Self Defense Claimed In "Milkshake Murder"

(AP)  An American woman who gave her husband a strawberry milkshake spiked with drugs before beating him to death was only trying to defend herself from the baseball bat-wielding man in their luxury flat in Hong Kong, a defense attorney said Monday.

The defendant, one-time University of Minnesota student Nancy Kissel, has spent the past week trying to appeal the 2005 verdict that got her sentenced to life for what's widely known in Hong Kong as the "milkshake murder." The case has made headlines here because it provided a glimpse into a wealthy expatriate world of summer houses, sexual affairs and alleged drug and alcohol abuse.

Kissel has said she struck her investment banker husband, Robert, with a metal ornament when he was attacking her with a baseball bat in 2003. Her lawyer, Gerard McCoy, said Monday evidence of the bat was left on the metal ornament, which had been "distorted and damaged by a cylindrical shape object."

McCoy argued the judge in the original trial failed to fully address the self-defense argument when he summed up the case for the jury.

"The jury had to hear the defense case coherently and comprehensively put by the judge," McCoy said on the sixth day of the appeal.

The appeal hearing was adjourned until April 29 to give prosecutors time to prepare a response to McCoy's arguments.

Prosecutors have argued that before Nancy Kissel killed her husband, she was caught having an affair with a handyman who worked on the couple's summer house. They said the woman subdued her husband with a strawberry milkshake laced with the "date-rape drug" Rohypnol before she bashed in his head. She had the body rolled up in a carpet and hauled away to a storage area.

Nancy Kissel has said her husband was a whiskey-drinking workaholic with a violent temper. She said he also abused cocaine and forced her to have painful anal sex.

[tomanyt]

diatreme...If she was being abused as she claims, why then, didn''t she just leave???? Leaving is a whole lot easier than drugging someone and then beating their skull in. And how exactly is it self defense if you drug someone before you beat them to death??????

[mjvw2]

who beat her with the ugly stick. shows you there''s always a man ***** enough

[gmond]

He drank her milkshake! Sluuuuuuuuuurp! He drank it up!

[ranger1948]

I don''t buy her defense. Killing someoen in defense is when there is imminent danger. If she drugged him then she planned to kill and there couldn''t be imminent danger. She is guilty.