After 60 Years, Black Officers Still Rare

Truman's 1948 Order Desegregated The U.S. Military, But Glass Ceiling Remains

(AP)  Sixty years after President Truman desegregated the military, senior black officers are still rare, particularly among the highest ranks.

Blacks make up about 17 percent of the total force, yet just 9 percent of all officers. That fraction falls to less than 6 percent for general officers with one to four stars, according to data obtained and analyzed by The Associated Press.

The rarity of blacks in the top ranks is apparent in one startling statistic: Only one of the 38 four-star generals or admirals serving as of May was black. And just 10 black men have ever gained four-star rank - five in the Army, four in the Air Force and one in the Navy, according to the Pentagon.

The dearth of blacks in high-ranking positions gives younger African-American soldiers few mentors of their own race. And as the overall percentage of blacks in the service falls, particularly in combat careers that lead to top posts, the situation seems unlikely to change.

Still, officials this week can point to some historic gains by blacks in the services as the Pentagon commemorates Truman's signing of an executive order on July 26, 1948, mandating the end of segregation in the military.

Best known among the four-stars is retired Gen. Colin Powell, who later became the country's first black secretary of state, under President Bush. Another is retired Gen. Johnnie E. Wilson, who in 1961, at age 17, spied an "Uncle Sam Wants You" poster and joined the Army.

The second of 12 children, Wilson grew up in a housing project outside Cleveland. Enlisting in the Army, he said, was the only way he'd get a college education.

As a young recruit, he found that the older, black noncommissioned officers were eager to guide him, and they urged him to try for Officer Candidate School. Over the next 38 years, he rose through the ranks to become a four-star general.

Why haven't more done the same?

For one thing, Wilson said, "it's hard to tell young people the sky's the limit when they look up and don't see anyone" who looks like them.

According to Pentagon data, as of May:

• 5.6 percent of the 923 general officers or admirals were black.
  
  
• Eight blacks were three-star lieutenant generals or vice admirals.
  
  
• Seventeen were two-star major generals or rear admirals.
  
  
• Twenty-six were one-star brigadier generals or rear admirals.
  
  
• Three of the black one-stars were women.

The Army has led the way with black officers, with nearly double the percentage at times over the past three decades as the other services. Blacks represented 11 percent to 12 percent of all Army officers during that time, compared with 4 percent to 8 percent in the Navy, Air Force and Marines.

The reasons for the lack of blacks in the higher ranks are many and complex, ranging from simple career choices to Congress and family recommendations. Most often mentioned is that black recruits are showing less interest in pursuing combat jobs, which are more likely to propel them through the officer ranks.

"Kids I've spoken to, who choose to do supply, who choose to do lawyer, who choose to do admin, have the impression that 'If I go to Army and become an infantry person, that is not a skill that I can carry to the civilian work force,"' said Clarence Johnson, director of the Pentagon's Office of Diversity Management.

Wilson - who specialized in logistics and did not take the combat route - said he does not believe ROTC programs or the military steer black recruits to the non-combat jobs - although that may have been a problem many years ago.

Instead, he said young black officers choose other fields because "they want to prepare for a future outside of the military, and they believe that being in communications, being in logistics will provide them a better opportunity to succeed."

In 1998, nearly a quarter of all active duty black officers were in various combat fields. As of this month, that had fallen to 20 percent, compared with nearly 40 percent for non-blacks, according to Pentagon data.

This year, roughly half of all black active duty officers gravitated toward supply, maintenance, engineering and administrative jobs - almost double the rate of non-black officers.

"That tells me, honestly, over the years the pipeline for those blacks going to general officer is not going to be markedly improved above what it is now," Johnson said.

He said he hears recruits say, "I'm joining this ROTC thing, so that when I get out in four years or eight years, whatever time frame it is, I want a skill I can use."

Army Lt. Gen. Lloyd J. Austin III, the No. 2 U.S. commander in Iraq, echoes those pipeline concerns.

"It's all about how many people you put in the front end of the pipe," Austin said in an interview from Baghdad. "It's very difficult for anybody to get to be a colonel or general in any branch of the service if you don't have enough young officers coming in."

Austin took the combat path to his three-star rank, starting as an infantryman and tactical officer. Later - as a general officer - he commanded troops in Iraq and Afghanistan.

The forces he sees now, he said, are far more diverse than when he graduated from the U.S. Military Academy at West Point in 1975. Then, he said, blacks made up only about 2.5 percent of the Army's officer corps.

"We treasure diversity because it brings in a lot of different viewpoints and blends in a lot of cultures," he said. "It makes us better."

To achieve that diversity, he said, the military must encourage more blacks to join, highlight the successes of those who have done well and "talk about the opportunities that are offered and how those opportunities can help them in their quest to be successful people."

Another stumbling block is getting more members of minority groups into the military academies.

While white cadets often come from families steeped in military history, black students may not have that long line of ancestral officers.

A review of congressional nominations to the military academies shows that black and Hispanic lawmakers often recommend fewer students.

The fewest appointments to the academies came from Rep. Nydia Velazquez, D-N.Y., who forwarded just three names for the classes of 2009-2012. Two other members of Congress - Massachusetts Democrat Michael Capuano and New York Democrat Jose Serrano- sent up five names.

According to Pentagon data, the number of lawmakers who failed to nominate at least one candidate to each academy increased from 24 in 2005 to 38 this year. Of the 75 lawmakers overall who did not nominate someone to each academy in all four years, 40 were either black or Hispanic.

Senior black officers say they work hard to mentor younger troops, and they can all recall the people who helped shape their careers. And not all of them were black.

Navy Rear Adm. Sinclair Harris vividly remembers his white commander on the frigate USS Jarrett - a tough, Pittsburgh Steelers fan from western Pennsylvania.

"Tough love," said Harris, who was a lieutenant at the time. "He insisted I take my command qualifications test, and when I didn't do good, he had me take it again."

Harris, deputy director for expeditionary warfare for the Navy chief, said networking and relationships are critical. But he cautions that mentoring is a two-way street that hinges on what the recruits do with the help they get.

"You can't get lazy in this man and this woman's Navy," he said. "You have to keep learning to stay ahead."

Nonetheless, blacks have come a long way since Truman, with the stroke of a pen, ordered the integration of the military. Before that, the Army had segregated black units and the Navy had minority members assigned to particular, lower-level jobs.

His mandate was aided by the Korean War, when a shortage of soldiers forced American commanders to begin integrating their units.

Defense officials say the Pentagon is now colorblind, offering the same opportunities, promotions and jobs to all races.

Compared with the corporate world, the military appears to provide a bit more high-level opportunities. As of late 2007, just five of the Fortune 500 companies were headed by black chief executives - or just 1 percent.

While the percentage of black recruits has grown during the past 60 years, it peaked at almost 26 percent in 1979. That year, they represented nearly four in 10 of all Army recruits and almost three in 10 for the Marines, both all-time highs for the services that see the most battlefield combat.

The Air Force and Navy, meanwhile, peaked in later years, with blacks accounting for roughly 20 percent of enlistees.

Since the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan began, the percentage of blacks coming into the Army has plunged from 22 percent to 13 percent. Also, the percentage of blacks in military overall has dipped in the past 10 years, from more than 20 percent to 17 percent today.

The decline has come in part because family members and other adults who influence young people have become less likely to recommend military service.

Still, Johnson points to positive indicators. Over the past decade, the percentage of black officers has grown slightly, including the share of black women at higher grades.

The military, Wilson said, has worked hard to create mentoring and outreach programs that identify and encourage minority officers. But, he said, the services have to do more marketing and recruiting.

"We as a military just have to find a way to tell our story," he said, adding, "If I had it to do all over again, I would still join the Army. It has paid off for thousands of us. If it had not been for the U.S. Army, I'm not sure what our station in life would be."

[petersoncc]

Major Tom said "IDIOTS just print whatever you want and call it fact. 12% of americans are black 17% of Military officers are black."

No, seems YOU are the idiot Major Tom. If you had read the article and not the blurb on Fark then you would see that what was actually stated is that 17% of the total force of military are Blacks. 9% of officers are Black.

For those who are not idiots this means.... Blacks make up a higher proportion of the military than the average in the United States (17% of all personnel but 12.9% of America reported themselves as Black)

And yes, a smaller percentage of officers are Black. 9% vs. the 17% of all personnel.

This is not from racism but because of personal CHOICE.

It would be interesting to know what percentage of NCO''s are Black (E7''s, E8''s and E9''s) I have a feeling there is a higher percentage number there, than the 12.9% of Americans who report they are Black.

Amazing people start to rant without reading the article closely or getting their facts right.

Voice of Reason at your service.

[petersoncc]

Major Tom said "IDIOTS just print whatever you want and call it fact. 12% of americans are black 17% of Military officers are black."

No, seems YOU are the idiot Major Tom. If you had read the article and not the blurb on Fark then you would see that what was actually stated is that 17% of the total force of military are Blacks. 9% of officers are Black.

For those who are not idiots this means.... Blacks make up a higher proportion of the military than the average in the United States (17% of all personnel but 12.9% of America reported themselves as Black)

And yes, a smaller percentage of officers are Black. 9% vs. the 17% of all personnel.

This is not from racism but because of personal CHOICE.

It would be interesting to know what percentage of NCO''s are Black (E7''s, E8''s and E9''s) I have a feeling there is a higher percentage number there, than the 12.9% of Americans who report they are Black.

Amazing people start to rant without reading the article closely or getting their facts right.

Voice of Reason at your service.

[majortom3030]

IDIOTS just print whatever you want and call it fact. 12% of americans are black 17% of Military officers are black. Hmm sounds like blacks do well. How many asian officers are there? American indian? Hispanic? Oh no those stories are no fun, just another case fear Mongering by CBS news.

USMCR

[deacon20081]

General Powell sat in front of the US House and Senate and LIED. He knew full well what the truth was and he LIED anyway.
Why do you think he resigned from that Lofty Position of Secretary of State? It was NOT to spend more time with his family, the usual spew from the White House when someone abandons their sinking ship.

[patriot12436]

I agree, Powell is under a dark cloud because of hiusassociation withbush. If he were running for president i would choose him over obama and mccain

[patriot12436]

libh8er
I was in from 66 rill90, was just going by what i experienced. I did notice a lot more racial tensin after i left.

[shippg-2009]

I read the whole article and found it very refreshing that it mentioned only personal choice, family background and lack-of-mentorship as reasons more blacks are not deciding to stay in the field and get promoted.

[msay3]

Well let me see Collin Powell was a general but of course he told us that Iraq had mobil weapons labs builing WMD''''s and that we should attack Iraq.

That proved to be wrong let me see you think this might help their cause.

Posted by antoniof123 at 04:01 PM : Jul 23, 2008
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Colin Powell is probably the most honorable and ethical person connected to the Bush administration...He relied upon the intelligence that was provided at the time (which proved to be erroneous). When he realized this, he made his position known, and as a result, created a rift among the white house staff....It wasn''t long before Gen. Powell was no longer smiled upon by Bushy and his cohorts, and so Colin Powell resigned....A tribute to a gentleman who place more value on sticking to his guns and being upstanding and honorable than remaining in an important political position in order further his goals....
So don''t blame Colin Powell for the WMD fiasco...Blame the CIA and the Bush Administration....If Colin Powell ran for president I would not only vote for him, but I would campaign to get everyone I know to vote for him as well.....

[hypnotoad72]

A shame.

But more will side with that dingaling rapper who says "snitching" is bad. :rollseyes: (That 60 Minutes article was an eye-opener.)

[msay3]

It''''s more than clear that if you''''re black you''''ll have a much more difficult time being accepted by your peers for leadership positions. Posted by closethippy1
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
And why is that? It isn''t clear to me.....

[qt68]

Clearly, the people who are not being promoted are done because of race and not based on the merit of their work.
-------------------------
Posted by closethippy1

Clearly the person amking this erroneous statement has never served in the military and cannot comprehend what is read.

[antoniof123]

Well let me see Collin Powell was a general but of course he told us that Iraq had mobil weapons labs builing WMD''s and that we should attack Iraq.

That proved to be wrong let me see you think this might help their cause.

[beader59]

I guess unless we see the statistics in black and white(excuse the terrible pun), we have to do a lot of research ourselves. You cannot take one media outlet''s article as gospel like you cannot take one person''s view as the only word either. Check into issues yourselves from several different sources and then make a intelligent and educated opinion. I think it it terrible that racism of anykind still exists, but it doesn''t exist everywhere all of the time. And remember there is such a thing as reverse racism.

[krenz4]

Read some of the racist statements on this post and you will know why backs and minorities are left behind when it comes to positions of power..... This country STINKS of predjudice and racial hatred. White people run the country, and from the tone of some people here, they would like to keep it that way. (Heh, I bet you all have a "black friend" too.. )

[iuphockey12]

We''''re talking about the highest ranks which are saturated with white men in the same way that the corporate world is saturated with white CEO''''s.
So something is going on here.
It''''s more than clear that if you''''re black you''''ll have a much more difficult time being accepted by your peers for leadership positions.
To not promote someone based on race and then argue that you''''re not bound by any kind of "racial quota" is bogus.
Clearly, the people who are not being promoted are done because of race and not based on the merit of their work.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by closethippy1

WE HAVE A BLACK MAN RUNNING FOR PRESIDENT!! WHAT PART OF THAT DONT YOU GET? PEOPLE WHO ARE QUALIFIED GET THE JOBS!

[closethippy1]

This is so very tiresome. Are we suppost to stock our military based on a racial quota system as opposed to leadership abilities/skills? Qualified candidates get commisions regardless of race. Unqualified candidates, regardless of race, do not.
Posted by sincityq at 03:09 PM : Jul 23, 2008

We''re talking about the highest ranks which are saturated with white men in the same way that the corporate world is saturated with white CEO''s.
So something is going on here.
It''s more than clear that if you''re black you''ll have a much more difficult time being accepted by your peers for leadership positions.
To not promote someone based on race and then argue that you''re not bound by any kind of "racial quota" is bogus.
Clearly, the people who are not being promoted are done because of race and not based on the merit of their work.

[rudy2281]

There is probably a long list of answers to the question ''why''. I did a study a few years ago on why more black applicants did not apply as candidates for police officer. Among young black males applying for a first job the primary reason was they did not like or trust the department. However, as a second career, blacks applied in greater numbers. As a result, the majority of blacks applying were in their late 20''s and into their 30''s.

Another answer is society sure is slow to recognize their achievements. How long did it take before the public learned about the Tuskegee airmen, or the Native American code talkers, or the Japanese Americans who saved a few white necks in WWII during the Italian campaign.

Still another might be they don''t trust how a white administration and congress is going to use the military for. Certainly, the sharp drop in black enlistments at present has a lot to do with Bush''s war, that is, an aversion to unilateralism.

As for competence which someone crudely referenced, the minorities are as competent, tough, loyal and hard working as any white.

[jim-n-tex]

during my 20 yrs in the army signal corp I served under a number of black officers. The best one was LTG Emmett Paige. At the time of his retirement he was the highest ranking signal officer in the army. He then went on to become an asst secretary of defence for communications. If he had wanted to take the combat arms career path in the army he would have been a four star general and probally the army chief of staff

When is the last time you heard or saw a Japanese General in the US Military?

What about Eric Shinseki? Army Chief of Staff 1999-2003.

[vastr-wcon]

.
As in many areas, COMPETENCE (NOT QUOTAS) MATTERS.

/