WASHINGTON, Dec. 18, 2008
Clinton Group Got Millions From Overseas
Former President's Foreign Donors Could Complicate Hillary Clinton's Secretary Of State Bid
-
Play CBS Video Video Bill Clinton Releases Donor List The Clinton Foundation's donor list has been released, and large sum donors include the Blackwater security firm, Barbra Streisand and Saudi Arabia. Sharyl Attkisson reports.
-
Former President Bill Clinton's overseas fundraising for his foundation could pose a conflict of interest if his wife, Sen. Hillary Clinton, becomes U.S. Secretary of State. (AP)
-
Photo Essay Hillary Clinton A look at a life and career full of firsts.
-
Interactive William Jefferson Clinton Follow the ups and downs of President Clinton's years in office, see photos and learn about his life before and after the presidency.
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia gave $10 million to $25 million to the William J. Clinton Foundation, a nonprofit created by the former president to finance his library in Little Rock, Ark., and charitable efforts to reduce poverty and treat AIDS. Other foreign government givers include Norway, Kuwait, Qatar, Brunei, Oman, Italy and Jamaica.
Buried among the names of Saudi royals and super-rich businesses are thousands of people who gave to victims of Hurricane Katrina, reports CBS News correspondent Sharyl Attkisson.
Katrina donors ended up on the list of Clinton supporters when donations poured in before the Bush-Clinton Katrina Fund was fully set up, so the former presidents held the money in two other charities: the Greater Houston Community Foundation and the Clinton Foundation.
Four months after the hurricane, the Houston Charity passed more than $50 million dollars onto the national Katrina Fund, Attkisson reports. A month after that, in January and February of '06, the Clinton Foundation gave about $30 million.
That pit stop in the Clinton fund officially turned those Katrina donors into Clinton donors--people who expected their money to go directly to hurricane relief.And just two weeks ago, thousands of them got letters saying their names were about to be made public.
Among those "surprised" to find themselves on today's list was former Congressman Rob Portman, a Republican on Bush's cabinet at the time.
"These are folks who saw the tragedies of Katrina and wanted to donate," said Dean Zerbe, who was the lead investigator of charities for Congress. "How they've gotten themselves wrapped up into having their names put on a web site is beyond me."
The foundation disclosed the names of its 205,000 donors on a Web site Thursday, ending a decade of resistance to identifying the sources of its money. While the list is heavy with international business leaders and billionaires, some 12,000 donors gave $10 or less.
Click here for a complete list of the donors.
Clinton agreed to release the information after concerns emerged that his extensive international fundraising and business deals could conflict with America's interests if his wife became President-elect Barack Obama's top diplomat. The foundation has insisted for years it is under no legal obligation to identify its contributors, contending that many expected confidentiality when they donated.
The list also underscores ties between the Clintons and India, a connection that could complicate diplomatic perceptions of whether Hillary Clinton can be a neutral broker between India and neighbor Pakistan in a region where Mr. Obama will face an early test of his foreign policy leadership.
The former president did not release specific totals for each donor, providing only ranges of giving. Nor did he identify individual contributors' occupations or countries of residence.
Fast Facts
Donors gave Clinton's foundation at least $492 million from its inception in 1997 through last year, the most recent figures available.The list underscores ties between the Clintons and India, a connection that could complicate diplomatic perceptions of whether Hillary Clinton can be a neutral broker between India and neighbor Pakistan.
After negotiations with Mr. Obama's transition team, Clinton promised to reveal the contributors, submit future foundation activities and paid speeches to an ethics review, step away from the day-to-day operation of his annual charitable conference and inform the State Department about new sources of income and speeches.
Representatives of the foundation, including CEO Bruce Lindsay and attorney Cheryl Mills, met privately Wednesday with aides to incoming Foreign Relations Committee Chairman John Kerry of Massachusetts and ranking Republican Dick Lugar of Indiana to discuss the foundation's activities and review a memorandum of understanding drawn up by the Clinton and Obama teams.
The Foreign Relations Committee will hold hearings and vote on Hillary Clinton's nomination before sending it to the full Senate. Shortly after Mr. Obama tapped Clinton, Lugar said he would support her, though he said there would still be "legitimate questions" raised about the former president's extensive international involvement.
"I don't know how, given all of our ethics standards now, anyone quite measures up to this - who has such cosmic ties," Lugar said.
Some of the donors have extensive ties to Indian interests that could prove troubling to Pakistan. Tensions between the two nuclear nations are high since last month's deadly terrorist attacks in Mumbai.
Amar Singh, a donor in the $1 million to $5 million category, is an Indian politician who played host to Bill Clinton on a visit to India in 2005 and met Hillary Clinton in New York in September to discuss an India-U.S. civil nuclear agreement.
Also in that giving category was Suzlon Energy Ltd. of Amsterdam, a leading supplier of wind turbines. Its chairman is Tulsi R. Tanti, one of India's wealthiest executives. Tanti announced plans at Clinton's Global Initiative meeting earlier this year for a $5 billion project to develop environmentally friendly power generation in India and China.
Two other Indian interests gave between $500,000 and $1 million each:
Other foreign governments also contributed heavily to the foundation.
AUSAID, the Australian government's overseas aid program, and COPRESIDA-Secretariado Tecnico, a Dominican Republic government agency formed to fight AIDS, each gave $10 million to $25 million. Norway gave $5 million to $10 million. Kuwait, Qatar, Brunei and Oman gave $1 million to $5 million each. The government of Jamaica and Italy's Ministry for Environment and Territory gave $50,000 to $100,000 each.
The biggest donations - more than $25 million each - came from two donors. They are the Children's Investment Fund Foundation, a London-based philanthropic organization founded by hedge fund manager Chris Hohn and his wife Jamie Cooper-Hohn and dedicated to helping children, primarily in Africa and India; and UNITAID, an international drug purchase organization formed by Brazil, France, Chile, Norway and Britain to help provide care for HIV-AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis patients in countries with high disease rates.
The foundation's donor list is heavy with overseas business interests.
Saudi businessman Nasser Al-Rashid gave $1 million to $5 million. Friends of Saudi Arabia and the Dubai Foundation each gave $1 million to $5 million, as did the Taiwan Economic and Cultural Office. The Confederation of Indian Industry and the Swedish Postcode Lottery gave $500,000 to $1 million each. China Overseas Real Estate Development and the U.S. Islamic World Conference gave $250,000 to $500,000 apiece.
The No. 4 person on the Forbes billionaire list, Lakshmi Mittal, the chief executive of international steel company ArcelorMittal, gave $1 million to $5 million. Mittal is a member of the Foreign Investment Council in Kazakhstan, Goldman Sachs' board of directors and the World Economic Forum's International Business Council, according to the biography on his corporate Web site.
Among other $1 million to $5 million donors:
The top ranks of Clinton's donor list are heavy with longtime Democratic givers, including some who are notable for their staunch support of Israel.
TV producer Haim Saban and his family foundation, who donated between $5 million and $10 million, splits his time between homes in Israel and California. "I'm a one-issue guy and my issue is Israel," he told The New York Times in 2004.
Slim-Fast diet foods tycoon S. Daniel Abraham, a donor of between $1 million and $5 million, has been a board member of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, which promotes Israel's interests before the U.S. government.
The American Jewish Committee and the United Nations Foundation donated $100,000 to $250,000.
Clinton thanked his donors in a statement for being "steadfast partners in our work to impact the lives of so many around the world in measurable and meaningful ways."
According to the memorandum negotiated by the foundation and top Obama advisers, Bill Clinton agreed to publish the names of all past and future contributors to his foundation during Hillary Clinton's tenure as secretary of state.
The former president also agreed to step away from direct involvement in the Clinton Global Initiative, an annual charitable conference where businesses and many foreign governments pledge donations to help ameliorate AIDS, poverty and other social ills. He will continue serving as CGI's founding chairman but will not solicit money or sponsorships. The CGI will cease accepting foreign contributions and will not host events outside the United States.
Clinton started raising money for his library before leaving the White House. Over the years, the Clintons repeatedly refused to identify all the foundation donors, and continued to do so during Hillary Clinton's 2007-08 presidential campaign.
Names surfaced nonetheless. Several news organizations unearthed foreign-government donors, and in 2001, Bill Clinton turned over a list of 150 top foundation donors to a House committee investigating his pardon of fugitive businessman Marc Rich, whose ex-wife, Denise Rich, gave the library foundation at least $450,000.
©MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
More From Politics
Add a Comment See all 121 Comments
- Recall Hillary''s theatrical opposition in the Senate to the Dubai Ports deal- she was in the vanguard, forcing this company from (US ally) the UAE out of the contract. Subsequently, Bill Clinton was hired and paid millions of dollars by the UAE to clean up the resulting PR debacle... which was much his own wife''s creation.
Clinton has not one iota of foreign policy experience. She lacks basic diplomatic skills, is known for a violent temper, and use of foul language when angry. Hillary was caught lying during the primaries, when she claimed to have come %u201Cunder fire%u201D on a visit to Bosnia in 1996%u2026 what happened to honesty and integrity as selection criteria?
The biggest cause for concern is Hillary%u2019s judgement, which is warped by her thirst for power and control. Thustly, she%u2019s developed a tendency to be manipulative and Machiavellian in her dealings with others- is this the kind of person who should represent the United States with foreign governments?
Anyone who would expect Obama to put the country%u2019s interests before his own political security (and select the best available person) has not really taken a serious look at how he got this far in the first place.
http://reaganiterepublicanresistance.blogspot.com/ - Reply to this comment
- hillary should not be approved for the sos cabinet slot. there is definitely a conflict of interest here if not openly then in the bedroom with husband bill clinton. obama could have rice stay on a year until he finds someone else just as obama has gates holding down the sod cabinet slot. or obama can give hillary another job but not secretary of state!
- Reply to this comment
- Posted by harborsparro at 09:17 PM : Dec 18, 2008
You''re right...this is a non-story and not news at all. - Reply to this comment
- Posted by sockpuppet4 at 07:39 PM : Dec 18, 2008
Some interseting Neocrap scandals for you, enjoy :-)
http://www.boycottliberalism.com/Scandals.htm - Reply to this comment
- oh puh-leeze. who bloody cares. it''s a NON-PROFIT. as in, donors and managers do not profit from giving to it. would the extreme right and clinton haters consider giving up beating a dead horse?
- Reply to this comment
- This must make Hillary happy! She looks greedy!!!!!!!!!!
- Reply to this comment
- She was 19 - a child in my book. He was president of the United states using a mindless idiot for his own personal sexual pleasure - frankly the differences are a matter of degree.
______________
Your a liar. Lewinsky was 21 years old. And it was she who seduced Clinton.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by mtee12
she was a mindless idiot...19 or 21...she was still of age and being a mindless idiot doesn''t mean she didn''t consent. Bill''s reputation preceded him and she had a ''friend'' who hated him enough she had to know how stupid she was being...Bill lied and BO was taking notes...which is coming in handy right about now. - Reply to this comment
- Now is a good time for Hilary to divorce this dirt bag!
- Reply to this comment
- Have you watched this torture film on PBS? We should prosecute Cheney and Rumsfield. These two worms don''t represent America. They got in power, god help the USA and Congress approved their torture package. Is anyone aware of these two?
- Reply to this comment
- This is not shocking. Ronnie Reagan I got mine did you get yours ($2 million for speaking ingagements from Japan) They are all crooked. Me first you second, country last.
- Reply to this comment
- Posted by AJMarine111 at 07:16 PM :
Does anyone think that Monica regrets her actions, moments of glory, claim to fame, racey memories for when she''''s an old broad? I don''''t think so.
Posted by IrishWench at 07:20 PM : Dec 18, 2008
I agree.
I''m surprised she hasn''t written a book by now,....or has she and I have just missed it? - Reply to this comment
- She was 19 - a child in my book. He was president of the United states using a mindless idiot for his own personal sexual pleasure - frankly the differences are a matter of degree.
- Reply to this comment
- We all know all republicans are pedophiles.
...and war mongers, greedy, fake evangelical christian, union busters, corporate puppets, lobbyist butt buddies, foaming at the mouth lusting for dollars, third world slave creators, and so on, and so on......
Do you actually believe that every Republican is what you describe above?
50 years ago it was common knowledge that all blacks were lazy, shiftless, ignorant, *** maniancs.
That kind of stereo typing is mindless, corrosive and dangerous - and a perfect example of liberal bigots just like the KKK. - Reply to this comment
- Posted by jimmyc1955 at 07:11 PM
What child?
Posted by IrishWench at 07:15 PM : Dec 18, 2008
The little innocent thing that snapped her thong underwear at Bill. - Reply to this comment
- IrishWench - I agree. Having an ex-president as husband of the current sec of state may be unique in American history and as such poses a unique set of ethical conditions we will have to continue to work through going forward.
But my sense of propriety would be better satisifed if the fund were put into receivership for the duration of Hillaries tenure. - Reply to this comment
- I know! Let''s talk about the big donors to the George Bush Library! Talk about conflict of interest.
- Reply to this comment
- sockpuppet4 - Your a bigot and an idiot. You list pedofiles and imply that all republicans are pedophiles.
Does that mean since a president molested a child in the oval office all democrats are child molesters who victimize dumb interns? - Reply to this comment
- But Bill Clinton has taken money from countries that are not American allies - like Saudi Arabia. That isn''''''''''''''''t a good thing for an ex-president and husband of the sec of state.
Posted by jimmyc1955 at 06:56 PM
I thought the Saudi''s were our allies. - Reply to this comment
- mtee12 - Fools for conspiracy are on both sides. I believe I remember that Cheney was going to steer all the oil from Iraq through Haliburton for his own wealth. Last I checked no American companies own any contracts.
- Reply to this comment
- sockpuppet4 - and why am I a creep?
- Reply to this comment
The road ahead in Afghanistan, and the crucial decision Obama faces.
