Don't Fear The Vista From Your Windows

Larry Magid Reviews Window's New Operating System As XP Goes The Way Of The Dodo

(CBS)  Today, June 30, Microsoft stops selling Windows XP at retail and major PC vendors, and will stop offering it as an option for consumers who buy new PCs.

By coincidence, this change came three days after Microsoft founder Bill gates retired from his job as Chief Software Architect, but neither Gates nor XP are completely removed from the scene.

Gates will stay on as Microsoft Chairman and - even though it will no longer be sold at retail - large companies can still get Windows XP, and Microsoft will continue to offer XP tech support through April 2014. Vendors of some low power laptops, such as the Asus Eee PC will be able to continue to offer XP for the next two years.

By dropping XP from mainstream PCs, Microsoft is pretty much forcing most consumers who need a new PC to migrate to Windows Vista, and there are some people who simply don't want to make the switch.

Standing in the computer aisle at an electronics store this weekend, I overheard a woman asking the salesperson if she could buy a PC with XP. He said no. I then asked the woman why she wanted XP rather than Vista and she expressed two concerns. The first was that she was already acquainted with XP and didn't want to learn a new operating system. The second was her worry that some of her software or devices wouldn't work with Vista.

Another common concern is that Vista takes up too much computing power and might not work as well or as fast as XP.

Personally, I'm not particularly concerned about any of these issues, and I recommend most people just go with Vista. I've been using it since before it came out and I'm pretty happy with it.

As for the would-be XP-buyer's first concern; I feel her pain. Learning anything new can always be challenging and once someone has gone through the trouble of learning an operating system, I can understand a reluctance to make a change. But, I have good news for XP users thinking about Vista - the user interface is not all that different.

The main difference is a slight re-organization to the Start menu, which actually makes it easier to find the programs you want to run. Just as before, you can find all your software by clicking on "All Programs," but instead of cascading menus you now have a full list of all your programs.

The best change to the user interface is that you no longer have to hunt around to find a program. You can just type its name in the search box and Windows will find it and launch it for you. Search also allows you to find documents by typing in any word likely to be in the document. The same is true for email messages and words in other documents. And because Vista now "indexes" the contents of your drive, search is virtually instantaneous.

---

Podcast: To weigh the ups and downs of Vista, CBS News technology analyst Larry Magid spoke with Ed Bott, a Windows author, blogger and technical expert.

---

There are other visual changes, such as the aero interface that makes Windows translucent and more attractive, but it doesn't really affect the way you use the computer.

There are plenty of books out there (including Microsoft Windows Vista: Peachpit Learning Series, which I co-wrote with Dwight Silverman), but the main advantage to the books is that they help you discover new features. Most people won't need a book just to transition from XP to Vista.

The second concern, about compatibility, was a real issue when Vista first came out. But today there are very few programs and devices that won't work with the new operating system. If you have any doubts, check the websites or technical support phone lines of your software vendors, but unless you have some pretty obscure programs, chances are they will work. Anyone who uses software or a virtual private network from their employer or other organization should definitely check with your IT department before migrating.

Finally, there is the issue of performance. It is true that Vista requires a bit more horsepower than Windows XP, which is one of the reasons I urge caution before upgrading an old PC to Vista, but if you're getting it on a new machine, then the PC maker has already determined that it will work. Fact is, just about any new hardware - at almost any price - is powerful enough to run Vista.

For the home premium edition, Microsoft recommends at least a 1 GHz processor, a gigabyte of memory and at least a 40 gigabyte or larger hard drive. You also need at least 128 MB of graphics memory with hardware that includes "pixel shader 2.0." So, if you want to be sure, make sure your hardware has these requirements. Some of the least expensive systems may come with Windows Home Basic, which has lower requirements, but I still recommend at least a gigabyte of memory - two is better.

There are plenty of things to like about Vista, including that great search feature, much better security and a new and improved photo management program called Windows Photo Gallery. There is also integrated speech recognition software.

There is one company based in Cupertino, California that loves to make fun of Vista. Apple, of course, doesn't want you to abandon XP for Vista, but in favor of its own Macintosh system. The commercials (http://www.apple.com/getamac/ads/) are hilarious and - based on Apple's growing market share - apparently somewhat successful, but don't take them too literally.

Yes, Vista users have had their share of problems, but so have some people who use Macintosh's new Leopard operating system (try Googling "problems with Leopard").

In the meantime, Microsoft is working on the next version of Windows, which should be out by the end of next year or early 2010. If you really want to skip Vista, you could try keeping your old XP machine running until then and be on the "bleeding edge" of that new operating system.

Or, you can go with the flow and upgrade. Trust me, it's not that hard and the benefits of Vista, in my opinion, outweigh the hassles.

[barbaram99]

I do have to say they sure changed things around. Vince is using Word-07 and me Word-02. So hw asked me how do I do this/that. I said I don''t know but let''s look in there and see if yer work was saved ''fore ye hit the red x. He is using Vists and me XP and yes he got me a Vista pc 64 bit. His is 32 bit. Any way I got my Vista library together thanks to that help. He is happy with Vista and me I am slowly falling in love with it. We don''t mess with each other''s computer. I will teach him what I know and together figger it out. He does the hands on. So it is exciting for a first timer. Everyone told him to go with a pc that is under $300.00. He out grow it in no time. I asked what do ye want to do. Vince told me, and so we went shoppping for his. He wanted an off the shelf and I did not. I told him what to look for. He was scared and felt he would not get the hang of it. He will. I ''member him fussing, the computer don''t belong in the home . that was in the early 2000s. It is a home tool dear. We beat that. Vista is pretty smart.

[barbaram99]

What is the fuss. Can ye afford all the changes..I can''t.

[ridos-2009]

I think it says a lot when a company like Intel decides against switching over to Vista.

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/06/25/et-tu-intel/index.html?ref=technology

[cheetah-man7]

I''m no PC guru, but I am pretty happy with my new laptop and Vista. I find some things remarkably easier to handle with Vista and really can not see what all the fuss is about.

[barbaram99]

MS what next. They always want to change things. Now Vista what next? A TOUCH system no thank ye. I HATE IT. As a legally blind user I can''t use the touch on sceens. So now they say run Vista..Vince likes Vista. It is pretty from what I have seen on his.

[barbaram99]

I am a as my friend calls me a die hard home XP user, That said..He has a Vista 32 bit system. He loves it. He bought me a 64 bit Vista system. I told him I don''t want store bought one. It is costomised. That said. Now can I run my XP games on a Vista pc. The tech told him no. I want to know as can I put XP programs. I don''t to mess things up.

[undermyboot]

Here''s the plan: Once everyone has Vista, computers will work so erratically that no one will be able to write bad things about Microsoft. Those with a few minutes of actual functioning time will not be able to get past the "anti-microsoft filters" installed in Vista. Larry Micsoroft Maggot will still have his custom modified MS operating system that works for his laughably paid-for articles. Everyone important (no one except Microsoft) wins.

[smurfcrusher]

Vista? Bad? Come on, don''t kid us. What''s a little er... well... may be more than a little instability to computer professionals?

And who needs drivers, anyway? You probably needed an excuse to buy lots of new peripherals... now you have one! After all, you can''t use the hardware if the software doesn''t support it...

[smurfcrusher]

"Microsoft will continue to offer XP tech support through April 2014. "

Excellent!! I was wondering what date I should convert to 100% LINUX. Now I know! Thanks, Microsoft!

[cdfoxtrot]

I have avoided buying a new PC since Vista emerged. I did make the mistake of upgrading to the latest version of Office, and it''s the buggiest and least stable version of Office I have ever used, in the 14+ years I''ve been using Office. Microsoft puts out absolute cr_a_p and gets away with it. I''m very likely to try using an Apple next time, for the first time ever. Why is no-one challenging Microsoft''s domination of the operating system?? It''s the key to everything.

[jsutaguy]

...additionally, the latest SP3 upgrade to Vista is also an incredibly bad piece of software...there are thousands of Beta testers who have had to COMPLETELY RESTORE THEIR PC''s FROM SCRATCH after installing the current Service Pack for XP. If you have not already done so, you need to disable automatic updates from Microsoft. I am not kidding. Google "SP3" and "Blue Screen"...you''ll find thousands of people whose machines were completely broken by this installation. In fact, the problems are so widespread, Microsoft has offered free realtime support for anyone whose PC is broken by the new SP3 installation....but don''t be fooled. It is just bad. Don''t install it.

Microsoft is a company headed towards the brink...don''t pay thousands for a PC that is going to fail...find another company''s OS to use.

[jsutaguy]

This article is a lie. Vista is utter cr*p. So far, there are 101 comments pointing out what an abomination Vista is.
I cannot BELIEVE the idiot who wrote this article wasn''t paid off by somebody. It is extremely common knowledge among all professional computer people that Vista is the worst operating system release in the history of operating system releases.

[jsutaguy]

This article is a lie. Vista is utter cr*p. So far, there are 101 comments pointing out what an abomination Vista is.
I cannot BELIEVE the idiot who wrote this article wasn''t paid off by somebody. It is extremely common knowledge among all professional computer people that Vista is the worst operating system release in the history of operating system releases.

[jsutaguy]

This article is a lie. Vista is utter cr*p. So far, there are 101 comments pointing out what an abomination Vista is.
I cannot BELIEVE the idiot who wrote this article wasn''t paid off by somebody. It is extremely common knowledge among all professional computer people that Vista is the worst operating system release in the history of operating system releases.

[jsutaguy]

This article is a lie. Vista is utter cr*p. So far, there are 101 comments pointing out what an abomination Vista is.
I cannot BELIEVE the idiot who wrote this article wasn''t paid off by somebody. It is extremely common knowledge among all professional computer people that Vista is the worst operating system release in the history of operating system releases.

[republic1776]

Vista is a bloated Pig.
I can''t stand it and have not come across another IT person that likes it.

[random_radar]

I have Vista on my Sony laptop. It is horrifying and I would install Windows XP if I could. Vista locks up all the time, drops my WiFi connection every two minutes, and is totally screwed up.

Eventually we will be forced to use Vista, but you should avoid using it as long as possible. It won''t work with your current hardware, so plan on buying much better machines if you end up with Vista. It has been my worst Microsoft experience ever--and I was a beta tester for Windows 1.0.

[undermyboot]

I run both PCs and Macs (a total of 11 computers) in my business. Larry Maggot evidently just makes this garbage up- paid for by Microsoft.

We installed Vista on one machine. what a disaster. XP was bad enough. Vista is the biggest marketing lie ever perpetrated. It is slower, more restrictive, less compatible, harder to use, more bloated, and 10 times less stable than every Mac we run. It is TWICE as bad as the most overloaded XP machines we run.

*** is Maggot smoking? Or is he just in the pocket of MS? There is no other explanation. I guess this maggot just has no more shame.

[undermyboot]

This MAGGOT is just a SHILL for MICROSOFT. DO NOT BELIEVE HIS CR*P.

Amazing- Maggot doesn''t mention that Microsoft exerts complete control of your computer (including shutting down your computer) with Vista.

Maggot does not mention that Microsoft made Vista so restrictive that you cannot even watch media you own because Microsoft has made a deal with the big media companies to restrict your use of VIDEO AND MUSIC YOU ALREADY PAID FOR.

Maggot does not tell you that Vista is a constant irritant with pop-ups and uselsess alerts.

Maggot does not tell you that Vista reports back to Microsoft on what you do, where you go on the internet.

Maggot lies when he says MacOS is just as bad

[undermyboot]

Wow. Magid really is paid off by Microsoft. I guess payola goes a long way.

It probably helps that he''s a 100% big-corporate paid writer. Would not want to upset the big companies that put his salary in his pocket.

Completely disgusting.