WASHINGTON, May 1, 2008

VA: Brain-Injured Vets Lack Proper Care

Investigators Say Iraq War Veterans Still Not Getting Adequate Long-Term Recovery Assistance

  • The VA pledged to coordinate the necessary follow-up care with the Pentagon, but the latest audit concludes that efforts are still falling short for roughly one in four patients.

    The VA pledged to coordinate the necessary follow-up care with the Pentagon, but the latest audit concludes that efforts are still falling short for roughly one in four patients.  (AP / file)

  • Interactive Military 101

    Basic training to learn all about America's fighting force.

(AP)  Many Iraq war veterans with traumatic brain injury are not getting adequate health care and job assistance for their long-term recovery despite years of government pledges to do so, Veterans Affairs Department investigators say.

"Significant needs remain unmet," according to the report released Thursday by the VA's inspector general. It is the first to examine the Bush administration's long-term efforts in supporting veterans with traumatic brain injury, a leading problem among soldiers struck by roadside bombs that often causes lasting emotional and behavioral difficulties.

The study tracked a group of 52 patients that received VA treatment after sustaining brain injury during a seven-month period in 2004. An initial review by the IG in 2006 found gaps in follow-up care and family counseling 16 months after the injury and urged the VA to improve long-term case management.

The VA pledged to coordinate the necessary follow-up care with the Pentagon, but the latest audit concludes that efforts are still falling short for roughly one in four patients.

It found that 10 of the 41 veterans who agreed to be interviewed said they weren't getting needed help for health care, vocational rehabilitation, family support or housing. At least four patients specifically cited trouble in getting primary or specialty eye care, while others reported gaps with family counseling for problems such as depression and anger.

The report included a VA response in which the department acknowledged problems with case management but stated that with recent improvements it now had "systems in place to ensure that all veterans with TBI are being followed as their clinical needs require."

For example, the VA pointed to plans announced last week to start calling 570,000 recent combat veterans to make sure they know what services are available to them.

In the audit, investigators praised the new measures as "positive steps" but questioned whether the VA's latest promise to keep watch over veterans would prove to be a reality. They said that "at least 8 of 49 veterans we contacted had significant unmet needs and no evidence of VA case management in the previous year."

"We continue to be concerned that all veterans discharged after inpatient rehabilitation for TBI receive case management, unless this has been explicitly denied by the patient," investigators stated, adding that they will continue monitoring the VA to ensure Iraq war veterans are receiving the care they need.

Other findings based on the sample group:

  • Eighteen of the 41 interviewed veterans with brain injury, or 44 percent, said anger was "a problem" for them.

  • Twenty-one veterans, or 51 percent, reported receiving adequate counseling and support for their behavioral or emotional problems.

    The report comes amid renewed scrutiny of the Bush administration's efforts in treating veterans with traumatic brain injury, which in its mild form is known as a concussion, as well as post-traumatic stress disorder in light of a prolonged Iraq war. As many as 20 percent of U.S. combat troops who fought in Iraq or Afghanistan are believed to leave with signs of possible brain injury, an Army task force has said.

    Earlier this year, the Government Accountability Office found that thousands of Iraq war veterans who could have suffered traumatic brain injury may be getting unnecessary or inadequate health care because VA officials have yet to determine whether their initial screening tests are reliable.

    The VA also has faced complaints that a backlog in claims and bureaucratic hurdles have prevented some recent veterans from getting proper mental and physical care. Last week, Sens. Daniel Akaka, D-Hawaii, and Patty Murray, D-Wash., accused the VA's top mental health official of trying to cover up the number of veterans' suicides and said he should resign.

    "While VA has made progress since the last investigation, the inspector general continues to find that too many veterans with TBI and their loved ones are not receiving all the assistance and support they need," said Akaka, who chairs the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee. "This does not appear to be due to a lack of funding, but rather reflects a failure to give these veterans and their loved ones the priority attention they are due."

    Active-duty troops who sustain traumatic brain injury are treated for rehabilitation at one of the VA's four specialized medical centers located in Tampa, Fla., Richmond, Va., Minneapolis and Palo Alto, Calif.


    ©MMVIII, The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
    Add a Comment See all 23 Comments
    by vhalextillmr May 4, 2008 8:43 AM EDT
    Its not just TBI patients that are not getting proper care. IM A VA NURSE in ky and there are patients trying to get a primary care dr changed and still 4 months in the making, no meds, filled cant even get a blood sugar machine. there is no follow up care and its ALWAYS PASSING THE BUCK! one vet came to the er thinking his blood sugar was up has no machine and was told to wait on one lady to come in and she would call him. he was never called. no blood sugar test done.what if he got out and passed out and wrecked? he went and bought his own on a fixed disabled income. i would love for you to hear his entire va expierience. he can not go anywhere else, no insuance.he is a purple heart disabled vet.IM ASHAMED TO WORK THERE. ive placed my 2 weeks notice in.
    Reply to this comment
    by barbaraf4 May 3, 2008 11:07 PM EDT
    We need to make sure this article and similar ones are posted on the doors of the recruiting offices. Those who enlist thinking it is a black or white issue of live or die (be a hero for America) need to know there are gray areas. For example, losing a limb, losing your manhood, losing your brain, or simply losing your innocence.

    God bless and protect all who serve, but let''s cut down on the statistics.
    Reply to this comment
    by singingrick May 3, 2008 10:13 PM EDT


    So this is what Republicons mean when they say support the troops?


    Reply to this comment
    by thisisfunny May 3, 2008 9:33 PM EDT
    For these soldiers its all fun and games until they lose an eye and then they complain or their families. Suck it up and drive on christian soldiers. Just read a story about a Marine in Afghanistan who was involved in a firefight and according to him "this was fun". Well, then dont complain once you know what hits the fan.
    Reply to this comment
    by richmanlove May 3, 2008 6:16 PM EDT
    I had the opportunity to see the Minneapolis VA TBI Unit in action. My grandson, a soldier, was injured in an auto accident on Thanksgiving Day. He was transfered to that unit for treatment. The VA Staff and the Army Liaison Officer, in addition to the Army Case Managers, and Warrior Transition Command was awesum. I was able to spend almost 2 weeks with him and observed his care, other paitents and other family members. His injuries were very slight comnpared to some combat injures, but his care was not slighted or the others were not ignored. I don''t believe any care anyplace else could be as satisfactory as the Minneapolis VA. Thanks to the Minneapolis TBI Staff and US Army.
    Reply to this comment
    by ermarhick-2009 May 3, 2008 5:47 AM EDT
    Wow, what a big, shiny "thank you" to get for doing such work.
    A lot needs to be fixed, at the very least, from the military culture of catering to officers while basically ignoring enlisted personnel ( i served four years in the 90''s ), to the politico''s who haven''t a care in the world, save for their 4 or 5 homes. ALL politicians are elitist, period.
    Our elected leaders, of whom three are currently vying for our votes, all get government-mandated health care. The very same kind of health care that most every other western country gets, excluding us, of course. And while only one wants to extend that "privilege" to all of us, the other two argue against it.
    Why?
    For those against universal health care, would you tell one of these wounded vets that they should "take care of themselves...not expect a government hand-out"?
    Why do they, and you and me, not have that right?
    Why shouldn''t we?
    Reply to this comment
    by bnnielsen May 3, 2008 1:20 AM EDT
    MR. BU$H SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE. OUR SOLDIERS SHOULD NOT BE GETTING KILLED FOR NOTHING. WHEN NEEDED OUR SHOLDIERS HERE AT HOME TAKING CARE OF OUR COUNTRY. NOT WHERE THEY AREN''T EVEN WANTED. THE GOOD MEN AND WOMEN WE LOST IS A CRYING SHAME. WE HAVE LEFT OUR COUNTRY OUT FOR THE TAKING AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE LIKE ME KNOW IT. WERE ARE GIVING OUR COUNTRY AWAY, OUR JOBS, OUR SECURITY, WHAT MORE DO THEY WANT OTHER THAN OUR COUNTRY. WHAT DON''T SOME OF THESE BRAIN SURGEONS VOULENTER THEY''RE SERVICES TO OUR MEN AND WOMEN THAT HAVE PUT THE LIVES ON THE LINE FOR US, AND YES I''M SPEAKING FROM EXPERIENCE I''M A VET. AND WE ARE TREATED LIKE LEPORARDS. SO NEXT TIME NO EXCUSES EVERYONE GOES TO WAR AND SEE WHAT IT IS LIKE THERE AND WHEN YOU GET HOME. AND WHY IS OUR OPION CONCERDERED REPORT ABUSE?????????????????????????
    Reply to this comment
    by aldon61 May 2, 2008 7:57 PM EDT
    inventagod2: It''s not the Bush military, it''s ours! Bush has abused it, but they are honor bound to obey orders. You would not like this country if we didn''t have them defending us.....trust me on that!
    Reply to this comment
    by aldon61 May 2, 2008 7:53 PM EDT
    Our VA health system is broke. Sure, there are some exceptions, and there are many caring workers trying hard to give top-notch care to our soldiers and vererans. But the time has come to throw the baby out with the bath water and start anew. Our soldiers and veterans have put their lives on the line for our country and we have let them down. Pressure your congressmen to provide the funding necessary to build new hopitals or hospices and recruit top-notch medical personnel and cut the dam red tape. We need to build compassion into the new system; the veteran comes first, rules that don''t make sense need to be discarded. Our military deserves better treatment and we have GOT get it to them.....we owe them this!
    Reply to this comment
    by inventagod2 May 2, 2008 5:23 PM EDT

    Yer brain-injured to sign up with the Bu$h military...
    Reply to this comment
    by swwils May 2, 2008 3:35 PM EDT
    It takes time too do anything in the Government if anyone knows I do.We can''t get anything done without a bunch of hog wash through Congress,and the Senate.They need too have a special panel ,to handle the Veterans.There probably is one in place but it isn''t working fast enough.Only when someone knows someone of importance does the wheel turn.I hate it ,but that is our system.Articles like this one actually help turn the wheel.The Generals get notice ,and that helps!Just like the barracks being broke down at one of the most important Army bases we have .Fort Bragg is home to many of the soldiers deployed or have been.All bases are important so don''t get me wrong.I was their for many years so that is why I am using this example.
    Reply to this comment
    by wakeup60 May 2, 2008 1:38 PM EDT
    Dicknbush/the "MAGIC DUO"... have done and continue to do a number on OUR BELOVED VETS/Do believe they hope all the kids sent over there won''t come back/that''s pretty obvious/because they have not made the ultimate availability of providing the best of hospitals and care for our soldiers/along with having properly maintained,clean barricks and living quarters to those who are in the service and about to get out after their service to the US.HOW DARE these creeps do this to our kids/HOW DARE THEM!While they rake in all the retirement & hefty balance to add to their bank a/c''s from all the oil profits they will have on hand because of this monstrousity they''ve created called IRAQ/Give these people "THE BEST"...They''ve given their best! Watch "THE FOURTH OF JULY" again/w/Tom Cruise ... you''ll see something very familiar to what is going on and has gone on for decades/NO MORE WAR WITH THE WRONG COUNTRY or ANY other country for that matter! Take care of our own !!! Where''s Osama??? Only 9 months to birth a new nation ... and finally be rid of the FAKE TEXAN!
    Reply to this comment
    by inventagod2 May 2, 2008 12:27 PM EDT

    Bu$hCo was generous enough to give these guys employment opportunities...
    Dubya never said he would take care of them if they hurt themselves...
    Reply to this comment
    by incog-nito May 2, 2008 12:56 AM EDT
    Maybe so, but if you''re a "security contractor", then you get a six-figure income, the best armor and protection, living quarters, medical care, etc. Now you know where this administration''s priorities are.
    Reply to this comment
    by gce65 May 1, 2008 10:27 PM EDT
    CBS: Not covering this? The WaPost is.

    Study Finds No Cancer-Marijuana Connection
    By Marc Kaufman
    Washington Post Staff Writer
    Friday, May 26, 2006; Page A03

    The largest study of its kind has unexpectedly concluded that smoking marijuana, even regularly and heavily, does not lead to lung cancer.

    The new findings "were against our expectations," said Donald Tashkin of the University of California at Los Angeles, a pulmonologist who has studied marijuana for 30 years.

    "We hypothesized that there would be a positive association between marijuana use and lung cancer, and that the association would be more positive with heavier use," he said. "What we found instead was no association at all, and even a suggestion of some protective effect."

    Federal health and drug enforcement officials have widely used Tashkin''s previous work on marijuana to make the case that the drug is dangerous. Tashkin said that while he still believes marijuana is potentially harmful, its cancer-causing effects appear to be of less concern than previously thought.

    Earlier work established that marijuana does contain cancer-causing chemicals as potentially harmful as those in tobacco, he said. However, marijuana also contains the chemical THC, which he said may kill aging cells and keep them from becoming cancerous.

    MORE ON WA POST WEBSITE
    Read it quick, before the Bush Admin rewrites the reports with non-scientists and changes their conclusions!
    Reply to this comment
    by tibu987 May 1, 2008 9:53 PM EDT
    It is time for a complete overhaul of the VA.
    From the lackadaisical employees who seem to have time for everything except taking care of the vets.
    From the top, the decision makers who decide that a vet who has lost a quarter of his brain and head and is given a 10% disability.
    And, for the VA hospitals that have a higher death and MRSA rate than all other hospitals.
    Etc., etc., etc.

    Our vets deserve nothing less than the very best care that this Country can give, NOTHING less.
    And, it is our duty as appreciative Americans to see that our vets get the very best of everything.
    Write the President, your senator, your congressman and tell them.
    I do.
    Reply to this comment
    by decotoguy May 1, 2008 9:01 PM EDT
    I don''t see any problems here,these boys knew from the get go they were to die...it''s called suicide by goverment....they know their the lucky ones....
    Reply to this comment
    by firststate May 1, 2008 8:44 PM EDT
    TheGateway1
    The VA doesn''t want to pay for quality civilian medical care. They are like the HMO from he[[. If a vet goes outside the VA system the VA usually won''t pay.

    The VA consistently proves that taking care of veterans is not its top priority. They work harder at covering up their failures than actually helping our heroes. They think it''s okay because they have the magnetic ribbon on the back of the VA SUV''s.

    Our veterans deserve the best health care available on the planet. Members of the VA''s administration should be replaced at the top and as far down as necessary until that happens. Lying about the suicide and attempted suicide rates while discussing the real numbers in house is grounds for their removal. These incompetents don''t deserve their pensions. If they knew they would be held accountable, they might try to do their jobs better.
    Reply to this comment
    by erasmus81 May 1, 2008 8:25 PM EDT
    How do you send men and women off to fight, and not have something set up to help them when they get back?
    Reply to this comment
    by termtex01 May 1, 2008 8:07 PM EDT
    Where are all the so-called ''civilian'' hospitals helping out with this?

    We have tons of civilian providers, but they aren''t helping. You know why? The fees they charge are beyond what can be afforded for long-term follow-up care because of all the outrageous medical insurance rates doctors have to pay to protect themselves from malpractice suits.

    That and Congress closing so many military hospitals in the past 30 years, it''s no wonder we can''t get the care we were promiesed.

    Congress made sure they stood up to their word. The promise, then break their promises.
    Reply to this comment
    See all 23 Comments
  • Exclusive Webshow

    Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

    Latest News
    News in Pictures
    Scroll Left Scroll Right
    Connect with CBS News

    Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: