NEW YORK, Dec. 6, 2008

After 28-Year Coma, Sunny Von Bulow Dies

Heiress' Husband Claus Was Acquitted Of Attempted Murder In Two Sensational 1980s Trials

    • Martha Photo

      Martha "Sonny" Von Bulow (in this undated file photo) survived 28 years in a persistent vegetative state, during which her husband was twice acquitted of attempting to kill her. She died in a New York City nursing home Saturday, Dec. 6, 2008, age 76.  (AP Photo)

    • Claus Von Bulow (right) sits in court during opening arguments on the first day of his retrial on charges that he attempted to murder his wife, Martha Photo

      Claus Von Bulow (right) sits in court during opening arguments on the first day of his retrial on charges that he attempted to murder his wife, Martha "Sunny" Von Bulow, in Providence, R.I. on April 25, 1985.  (AP Photo)

    • Exterior view of the von Bulow estate in Newport, R.I., January 1982. Photo

      Exterior view of the von Bulow estate in Newport, R.I., January 1982.  (AP Photo)

    Previous slide Next slide
(AP)  Martha "Sunny" von Bulow, who spent the last 28 years of her life in oblivion after what prosecutors alleged was two murder attempts by her husband, Claus, died Saturday at a nursing home in New York.

She was 76. Her death was announced by her children in a statement released by family spokeswoman Maureen Connelly.

Mrs. von Bulow was a living example of romantic notions about high society - a stunning heiress who brought her American millions to marriages to men who gave her honored old European names.

But she ended her days as an ever-sleeping beauty, visited by her children, pampered around the clock by nurses, sometimes conscious but giving no sign of awareness.

She was the offstage presence that haunted her husband's two sensational trials in Providence, R.I.

At the first trial, in 1982, Claus von Bulow was convicted of trying twice to kill her by injecting her with insulin at their estate in Newport, R.I. The verdict was thrown out on appeal, and von Bulow was acquitted at a second trial in 1985.

The murder case split Newport society, produced lurid headlines and was later made into a film, "Reversal of Fortune," starring Glenn Close and Jeremy Irons.

Claus von Bulow is living in London, "mostly taking care of his grandchildren," said Alan Dershowitz, the defense lawyer who won his acquittal at the second trial.

"It's a sad ending to a sad tragedy that some people tried to turn into a crime," Dershowitz said. "I hope this finally will put to an end to this terrible tragedy."

"There are no winners in a case like this. I'm happy to have played a role in getting the criminal conviction reversed, because it was an unjust conviction, but there were no victory parties or celebrations afterwards because there was a woman in a coma," Dershowitz said.

His main accusers were Mrs. von Bulow's children by a previous marriage, Princess Annie Laurie von Auersperg Kniessl and Prince Alexander von Auersperg. They renewed the charges against their stepfather in a civil lawsuit a month after his acquittal.

Two years later, von Bulow agreed to give up any claims to his wife's estimated $25 million-to-$40 million fortune and to the $120,000-a-year income of a trust she set up for him. He also agreed to divorce her, leave the country and never profit from their story.

A sell-off of Mrs. von Bulow's property followed - her oceanfront estate in Newport for $4.2 million, her 12-room apartment on Fifth Avenue for $6.25 million, and the art and antiques from the homes for $11.5 million at a spirited two-day auction.

The government contended that von Bulow wanted to get rid of his wife to inherit a large hunk of her wealth and be free to marry a mistress. The defense countered by picturing Mrs. von Bulow, who suffered from low blood sugar, as a boozer and pill popper who drank herself into a coma.

Von Bulow was accused of injecting his wife with insulin first in December of 1979, causing a coma from which she revived. The second alleged attempt was a year later and this time, Dec. 21, 1980, at age 49, Mrs. von Bulow slipped into an irreversible coma.

Her world was reduced to a private, guarded room in the Harkness Pavilion and later the McKeen Pavilion of Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center. She died at the Mary Manning Walsh Nursing Home, her family said.

Her doctor testified that the cost of maintaining her was $375,000 the first year, 1981.

No figures were available for the years that followed, but by the early 1990s room charges were up to about $1,500 a day - $547,000 a year, plus another $200,000 to $300,000 for round-the-clock private nursing.

Mrs. von Bulow was born Martha Sharp Crawford in Pittsburgh, Sept. 1, 1931, daughter of utilities tycoon George Crawford, who died when she was 4.

"Sunny," nicknamed for her disposition, was raised by her mother in New York City. She attended Chapin School and St. Timothy's in Maryland, skipped college and came out in 1951.

While touring Europe with her mother, she met Prince Alfred von Auersperg, who was younger, penniless and working as the tennis pro in an Austrian resort catering to rich Americans.

They were married in 1957 and divorced eight years later after she returned alone to New York with their young son and daughter.

On June 6, 1966, she married von Bulow, who then quit his job as an aide of oilman J. Paul Getty.

© MMVIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Video and Galleries from U.S.

Add a Comment See all 47 Comments
by lemonskink December 6, 2008 3:19 PM PST
Thank God, she was able to afford the hospital stay. 28 years in a coma...wow, Bush beat her record though at 61 years in one.
Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 3:23 PM PST
What good did it do her to stay in a vegetative state for 28 years?
Reply to this comment
by garyl615 December 6, 2008 3:23 PM PST
Lemonskink:
Way to go. That was a good one.
Reply to this comment
by slim1h2o December 6, 2008 3:32 PM PST
Posted by Lemonskink at 03:19 PM : Dec 06, 2008

If she was middle class, they would have pulled the plug while her husband and children watching.

Reply to this comment
by tiredofitnow December 6, 2008 3:47 PM PST
If she was middle class, they would have pulled the plug while her husband and children watching. - Posted by slim1h2o at 03:32 PM

Nowhere did I see anything about her being on life support.


What good did it do her to stay in a vegetative state for 28 years? - Posted by shanev137 at 03:23 PM

She was alive. Who are you to decide that those who aren''t living what you deem to be a life of "quality" aren''t worth the time and effort needed to care for them?


Reply to this comment
by laticamba December 6, 2008 3:52 PM PST
amazing what men will do for money..
Reply to this comment
by slim1h2o December 6, 2008 3:53 PM PST
Nowhere did I see anything about her being on life support.

posted by tireofitnow...

Trust me, if she had been middle class, the doctors would have induced death on Christmas morning.

One way or the other....if not by drugs, then some other way that would have done the trick, without accepting blame on their part.

Just because the middle class ain''t worthy of our fine medical/health care.
Sarcasm)


Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 3:56 PM PST
Posted by tiredofitnow at 03:47 PM : Dec 06, 2008


So you would want to be in a vegetative state for 28 years then is what you''re saying.
Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 4:08 PM PST
Hey tiredofitnow....if you want to be a pile of sludge on a bed for 28 years with goo dripping out of your mouth and a 1,000 mile stare at the ceiling, hooked up to every know piece of life support, and call it "living" and "life"....go right ahead....but just make sure you have enough of your own money to do it with.
Reply to this comment
by southernxyl December 6, 2008 4:16 PM PST
No one would want to be in a vegetative state. This is different from saying that once one finds onesself in a vegetative state, one would want to be murdered or to be dehydrated/starved to death (same thing).

shanev137, you could describe your own normal life processes in just such a disgusting manner if you wanted to.
Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 4:29 PM PST
Posted by southernxyl at 04:16 PM : Dec 06, 2008

I have what''s called a living will.

I made it precisely to prevent morons like you from letting a doctor pull the plug on me, and living out 28 years of your version of "life".
Reply to this comment
by southernxyl December 6, 2008 4:33 PM PST
You made it to prevent morons like me from letting the doctor pull the plug on you? No need to prevent me, or morons like me pulling your plug. I wouldn''t be the one letting the doctor pull the plug.

Or maybe the person initially using the word "moron" has a bit of trouble communicating exactly what he means?
Reply to this comment
by puzzler125 December 6, 2008 4:53 PM PST
One would be an "aide to" not an "aide of" someone.
Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 4:54 PM PST
Posted by southernxyl at 04:33 PM : Dec 06, 2008

Moron, idiot, imbecile.... are all the same words you could use to define the type of person who would want someone to spend 28 years in a vegetative state calling it "living a life".

Take your pick.
Reply to this comment
by southernxyl December 6, 2008 4:59 PM PST
Shanev, find a dictionary.

Look up "moron", "imbecile" and "idiot". They do not mean "person who has views that differ from shanev''s".

Also, try to find a dictionary or biology textbook whose definition of "life" matches yours. You might have to write your own.
Reply to this comment
by shanev137 December 6, 2008 5:19 PM PST
Posted by southernxyl at 04:59 PM : Dec 06, 2008

I''m all ears. Go ahead and start backing up your views on here then, and stop with the insults. Give us your best argument as to why it''s "so good" to hook vegetables up to life support for 28 years.
Reply to this comment
by southernxyl December 6, 2008 5:38 PM PST
"... stop with the insults." ??? Who used the word "moron" to refer to the other person? Hint: It wasn''t me.

"Give us your best argument as to why it''''s ''so good'' to hook vegetables up to life support for 28 years."

Please point to where I used the term "so good" in reference to hooking up life support to vegetables. What vegetables are you claiming I used that term in reference to, anyway? Carrots? Potatoes?

What I said was that starving/dehydrating human beings who are in either a coma or a persistent vegetative state (they are not the same thing) is the same as murder, and not everyone would choose that for themselves. To say "who would want to live that way" compared to the way we live now, those of us who have enough functionality to comment on this article, is very different than to say "who would want to live that way" if the alternative is to be murdered.

People do come out of these states. Perhaps you read the articles a few weeks back about a boy whose doctors thought he was brain-dead and were actually getting ready to harvest his organs when he woke up. And even if they don''t - we''re all going to die anyway, including you and I. What is the big rush?

But you don''t have to counter any of this. Just find another insulting word to call me, and then you don''t have to admit that a reasonable person wouldn''t necessarily agree with all of your opinions.
Reply to this comment
by obamamabus December 6, 2008 5:49 PM PST
Shanev -- She wasn''t on a respirator, she was in a coma. The fact that you think you have the authority to dictate that the victim of a murder attempt should be finished off by the government speaks volumes of your shallow moral code. You think that someone -- with the means to be kept alive with the hope of someday coming out of the coma -- should be killed instead. Now who is the vegetable in this discussion?
Reply to this comment
by bandmom4145 December 6, 2008 5:50 PM PST
As one that was in a coma for 5 weeks, I can tell you that it''s one of the worst thing''s that can happen to u. you have very bad, terror thing''s that you dream?(I don''t know what else to call it)All I know is that a few hour''s seem like year''s, I suffered during a war, had snake''s all around me, thought my kids were very much older, didn''t remember friend''s and family that came to sit with me , and so many horrible thing''s that I won.t even tell you. Just know that if I were in that position again, I would want someone to pull the plug, if I did''t come out of it within 6 month''s or a year, at the most. Unless you''ve lived through it, you''ll never understand, It''s one of the most terrifieing thing''s that will ever happen to you. I still have to ask my family if certain thing''s actually happened.It''s so real that you don''t beleive people when they tell you it didn''t happen. Some thing''s you just have to see for your self.
Reply to this comment
by obamamabus December 6, 2008 5:50 PM PST
Shanev, by your own callous thinking...perhaps you also think that you should be put to sleep?
Reply to this comment
by mtminds December 6, 2008 5:52 PM PST
A wonderful quality of life. Kept alive by greedy children dieing for her fortune.
Reply to this comment
by obamamabus December 6, 2008 5:54 PM PST
Bandmom, much sympathy for your experience, but...would you rather they had pulled the plug after, say, four weeks? Who decides when enough time has passed? Can''t we leave that up to God?
Reply to this comment
by obamamabus December 6, 2008 5:57 PM PST
Mtminds -- what a heartless and idiotic comment. If her kids were "greedy" and "dying for her fortune" wouldn''t they have pulled the plug decades ago, and saved millions while netting a huge inheritance? You are obviously another vegetable being kept alive by artificial life support.
Reply to this comment
by southernxyl December 6, 2008 6:04 PM PST
Bandmom, I''m sorry about your horrifying experience. Presumably your kids are glad to still have their mother around?

Not everyone reports the bad experience you had. The boy I mentioned earlier could hear people saying he was really dead and the plug needed to be pulled, and he said he wanted to throw them out the window.
Reply to this comment
by hitoyou11 December 6, 2008 7:02 PM PST
Thank God, she was able to afford the hospital stay. 28 years in a coma...wow, Bush beat her record though at 61 years in one.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by Lemonskink at 03:19 PM : Dec 06, 2008

I take it you don''t like Bush. Ok What about tiy Den''s that gave are money away to the nO GOOD AUTOMAKERS AND THE WORST NO GOODS OF ALL THE UAW. You SUCK
Reply to this comment
by psk123-2009 December 6, 2008 8:58 PM PST
what an utterly sad and tragic story.
Reply to this comment
by dennisjr6 December 6, 2008 9:30 PM PST
Sad day for the family...I am sending my condolences and sympathy to the family of Ms. Von Burlow.
Reply to this comment
by hagar39 December 6, 2008 9:48 PM PST
Just think how much money the place where she stayed is going to lose now... Just think how much money they..MADE!
This is the main reason doctors etc. like to keep people...on machines etc. MONEY
A doctor can make a few thousand in an hour visting patinets. The place where they stay can make millions a year.... SAD....
Reply to this comment
by evian_ycnan December 6, 2008 10:39 PM PST
Okay Klaus, this time it`s murder. Call your lawyer.
Reply to this comment
by messiahx4eve December 6, 2008 11:57 PM PST
And this story has relevance to???
Reply to this comment
by clovisbuford December 7, 2008 12:39 AM PST
now this is just a sad ending to a sad story , and all you trolls dragging other *** in .. not only do you have no sense of shame , but very little of a life eh .
Reply to this comment
by pete_in_az December 7, 2008 12:59 AM PST
Thank God, she was able to afford the hospital stay. 28 years in a coma...wow, Bush beat her record though at 61 years in one.
---
Posted by Lemonskink at 03:19 PM : Dec 06, 2008

I take it you don''''t like Bush. Ok What about tiy Den''''s that gave are money away to the nO GOOD AUTOMAKERS AND THE WORST NO GOODS OF ALL THE UAW. You SUCK
---
Posted by hitoyou11 at 07:02 PM : Dec 06, 2008


Your both complete f''''''ing idiots.
Reply to this comment
by msay3 December 7, 2008 3:05 PM PST
she was was of the meanest women around and her children are all drug addicts..good riddens

Posted by markjessup1 at 08:55 PM : Dec 06, 2008
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Typical comment from an illiterate idiot
Reply to this comment
by yeswedid December 7, 2008 3:37 PM PST
WOW, THAT IS LIKE FLUSHING MILLIONS OF DOLLARS DOWN THE TOILET. Can you imagine all the better ways that $ could have been used? Absolutely sickening. That is precisely why if I am ever put into a "pull the plug" situation I ask that my family let me go.
Reply to this comment
by mtminds December 7, 2008 5:01 PM PST
Did she take the Red pill or the Blue pill?
Reply to this comment
by colonieny December 7, 2008 7:08 PM PST
This is a sad coda to a sad long good-bye. What suffering for the family and hopefully not for her.
Reply to this comment
by thisandthat1 December 7, 2008 7:14 PM PST
Just the fact that Alan Dershowitz''s public stance is that Von Bulow is innocent ... makes me almost certain he did it and got away with it.
Reply to this comment
by meinnv December 7, 2008 7:19 PM PST
From what I have been able to gather, this lady was not on life support. According to the article, she was comatose, ergo "sometimes conscious but giving no sign of awareness".

Also, she was, at the time of the comas, worth $25 million to $40 million, and as of the late 90''s room charges were up to about $1,500 a day - $547,000 a year, plus another $200,000 to $300,000 for round-the-clock private nursing; that is maintenance right there. And she apparently had sufficient funds to cover her care. The article says nothing about life support.

She was in what was known as "A persistent vegetative state (PVS) is a condition of patients with severe brain damage in whom coma has progressed to a state of wakefulness without detectable awareness. ". Individuals in PVS are seldom on any life-sustaining equipment other than a feeding tube because the brainstem, the center of vegetative functions (such as heart rate and rhythm, respiration, gastrointestinal activity), is relatively intact.
Reply to this comment
by meinnv December 7, 2008 7:25 PM PST
If it was her own money being spent, then who are we to decide whether or not a plug should be pulled?? It''s her money and her children were in charge. If they were geedy why wait 28 years when there is nothing left?? That makes no sense.

That was not her case. She was in a vegetative state (life support is when you are "artificially" kept alive; blood pumping and breathing for you), she was breathing with a pulse, thus resulting in "sometimes conscious but giving no sign of awareness".

As CBS so nicely and eloquently put (sarcastic eye-rolling) she "spent the last 28 years of her life in oblivion".

CBS, please try to remember you were reporting on someone''s mother and do try to remember that humans do have emotions.
Reply to this comment
by meinnv December 7, 2008 7:30 PM PST
The fact that her husband, according to the evidence attempted to kill her (or at least he had motive or was under reasonable suspicion of) and got by with it was the main story. All CBS is doing is "closing the chapter" on what might be perhaps a good mystery or a case of someone getting by with murder.

As with all good mysteries, you want to know how it ended or the conclusion.
Reply to this comment
by cbsblogger December 7, 2008 8:33 PM PST
Who cares about the rich and famous?

What have they done for the country that benefits the greater good? It''s likely that you and your neighbors have done more, yet when was the last time you saw your neighbor''s obituary on CBS?

I''m more than tired seeing the media inform us about about the so-called elite.
Reply to this comment
by oneworldusa December 8, 2008 3:29 AM PST
Her husbands were penniless...is there any other real motive for murder other than MONEY????
Reply to this comment
by alindgr1 December 8, 2008 5:04 AM PST
It''s all George Bush''s fault
Reply to this comment
by usclimey December 8, 2008 11:11 AM PST
What a waste of time and money. The hosptal sure made out like a bandit though.
Reply to this comment
by missybelle-2009 December 8, 2008 11:20 AM PST
Who cares about the rich and famous?

What have they done for the country that benefits the greater good? It''''s likely that you and your neighbors have done more, yet when was the last time you saw your neighbor''''s obituary on CBS?

I''''m more than tired seeing the media inform us about about the so-called elite.


Posted by cbsblogger at 08:33 PM : Dec 07, 2008

Wow, that is really.... sad-- how do you sleep at night with such bitterness and loathing? Apparently her family cares very much. I hope you have a family who cares about you, if you don''t then I feel for you.
Reply to this comment
by meinnv December 10, 2008 1:22 PM PST
Yes people die in horrible tragedies everyday. Yet most of them never have a movie about them, as in this case, as it was a unique case.

There are those who are interested in the case, and this story is a "footnote" as it were. It is educational for those who are studying criminal justice, and part of the reason forensic science is so integral to the investigative process.

Someone else may not care, others might. For some it is a histoy lesson, others it isn''t. It is a good wake-up call to make sure to protect yourself going into a marriage if you have anything of value. And, to make certain to get out of a bad situation before it is too late.
Reply to this comment
by meinnv December 10, 2008 1:24 PM PST
And contrary to everyone else''s belief, the current president was not to blame for the incident which occurred back in the early 80''s.
Reply to this comment
See all 47 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs