No Purple Hearts For Post-Traumatic Stress

Pentagon Won't Give Prestigious Medal To Soldiers Suffering From PTSD

(CBS/AP)  The Pentagon has decided it will not give the Purple Heart, the prestigious medal awarded to service members wounded or killed in action, to sufferers of post-traumatic stress disorder.

"The Defense Department has determined that based on current Purple Heart criteria, PTSD is not a qualifying Purple Heart wound," department spokeswoman Eileen Lainez said.

"PTSD is an anxiety disorder caused by witnessing or experiencing a traumatic event," Lainez said. It is not "a wound intentionally caused by the enemy from an outside force or agent."

The Defense Department statement announcing the decision, released Tuesday, said the Purple Heart has never been awarded for mental disorders of psychological conditions.

Veterans diagnosed with PTSD "still warrant appropriate medical care and disability compensation, Lainez said, and the department "is working hard to encourage service members and their families to seek care for PTSD by reducing the stigma and urging them to seek professional care."

Last month, CBS News correspondent Kimberly Dozier reported on the astoinishing number of soldiers coming back from war to face new horrors at home. The Pentagon says 1 in 5 service members who come home from Iraq or Afghanistan suffer from post-traumatic stress, Dozier reported.

Some find their experiences too much to bear. There were 115 military suicides in 2007, and 93 through August of 2008.

The biggest obstacle to getting those numbers down may be the military culture itself, according to Dozier's report. Commanders at one army base posted a fake "Hurt Feelings Report" - portraying a crying cartoon face - to mock soldiers seeking help for combat stress. Selections on the form included: "I am a crybaby," "I want my mommy" and "All of the above." It was tacked on the barracks bulletin board, next to the sign-up sheet, for the mental health clinic.

CBS News correspondent Randall Pinkston reported on a veteran's movement to change the requirements for earning a Purple Heart in June 2008.

Former Marine Lieutenant Robert Muller, a Vietnam vet who was wounded in the the line of duty and has been bound to a wheel chair ever since, has a Purple Heart, Pinkston reported.

"Took a bullet through the chest and that qualified," said Muller.

As head of a veteran's advocacy group, Muller thinks PTSD victims should also be eligible for the Purple Heart, a medal traditionally only given for physical injuries, not psychological illnesses.

"We're not talking about an illness, we're talking about an injury," said Muller. "If you go to war and you have psychic trauma, that's injury."

The Purple Heart has been around for more than two centuries - General George Washington made the first presentations. The criteria for receiving the award have changed several times.

Supporters of changing the rules for awarding Purple Hearts say it could be one way of removing the stigma some soldiers feel about admitting they are suffering from mental illness, Pinkston reported.

[barbaram99]

give them the purple heart. They bloody earnt it. Time to end that war. Vets thank ye. i know that can''t heal ye. if they never went to war they would never have seen horrors they face. I think it time to to raise the age of them that go. They go in as kids at 18. and fight for this nation and the lies. My Dad is a vet and he won''t talk about it.

[ms1-1-1]

The Pentagon has decided it will not give the Purple Heart, the prestigious medal awarded to service members wounded or killed in action, to sufferers of post-traumatic stress disorder.
- - -

THEY HAD NO PROBLEM AWARDING JOHN KERRY ample witnesses to what he did to get his MR. FAKE...

[ms1-1-1]

photogeezer


-T-H-A-N-K---- Y-O-U

AMEN...

the tragedy here is these people are EXPERTs yeah right...

[ms1-1-1]

... John Kerry ... shot himself for his and was awarded ... so people go shoot yourselfs

[coppertales]

Good.........................I have seen too many fakers out for a quick buck.....

[brannigon]

No Purple Hearts For Post-Traumatic Stress? Why not, they don''t seem to be doing anything else about it!

[rickl647]

Read "The Beast Within - The Cause and Effect of PTSD". PTSD is indeed a wound.

[photogeezer]

This decision is consistent with the widely held view that people with mental illness (bipolar disorder, depression, OCD, etc) aren''t "really" sick. This silly notion affects how insurance and government programs treat mental illness.

As vet rep, a Vietnam vet diagnosed with PTSD, and the son of a WWI combat vet, I can tell you that PTSD is a wound. Like a bullet hole in the leg, you don''t wake up some morning and its gone. I don''t think there''s any cure, any magic pill, or magic words that will make it go away. If you have PTSD, you get treatment at your loclal Vet Center or other trained professional, and learn to live its shadow.