred from GE.
I believe Obama''s and Biden''s statement was that the investigations and any prosecutions considered appropriate would be handled by an independent DOJ in the best tradition of the country. I believe this is important that the President, VP, Cabinet members in General and others Outside the DOJ, FBI and others charged specifically charged with these tasks not become partisan in terms of the whether or not there is a prosecution. I further hope the Attorney General will be empowered or authorized when appropriate (and he requests) the option of special prosecutors where appropriate to investigate critical agencies like the FBI, DOJ, etc that cannot effectively investigate themselves.
Anyone giving up there income to occult that pretend''s to be a good government is a fool.
The US government is a Terrorist organization of unimaginable horror on the people.
American Leadership is nothing short of a *** with aids.
The people have been lied to and used for there wages to create a military so powerful that no nation would dare to match.
Israel owns the US in every way and if you all dont wake up this reality soon you will be hunted down just like Gaza citizen from your own military.
Abe Lincoln killed 650 thousand citizens and Obama admires him.
Be afraid your soul will be sacrificed on the alter of war like so many in the past dieing for there country only to find they died for an Occult to bring the human mind under there domain with fear and chaos.
Posted by excoachken at 09:33 PM : Jan 12, 2009
Sure, I''''d be glad to .
UP YOURS.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:36 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
Neocon Rule #73:
"When confronted with overwhelming proof of your Stupidity, simply hurl insults and continue your Inane postulations".....LOL
Posted by excoachken at 09:41 PM : Jan 12, 2009
Whatever Reagan did wrong, Clinton had eight years to fix it.
If you want to bring up the past, focus on Clinton.
He was the last "popular" president we had.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:43 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
...."and,...and,...he got a BJ".....*sniff*....
I told you he was popular!
I''''m not sure about him sniffing things, though
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:47 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
Somewhere deep in the recesses of your clouded 59 IQ mind, I''m sure all these things you imagine are stone-carved absolutes, (just like when Dad (Brother) and Mom (Sis) got together at the single-wide and created little repoboy)......
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by FLSunJnky at 09:56 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
No, this entire thing is Clinton''s fault.....just ask the Drooling Wingnuts here.....LOL
Posted by stinginrich at 09:54 PM : Jan 12, 2009
You''''ve been drinking Cisco, I can tell.
you aren''''t making any sense at all
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:58 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
Reading Comprehension: Yet another item to add to the long list of your personal failings.....LOL
If you want to bring up the past, focus on Clinton.
He was the last "popular" president we had.
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:43 PM : Jan 12, 2009
It seems he DID fix it, only to have Bush come along and break it again.
The Military Brass want to hide these events to try and distort the realities of this Civil War in IRAQ. US TROOPS are viewed as "occupiers" no longer liberators... and thus, just as much a problem as the insurgents to the ultimate stability of their country!
These are IRAQI citizens people and whether you want to label them "yankess" or "rebs" neither of them are Americans and it is their destiny to decide the fate of their country!
You read the reports about IRANIANS traing Shia Militia and in IRAN and the other 100 Muslim Nations you read about the US Training Shia Security Forces - PLEASE TELL ME THE DIFFERENCE!!!
This is the type of deceit that Bush has been shielding from America for over four years in order to keep US Support behind Keeping our Soldiers in HARMS WAY - with Cheerleaders like Cheney saying on CNN - that we are making enormous progress in IRAQ - STATE of DENIAL!
How Tragically SAD!
This greed has got to stop and I mean now.
If you want to bring up the past, focus on Clinton.
He was the last "popular" president we had.
Posted by repo_man_08 at 09:43 PM : Jan 12, 2009
It seems he DID fix it, only to have Bush come along and break it again.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by kazoodan at 10:03 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
But he got a BJ!!!.....from a FEMALE WOMAN!!!...(*Yuk*), the worst offense imaginable on Planet Neocon Toe-Tapper.....
Posted by stinginrich at 10:07 PM : Jan 12, 2009
What, do you have some problem with women?
Oh, I get it. YOU voted for Barny Frank.
HAHAHAHAHAHA
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by repo_man_08 at 10:08 PM : Jan 12, 2009
+ report abuse
No, WE get it....in addition to being uneducated and quite deluded, you''re also a closeted, self-loathing, "Family-Values" Toe-Tapper.......you should join the Democratic Party - they won''t judge you for who you really are......LOL
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- next
See all 163 Comments