WASHINGTON, July 1, 2008

U.S. Not Faulted For Detainee Deaths

Internal Review Finds Feds Not Negligent In Two Deaths Of Immigrant Detainees In 2006

  •  (AP)

  • Video Archive Hot Topic: Immigration

    Video Coverage: CBS News examines the heated debate over immigration in the United States.

(AP)  The federal government was not negligent in two 2006 immigration detainee deaths, but officials can do a better job overseeing detainees' medical treatment, an internal review concluded.

The Homeland Security Department's internal watchdog investigated two specific detainee deaths to see if the government did everything it was supposed to do. The report was issued Tuesday amid ongoing accusations that the agency with oversight of immigrant detainees - Immigration and Customs Enforcement - has provided insufficient and in some cases negligent medical treatment for immigrant detainees over the past five years. This issue has been raised for years by human rights groups such as the American Civil Liberties Union.

Investigators with the Homeland Security inspector general looked at two deaths and described these circumstances:

In April 2006, a detainee was being held in a county detention center in St. Paul, Minn., and died of a brain infection caused by a pork tapeworm, known as neurocysticercosis - which affects many Latin American immigrants. While in detention, the detainee had reported a series of headaches, which were treated with aspirin, per the detention center's policy. The case review showed that the detainee's head injury 10 days before the death called for expedited transportation to a hospital, which the detainee did not receive; in addition, the detainee did not receive a physical exam within 14 days of arriving at the detention center, which is an ICE requirement.

Neither of these oversights, however, contributed to the detainee's death, according to the investigation. However, records showed that four years earlier the mother of the detainee had surgery to treat "eggs of bugs inside her head," as explained by the detainee. Investigators say this could have been a clue for caretakers to ask more questions because if one family member has this condition, other family members should also receive treatment. Asking the detainee medical screening questions could help identify potentially life-threatening conditions, the report said.

In September 2006, a detainee at an Albuquerque correction center run by a private company died from pancreatic cancer that spread to other parts of the body. Hospital records showed that the detainee's cancer was at an advanced stage when the detainee arrived at the detention center, but medical examinations at the center did not mention the condition. After complaining about stomach pain, the detainee received antacid tablets. Investigators were told that sick calls were not responded to quickly at the detention center, and detainees with chronic conditions did not all receive regular care.

ICE needs to improve oversight at detention facilities to improve detainee care, the report found. And in the future, ICE should make sure all detainee deaths are reported to the state governments and appropriate federal agencies.

"ICE is pleased that the outside report corroborates our position that the deaths investigated were not at the fault of ICE nor could they have been prevented," ICE spokesman Brandon Montgomery said Tuesday. The head of ICE has already directed detention centers to immediately report detainee deaths to the appropriate state and federal agencies.

But the ACLU does not think the inspector general investigation is enough, because it did not investigate 31 of 33 reported deaths between Jan. 1, 2005 and May 31, 2007. Gouri Bhat, the ACLU's national prison project's counsel, said ICE has not provided information on most of these deaths. The ACLU recently filed a federal lawsuit to require the government to turn over information about deaths during ICE custody.

ICE spends $100 million a year on detainee health care which is twice as much as it spent a few years ago. Since ICE was formed in 2003, 71 people out of 1.5 million have died in its custody.

"Every death in custody - any death in custody - is a regrettable, sad occurrence," ICE spokeswoman Kelly Nantel said in May. "It is not an indication of a broken system."

In April, the federal government acknowledged it was negligent in the death of an immigrant whose cancer went undiagnosed for nearly a year while he was in custody.



© MMVIII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
by vortex1001 July 2, 2008 5:29 PM EDT
Well surprise surprise - the US finds itself not guilty


Latest news from Afghanistan.......OBL announces that an internal inquiry has found that Al-Qaeda was not at fault for the 9/11 incidents - the report concluded that the 19 passengers did all they could to avoid crashing those planes into the WTC and Pentagon
Reply to this comment
by kaviz July 2, 2008 2:44 PM EDT
I''m kind of interested in hearing more about the detainees mother and the bug eggs that were in her head.
Reply to this comment
by liberalme July 2, 2008 1:18 PM EDT
FASCIST NAZI TERRORISLAM IS THE PROBLEM,,,

DEMONIC-RAT HUSSEIN IS NOT THE SOLUTION,,,
Posted by terrorislamo at 07:20 AM : Jul 02, 2008

Neither is McCain you chicken little--skeered of a black man becoming president--just think--perhaps they''ll take over the country and make slaves of us whities!! Horrors!!!!
Is that what your skeered of or do you just hate anything your not familiar with and too afraid to find out about?
Reply to this comment
by ianlou July 2, 2008 11:06 AM EDT
Internal Review Finds Feds Not Negligent In Two Deaths Of Immigrant Detainees In 2006

I am happy to announce that I have done an Internal Review of my shorts and have found myself Not Negligent in keeping them clean.

No external investigation will be necessary.
Reply to this comment
by floydzepp2 July 2, 2008 10:48 AM EDT
Posted by terrorislamo at 07:21 AM : Jul 02, 2008
----------
terror whamo = spammer
Reply to this comment
by terrorislamo July 2, 2008 10:21 AM EDT
REAL AMERICAN STORIES

http://www.realamericanstories.com/
Reply to this comment
by terrorislamo July 2, 2008 10:20 AM EDT
FASCIST NAZI TERRORISLAM IS THE PROBLEM,,,

DEMONIC-RAT HUSSEIN IS NOT THE SOLUTION,,,
Reply to this comment
by terrorislamo July 2, 2008 10:19 AM EDT
HUSSEIN BELONGED TO A CHURCH THAT DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITE US,,,

HUSSEIN STAFFS HIS CAMPAIGN WITM MEMBERS OF THE NEW BLACK PANTHER PARTY THAT DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,

HUSSEIN STAFFS HIS CAMPAIGN WITM MEMBERS OF THE NATION OF TERRORISLAM THAT DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,

HUSSEIN IS A RACIST WHICH DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,

HUSSEIN IS A BIGOT WHICH DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,

HUSSEIN IS A ANTI-JEW WHICH DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,

HUSSEIN IS A ANTI-AMERICAN WHICH DIVIDES US RATHER THAN UNITES US,,,
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso12 July 2, 2008 10:13 AM EDT
Time to erase: Send us your poor, your sick, your decrepit and your stupid--from the Statue of liberty''s litany, before the poor, the sick the decrepit and stupid overwhelm us with their medical expenses. For his and every other illegal''s health concerns, they should get expedited shipment back to Mexico with a monitoring anklet that shocks the ****** out of them if they come within 500 feet of the US border and electrocutes them to death if they try to remove the anklet.
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso12 July 2, 2008 10:09 AM EDT
"Neither of these oversights, however, contributed to the detainee''s death, according to the investigation. However, records showed that four years earlier the mother of the detainee had surgery to treat "eggs of bugs inside her head," as explained by the detainee. Investigators say this could have been a clue for caretakers to ask more questions because if one family member has this condition, other family members should also receive treatment. Asking the detainee medical screening questions could help identify potentially life-threatening conditions, the report said."

Fact: Illegal immigrants pose a severe health hazard to the US due to sneaking in with a large amount of diseases that we do not have or have under control. One of them is leprosy, several staph, flesh eating bacteria, TB, and numerous parasitical infections. Had this man stayed in Mexico, he would simply have died there, had he gone to the hospital here, he would have been given tylenol or perhaps a migraine medication--never in a million years would Americans suspect worms in his brain as that is a bit of nastiness that we do not normally encounter. Given the course of the disease and the fact that most hospitals treat for common ailments in the face of most acute illness; the man would have just died just the same, but perhaps on cleaner sheets and at a higher cost to taxpayers, who should never have to have been bothered with his illegal azz in the first place.
Reply to this comment

60 Minutes

Restoring the marshlands of Iraq; finding IEDs in Afghanistan; Resurrecting Dinosaurs; and more.
Read More

  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Sarah Palin's Book: The Fact Check

    (411 recent comments)

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: