CLARKSVILLE, Indiana, April 21, 2008

New Girl Beating Video Posted Online

Indiana Police: 12-Year-Old's Beating By Classmates Inspired By Widely-Viewed Fla. Attack

  • Play CBS Video Video Indiana Teens Tape Fight

    Indiana police are investigating a taped beating of a 12-year-old girl, similar to one that surfaced in Fla. recently. Maggie Rodriguez reports.

    • Police said the girls lured the victim to a parking lot near a warehouse in the town just north of Louisville, Ky., on April 12 and beat her up.

      Police said the girls lured the victim to a parking lot near a warehouse in the town just north of Louisville, Ky., on April 12 and beat her up.  (CBS)

    • A group of Indiana middle school girls videotaped the beating of a 12-year-old schoolmate and posted it on the Internet.

      A group of Indiana middle school girls videotaped the beating of a 12-year-old schoolmate and posted it on the Internet.  (CBS)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Interactive Crime Beat

    Statistics and specifics on crime in America.

(CBS/AP)  A group of middle school girls videotaped the beating of a 12-year-old schoolmate and posted it on the Internet in an attack that authorities believe was inspired by a similar one in Florida, police said.

No charges have been filed and police said they have not yet interviewed all the girls, ages 12-14, who are students at Clarksville Middle School in Indiana. The girls' identities were not released because they are juveniles.

The victim, who was treated for cuts and bruises at a hospital, was the daughter of a police officer, said Police Chief Dwight Ingle.

Ingle told CBS' The Early Show that the girls were using rocks as weapons.

"You can actually hear the rocks thumping on the skull of the victim," he said.

Police said the girls lured the victim to a parking lot near a warehouse in the town just north of Louisville, Ky., on April 12 and beat her up. The violence was videotaped and later posted on the video-sharing Web site PhotoBucket, Ingle said. It has since been removed.

The video begins with one girl arguing with the victim and escalates into a fight during which the 12-year-old is repeatedly hit in the head as other girls watch and laugh, police said.

Detective Darrell Rayborn said Thursday police believed the plot was inspired by a similar scheme in which a group of teenage girls in central Florida posted the videotaped beating of a 16-year-old victim online. Parts of that video have been widely seen on TV and YouTube.

Clarksville school Superintendent Stephen G. Fisher said he did not anticipate disciplinary action against the students because the fight did not occur on school grounds.

© MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 97 Comments
by ranger1948 April 23, 2008 12:43 AM EDT
happy_dan
You write a good article for someone so young. I agree it was a mistake to take religion out of the schools and i respect everyones right to their beliefs about religion. I however spent 56 years looking for answers in christianity and was not satisfied. I found what i was looking for in Budhism. Personally whether you worship God, Budha, Allah or what ever you call him, i think we will find he is one and the same just with different names. My biggest thing i didn''t agree with in christianity was they''re saying animals do not have souls. The animals i have seen usually have more soul than most people. I am in Thailand now and we have a lot of cobra''s here. I have had several experiences with them and even bitten once. Budha teaches to live in harmony with all things. When i find a cobra i give it to the red cross snake farm in Bangkok. I know it will have a good home and they provide antivenom for the people here. I have also seen if you give a cobra his space he only wants to get away from you. He bites to defend himself or when he feels threatened.
Reply to this comment
by me_nz April 22, 2008 9:50 PM EDT
The US needs learn from the experience we have had of this in the UK and to clamp on this fast via the ISP providers. We have had a fad here for some time called "Happy Slapping". This is where gangs of young people (yobs) go about beating up people including inflicting GBH (grievous bodily harm) manslaughter and murder. They film these attacks usually with mobile phones and post them on websites for entertainment e.g. UTube and Face book. I have been threatened with 1 of these attacks myself and only just managed to fight my attackers off. It is a cycle, which feeds of itself with young people trying to out do each other with the ferocity and length of the attacks to post on the websites. It is aided and abetted by the websites having no effective policing of the content posted on them and an unwillingness to do so. They go on about freedom of speech and censorship etc. It is also aided by a weak justice system e.g. where young perpetrators e.g. under 18 are not allowed to be identified (named and shamed) and might only be convicted of manslaughter for a gang attack e.g. kicking someone to death. For this they might be sentenced to 5 years in prison (which is more like a holiday camp) but be out in 21 months on early release. The lesson is get early tough and stay tough and force the Internet sites to police this stuff before you have a real problem otherwise it could snowball.
Reply to this comment
by happy_dan April 22, 2008 9:46 PM EDT
o my bad I did not give contact info...
jkz450@care2.com
http://www.dittytalk.com/PraiseGodThoughTheRain
Also can be found on Faith Freaks, Fallensword, Duels, http://www.knightfight.co.uk/index.php, I think thats it.
But really feel free to have at it.

(man they really should have an edit button I should have been a little nicer. I personally apologize for being so mean but I do not apologize for what I meant. Just how I said it.)
Reply to this comment
by happy_dan April 22, 2008 9:44 PM EDT
o my bad I did not give contact info...
jkz450@care2.com
http://www.dittytalk.com/PraiseGodThoughTheRain
Also can be found on Faith Freaks, Fallensword, Duels, http://www.knightfight.co.uk/index.php, I think thats it.
But really feel free to have at it.

(man they really should have an edit button I should have been a little nicer. I personally apologize for being so mean but I do not apologize for what I meant. Just how I said it.)
Reply to this comment
by happy_dan April 22, 2008 9:34 PM EDT
I cannot believe that no one mentioned something to the like of...
Violence is not ok, however yes it is normal.
Sadly yes.
Now what no one has said:
PATHETIC here you stand on top of a home made box trying to down everyone else, when you are saying these people can''t raise their kids right they need a good dose of old days. Old days weren''t nice! Where did people go wrong...when they we born from Adam and Eve...Cain and Able?...They knew God...Take a look at Genesis 34. Thats pretty violent. My goodness ISRAEL''s sons did not know God? Maybe you should...well gosh...actually read your bible. You say they were raised wrong, how the heck could Noah raise his kids wrong? He was the only one left to survive. If old days raised thier kids right we would not have fighting unless... FIGHTING IS NORMAL!
Now to all those who think this problem is related to refusing God. I am an inner city kid. I live 15 minutes from North Minneapolis, AKA Murderapolis. I go to a school with student that were kicked out of the public schools cause they got in so many fights. The worst among them would not drop a Bible on ACCIDENT for fear of God''s wrath. How about you people pay attention to a little thing called realality then try to say something. When I grow up I hope to be just like you, so pathetic that I have to latch onto God to get mad at people instead of actually reading my Bible. And yes I have read Romans 12 so please don''t shout that in my face.
Reply to this comment
by memerider April 22, 2008 8:35 PM EDT
Time to tighten the supervision of kids. We were much more closely supervised at that age to avoid things like this. There were some mean girls when I was a child, but it was easier to stay away from them.
Reply to this comment
by DocD--2008 April 22, 2008 8:00 PM EDT
%u201CThe schools do not have jurisdiction for actions that occur off of school property. They are ONLY responsible for things that happen on school property or at school events.%u201D

Posted by AR_Teacher

Wrong. In most states, schools are responsible for the kids from the time they leave for school till the time they return home from school. Schools also have the right to not let violent kids that may be a threat to other students attend their campus period.
Reply to this comment
by lpro65 April 22, 2008 7:51 PM EDT
Hmmm....maybe if mothers tried actually raising their daughters to be decent human beings instead of snotty little monstrous bee-atches these types of things wouldn''t happen. But no..mommy wants to live through their daughters vicariously and be their best friend. Look at what happened to young girls like Britney, Lilo, etc. Granted they are celebrities but this trend trickles down. Meaning that girls now feel no sense of responsibilite for their own actions....
Reply to this comment
by libsrweak April 22, 2008 7:32 PM EDT
and by the way, the liberal media IS complicating matters by hiding and twisting the true meaning of ''freedom of speech and expression'' for financial gain..
Reply to this comment
by libsrweak April 22, 2008 7:23 PM EDT
The School Superintendent does not anticipate disciplinary actions because the attack did not take place in school ground??? I dont get it!!


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by enzoc45 at 11:05 AM : Apr 22, 2008
+ report abuse

***********************

if you cannot comprehend who is repsonsible for these 12 year olders..THEN IT BEST YOU STAY AWAY..
Reply to this comment
by missybelle-2009 April 22, 2008 7:15 PM EDT
Why would anyone want the schools to have to take responsbility for the actions of these little monsters off school grounds? Doesn''t the education community have enough to do?
Reply to this comment
by April 22, 2008 6:15 PM EDT
The School Superintendent does not anticipate disciplinary actions because the attack did not take place in school ground??? I dont get it!!

Posted by enzoc45 at 11:05 AM : Apr 22, 2008

The schools do not have jurisdiction for actions that occur off of school property. They are ONLY responsible for things that happen on school property or at school events. Precautions will mostly likely be taken to monitor these students, but because it occured in the purvue of the POLICE, the schools can''t and shouldn''t do anything.
Reply to this comment
by caliengineer April 22, 2008 3:26 PM EDT
These videos have been on YouTube for years. It is far past due for authorities to start prosecuting. I think there should be a federal team which notifies local authorities, who then prosecute.

In many of the videos, one of the people does not want to fight at all. Some don''t even resist, but offer peace. Then, the aggressor attacks. Posting is just an effort to humiliate their victims.
Reply to this comment
by missybelle-2009 April 22, 2008 3:01 PM EDT
'''' ..

i counted the number of my friends

to be infinite to infinite exponents,

together we tax the worlds and make all pay for lunch,

Posted by vegishsuch at 08:54 AM : Apr 22, 2008

Wow, is this really necessary and pertinent? Anyway... there are very few consequences anymore for children, we praise them for every dang thing they do, and don''t correct their behavior for fear of stifling their egos. The egos are too big right now, and these girls need some intensive real world training. They may think they''re untouchable right now, but someone with a bigger stick or bigger gun, a past victim of their little shenanigans, is going to perform a little payback... it won''t ever end.
Reply to this comment
by enzoc45 April 22, 2008 2:05 PM EDT
The School Superintendent does not anticipate disciplinary actions because the attack did not take place in school ground??? I dont get it!!
Reply to this comment
by talessman April 22, 2008 1:42 PM EDT
This just reinforces my point that (some) women are just as violent as (some) men.

Neither gender is more innocent or more violent than the other; we''re all equally human.

And it''s time to apply that equality to domestic violence laws, where women are just as likely to be the agressor.

Respectfully,

Thomas Lessman
Website: www.ThomasLessman.com
Blog: www.talessman.blogspot.com
-----------------------------
Reply to this comment
by akakjb April 22, 2008 1:39 PM EDT
Wow. And I thought Ritalin was supposed to stop this kind of behavior in kids. Must be time for some new chemical that we have no idea what it will produce once the kids go through puberty. As for more God is schools being the answer, I am a Catholic school graduate / survivor & I can assure you that we had more than our share off gang whuppins and proto-sociopaths, usually in the name of God. Lets just get to the basics of trying to teach kids to be decent to one another instead of being jerks as a step in the right direction. Of course, monkey-see, monkey-do: it does require that the adults stop acting like idiots as an example and as I don''t see that happening any time soon, I''d say we''re pretty much doomed.
Reply to this comment
by bunnybaum April 22, 2008 1:29 PM EDT
We need to put God back into our schools and our every day life. Without God, nothing good will ever come of this world. I bet these girls never even heard of God.
Reply to this comment
by ranger1948 April 22, 2008 10:45 AM EDT
closethippy1
That isn''t all. She may not have thrown the first punch but she lured the victim there and she did assault her with rocks. That makes for assault with a deadly weapon. You would feel different if it were one of your family.
Reply to this comment
by ranger1948 April 22, 2008 10:42 AM EDT
h
Reply to this comment
See all 97 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: