Video Allegedly Shows India Terror Arrest
CBS News Obtains Exclusive Video Of Train Station Shooter Beaten Before Arrest
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Exclusive: Mumbai Arrest
"CBS News EXCLUSIVE:" Grainy cell-phone video obtained exclusively by CBS News allegedly shows police beating the only suspect to be caught alive in the Mumbai, India terror attacks.
-
Video
Looking For Answers
Following the massacre in Mumbai, officials lowered the death toll to 174 and the only surviving attacker claims to belong to a Pakistani militant group. Celia Hatton has more.
-
Video
Mumbai: Behind The Attacks
Authorities believe the terrorists who laid siege to Mumbai, India came to the city in rubber rafts, possibly from a hijacked fishing boat. Mark Phillips reports.
-
-
Photo
This image taken from a grainy cell phone video allegedly shows the only suspect in the Mumbai terror attacks to be captured alive being beaten by bystanders and police before his arrest, Dec. 27, 2008. (CBS)
-
Photo
An unidentified gunman walks through the Chatrapathi Sivaji Terminal railway station in Mumbai, India, Nov. 26, 2008. (Mumbai Mirror, Sebastian D'souza)
-
Photo
Fire engulfs part of the Taj Hotel in Mumbai, India, Nov. 27, 2008. (AP Photo/Gautam Singh)
-
Photo
People place petals and touch the photographs of slain policemen at a prayer meeting to pay tribute to Mumbai's policemen who lost their lives in the recent terrorist attacks, Sunday, Nov. 30, 2008. (AP Photo/Gautam Singh)
-
-
Photo Essay
Mumbai Mourns
Residents hold candlelight vigils, leave flowers in memory of those killed in terror attacks.
-
Fast Facts
India
Learn about the people, economy and history.
The one-minute, 35-second video opens with images that apparently show bystanders and Indian security forces beating a man on the ground with sticks.
The journalist from whom CBS News obtained the video says the man is Ajmal Qasab, who, according to a senior Indian police officer, confessed to interrogators that he is a member of the Pakistani militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba.
The low-resolution video shows Qasab being beaten by men in white shirts after he allegedly tried to hijack a car. The photographer says he turned to face a group of bystanders and police holding an assault rifle and shot at them, prompting the violent reaction by the group.
Whistles are heard amid shouting as police signal for more help.
Qasab is beaten repeatedly on the ground before more police arrive and take him into custody.
Joint Police Commissioner Rakesh Maria said Qasab told police the group had intended to hit more targets during their attacks on India's financial capital.
"Lashkar-e-Taiba is behind the terrorist acts in the city," Maria told reporters. "The terrorists were from a hardcore group in the L-e-T."
"Ajmal Qasab has received training in an L-e-T training camp in Pakistan," he said. "Our interrogation indicates that the terrorists had other places that they also intended to target."
Police have said Qasab is 21-years-old and a Pakistani national.
Six Americans were among the 172 killed in last week's attacks. President Bush on Sunday dispatched Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to New Delhi in support of India following the siege.
Rice said Monday that the U.S. expects nothing short of complete cooperation in investigations into the terrorist rampage, and Pakistan's response will be a test of the will of the new civilian government.
"What we are emphasizing to the Pakistani government is the need to follow the evidence wherever it leads," Rice said. "I don't want to jump to any conclusions myself on this, but I do think that this is a time for complete, absolute, total transparency and cooperation and that's what we expect."
The Secretary of State spoke Monday during a visit to London, where she was to meet her British counterpart David Miliband before traveling to Brussels for a NATO gathering. On Wednesday, following the NATO meeting, she is scheduled to travel to New Delhi, according to her new itinerary.
What we are emphasizing to the Pakistani government is the need to follow the evidence wherever it leads.
Secretary of State Condoleezza RiceQasab is allegedly the same militant gunman pictured in one of the few still photos to surface of the attackers as they besieged 10 locations Wednesday night. An image captured by newspaper photographer Sebastian D'Souza shows a man in his early 20s, believed to be Qasab, walking calmly through Mumbai's train station with an assault rifle at his hip.
Many witnesses have said the gunmen were remarkably calm. D'Souza followed militants operating in the train station, taking photos throughout.
"This is where I got the picture of the two and they exchanged some couple of words and then the guy dropped his bag," said D'Souza, who works for the Mumbai Mirror. "I think it was empty there was no ammo in it - he dropped his bag and then moved forward and kept firing from the hips, never raised the gun, very cool."
Meanwhile, CBS News reporter Celia Hatton says authorities finished removing bodies from the Taj Mahal hotel on Monday, the final site of the Mumbai siege to be cleared, as schools and businesses reopened and commuters returned to work.

"We were apprehensive about more bodies being found. But this is not likely - all rooms in the Taj have been opened and checked," said Maharashtra state government spokesman Bhushan Gagrani.
The L-e-T has long been seen as a creation of the Pakistani intelligence service to help wage its clandestine war against India in disputed Kashmir.Watch an eyewitness's account of the Mumbai horror on "The Early Show."
In April 2006, the U.S. Department of State listed Jamaat-ud-Dawa as terrorist organizations for being an "alias" of Lashkar-e-Taiba.
The Pakistani government offered no immediate response.
Speaking earlier Sunday, a spokesman for a Jamat-ud Dawa denied any link to Lashkar-e-Taiba and said he condemned the attack.
"We condemn the killings of civilians. We condemn such killings in a terrorist activity, and at the same time we condemn it happening in the shape of state terrorism, as we see in Srinagar, Kashmir," Abdullah Muntazir said, referring to alleged Indian army atrocities in the disputed Kashmir region.
Despite India's claim, Pakistan's ambassador to the United States, Husain Haqqani, said, "I don't think that this is the time for India or anybody in India to accuse Pakistan. It's time to work with Pakistan. Pakistan is now a democracy. India is a democracy. And as two democracies, we need to strengthen each other, rather than fall into the trap of the terrorists, who want us to fight with each other so that they can get greater strength."
India repeatedly has accused Pakistan of complicity in terrorist attacks on its soil, many of which it traces to militant groups fighting Indian rule in the divided Himalayan territory of Kashmir. The U.S. has tried to persuade Pakistan to shift its security focus from India, with which it has fought three wars, to Islamic militants along the Afghan border.
As investigations continued into one of India's deadliest terrorist attacks, pressure mounted on the Indian government to account for what went wrong, reported Hatton. Two top security officials resigned over the weekend and India's Prime Minister has vowed to boost the size of the country's anti-terrorism forces, which face criticism for arriving at the scene long after the gunfire began.
© MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Watch an eyewitness's account of the Mumbai horror on "The Early Show."



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymnjacioEmQ
so god sent his messengers in with grenades and machine guns to do his will because they wont accept jesus?
Yes, there are more Muslims in India than Pakistan. I didnt accuse all the Muslims. There are good as well as bad people in Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Jews and even in other religions.
Most of the nations think beyond religion. But some of the nations like Pak is standing for a Musliom-only world. I am not against Muslim. Mohammed nabi was a great man. Muslims who are real followers of ''Nabi'' won''t kill others or stand against other religions. All the religions teaches good. But what if someone wants only one religion in the universe ?
Think. Think and think Mr.Nokia3210C
I bet if they beat some link to Iran out of him, It will be all the justification Isreal needs. We will have to act to keep them from doing Iran themselves.
You are wrong. He along with his friend shot more than 70 people to death and 100 plus to serious injuries.
Om Prema Nam Om.
I bet if they beat some link to Iran out of him, It will be all the justification Isreal needs. We will have to act to keep them from doing Iran themselves.
Posted by impeach___w at 10:18 AM : Dec 01, 2008
Beat him with sticks?
Isn''t what they did called torture of a suspect?
Well, at least they didn''t water-board him. That would have gotten people upset.
The low-resolution video shows Qasab being beaten by men in white shirts after he allegedly tried to hijack a car. The photographer says he turned to face a group of bystanders and police holding an assault rifle and shot at them, prompting the violent reaction by the group.
Whistles are heard amid shouting as police signal for more help.
Qasab is beaten repeatedly on the ground before more police arrive and take him into custody.
...he dropped his bag and then moved forward and kept firing from the hips, never raised the gun,
..."Ajmal Qasab has received training in an L-e-T training camp in Pakistan," he said. "Our interrogation indicates that the terrorists had other places that they also intended to target."
*** do you think interrogation is India is like?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by lady_organs at 10:39 AM : Dec 01, 2008
...I am a ''Christian'' yogi...I do accept Jesus, and Krishna and Ram...as a ''Chela'' of the ''Word'' I have no innate need for ''Avatars''....Jesus/Yeshua said He was one with the ''Light''. The "Light and the ''Word'' are ''One''...so you fundamentalists will get no agrument from me....''nuff said
How did you go from GOP_Will_Win to lady_organs?
Doesn''t really go with your previous themes.
You are a slimy character, all your posts are a systematic attack on Pakistan. Who was it that killed 2000 muslims in Gujarat.India???, a few months ago. Was it Pakistan??. You are trying to blame all on the people of Pakistan. What about thousands killed in Kashmir by Indian forces???. You are one Garbage head.
Pakistan have a history of 60 years. In those 60 years, the pakistan military overpowered the government 5 or 6 times. Many of the leaders were killed by the military to seize power. And some of those military rulers even killed by his sub-ordinates to take control of the country.
The country is not really ruled by elected government. Infact, the military and ISI is ruling the country. The President and Prime Mininster are just the rubber stamps. If they do something of their own to make peace in the area, they will be killed or overpowered by Military and ISI.
They engaged in war with India 3 times and failed. And a proxy-war in 1999 but the result was same. They wanted to use nuclear bomb on India in 1999 and they presented this plan infront of US President Clinton. The reply from Clinton was a shock to them. He said, ''If you use nuclear bomb on India, they can turn your country in to ashes in no time, And the US will not question India''. India agreed not to use nuclear-bomb first. But they said if pakistan use it, they will be forced to use it. US asked Pakistan whether they can agree not to use it First. They said we cant promise it.
Hope you got it. If you are still confused, search in wikipedia. It will clarify.
You forgot to mention the real story, since the birth of Pakistan you and your friends in power in India, have tried every which way to destabilize Pakistan, using horrendous torture and killings.
I asked you a simple question. WHO KILLED 2000 MUSLIMS IN GUJARAT. Was it Pakistan????.
Posted by blitzder at 11:16 AM : Dec 01, 2008"
There are 150 millions of Muslims living in India. More than in Pakistan. In India a Muslim legally marry 4 ladies by the law there. They are given religious holidays, education and job reservations(affirmative action). In Kargil war it self 1000 Indian soldiers are dead. Since 1984 how many innocent lives are lost in the hands of Pakistani trained terrorists? Do you know or care to search ?
By the way how many innocent civilians are dead due to missile strikes by US in Pakistan/Afghanistan border. Does that give you a right to kill innocent Americans?
PAKISTAN is an Acronym that stands for Punjab, Afghania (also known as North-West Frontier Province), Kashmir, Sindh, and Baluchistan.
If you put most of the nutty people we wanted to fight or have kill each other in one country, this would be it.
Although, I don''t know what this group was trying to prove. Whatever they wanted obviously this is a horrific way to get it.
The targets for the attacks, many of them symbols of Mumbai''s growing power and wealth, were not randomly selected and were intended to send a direct message to India, Israel and the West.
Indeed, the Mumbai attacks had all the hallmarks of a powerful transnational terrorist group inspired by the ideology of al Qaeda.
As I said, all that has to be done now is finding a link of this attack to Iran and the Future of the middle east is sealed
I strongly condemn the horrendous activities by Hindu extremists. They acted aginst Muslims and Christian in the country. It has to be stopped. Anyway its their internal affair.
The terrorism or extremeism across the border is different from that. Do you know the death toll in India by the hands of Pak terrorists is more than 37,000 in the last 15-20 years. (by CNN last week).
Whether it is Hindu or Muslim, extremism and terrorism from any side is no way acceptable. What do they earn by killing innocent people ? Can we see an end to this ? the future will tell.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by lady_organs at 10:58 AM : Dec 01, 2008
...You serve either the ''Light" or the ''Dark'' and it''s your choice and yours alone.
The ''Avatar'' you choose to assist you to this destination is your choice also. [these choices are conditioned by the societies and customs of the lands we different people live in]. Jesus IS ONE WITH THE LIGHT and not THE ONLY WAY TO IT...HE IS THE DESTINATION AND NOT NECESSARILY THE FORM OF THE VEHICLE ALSO...KHRISHNA, RAMA ET.AL ARE VEHICLES OF THE LIGHT.
You must choose either the Light or the Dark to serve. In my wide experiences in these matters I notice that those that don''t, utimately get ''Served Up''...[in other words you are just ''collateral damage'' in the ''Spiritual War'' of these two Forces'' of "Light" and "Darkness"].
May God and Yeshua watch over you if you so desire it.
Well said, I would like to see a day when both countries, instead of spending 1 TRILLION dollars on arms and armaments, can use that money to alleviate the lives of millions of people who barely survive.The two countries are really rich with resources, culture and history.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by lady_organs ...
so true, they should pick between a fat purple dinosaur 24/7
or a Fat Pastor Hagee...
and these people will run the white house next year....
if terrorism has stocks..it be the best time to buy because its going to be a very lucrative BUSINESS in the next 4 years..
And your a Media plant. Can''t say anything without name calling. The true sign of a rightwing folower.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by brianwwb at 06:28 PM : Dec 01, 20
Nice try plant, Is that the company line? You are one of "God Chosen People" so sing on.
Face it, Pakistan and Kashmir is home to some lunatic Islamists who are hell bent on transforming their country and everything around it back into the stone age. They are the enemies of not just the West, but ALL civilization.
Your Judge and Jury on this issue. How can you be so convinced when we haven''t received all the facts yet? So grab yourself up and go enlist with the mossad, if you haven''t already. Go start another war using a country that can afford to fight it for you. We can''t!!
point out that the room the gunmen had stayed in had four empty bottle%u2019s of assorted liquor laying about. They stated they''re slaughter began from a bar after slamming a beer. It%u2019s a known fact that Islamic Muslims to not drink alcohol. Not even the extremist. So before we all start pointing fingers where the media says we should lets wait for the investigations to bring the facts to a more transparent level.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by brianwwb at 06:45 PM : Dec 01, 2008
As we can see people, another post with the same verbage. These guys are plants and trying to drum up hate. Don''t allow yourself to be convinced and driven to action by hatred until we have all the facts. There has been a horrible crime and we need to find out who in fact started this, not a witch hunt.
While I agree Israel is just as guilty of bad behavior as its neighbors, it is not a systematic enemy of science, music, and religious freedoms. Israel has Muslims, Jews, and Christians all living together. Yes, Muslims do live in Israel.
These bearded butt-f&#ks attack and kill innocent people in order to establish THEIR version of Islam. And yet, you feel compelled to defend them...very strange.
It must suck to [CALL EVERYONE] a useless terrorist sympathizer like you.
Seeing you are alive why don''t you so something useful and uplifting for your fellow man. Lots of opportunities other than [CALLING EVERYONE] a terrorist sympathizer.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by brianwwb
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by cause_a at 07:05 PM : Dec 01, 2008
Nice key stroke brian, point well made!!
A secret investigation into detained Ergenekon group members and other studies outside Turkey indicate that Mossad orchestrated the coup plot against the Turkish government, the report says.
Gotta look at the whole picture to see this new offensive. We need real media to look into this stuff and give us real up to date "News". Please do something before the whole world goes crazy!!
What''s going on here? There''s no excuse to beat this poor defenseless, disarmed, muslum after he has been captured. This is a matter that should be taken up with the UN or the ACLU. He deserves to be treated with dignity & respect. Instead of being discriminated against. This will only serve to encourage more of these kinds of attacks. BO & Hillary will bring these people on board an America will clean up its act. So Sadd!
-
by xyno-2009
December 2, 2008 3:28 PM PST
- There''''s no excuse to beat this poor defenseless, disarmed, muslum after he has been captured. This is a matter that should be taken up with the UN or the ACLU.
-
Reply to this comment
-
See all 48 CommentsPosted by pepperwood2 at 08:19 PM : Dec 01, 2008
=========
LOL