February 11, 2009 2:09 PM

McCain's Challenge In "Must-Win" Ohio

By
Jeff Greenfield
(CBS)  For the series, "Final Battleground," the CBS Evening News is traveling to three key areas of the country - the South, the Midwest and the West - to hone in on the states that will decide this presidential election. Ohio is one state that could swing toward either Barack Obama or John McCain, CBS News senior political correspondent Jeff Greenfield reports.


Nobody has to spell it out for John McCain. Like every other Republican nominee in history, if he does not win Ohio, he won't win the White House, Greenfield reports.

And the terrain is daunting: with more than 88 offices throughout the Buckeye state - more than double that of McCain - and with more than 10,000 volunteers, Obama's ground game has neutralized the Republican operation that gave President Bush his narrow victory there four years ago.

"What's significant compared to '04 is that the Democrats and the Obama campaign are making a run at the collar counties. They were ignored by, largely ignored by, Kerry in 2004," said Mark Naymik of the Cleveland Plain Dealer.

The "collar counties" are ones surrounding large cities like Cleveland.

That city and Columbus will likely generate huge majorities for Obama; Cincinnati, and Southern Ohio will likely be big for McCain. So the key are those collar counties - like Lake County, narrowly won by Mr. Bush four years ago.

John McCain's fate in Ohio may come down to places like Painesville, some 30 miles northwest of Cleveland. Without big majorities among working and middle-class whites in places like these, McCain simply cannot win the state.

"We're going to have to do a little bit stronger here in Lake County as other collar counties," said Lake County GOP chair Dale Fellows. "That's where the battleground is going to be to offset what we know we're going to lose in the urban counties."

Fellows says that apart from taxes and McCain's personal story, the message is to raise doubts about Obama - as with the "robocalls" that link Obama to Bill Ayers.

"What Sen. Obama represents is so far out of the mainstream but he's been able to paint himself more into the mainstream. What we're trying to do is just say, here's really who Barack Obama is," Fellows said.

Ways To Win
Calculate paths to the presidency with our electoral vote map.
Tim Hagan a 40-year veteran of Ohio Democratic politics, says there's a racial undertone to "out-of-the-mainstream" message - but it is complex.

"They're making a case, not in a boldness of saying, you know, 'don't vote for the black guy,' they're making the case of saying, 'vote for one of your own.' The subtlety of it is simply this: He's not like us."

A McCain victory in Ohio will not be enough to save his campaign, but it is an absolute necessity for his presidential hopes.

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment See all 37 Comments
by mamami_198 October 22, 2008 11:47 AM EDT
Being from Southern Ohio I would hope that North Ohio and all of Ohio would vote FOR McCain.. We are losing to to many jobs here and I do believe that Obamas tax raise on companies is just gonna hurt us more, and we are gonna see more jobs lost.. McCain''s strategy of dropping the tax to 25 percent makes sence ,, it would allow companys to free up money for extended payroll or new hirings that would otherwise be used to pay the outrageous Tax increase that Obama is suggesting...

We Support John McCain
Reply to this comment
by hbevis October 21, 2008 11:02 PM EDT
Look at the skinny appearance of Obama. He could be a puppet or assistant. He should NOT be a leader.

Posted by Timmothy8 at 06:52 PM : Oct 21,
2008

If he gets in he will be a Puppet of Allah for the Muslims. And of course of the crime boss''s in Chicago.
Reply to this comment
by timnguyen October 21, 2008 10:09 PM EDT
I am voting against Obama and his crooked campaign that employed ACORN, Foreign money that will be investigated eventually, the race card, dirty campaign literature distorting Hillarys positions, snubbing women - until they found out they might just need their votes etc etc etc....He has run a very dishonest campaign after proclaiming he would run a different type of campaign. He claimed not to take any lobbyist money but found a way around that by bundling it and using employee names to get the money instead of showing it coming from corporations. He flip flopped on everything and never kept his word. He and Michelle criticized Americans and talked down to us while praising the Europeans. He criticized our military and had to be shamed into going to Iraq and Afghanistan just once ! The campaign of fraud and illusion. I am voting against him based on his associations which he still lies about.. He will set black rights back 50 years when he loses...but it will be for the reasons mentioned...so dont cry race when it happens !!
Reply to this comment
by recession1 October 21, 2008 9:58 PM EDT
BREAKING NEWS!!!
THE "MAVERICK" SARAH PALIN, WHO THE REPUBS BELIEVE IS READY TO BE IN A POSITION WHERE SHE IS A BREATH AWAY FROM THE PRESIDENCY, IS ALL FOR SENDING U.S. NATURAL GAS TO ASIA!!!! WHAT???? NOT AFTER THE "MAVERICK" HAS SHOWERED HER RALLIES WITH THAT " U.S. NEEDS IT''''S OWN ENERGY INDEPENDENCE" ***!! WHAT A JOKE.. YOU CAN''''T BE SERIOUS.. ISN''''T THIS HER "EXPERTISE" THE ENERGY CRISIS??!!
Reply to this comment
by recession1 October 21, 2008 9:57 PM EDT
WOW!! DID THAT GUY SAY "LOOK AT THE SKINNY APPEARANCE OF OBAMA, HE''S NOT READY TO BE A LEADER BECAUSE HE''S SKINNY"?? ARE YOU THAT DESPERATE TO CONVINCE YOURSELF HE''S THE WRONG CANIDATE TO VOTE FOR?? THAT IS THE MOST PATHETIC SHOT I''VE SEEN/HEARD TAKEN AT THE MAN THUS FAR!! PATHETIC AND JUST PLAIN SAD!!
Reply to this comment
by timnguyen October 21, 2008 9:52 PM EDT
Look at the skinny appearance of Obama. He could be a puppet or assistant. He should NOT be a leader.
Reply to this comment
by timnguyen October 21, 2008 9:49 PM EDT
I respect for a community organizer. But he could NOT be an US president.

Reply to this comment
by recession1 October 21, 2008 9:47 PM EDT
BREAKING NEWS!!!
THE "MAVERICK" SARAH PALIN, WHO THE REPUBS BELIEVE IS READY TO BE IN A POSITION WHERE SHE IS A BREATH AWAY FROM THE PRESIDENCY, IS ALL FOR SENDING U.S. NATURAL GAS TO ASIA!!!! WHAT???? NOT AFTER THE "MAVERICK" HAS SHOWERED HER RALLIES WITH THAT " U.S. NEEDS IT''S OWN ENERGY INDEPENDENCE" ***!! WHAT A JOKE.. YOU CAN''T BE SERIOUS.. ISN''T THIS HER "EXPERTISE" THE ENERGY CRISIS??!!
Reply to this comment
by misha128-2009 October 21, 2008 9:30 PM EDT
Can''t find a single McCain supporter willing to discuss real issues like the ecomony that affect real families across the nation, just a bunch of robo-posters trying to imitate McCain''s robo-calls that are destroying his party as well as his own campaign.
Reply to this comment
by emily022 October 21, 2008 9:25 PM EDT
Maybe when this is over on November 4th, both John McCain and Sarah Palin will have a little more respect for a community organizer, as Barack Obama has a highly organized campaign in all the battleground states, as well as their own blue states, to register people and to get out the vote. He surrounds himself with intelligent people, with years or experience, he has a transition team in place, and people like Colin Powell to be advisors. He is ready to be President and Commander in Chief.

What, exactly, does John McCain have in place in case he should win? All those lobbyist he employs, I personally wouldn''t trust any of them in a position of power in the government.
Reply to this comment
See all 37 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook