WASHINGTON, July 27, 2008

Is The Bush Admin. Blowing Smoke?

Bob Schieffer Says Not Allowing The FDA To Regulate Tobacco Because They're Overworked Makes No Sense

  •  (AP)

  • Play CBS Video Video Bush Tobacco Stance Under Fire

    Bob Schieffer supports the House's proposed bill which would impose stronger regulations on the tobacco industry, but fails to understand how the Bush Administration could not support such an act.


(CBS)  Weekly commentary by CBS Evening News chief Washington correspondent and Face the Nation host Bob Schieffer.
First disclosure: I'm a cancer survivor, and have lived for a long time with another disease called ulcerative colitis, both of which I probably got because of a long-ago, heavy addiction to nicotine.

So I am delighted the House will vote this week on legislation that for the fist time will give the Food and Drug Administration real power to regulate tobacco products. I hope it passes.

For the record, John McCain and Barack Obama, who don't agree on much, agree this needs to be done. So does the American Cancer Society, as well as the American Heart Association, the American Lung Association, and on and on.

The administration - incredibly, in my opinion - opposes it for a reason that would make the Queen of Hearts from "Alice in Wonderland" proud.

Their reason: that the FDA already has such a huge job monitoring food safety that it just doesn't have the resources to take on the additional job of regulating tobacco.

If it did, the administration argues, regulating food and drugs might suffer.

I couldn't be more serious. That really is their main reason.

By that logic, we shouldn't have asked the military or our intelligence agencies to get involved in fighting terrorism after 9/11. For sure, they already had plenty to do before Osama bin Laden came along.

In "Alice," after the Queen of Hearts issued her weird orders, her husband the King had a way of undoing them when she wasn't looking.

Well, maybe Congress can do the same and pass this by veto-proof margins.

Because every day, 1,000 children in America are learning to smoke, and for 20 years now, 400,000 Americans have died each year from tobacco-related diseases.

That's no fairy tale. Those are just the facts.

E-mail Face the Nation.


By Bob Schieffer
© MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Add a Comment See all 48 Comments
by martublade March 14, 2009 1:21 PM EDT
http://niconotnow.blogspot.com/
Reply to this comment
by ewinters2 July 29, 2008 10:08 PM EDT
What I find amazing in this forum and almost every other forum is that the democrat-liberal-marxists use any and every opportunity to call Bush names and make baseless and stupid accusations without ever defending their positions. Is the left in this country even capable of developing an argument in favor of their bigger government, more taxes and greater control over The People''s lives policies? I am rooting for Obama and a democrat congress just to be able to say "I told you so" as we pick ourselves up from the shambles of Marxism 4-6 year hence. So sad.
Reply to this comment
by ewinters2 July 29, 2008 10:03 PM EDT
Veteran188,

You are nothing but a malcontent and an extraordinarily ignorant person. Your statements in this forum are so idiotic, so completely outrageous and without foundation that you should be ashamed of yourself.

What are you a "veteran" of anyway? The insane asylum??
Reply to this comment
by rossborba July 29, 2008 7:53 PM EDT
Mr. Schieffer should check his facts before asserting that smoking (nicotine) causes ulcerative colitus. Here, from the Medicine Net website (http://www.medicinenet.com/ulcerative_colitis/page4.htm) is a direct quote by: "It has long been observed that the risk of ulcerative colitis appears to be higher in nonsmokers and in ex-smokers. In certain circumstances, patients improve when treated with nicotine."
Additionally, if FDA were charged with regulation of tobacco products, they''d have no choice but to outlaw it, totally.
I agree with President Bush that FDA has enough on their plate without becoming political footballs for the anti-smoking crowd.

RB,J
Reply to this comment
by veteran188 July 29, 2008 4:36 PM EDT
gunfighter51

socialism is what your senator , McSame, and even Bush use to get their healthcare, they have socialized medical care,

have you heard any one of them complain about socialism,

the only thing wrong with socialism is that people like you do not understand it
Reply to this comment
by veteran188 July 29, 2008 4:35 PM EDT
is Bush blowing smoke?

what a joke , has he ever done anything but blow smoke?

the criminal conservative agenda, hey will protect any business, even tobacco, prostitution, illegal drugs, or religions, if they can keep a little of their power because of it,

They are greed driven, anything for money

check out Larry Craig and Ted Stevens for good examples

gunfghter51 is another typical example of the kind of

goose stepping fascism we are talking about,

It is a mindless voting machine that props up republiCons
Reply to this comment
by rosalbanj79 July 29, 2008 10:00 AM EDT
Soultion: Get the the resources to take on the additional job of regulating tobacco.
Reply to this comment
by gunfighter51 July 28, 2008 5:38 PM EDT
If it was''nt for stupid liberals talking about issues not even related to the article, I would have kept my mouth shut.

Reply to this comment
by gunfighter51 July 28, 2008 5:36 PM EDT
Chalres,
What does the party that''s controlling America have to do with losing union jobs?
That sounds like a union problem to me!

Reply to this comment
by chalres-2009 July 28, 2008 4:53 PM EDT
Gunfighter51 You have got to be kidding me. You conservatives (neocons) have been running the show since 1994. Newt and the contract on america. Get you facts straight befor spouting them...
Reply to this comment
by Syndicate July 28, 2008 2:45 PM EDT
Remove the nicotine from tobacco products.
Reply to this comment
by jjp735i July 28, 2008 1:36 PM EDT
Is The Bush Admin. Blowing Smoke? Aren''t they always?
Reply to this comment
by neobrian-2009 July 28, 2008 11:01 AM EDT
Complete Failure is spelled,
" SHRUB "
Far and Away The W Worst resident to EVER Occupy the White House .A Criminal operate like Shrove has made a mockery of the Justice system .Dicck,Scooter,Delay,Harriet,Gonzo and All others ned to be W Waterboarded !
Reply to this comment
by gunfighter51 July 28, 2008 8:19 AM EDT
Mr Aint,
Do you wear a sack over your head, ala Katrina.

You best look at your lame unions as the cause of all your good jobs going overseas. When Clinton was in office, 2 million union workers, when he left, 500,000 workers, now 250,000 workers. Put the blame where it belongs.
LIBERALISM, combined with SOCIALISM.
Reply to this comment
by yamuttya July 28, 2008 7:25 AM EDT
I don''''t know if smoking causes cancer or not. But I do know this. As a smoker who has tried to quit many times without success it is one of the strongest psychological addictions known to man.
Element 51

I smoked for 30 years, trying to quit for 29.
Tried a million times to quit.Got sick and couldnt stand the thought of smoke. That did it. When my cold was gone I just stayed with it and havent touched a smoke since. That was ten years ago.
Met a new girlfriend this year and she told me to lose the beer ( and the gut ). Havent had a beer in 6 months.Now we play tennis and go swimming together. Never felt better .Saving a lot of dough.
Nothing is impossible.
Good luck ( next time you get sick , just stop ! )
The key is to really ,really want to quit.

Just thought I''d share.
Reply to this comment
by yamuttya July 28, 2008 7:13 AM EDT
I don''''t know if smoking causes cancer or not. But I do know this. As a smoker who has tried to quit many times without success it is one of the strongest psychological addictions known to man.
Element 51

I smoked for 30 years, trying to quit for 29.
Tried a million times to quit.Got sick and couldnt stand the thought of smoke. That did it. When my cold was gone I just stayed with it and havent touched a smoke since. That was ten years ago.
Met a new girlfriend this year and she told me to lose the beer ( and the gut ). Havent had a beer in 6 months.Now we play tennis and go swimming together. Never felt better .Saving a lot of dough.
Nothing is impossible.
Good luck ( next time you get sick , just stop ! )
The key is to really ,really want to quit.

Just thought I''d share.
Reply to this comment
by yamuttya July 28, 2008 7:11 AM EDT
I don''''t know if smoking causes cancer or not. But I do know this. As a smoker who has tried to quit many times without success it is one of the strongest psychological addictions known to man.
Element 51

I smoked for 30 years, trying to quit for 29.
Tried a million times to quit.Got sick and couldnt stand the thought of smoke. That did it. When my cold was gone I just stayed with it and havent touched a smoke since. That was ten years ago.
Met a new girlfriend this year and she told me to lose the beer ( and the gut ). Havent had a beer in 6 months.Now we play tennis and go swimming together. Never felt better .Saving a lot of dough.
Nothing is impossible.
Good luck ( next time you get sick , just stop ! )
The key is to really ,really want to quit.
Just thought I''d share.
Reply to this comment
by yamuttya July 28, 2008 7:09 AM EDT
I don''''t know if smoking causes cancer or not. But I do know this. As a smoker who has tried to quit many times without success it is one of the strongest psychological addictions known to man.
Element 51

I smoked for 30 years, trying to quit for 29.
Tried a million times to quit.Got sick and couldnt stand the thought of smoke. That did it. When my cold was gone I just stayed with it and havent touched a smoke since. That was ten years ago.
Met a new girlfriend this year and she told me to lose the beer ( and the gut ). Havent had a beer in 6 months.Now we play tennis and go swimming together. Never felt better .Saving a lot of dough.
Nothing is impossible.
Good luck ( next time you get sick , just stop ! )
The key is to really ,really want to quit.
Just thought I''d share.
Reply to this comment
by yamuttya July 28, 2008 7:08 AM EDT
I don''''t know if smoking causes cancer or not. But I do know this. As a smoker who has tried to quit many times without success it is one of the strongest psychological addictions known to man.
Element 51

I smoked for 30 years, trying to quit for 29.
Tried a million times to quit.Got sick and couldnt stand the thought of smoke. That did it. When my cold was gone I just stayed with it and havent touched a smoke since. That was ten years ago.
Met a new girlfriend this year and she told me to lose the beer ( and the gut ). Havent had a beer in 6 months.Now we play tennis and go swimming together. Never felt better .Saving a lot of dough.
Nothing is impossible.
Good luck ( next time you get sick , just stop ! )
The key is to really ,really want to quit.
Just thought I''d share.
Reply to this comment
by sociald63 July 28, 2008 4:30 AM EDT
"Is The Bush Admin. Blowing Smoke?"

since 1984 :(
Reply to this comment
See all 48 Comments

60 Minutes

The secrets of tennis legend Andre Agassi; the growing threat of cyber wars; and more.
Read More

  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. House Passes Landmark Health Care Bill

    (480 recent comments)

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: