The Answer To Failed Urban Schools?
Washington's School Chancellor Hopes Her Tough Methods Will Yield Major Results
-
Play CBS Video
Video
D.C. Schools Face Overhaul
Public schools in Washington D.C. were in desperate need of change. So, when Michelle Rhee was appointed chancellor, she did just that and fired many of the city's employees. Wyatt Andrews reports.
-
Photo
Washington D.C. public schools chancellor Michelle Rhee. (CBS)
-
Interactive
Education In America
Backpack ready? Learn more about education in America through fun facts, national statistics and unusual schools.
"Let me see who's working nicely," Rhee says
Rhee is not doing it nicely, reports CBS News correspondent Wyatt Andrews.
Just one year into office, Rhee has closed 23 schools, fired 34 principals, offered buyouts to 700 teachers, while pressuring hundreds more to leave-and fired 98 employees at the central school office.
"Drastic change is needed because the situation is incredibly dire," Rhee says.
School reform on this scale was the brainchild of D.C.'s Mayor Adrian Fenty.
"We saw a system where mismanagement reigned," Fenty says.
Fenty's 2006 election mandate to improve the schools was so strong, he got rid of the elected school board and then found Rhee, who for a decade had been running a nonprofit group successfully recruiting thousands of new teachers for urban schools nationwide.
He hired Rhee with orders to take no prisoners.
"Chancellor Rhee and I are saying the days of talk are over … We've gotta move fast," Fenty says.
Chancellor Rhee is convinced that every child-even the most disadvantaged-can learn and achieve if taught by a motivated teacher in a school led by a driven principal.
For example, when Andrews visited DC's Coolidge High School, he found a geometry class on task and well behaved but also a current events class where students were literally screaming out of control.
Rhee argues the difference is the teacher.
"So it's not about this group of kids just happens to want to learn and this group of kids doesn't," she says. "It's about what are we inspiring? What are we doing in the classroom?"
Rhee's angriest critics say all she's produced so far is chaos, and worse, that she fired all those principals without notice or probation.
"When you fire the principals and you don't give reasons why, that's not right," parent Cherita Whiting says.
Lots of other parents though support Rhee's policy of no excuses.
"Whatever is necessary," says Jackie Clopton. "If you're not doing what's best for the kids, then you need to be removed."
"Nobody hired me into this position and said, 'Make the adults feel good, Michelle,' Rhee says. "When the mayor hired me into this job, he said, 'Improve the schools.'"
So she now faces the test of a lifetime. A woman who has never run a school system is testing her theory that better teaching is the answer to failed urban schools.
©MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News
- Latest in CBS Evening News
- Visas for Foreign Retirees Could Be a Boon
- Senators Criticize Cheney Cover-Up
- Swine Flu Threat Not Gone, U.S. Warns



People point at the teachers who endure low pay, lower societal status, and children who are not disciplined by their parents. Why would anyone ever endure what these DC employees are enduring en masse? Shame on these politicians!
It stinks as much as No Child Left Behind!
Eric
Stop robbing urban America to pay rural America.
Rural american communities typically get THREE TIMES as much Federal aid per capita as urban communities. We routinely (and for many decades) rob places like Wash DC to pay rural Wyoming. The result: excellent schools in Wyoming, while DC sucks.
check out:
http://www.taxfoundation.org/research/show/266.html
and you''ll know I''m not lying.
(The father of public education in America)
He declared government was responsible to:
"Discipline our youth in early life in sound maxims of moral, political, and religious duties."
"Education is useless without the Bible."
"The Bible was America''s basic text book in all fields."
"God''s Word, contained in the Bible, has fumished all necessary rules to direct our conduct."
"In my view, the Christian religion is the most important and one of the first things in which all children, under a free government ought to be instructed....No truth is more evident to my mind than that the Christian religion must be the basis of any government intended to secure the rights and privileges of a free people."
"There is no nation on earth powerful enough to accomplish our overthrow. Our destruction, should it come at all, will be from another quarter. From the inattention of the people to the concerns of their government, from their carelessness and negligence. I must confess that I do apprehend some danger. I fear that they may place too implicit a confidence in their public servants and fail properly to scrutinize their conduct; that in this way they may be made the dupes of designing men and become the instruments of their own undoing."
"Hold on, my friends, to the Constitution and to the Republic for which it stands. Miracles do not cluster, and what has happened once in 6000 years, may not happen again. Hold on to the Constitution, for if the American Constitution should fail, there will be anarchy throughout the world."
"If we abide by the principles taught in the Bible, our country will go on prospering and to prosper; but if we and our posterity neglect its instruction and authority, no man can tell how sudden a catastrophe may ovenvhelm us and bury all our glory in profound obscurity."
"Finally, let us not forget the religious character of our origin. Our fathers were brought hither by their high veneration for the Christian religion. They journeyed by its light, and labored in its hope. They sought to incorporate its principles with the elements of their society, and to diffuse its influence through all their institutions, civil, political, or literary.
The problem with urban schools, first, was been the misguilded and wasteful pursuit of intergration as opposed to fixing the schools themselves. To force black children to sit next to people who didn''t want them near their children has been for naught. Four generations of children lost and still segragated. What urban school should do is segregate them further; placing motivated students on one campus and the non-motivated elsewhere. We sent themm across town or out of town because of race, doing it because of achievement is moral and constitutional.
Base placement of students on merit and individual achievement and expectations of black student must be elevated. The environment in these schools do not allow for those willing to learn to do so. These schools allow one or two students to disrupt the entire class because they have more right than those in control and ready to learn.
Our schools are definitely in need of drastic measures. This "No Child Leftr Behind" *** is at the root of all of our educational problems today. Kids are learning how to take tests, not how to evaluate situations and data and apply principles.
Posted by catlady1412 at 12:13 AM : Jun 12, 2008----Mine did also. I hated it at the time, but am thankful they did it. It''s much better then than prison latter. My wife and I told our kids they might be craftier than us, but the Sheriff Department takes over for us as your new disciplinarians for the rest of your life when of age to be on your own,.....And they can and will throw you in jail for disobedience. They''re not suckers either. Your parents did teach you a biblical principal whether they realized it or not. Proverbs 22:6 - Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it.
I''m no fan of Bush, but the crux of the matter is accountablity, even if it isn''t funded, the principle is basic and necessary. Another aspect of LNCB is perantal choice. Those who care enough should be free to choose, no matter the consequince to teacher''s union, community leaders and poor performing students. Parent who care and want help should be given the right to pass that on to their children for whom they are responsible.
Just one year into office, Rhee has closed 23 schools, fired 34 principals, offered buyouts to 700 teachers, while pressuring hundreds more to leave-and fired 98 employees at the central school office.
"Drastic change is needed because the situation is incredibly dire,"
CBS News
Dire is an understatement. I remember listening to an NPR report about a valedictorian from a D.C. High School and based on his placing at the top of his school, received entry into MIT, where during the summer before attending, he and other urban school children (that''s the nice way of say BLACK BOYS) went to the campus for remediation and they were crushed to find how much they just didn''t know. The young man dropped himself from the program, his confidence shattered. It was so heart breaking to see how this process of helping them only ended up hurting them. It''s time to be honest with these children and treat them just like anyone else. No Affirmative-Action or pitty curriculums to make them feel good. How pernicious the half-hearted attempts to bring these children into the fold by violating the very principle of higher education. MERIT. And that requires a real attempt to teach them during their early years. These aren''t basketball players granted a pass on learning to get to the hardwood. These student have brains that need to be filled.
THE KEY IS NOT BEING AFRAID TO IMPLEMENT DISCIPLINE, SO THE CLASSROOM CAN BE SAFE FOR BOTH STUDENTS AND TEACHERS.
If this was happening to white students on Long Island, the ACLU would give legal assistance to the School District or System because their children, the future "reds" of America needs to learn how to read the U.S. Constitution so that they, too, can learn how to decontruct it and continue to use it to disadvantage black children for another 40 years.
Why don''t you put the blame where it belongs? On the parents! What do you do with kids that refuse to participate and refuse to do homework or anything else? And then when you call the parents, they respond with: "You better not be harrassing my little angel!" I get sick and tired of people like you blaming the teachers who get so little pay, while being required to be highly qualified as per the NCLBA, only to be slapped back by the likes of you. No wonder its hard to find new teachers anymore.
Name a city with a black majority population that has a good school system with a high graduation rate & low truancy.
Of course it comes down to the parents! Kids need discipline & order. Don''t try to be your kid''s best friend. If your parents care about where you go & how late you stay out then you don''t need a curfew in a city. Stay involved & participate in your kid''s education. Go to the PTA meetings.
If you can''t handle the responsibility & hard work of raising kids, don''t have them. Discover a little something called BIRTH CONTROL, people. You know, CONDOMS. This is the 21st century. We''re not living in the Amazon jungle.
Baby mamas have kids who usually end up as thugs & criminals. Not always but a lot. A teenage girl is not mature enough. It''s not normal. They can''t handle being a parent.
How many of the men behind bars would say that they had at least one parent who really loved them, cared about them & put them first? Maybe 5%? Very few.
They drop out of high school. Get girls pregnant. "Look at me! I''m a major pimp/playa!" A lot of them end up dealing drugs or in gangs. Young black men shooting & killing other young black men every day. You know it. I know it. We all know it.
It''s a lot easier to motivate the black girls than the black boys when it comes to high school/university. The black boys just don''t care unless it involves a ball. Sports rule. They worship pro athletes. Sitting in a library studying? Getting all A''s? Wha----? That''s acting white. They don''t want to be a "nerd." All about being COOL 24-7. Picking up the ladies. The only thing they want to read is the sports page & the label on a bottle of Colt 45.
When was the last time a black boy (not one born in Africa) was voted valedictorian of any high school in the USA? They do not care.
Black women are graduating from university left & right. They don''t want to marry a high school dropout or someone with no plans to ever go to university. 70% of black women are single.
March 23, 1775
"The Bible is worth all other books which have ever been printed."
"Bad men cannot make good citizens. A vitiated state of morals, a corrupted public conscience are incompatible with freedom."
"It is when people forget God that tyrants forge their chains."
Posted by Keithle1 at 06:13 AM :
Your comment borders on being the most ignorant I''ve ever read. Have you checked every high school in America? You, that other fool myopinion1 and people like you are way worse for America than ALL the people you disparage.
That is just the tip of the iceberg. Racism still exists and it still holds blacks down in MANY more ways that you will EVER admit. Racism is not the only reason for the problem but it contributes greatly to it. Until you take an honest look at the problem, there will never be a solution.
"I am talking about these people who cry when their son is standing there in an orange suit. Where were you when he was 2? Where were you when he was 12? Where were you when he was 18 and how come you didn''t know that he had a pistol? And where is the father?"
"People putting their clothes on backward: Isn''t that a sign of something gone wrong? . . . People with their hats on backward, pants down around the crack, isn''t that a sign of something, or are you waiting for Jesus to pull his pants up? Isn''t it a sign of something when she has her dress all the way up . . . and got all type of needles (piercing) going through her body? What part of Africa did this come from? We are not Africans. Those people are not Africans; they don''t know a . . . thing about Africa."
Quotes from Bill Cosby at the Rainbow/PUSH Coalition conference.
"People used to be ashamed. . . . [Today] a woman has eight children with eight different ''husbands,'' or men or whatever you call them now."
"We have millionaire football players who can''t read. We have million-dollar basketball players who can''t write two paragraphs."
"We cannot blame white people%u2026"
More quotes from Bill Cosby at the Rainbow/PUSH Coalition conference.
My son goes to a school that is predominantly Black and Hispanic. I had to go to the superintendent to get books for him! They just had class sets of books and sent my son home every evening with homework for Algebra II and Biology, and chemistry with NO BOOKS! Minority schools are underfunded. We fund schools based on property taxes. So if you live in a wealthy area, your child has books, computers, new schools, and good teachers. If you live in a poor area....Well you get the point.
And we wonder why the children aren''t learning. It''s time to wake up and save our children. we need to stop blaming and talking and start doing. Fund the schools fairly, Pay more and get better teachers instead of these idiots who are currently becoming teachers. When I was in college the only people who went into education were the ones who failed something else. We must pay more and get better teachers!
If you remember in the 90''s when clinton created millions of jobs, gues What, Crime went way down, people went to work and everyone did better. People turn to crime because there are no other options.
When you can''t feed your family because some corporation decided to give your job to china or india, what are you to do? Go to some fast food place and work 60 hours a week and still can''t afford a place to live.
It''s time to wake up!
Posted by Questionnews at 10:42 AM
OK. So what? Why do so many of you feel the need to quote Bill Cosby or Jesse Jackson (when you are not busy calling him a racist) every time something like this comes up? They don''t speak for all black people and I think most blacks understand the nature of the problem, anyway. Also, how come the (greater number of) poor whites who are on welfare or have kids out of wedlock or stay at home and drink beer in their trailer all day are never mentioned by the bigots who are always quick to point out the problems with other groups? The government spends WAY more on them than on blacks. Go ahead and point out that as a percentage blacks make up more. WE KNOW THAT. But don''t come talking like whites aren''t getting handouts. Memo to all of you: Blacks know what''s wrong and the VAST majority want to see changes. All of you smart posters who seem to know everything need to apply all your great ideas in person instead of using your keyboard to show your ignorance. Believe me, people are dying to hear your bright ideas.
Another colossal lib failure....government run schools.
Hell, they don''t even want to hear criticism from Bill Cosby & he''s one of them!