MANILA, Philippines, July 27, 2008

Did Oxygen Tank Explode On Qantas Jet?

Investigators Focus On Possible Cause For Hole In Plane's Fuselage During Hong Kong-Australia Flight

  • This photo released by the Media Affairs Division of the Ninoy Aquino International Airport shows Qantas pilot Capt. John Francis Bartels looking at the right wing damaged fuselage of Qantas Airways Boeing 747-400 after it made an emergency landing July 25, 2008 in Manila, Philippines.

    This photo released by the Media Affairs Division of the Ninoy Aquino International Airport shows Qantas pilot Capt. John Francis Bartels looking at the right wing damaged fuselage of Qantas Airways Boeing 747-400 after it made an emergency landing July 25, 2008 in Manila, Philippines.  (AP)

  • Video Close Call For Qantas 747

    A Qantas jumbo jet was forced to make an emergency landing in the Philippines after something punched a massive hole in the fuselage as the plane reached cruising altitude. Nancy Cordes reports.

  • Interactive Air Disasters

    Review the worst air disasters in the past four decades, see how safety officials investigate plane crashes and more.

(AP)  Australian investigators are focusing on the possibility that an oxygen cylinder could have exploded mid-flight on a Qantas jumbo jet that made an emergency landing in the Philippines with a giant hole in its fuselage, officials said Sunday.

Australia's Civil Aviation Safety Authority said Qantas has been ordered to urgently inspect every oxygen bottle aboard its fleet of 30 Boeing 747s.

"At this stage, there is no evidence whatsoever that this is a security-related event," Neville Blyth, senior investigator from the Australian Transport and Safety Bureau, told a news conference in Manila. "This is being treated as a safety investigation."

Blyth said tests for bomb residue were negative. Philippine bomb-sniffing dogs went through the aircraft, particularly the cargo hold and the passenger baggage, and found no indication of explosives.

He said the focus is now on an oxygen bottle missing from the cargo hold that was left exposed when a section of the 747-400's metal skin ripped away at 29,000 feet over the South China Sea on Friday.

"I can't speculate as to indeed the probability of that cylinder having caused the damage," Blyth said, when asked if there were indications that the scuba tank-like cylinder had exploded and damaged the plane.

"In the vicinity of the damage, we are missing one cylinder. The areas around the damage will be inspected. We're obviously looking for evidence on where that cylinder may have gone," he said.

Peter Gibson, spokesman for the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, said an inspection of all oxygen bottles in Qantas' fleet will take several days. He said bottles located near the hole contained emergency oxygen for the flight deck.

Passengers described the plane being shaken by a loud bang. Oxygen masks dropped from the ceiling due to rapid decompression caused by the 9-foot hole in its fuselage, and the plane descended rapidly as debris flew through the cabin. The plane, en route from London to Melbourne, Australia, had made a stopover in Hong Kong an hour earlier.

Four Australian Transport Safety Bureau specialists began inspecting the aircraft Saturday and were expected to continue their work for two or three days with assistance from Boeing and the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board, Blyth said.

The plane's flight data recorder, cockpit voice recorder and a small disc that records maintenance details have been sent to Australia to be analyzed "in respect of the handling of the aircraft," Blyth said.

The possibility of an explosion is one of several scenarios being considered by investigators, said Julian Walsh of the Australian Transport Safety Bureau.

"There are oxygen cylinders contained in the cargo compartment," he told reporters. "The relevance of that will certainly be covered in the investigation."

An official of the U.S. Transportation Security Administration said initial reports indicated no link to terrorism.

Some passengers told Australian media that their oxygen masks failed to work properly during the crisis, causing some to nearly pass out.

Other passengers, while applauding the pilot and crew's performance, told of having to share oxygen masks among three people.

"Ours didn't come down, and my husband just about (passed out) because he didn't have any oxygen for about three minutes," Beverley Doors told Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio.

Passenger David Saunders said one man in front of him smashed the ceiling panel to force his mask to come down and that children were screaming and flailing.

"Their cheeks and lips were turning blue from lack of oxygen," he said.

Boeing spokeswoman Liz Verdier said the design of the Qantas jet includes dozens of oxygen tanks located throughout the lower part of the aircraft, including below the passenger compartment where the hole is.

Gibson of Australia's Civil Aviation Safety Authority said speculation that corrosion contributed to the accident could be discounted.

"It's clearly an extremely rare and unusual event that a hole opens up in the fuselage," he told reporters in Australia. "I know there's a number of theories around, but they're just that at this stage, they're just theories. We don't have the solid facts."

Blyth, however, said investigators will check whether there was any corrosion in the aircraft wall or the oxygen cylinders that may have caused a problem.

Qantas boasts a strong safety record and has never lost a jet to an accident. Its last crash of a smaller plane was in 1951.

© MMVIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Add a Comment
by cyberus-2009 July 28, 2008 12:26 AM EDT
----
Its strange flicking thru the channels about this story. On fox I got the impression it was a bomb, and on CNN, that it was some mechanical breakdown like this.

Posted by donnie10411
----
Gee ... foxnews trying to turn everything into a terrorist bomb attack ... whoda thunk it (heavy note of sarcasm)
Reply to this comment
by yongamerica July 27, 2008 10:05 PM EDT
Chances an Oxygen bottle exploded is nill to none. Each bottle has its own service and test regime. Had the tank exploded there would be obvious shrapnel that could have penetrated into the passenger compartment with ease. From the pictures shown there is no shredded metal as one would expect from a bursting aluminum tank holding more than 3 thousands pounds per square inch of pressurized oxygen. For example, a scuba tank which has similar pressures, can penetrate 3 feet of concrete if the valve is broken off. The occurrence of scuba tanks exploding is so rare none have made the news in over 30 years.

But it seems apparent there was something that caused over pressurization. But the skin seems to have been torn off cleanly.
Reply to this comment
by hbevis July 27, 2008 6:05 PM EDT
I''''ll stick with Boeing airframes.......

I will agree that the Boeing has a strong airframe. Whatever was the cause of this accident it showed how well the plane held up after the fact.
Reply to this comment
by j_flood July 27, 2008 5:43 PM EDT
I''ll stick with Boeing airframes.......

PS - Agree donnie10411 - first it was ''plunging to safety'' and ''terror in the sky'' - know it sounds more like what it was - rapid decompression, pilots and crew responding right to the checklist......
Reply to this comment

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: