February 11, 2009 2:57 PM
- Text
Dennis Quaid Gives Congress An Earful
(CBS/AP)
Actor Dennis Quaid told Congress on Wednesday of a harrowing, near-fatal drug mix-up in which his newborn twins were administered 1,000 times the normal dose of a blood thinner.
The actor said his family's brush with tragedy underscores the need to hold pharmaceutical companies accountable through lawsuits, a remedy that is becoming increasingly problematic for injured consumers.
Some 7,000 Americans die every year from medication errors.
At issue before the House Reform and Government Oversight Committee is a move by regulators at the Food and Drug Administration to step into lawsuits on the side of defendant drug companies.
In court, the drug companies argue that federal regulation should pre-empt the filing of lawsuits under state law, a matter that will come before the Supreme Court later this year in a case from Vermont.
The Quaid family is suing drug maker Baxter Healthcare Corp., which is seeking dismissal of the lawsuit on federal pre-emption grounds that the FDA approved the labeling.
"Like many Americans, I believed that a big problem in our country was frivolous lawsuits," Quaid testified. "But now I know that the courts are often the only path to justice."
Quaid said that if all lawsuits are pre-empted, "it will basically make us uninformed and uncompensated lab rats."
The committee's ranking Republican, Rep. Tom Davis of Virginia, sympathized with Quaid, saying that if this had happened to the Davis family, "I'd be suing everybody in sight." Apart from Quaid's case, Davis called for balance between total pre-emption and unrestrained litigation.
Committee Chairman Henry Waxman, D-Calif., said that if manufacturers face no liability, all the financial incentives will point them in the wrong direction and that abusive practices will multiply.
Quaid told the committee his family's life-altering story began in November 2007 when twins Thomas and Zoe, at the time 12 days old, developed a staph infection and had to be hospitalized.
The children were mistakenly administered the wrong version of the drug heparin, due to two concentrations of the drug being bottled with similar labels and size. When rotated slightly as they often are when stored, the light blue 10-unit bottle and the 10,000-unit dark blue bottle are virtually indistinguishable, Quaid told the panel.
"It was the scariest, most frightening day that I think either of us have ever been through, to come face to face with your little kids who - so young in that kinda situation," Quaid told "60 Minutes" correspondent Steve Kroft in a March interview.
The actor asked whether consumers' rights to sue under state law should be blocked just because the FDA approves the drug and its labeling and packaging.
The actor said that under the approach favored by business and the federal government, the FDA handed the drug maker "a get-out-of-jail-free card" when the regulatory agency allowed heparin onto the market.
The Quaids' children recovered, though "we don't know what the longer-term effects will be," said Quaid.
But Calif. Congressman Brian Bilbray told Quaid there's another side to the argument - that suing drug companies can also lead to tragedy, reports CBS News correspondent Chip Reid.
Two decades ago Bilbray's pregnant wife needed a drug that had been taken off the market because of a lawsuit.
"I will go to my grave believing that my child is dead because he was denied the product that he desperately needed in his first trimester," Bilbray said.
It's not just Congress that's wrestling with the question of when consumers can sue drug companies, reports Reid. Later this year, the issue will go before the Supreme Court.
The actor said his family's brush with tragedy underscores the need to hold pharmaceutical companies accountable through lawsuits, a remedy that is becoming increasingly problematic for injured consumers.
Some 7,000 Americans die every year from medication errors.
At issue before the House Reform and Government Oversight Committee is a move by regulators at the Food and Drug Administration to step into lawsuits on the side of defendant drug companies.
In court, the drug companies argue that federal regulation should pre-empt the filing of lawsuits under state law, a matter that will come before the Supreme Court later this year in a case from Vermont.
The Quaid family is suing drug maker Baxter Healthcare Corp., which is seeking dismissal of the lawsuit on federal pre-emption grounds that the FDA approved the labeling.
"Like many Americans, I believed that a big problem in our country was frivolous lawsuits," Quaid testified. "But now I know that the courts are often the only path to justice."
Quaid said that if all lawsuits are pre-empted, "it will basically make us uninformed and uncompensated lab rats."
The committee's ranking Republican, Rep. Tom Davis of Virginia, sympathized with Quaid, saying that if this had happened to the Davis family, "I'd be suing everybody in sight." Apart from Quaid's case, Davis called for balance between total pre-emption and unrestrained litigation.
Committee Chairman Henry Waxman, D-Calif., said that if manufacturers face no liability, all the financial incentives will point them in the wrong direction and that abusive practices will multiply.
Quaid told the committee his family's life-altering story began in November 2007 when twins Thomas and Zoe, at the time 12 days old, developed a staph infection and had to be hospitalized.
The children were mistakenly administered the wrong version of the drug heparin, due to two concentrations of the drug being bottled with similar labels and size. When rotated slightly as they often are when stored, the light blue 10-unit bottle and the 10,000-unit dark blue bottle are virtually indistinguishable, Quaid told the panel.
"It was the scariest, most frightening day that I think either of us have ever been through, to come face to face with your little kids who - so young in that kinda situation," Quaid told "60 Minutes" correspondent Steve Kroft in a March interview.
The actor asked whether consumers' rights to sue under state law should be blocked just because the FDA approves the drug and its labeling and packaging.
The actor said that under the approach favored by business and the federal government, the FDA handed the drug maker "a get-out-of-jail-free card" when the regulatory agency allowed heparin onto the market.
The Quaids' children recovered, though "we don't know what the longer-term effects will be," said Quaid.
But Calif. Congressman Brian Bilbray told Quaid there's another side to the argument - that suing drug companies can also lead to tragedy, reports CBS News correspondent Chip Reid.
Two decades ago Bilbray's pregnant wife needed a drug that had been taken off the market because of a lawsuit.
"I will go to my grave believing that my child is dead because he was denied the product that he desperately needed in his first trimester," Bilbray said.
It's not just Congress that's wrestling with the question of when consumers can sue drug companies, reports Reid. Later this year, the issue will go before the Supreme Court.
Popular Now in Health
- America's sodium problem: Not from salty snacks?
- Caffeine inhalers - the next club drug?
- Norovirus outbreak hits Rider University in N.J
- Chinese mom gives birth to 15-pound baby
- Electric shocks to brain may boost memory: Study
- Marijuana-smoking motorists twice as likely to crash
- Skin cancer self-exam: What to look for (PHOTOS)
- America's pets also have an obesity epidemic
- Measles patient at Super Bowl prompts health alert
- STD rates rise among elderly: Why?
- Scottish twins, 102, are world's oldest: Guinness
- Drinking soda raises risk for asthma, COPD: Study
- Things You Didn't Know About Your Penis
- PICTURES: 15 Shocking Sexual Fetishes
- Dr. Liar? Study finds dishonest docs common
- Egg recall in 34 states over Listeria concerns
- Woman spotlights uterus didelphys on talk show
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- Pakistan PM's appeal in contempt case rejected
- Euro falls against dollar on Greek default fears
- Summary Box: Barclays cuts bonuses after '11 fall
- Sector Snap: Morgan Stanley on biotech drugmakers
on Facebook
- Josh Powell had "incestuous" images on his home computer, authorities say
- Adele sings a cappella for Anderson Cooper
on CBS News
