Dec. 14, 2008

Barney Frank On Bailouts, Welfare

Tells 60 Minutes An Auto Industry Bailout Would Help People, Not Companies

  • Play CBS Video Video Chairman Of The Board

    Rep. Barney Frank (D.-Mass.), whose position as House Financial Services Committee Chairman puts him right in the middle of the controversial government bailouts, talks to Lesley Stahl.

  • Barney Frank

    Barney Frank  (CBS)

  • In-Depth Meltdown Primer

    Questions and answers regarding various aspects of the current economic crisis.

  • In-Depth Q&A: Big Three Bailout?

    Why Detroit's automakers might get a rescue package

(CBS)  Remarks like this explain President Bush’s nickname for him: "saber tooth." There are many ways to describe Barney Frank:

"I wanted to read you a sampling of descriptions of you. They kind of come in couplets. We have, 'Impatient and antisocial.' 'Sharp tongued and downright mean,'" Stahl ticks off a list.

"I'm antisocial, there's no question about it. I think that I love this job. But the biggest problem is there are thousands of people in Washington who earn a living by trying to waste my time. They repeat themselves. They ask you stupid questions," he says.

And he can be sharp-tongued: a master of the putdown, and a master of the dress-down. When they sat down, Stahl escaped neither put-down nor dress-down.

"Television is apparently the enemy of nuance. But nuance is essential for a thoughtful discussion," Frank told her.

He also said, "Let me start with that second despicable comment you just made I am surprised at you that you would do something like that."

It's no wonder that when "saber tooth" the liberal took over the committee that oversees banking, Wall Street shuddered. But two years later, even the most hardened Republicans give him good reviews.

"I’m very proud of the fact I think we've shown with the last two years, and we will show going forward, that you can be a liberal Democrat and cooperate in creating the kind of climate that’s good for business as well as for everybody else," Frank says.

Frank says he is absolutely pro business.

Listen to what the financial community says: "Here’s Henry Paulson on Barney Frank: 'He’s a market savvy pragmatist who looks for areas of agreement because he wants to get things done.' Here's a guy from JP Morgan Chase. He said, 'He hasn’t veered off into crazyland.' Meaning liberalism. I've heard someone describe you this way. You're liberal on social issues. You're a pragmatist on economic issues," Stahl remarks.

"No! I reject the notion that you're talking about two different things. That's like saying are you more of a cook or are you left handed? I am a liberal. What I'm rejecting is this liberal here, pragmatist there. That's like comparing Tuesday to ice cream. As a liberal, I am morally obligated to be pragmatic. What good do I do poor people, elderly people, people who are being discriminated against because of their sexual orientation if I’m not realistic about accomplishing something," Frank says.

And he does accomplish. This week he shuttled from a hearing on the bank rescue package to negotiating and strategizing on the car loans to briefing Tim Geithner, Obama's choice for treasury secretary.

It's been like this ever since the credit crisis hit, and he worked hand in glove with Treasury Secretary Paulson to write the rescue plan for the banks, then pressed and prodded his colleagues in Congress to get it passed.

The relationship between Frank and Paulson has soured lately, since Paulson hasn’t spent any of the rescue money to help struggling homeowners. "Secretary Paulson is refusing to use that money that Congress voted to reduce foreclosures. The bill says he’s supposed to. He won’t do that," Frank says.

"You wrote the bill," Stahl points out. "You’re, quote, 'the smartest man in Congress.' How did it happen that you wrote a bill that the secretary of treasury has the power not to fulfill in the way you wanted it fulfilled?"

"Because there’s a metaphor that works here: you cannot push on a string. There’s no Constitutional way to force them to do things," Frank says.

"But didn’t you write the bill in a way that allows him to do this? And you could have written it differently," Stahl remarks.

"No. There’s no way you can force people to do things," Frank says.

Continued



Produced by Shachar Bar-On
© MMVIII, CBS Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Recent Segments
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Add a Comment See all 286 Comments
by sadrake December 17, 2008 8:09 PM EST
"Let me give you another unfairness. I wanna see what you think about this. What about someone who''s been working hard, 40 hours a week, maybe with some overtime, and goin'' to work every day. And then his neighbor loses his job. The neighbor starts getting unemployment insurance. The neighbor who lost his job is getting money for nothing, from the government. There''s some unfairness there," Frank argues.
Money for nothing?!?! What were all those payroll taxes I paid into the unemployment insurance system for over the last 35 years? By his reasoning, those drawing on social security must be deadbeats as well. And THIS is the smartest man in Congress? God help us all.
Reply to this comment
by karenteacup December 17, 2008 7:44 PM EST
I was disappointed with this interview. Leslie had someone who played a major role in this country''s financial collapse, (in that he was sleeping on the job and he gained financially from his connections with Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac)....you could have held his feet to the fire, you could have held him accountable for his actions, yet you chose to talk about his sexual orientation?! What?! What a wasted opportunity.
Reply to this comment
by frj256 December 17, 2008 7:36 PM EST
Do you not realize that that Buffoon, Barney Frank, was one of those whose negligence brought about the bad loan crash? He not only did nothing to prevent the crash, but blocked regulation that would have prevented it. And he announced publically that one of the federally founded morgage firms was sound and got his "boy friend" a job at one of them. Why were these things not mentioned in the program? Do you not care about your reputation?
Reply to this comment
by seabuggg December 17, 2008 7:05 PM EST
The next time you guys/gals interview a Democrat, I think it would be fitting to dress the interviewer in a short skirt and have Pom Poms. GET SERIOUS and ask some real questions and keep asking them until you get a answer! We are in trouble here. Brown nosing the guest who contributed to the problem does not help anyone!
PS luv the show Bruce in Georgia
Reply to this comment
by juicy327 December 16, 2008 11:52 PM EST
60 Minutes, in a previos life, was a fungible source of journalism. Leslie, your interview with Barney Franks was way beneath a novice. Why would any network waste primetime to pat a gay on the back that was so contributory to the fannie mae-freddie mac conspriracy. Just another arrow in the back of true patriots, thanks for helping kill AMERICA. In 1940 you would have been called a COMIE, gotta fill that time up with something, don''t you.
Reply to this comment
by earltim1 December 16, 2008 10:13 PM EST
Lesley, I viewed the Barney Franks interview (biography?). I noticed some displeasure on your part as to his demeaner, and the way he answered your questions. I would have much prefurred hearing the interview in more detail instead of the abbreviated Biographic presentation. I have worked in a field where there were gay men and Lesbian women. I have seldom met a gay adult who was without significant psychological issues, I would be surprised if Mr Frank was an exception. But even though you and your editors were apparently uncomfortable with Mr. Franks non-condiscending tone, I would like to hear from him ... NOT you. Perhaps the complete interview (without drama) could be aired sometime in the future. ( I was beginning to wonder who was behaving in the more inmature manner, Mr Frank .. or CBS ?)
Reply to this comment
by az1143t December 16, 2008 8:04 PM EST
Barney Frank, as the Chairman of the House Banking Committee, is paid with our tax dollars to be our watch-dog in the areas of banking,housing and auto industry. While he is "wide awake" now, he has been "asleep at the switch" in not addressing and alerting us to the problems in these industries. In the private sector, he would be fired. In the public sector politicians never get removed, which is why government seldom gets better. You didn''t ask the tough questions. We just got his life story. You are our only watchdog to negligence and corruption. what we need is Jack Anderson style reporting with follow-up.
Reply to this comment
by guysdigdirt December 16, 2008 7:57 PM EST
Who were the morons who put this self-important pig in office?
Reply to this comment
by sailon5 December 16, 2008 6:52 PM EST
what a joke! Leslie how about making this arrogant, bully answer your question about the people who took these irresponsible loans? You let him get away with comparing someone who looses his job through no fault of their own to an irresponsible borrower! This man encouraged these type of loans and no newsperson has the Ba*** to make him accountable. Thanks for NOT doing your job! You are a joke!
Reply to this comment
by dozer211 December 16, 2008 5:43 PM EST
this itrerview was a joke. hey lesley why is fannie and freddie not been investigated.how about his boyfriend whom he set up with a nice goverment job.how about harold raines walking away with over a 100 million dollars.

Reply to this comment
by pepperwood2 December 16, 2008 5:07 PM EST
Madoff boasted to regulators about profits
Accused money manager also advised GOVERNMENT on scam artists.

Don''t tell me, but I wonder where our GOVERNMENT''S Brilliant Barney, Financial Manager was during the time this has been going on??

Now Brilliant Barney wants the American People to go out, spend and run up more debt to make him look good. Its time to cut the spending, and balance our budget that won''t budge. Thanks to these Brilliant Wizards running the show.

Reply to this comment
by ronffg December 16, 2008 4:37 PM EST
Whaddaya mean, no real job ! One of the best male prostitution houses on the east coast was run from his residence ! And he said he didnt know that was happening. Let me ask you, if there was a male prosty operation being run from YOUR house, would YOU know ? I think so.
Reply to this comment
by kenlavine1 December 16, 2008 3:54 PM EST
Still waiting for the answer to the one good question asked. Is it fair to the person who works three jobs to pay his mortgage when we help the person who wont even pay a portion of his mortgage? Barney''s reaction was to compare a guy who lost his job and gets unemployment to a guy that still works. I thought Barney knew the difference between apples and oranges??? Must be he has never had a real job.
Reply to this comment
by ctarts1 December 16, 2008 3:41 PM EST
Did Ms. Stahl pick up her check from People Magazine yet? The story that she provided us regarding Barney Frank was so transparently a puff piece that I was embarrassed for her...and the rest of the 60 minutes crew. I even remarked to my daughters that if Mike Wallace were doing this, he would have dug into the issues of Fannie and Freddie. Ms. Stahl use to be a respected journalist, but in the minds of many, she should hang it up. Where is that hard hitting reporting that made 60 Minutes? Gone by the way of Extra and all the other entertainment shows.
Reply to this comment
by ronffg December 16, 2008 12:21 PM EST
Yea, let''s leave the "hard hitting" journalistic interviews to....say...Leslie Stahl. Yea, she''ll get to the bottom of things with Barney Frank. You bet. He might as well have been interviewed by Chris Mathews. At least Bill O''reilly has some rocks and isnt the least bit intimidated by that puffed up toad.
Reply to this comment
by seabuggg December 16, 2008 8:47 AM EST
The interview with Barney Frank was a JOKE. Just go ahead and dress the interviewer in a cheerleaders outfit with pom poms next time.
Bruce in Ga
Reply to this comment
by seabuggg December 16, 2008 8:43 AM EST
The interview with Barney Frank was embarrassing. The next time go ahead and dress the interviewer in a cheerleaders outfit and give her POM POMS. Get real and ask serious questions and expect a serious answers!
Just another disillusioned voter/taxpayer in Georgia
Reply to this comment
by seabuggg December 16, 2008 8:41 AM EST
The interview with Barney Frank was embarrassing. The next time go ahead and dress the interviewer in a cheerleaders outfit and give her POM POMS. Get real and ask serious questions and expect a serious answers!
Just another disillusioned voter/taxpayer in Georgia
Reply to this comment
by joule18 December 16, 2008 3:59 AM EST
ACORN was the strong-arm that protested and strong-armed the private banks into making the bad loans, but it was the policies headed by Frank and Dodd that allowed it to happen.

Let Congress have hearings on the mortgage lending practices and it will come back to Frank and Dodd. Except they''d rather spend their time on baseball and steroids. The Democratic let Congress and Senate are gutless and will not punish their own.
Reply to this comment
by clovisbuford December 16, 2008 3:25 AM EST
We should all show our support of GW and the job he has done ,by donating a pair of old wore out shoes like that iraqui jornalist did at Bush''s press conference
1600 Pennsylvania Ave NW, Washington, DC, 20500, . I am thinking the american people could fill a warehouse on their own
Reply to this comment
See all 286 Comments
60 Minutes RSS Feed