CNN Pundit's China Comments Draw Ire

Chinese Americans Protest Outside CNN Bureaus Calling For Jack Cafferty's Head

(AP)  Chinese-Americans rallied outside CNN's Hollywood office on Saturday to demand the firing of commentator Jack Cafferty for calling China's goods "junk" and its leaders a "bunch of goons and thugs."

"We understand free speech," Lake Wang, 39, told the Los Angeles Times. "But what if Cafferty said this about other racial groups? I think he would be fired. I think he's jealous of China."

A crowd estimated by police at 2,000 to 5,000 gathered, chanting and holding signs that read "Fire Cafferty" and "CNN: Chinese Negative News." The crowd was peaceful, and no arrests were made, police Sgt. David Torres said.

Another two dozen people holding Chinese flags also demonstrated outside CNN's corporate headquarters in Atlanta.

Cafferty made the comments during an appearance on "The Situation Room" that aired April 9.

Speaking about the U.S. trade deficit with China, Cafferty said: "We continue to import their junk with the lead paint on them and the poisoned pet food and export, you know, jobs to places where you can pay workers a dollar a month to turn out the stuff that we're buying from Wal-Mart."

"So I think our relationship with China has certainly changed," he continued. "I think they're basically the same bunch of goons and thugs they've been for the last 50 years."

A call Saturday seeking comment from CNN representatives was not immediately returned, but both Cafferty and a network statement earlier in the week stressed that the remarks were aimed at the Chinese government, not its people. CNN said it apologized to anyone who thought otherwise.

China on Thursday snubbed CNN's apology. Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Jiang Yu said the CNN statement lacked sincerity and instead "turned its attack on the Chinese government to try to sow division between the Chinese government and the people."

China has been under scrutiny as it prepares to host the Olympics in August. Criticism of its human rights record and unrest in Tibet have received widespread coverage, leading Chinese leaders to accuse Western media of smearing the country.

A wave of verbal assaults on foreign media has raised concerns about media controls at the Olympics. CNN has been singled out by the Chinese government, and activists have phoned and e-mailed death threats to Western reporters.

[cantshutup]

hey china, your goods are "junk" and your leaders a "bunch of goons and thugs."

i look at EVERY label and if it''s from china i put it back on the shelf...BUY LOCAL!

[timothyone-2009]

Are people so stupid that they cannot see that America does everything China and the former Soviet Union has ever done, to it''s own people, to it''s own allies, and to it''s enemies? How can anyone with any sense at all believe that the CIA is a fine and decent organization and the KGB was pure evil, or that Palestinians are terrorists and Jews are God''s special chosen people doing only what God has chosen them to do? LOL! Awake from your comic book mentality and see the world for what it is already! ***!

[brianbwb-2009]

"i look at EVERY label and if it''''s from china i put it back on the shelf...BUY LOCAL!" Posted by cantshutup

When is the last time you bought a US made TV, or computer, or handphone? Where does the engine in your Ford come from?

You cannot blame the Chinese. China is China, a feudal culture for 3,000 years, slavery is not taboo there. Communism held the promise of ending it, but as it alwas does, the power of the leaders made them drunk, and the addiction is not only Chinese.

The fault lies with greedy American corporations taking advantage of slave labor for increased profits. Globalization is all about finding new slaves, once your own become too expensive to maintain your profit margin. Power corrupts, and economic power corrupts absolutely.

[stinkymouth]

Put everything China back to shelf? Buy local?
OK, what is made local? I want to buy local. Tell me where I can buy stuff made local(USA)?
I tell you, so far the only thing I bought recently that is made in USA is SAS shoe, made in USA prison. LOL!!!

[stinkymouth]

Everything is about race and ethnical. White Americans, be it law makers or CNN commentators are racist deep in their hearts. China and Chinese people are miserable----they have been scapegoats historically. It doesnt matter Communist China or Taiwan Chinese. Wen Ho Lee is Taiwan Chinese, but he was singled out just because he is FXXX Chinese!!CIA director took computer files home and nothing happened. If a Chinese man spitting, something wrong because he is FXXX Chinese. If a white man spit, nothing is wrong.
I feel sorry for the Chinese.
When Goerge Bush just became president, he and his bunch was looking for a new enemy after the Soviet Union was gone and they naturally picked China as the next enemy and the CIA hired a bunch of Chinese speaking PHDs and a bunch of so-called China Experts who actually dont really know China---people who spent a few years in Taiwan and learned some stupid Chinese language and become professors such as University of Michigan Kenneth Liberthal and ready to fight the Chines, but suddenly BOOOOM 9/11 happened and they woke up---holy cow!!---Chinese is not the enemy? It is Bin Laden? ***, Chinese was lucky in this case or Americans trrops might in China instead of in Iraq.

[stinkymouth]

Human rights? Tibet crackdown? what Waco and David Koresh? What the US government did to the Davidians?
Goons and thugs?
If you have goons and thugs robbing and burning stores and business in Los Angeles, should the police be sent in to crack down? if a bunch of idiots trying to split Alaska out of the USA, what the US government will do?

[stinkymouth]

if a bunch of idiots stormed into CNN building in Atlanta and tried to punch Jack Greffery, would the police be there? whats the difference between this and Tibetan idiot monks?

[stinkymouth]

China Junks? why we let them then?
why we import them then? are we idiots? stupid?
why we had Wal-mart? You would have spent $500 dollars for Christmas gifts instead of $150 for the same merchandise if we dont import "China junks".
Who would suffer? the American poors who make $6 an hour.

[stinkymouth]

Who are China Experts in the USA government such as CIA? who is the China advisor to the president?
he must be white, born and raised and lived in America, spent 3 years in Taiwan and learned a few Chinese, read some books and researched some China shiiit and might have published a few ************ articles and, then became China experts?
they dont know NO *** about China!!!

[stinkymouth]

CNN used to be Chicken Noodle Network. And it is still is. Lou Dobbs? the only thing he can talk is illegal immigrants and outsourcing and American lower income class and communits China!!!
CNN: give Lou Dobbs a big raise so he will be happy and content and might shut up talking about people relative to foreign countries and start talking something else like how the US government burned down the Waco Davidian house.

[nikkicatt1]

Put everything China back to shelf? Buy local?
OK, what is made local? I want to buy local. Tell me where I can buy stuff made local(USA)?
I tell you, so far the only thing I bought recently that is made in USA is SAS shoe, made in USA prison. LOL!!! Posted by stinkymouth at 05:09 AM

Get off the board if you cannot tell the truth! SAS Shoes are made in San Antonio - not in a prison. Every post you have written is sooo full of lies. I am realy upset about the multitude of foreigners that seem to know what is good for America.To assume that all America is White or that all America voted for GW is wrong!!! Yes, we have alot of problems in our country. Most of them stem from trying to balance LAW with human rights. We make alot of mistakes, but at least America is TRYING! What has China done?

[xlib]

stinkymouth-so, you see racism everywhere, everywhere. Little paranoid there?? Such hate built up in you. You must be a joy to live with. In fact, could you be racist??

[iamthequeen-]

Get used to political correctness replacing freedom of speech. And we have the "nappy headed ho" comment and n****r to thank for that. Now it''s the Asian Americans'' turn to get someone fired. Anybody heard any good Polish jokes?

[slim1h2o]

Maybe if China would export products that were safe for human consumption, you would not have to listen to such remarks.

And quite possibly too,, stnkymouth,,if you''d use American tooth paste,,you wouldn''t be afflicted with stinky mouth.

[brianbwb-2009]

Posted by iamthequeen-

You call it "political correctness" when it really is taking the consequences of your free speech. It is not the government that is censoring, it is the reaction of the people offended by the speech. If you are afraid of the reaction, then censor yourself, if you can accept the consequence of your words, then by all means exercise your right to free speech.

Or is that the problem, you just want to say whatever you want, and have some government body shielding you from the consequence?

[rillifane]

As a Chinese American I condemn this pernicious nonsense which was, in fact, organized by agents provacateur from the Communist Chinese government. Americans should be aware that the Communists have infiltrated hundreds of intelligence agents into the United States in the guise of businessmen and students. In addition to to the usual duties of spies (primarily industrial espionage in this case) they monitor and attempt to control the Chinese America population. Jack Cafferty was absolutely correct to point out that the Communist regime today consists of "basically the same bunch of goons and thugs they''ve been for the last 50 years." No sensible person would read any general anti-Chinese racial animus into his statement.

[downsteamjim]

Why would anyone bad mouth the ChiComs? It''s not like they are supporting Sudan against the people of Dafur; suppressing dissent in Tibet; sending arms to Mugabe in Zimbabwe; etc.

[quetzal0666]

Some People just dont learn,
you can excersise your right to free speech, but when someone comes along and pops you in the head for offending them,
then someone has excexuted his version of free speech on you!!

[joyjoy18-2009]

The truth is: China is getting stronger both economically and politically each and every day, Cafferty''s comment was full of jealousy! so were some of the comments here! but hey, whose fault was that?
Go, China go!

[killtheliars]

Everything he said was true. Their stuff is junk, and the younger generation in the U.S. does not even know what quality means.
China may be getting stronger but that is all dependant on the U.S. importing thier cheap ***.
As i am always saying we need to cut all ties, especially trade with China. Once you take away the U.S. market thier huge population goes back to being a disadvantage instead of an asset. Once you take away the need to have them making fake Christmas trees and toxic toys bound for the U.S. the people are no longer needed and will not be able to eat. Then the riots start and the Chinese government will be so busy quelling dissent they won''t have time or energy to be competing with the U.S. on a global scale.
We need to cut them off. let them support themselves without U.S. help.

[joyjoy18-2009]

the world is not just about US, to boycott chinese imports would only hurt the american people, not the rich ones, but the poor ones who can only afford fake christmas trees, etc.

[stopracism]

So, what''s the difference between Cafferty''s remarks and Don Imus'' remarks (to the women''s college basketball team that happened to be all African-American)? None.

Look at all the stuff around you that are made in China...electronics, appliances, furnishings, all made in China and sold by big name brands such as Sony, Mitsubishi, etc. And guess what, nothing''s wrong with them. It''s all about quality control. If Sony can do a good job, then companies like Mattel and the U.S. government should be equally accountable for the so-called "junk" that made it to our stores. Had Mattel and others been more diligent rather than to focus on cost cutting, then we would have never been in this situation.

And just because the U.S. cuts off trade with China won''t do any good. The U.S. hold higher standards than other countries, and these other countries won''t stop trade with China as long as their standards are met. Stopping trade could very well hurt our economy, especially the goods that are being sold to China. Don''t you think other countries like Canada and Australia and Russia would more than be happy to step in and take over trade with China if the US backs out?

[stopracism]

P.S. killtheliars, would you be prepared to pay 25% to 50% more for every good you normally purchase that was either made or imported from China with your current budget and just buy US or non-Chinese made?

[killtheliars]

StopRacism,
Actually I always look for goods made in the U.S. and if they are more i pay the difference. I disagree that cutting all trade with china would hurt the U.S. but not China. They are much more dependant on our consumer base then we are theirs. what people don''t seem to realise is that even in tough times the average american has more disposable income then almost anyone else. What I am saying is keep it here, and what you cannot keep in the U.S. keep in this hemisphere. If we could learn to get along with countries like Venezuala and keep good relations with Brazil and Canada, and stop playing games with Mexico and say you want food aid medical aid financial aid forgivness of debt we want cheap oil, we could become independant of middle eastern oil, African oil ect.
We need to cut off or at least wean ourselves totally off of China. If we can do this in 10 years we would be back to the ultimate economic power and China would be backsliding. If you think Mexico, Russia, Austrailia and Canada are more lucrative markets then the U.S. you are nuts. Also once we get our manufacturing back up and running we would take the business from Austrailia and Canada and maybe even Russia.When I hear people say it would hurt us more i actually start to believe there is a global conspiracy to re-distribute wealth form the U.S. and other wealthy nations to other parts of the world.

[kansas1946]

(AP) Chinese-Americans rallied outside CNN''s Hollywood office on Saturday to demand the firing of commentator Jack Cafferty for calling China''s goods "junk" and its leaders a "bunch of goons and thugs."

"We understand free speech," Lake Wang, 39, told the Los Angeles Times. "But what if Cafferty said this about other racial groups? I think he would be fired. I think he''s jealous of China."
**************************************
Are these people Chinese or American. They need to make a choice. Nothing Cafferty said was untrue. If these folks think it is so grand in China, maybe they need to think about immigrating. No one will stop them. The Chinese have been oppresive to their people, have allowed sub-standard products to enter the consumer market, many of which have caused illnes and death. It is nuts to live in this country, enjoy the freedoms and economic rewards of our system, and then raise cain when the very oppression the they escaped is critcized.

[joyjoy18-2009]

What a stupid comment from FlangeSqueal!
Even the kids from the elementory know that the Olympic Games belong to the people from all over the world, not the country who hosts it. the rest part of your comment only shows how shallow and hateful you are, you really need to worry about your mental health if making such comment was not because of lack of education.

[keithle1]

American consumers want cheap stuff. They love Wal-Mart. No one could afford to buy it if it was made in USA by American-born workers. Retail is price, price, price. So are supermarkets. Who is going to pick fruit & vegetables in USA if Mexicans & people from Central America don''t do it? Whites & Blacks?

China doesn''t have the talking-heads-arguing-about-current-affairs programs that we do such as The McLaughlin Group, Hardball & the Beltway Boys. All they have is the news reader giving the people the party line. The world according to the Chinese Communist Party. There is no room for anyone''s opinion or editorial comment if it''s critical of th powers-that-be. Chinese aren''t allowed to surf the web like we are.

We''ll see how polite & well-mannered the government & the Chinese police are if there are protests at the Olympics & they get out of hand.

[stinkymouth]

Flangesequel is just clearly a racist--period.
Too many Americans are ignorant---they dont have a decent education---especially those low class and poor class have no decent education---they are just a bunch of low-lifes---white trash, red necks, idiots or "thugs and goons" themselves.

[stinkymouth]

The stupidest people are Americans themselves. if Chinese stuff are "junks", why let them in? If Chinese are goons and thugs, why we let them in?
Other people are better? Koreans, Viets, Armenias?
If a Chinese spit on the street, its because he is a phucking *****. if a white man spit, be it Irish or French, nothing is wrong--it just happened.
Americans and its system will never be back on track when it comes to manufacturing daily necessity goods--period--never ever becuase its stupid system. Americans will never be able make shoes and T-shirts and fake Xmas trees again except in prison. Hahaha!!!

[stinkymouth]

I will pitty for many Americans who live in poverty while the rich are ******** cheap Chinese stuff. Without Wal-mart getting stuff from China, American system must raise minimum wage to $25/hour. Can America do it? never ever so if not , shut up Jack Cafferty and go to Wal mart buy a pair of towels for children to go the beach.

[stinkymouth]

Another thing Chinese is miserable is that even we talk about their rising strength, the Chinese are historically weak--especially without Mao Zetung.
The Russians dont give it ***---they would have shot down a US plane deviated into their territory--
and if Mao Zetung was alive, he would oreded to shoot down that US spy plane. When US bombed China Embassy in Belgrade, if Mao Zetung was alive, we might have a nuclaer war by now.
Today''s China government is weak, no guts. They only think about making money. Money Slaves.
The Chinese need to learn from Venezuela president Hugo Chavez to deal with Americans.
Chavez is the man who would Americans. Mao Zetung said The USA is a paper tiger and Chavez learned that fast, so he knows how to deal with Americans.
Viva Chavez. The Chinese, if they learn, should have kicked CNN China station and its staff out of the country if they learned from Chavez. Chinese cannot fire Jack, cannot make CNN apologize, but they certainly can kick CNN out of the country---thats at least they can do if they want to.
But Mao Zetung is gone and with todays China leaders, they dont have the guts. They dont know how to deal with Americans--or they just dont want to be kicked out of their "junks" coming to America.