By

CBSNews /

CBS/ AP/ February 11, 2009, 2:48 PM

Girl Dies After Cancun Senior Class Trip

A Texas high school girl died Tuesday after being flown home in a coma after nearly drowning when a snorkeling tour boat began sinking near Cancun, Mexico, this weekend.

The Dallas County Medical Examiner's Office confirmed the death of Lisa Thang Chung, 18. She had been flown to Dallas on an air ambulance along with her parents, said Luis Raymundo Canche, assistant prosecutor for the Mexican state of Quintana Roo.

Chung suffered heart and lung failure after nearly drowning Saturday when the catamaran she was aboard sank between Cancun and Isla de Mujeres.

"She was so very, very happy, and that's why I gave her a trip to Cancun," Lisa's mother Oanh Chung told CBS News affiliate KTVT. "When she came back, she was ready to go to Baylor, and then she said that's her future."

KTVT reports that Chung was in the water and wearing a life jacket when she was struck by a rescue boat.

Several other teens who were on the snorkeling expedition told CBS News Early Show anchor Julie Chen that they had had close calls with other boats after they abandoned ship.

Jackie Filippi told Chen that she and others had to jump off of the life raft they had taken refuge on after a larger vessel almost collided with them.

"It was a bigger boat coming in trying to tow the boat that was sinking," she said. "We were just floating and they came very close to us and we yelled at them, but they didn't move, so we jumped off our lifeboat and swam to just random boaters."

Saya Arakawa had a similar experience after jumping into the water and swimming to a lift raft to await help.

"But then the boat that was towing our boat that sank, it started getting closer to us," she said. "We were like trying to tell them to move, but they just kind of stared at us. I don't know if they understood us or not. So we had to evacuate from our life raft and just started swimming."

Authorities said they were investigating whether the "Sea Star" catamaran was overloaded.

A preliminary report by the port captain said the boat appeared to be carrying 126 people when it is authorized to carry 80. But Sea Star Captain Agustin Cituk said the boat has the capacity to carry 250 people.

GradCity spokesman Jason Chute said the snorkeling excursion was part of a package trip organized by the U.S. tourist agency. GradCity has sent 32 chaperones and nearly 500 high school students to Cancun this summer, Chute said.

Chute also said the vessel was designed to carry 250, and described it as a 73-foot catamaran built less than six months ago. "It was nowhere near capacity," he said.

"We're trying to find out what caused the boat to go under and the series of events following the boat partially sinking," he told The Associated Press on Monday. "We've worked with them before. As I understand, his boat was new, less than six months old, at least that's what we've been told."
CBS/ AP
39 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
nottellin1 says:
Someone must be at fault .. there is no such thing as an accident when you have to assign fault in order to file a lawsuit.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by cyberus at 06:18 PM : Jun 12, 2008

The law suit will be against the American tour agency, GraCity because the legal system in Mex doesn''t support negligence awards like we do in the US. Rereading the story I note that GradCity boasts that they sent 32 chaperones with nearly 500 students. Thats like 1 chap for 15 students, not avery comforting ratio!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mljohns00 says:
Who needs to go to Cancun for watersports, when there''s plenty of water in Cedar Rapids, Iowa?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
guest173 says:
kansas1946 says it well. I''ve been to Korea, Japan, Mexico and many places in the US. the US is a great place to sight see and the safety standards are much higher than many other countries. that is why I say texas schools shouldn''t be going go less secured countries. (Japan has high safety standards, but Korea and Mexico and Okinawa didn''t the last time I went, if you die, they don''t change much either, you''re just dead)
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
guest173 says:
Texas schools should not offer trips to Mexico, but they do all the time. Mexico is not safe enough for students to go with their limited chaperone power and tourist mindset. it is too bad this young person died
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
garrett2216 says:
incog-nito: we were supposed to be going to see the "exotic" places you keep talking about; we had a snorkel trip and a jungle tour that included the mayan ruins and whatnot. but after this boat sank everyone kinda lost interest in putting ourselves under their supervision for the jungle tour. in fact some people left early.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Latrocinor says:
My sincere condolences to Ms. Chung''s family, friends and others who sorrow at this sad news.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
puzzler125 says:
Just lovely. Reread your comments about "Mexicans" and the names you call each other here. Have you forgotten the subject of the article is a serious accident?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cbsblogger says:
This blog has more info that CBS.


http://www.cancuncanuck.com/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tcart2 says:
Andrew_693 at least if you are going to take the time to make a comment, use your brain to do it with! Comments such as that are so intelligent!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kaffirboetie says:
I''m reluctant to take issue with sgbwarrior who clearly liked the young woman who was run down by a careless boat driver, but the sad reality is that it wasn''t God who said her time was up, but some idiot mexican who didn''t have the sense the motor carefully in an area where over 100 people had gone into the water. I sincerely hope that the Mexican authorities throw the book at that individual
reply
See all 39 Comments