March 17, 2008

Bill Clinton's Image Damaged

Politico: Former President's Return To Partisan Politics Causes Public Perception To Suffer

  • President Bill Clinton, center, hosting his Clinton Global Initiative University, and actor Brad Pitt, right, founder of the Make It Right Foundation, greet volunteers before breaking ground for new homes in the Lower Ninth Ward in New Orleans on Sunday, March 16, 2008.

    President Bill Clinton, center, hosting his Clinton Global Initiative University, and actor Brad Pitt, right, founder of the Make It Right Foundation, greet volunteers before breaking ground for new homes in the Lower Ninth Ward in New Orleans on Sunday, March 16, 2008.  (AP Photo/Cheryl Gerber)

  • Play CBS Video Video Hillary Defends Bill's Support

    Political commentators are blaming former President Bill Clinton for his wife's primary election loss in South Carolina. Hillary Clinton tells Bob Schieffer about her husband's campaign support.

  • Video Clinton Rekindles Race Issue

    Diversity expert Joe Watson tells Harry Smith that Bill Clinton's comparison of Sen. Barack Obama's S.C. primary win to Jesse Jackson's victory there 20 years ago was designed to cause sparks.

  • Photo Essay Clinton's 8 Years

    The former president's travels abroad, and triumphs and troubles at home.

  • Photo Essay Hillary Clinton

    A look at a life and career full of firsts.

(The Politico)  This story was written by David Paul Kuhn.


Bill Clinton’s reentry into the political arena appears to have come at some cost to his legacy. New polling now suggests that Clinton’s involvement in the Democratic nomination battle between his wife, Hillary Rodham Clinton, and Barack Obama, has significantly tarnished the former president’s image.

A Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll released Thursday found that more Americans view Bill Clinton negatively than positively, 45 to 42 percent. It marked the first time since January 2002 that a plurality of Americans disapproved of the former president. One month earlier, The Gallup Poll found that nearly as many Americans had an unfavorable as favorable view of Bill Clinton-for the first time in nearly five years.

Presidential historians said Clinton’s return to partisan politics made it likely that public perception of the former president would suffer. 

"There is a certain historical glow that surrounds a president as some of his historical battles become more distant. Clinton getting back in the mud again makes him a much more partisan figure,” said Allan Lichtman, a presidential historian at American University. "And it’s not like it’s been an acclaimed experience for him."


After leaving the White House in January 2001 amidst controversy surrounding his last-minute pardons, Clinton reconstituted his public persona with a return to the world stage. He traveled to Gujarat, India, after a devastating earthquake, and in later years barnstormed Africa as an advocate for lower AIDS drug prices. He also began hosting an annual pre-United Nations General Assembly meeting for world leaders and tycoons.

America came to know a newer, less self-centered Clinton, an energetic statesman working to better the world. Public opinion polls showed about six in ten Americans held a positive view of the former president, reminiscent of the apex of his support in the White House.

His return to elected politics changed all that. In New Hampshire, he referred to Obama’s early opposition to the Iraq war as the “biggest fairy tale I've ever seen,” a remark that would come to be seen by many as an attempt to belittle Obama. He later accused Obama’s staff of voter suppression in Nevada -- a sensitive charge in Democratic circles.

Clinton’s low point came in South Carolina, where he drew criticism for comparing Obama’s candidacy to Jesse Jackson, a remark widely viewed as an attempt to pigeonhole Obama as a candidate who appeals largely to black voters. Clinton also took on a much more adversarial role with the media, a posture unseen since his years in the White House.

By Super Tuesday, the former president himself had become part of the story. In the key competitive state of Missouri, 28 percent of Democratic primary voters had a negative view of Clinton, double the amount as in New Hampshire just weeks earlier.

"This guy’s chronic lack of focus, lack of self discipline, and his tendency to make politics a short run political game his bottom line, these characteristics led him to make moves that were counterproductive both to his reputation and his post-presidential rating and damage his wife’s campaign,” said Princeton University presidential historian Fred Greenstein.

The public was reminded of the undisciplined president who “is very good at shooting himself in the foot,” Greenstein added.

Since it became clear that the former president was doing as much harm as good, Clinton has taken on a much lower profile role, campaigning in small markets away from the crush of the national media.

Still, his earlier comments continue to haunt his wife’s campaign. Last week, at a forum of more than 200 black community newspaper publishers, Hillary Clinton apologized for her husband’s remark comparing Obama to Jackson. “I am sorry if anyone was offended,” she said.

“Certainly since New Hampshire and then South Carolina and then a little bit beyond, what that will do for legacy is, it takes the rose colored glasses off, particularly for historians,” said Kent Germany, a presidential historian at the University of South Carolina. “Historians now have this bit to say: ‘here’s the real pattern of the Clinton life.’ Maybe he’s not as brilliant a calculator as we had thought previously. Maybe he’s good in the moment and sometimes it doesn’t work out.”

But if Clinton has indeed seriously injured his public standing, a presidential victory by his wife might go a long way toward reversing the damage.

“It would help his legacy enormously, nothing in politics succeeds like success,” said American University’s Lichtman. “And that would be just absolutely extraordinary considering the gamble he’s taken.”


By David Paul Kuhn
Copyright 2008 POLITICO



We cover politics with enterprise, style, and impact.

Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
  • CBSNews.com on Digg
Add a Comment See all 175 Comments
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 8:13 PM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 8:36 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 4:12 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 4:12 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 3:44 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 3:43 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 3:35 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.

This man has proven to be a liar, a cheat, and not trustworthy, yet many of you still love him. I''m baffled by this and you are showing your stupidity.
Reply to this comment
by humwayno-2009 March 20, 2008 3:33 AM EDT
I am amazed at how so many Americans can''t see past the Clinton racism. It''s not towards Blacks or Hispanics, it towards anyone who doesn''t have money or power. Bill and Hillary both are possessed by the thought of power, and will get it anyway they can. They don''t really care about America or Americans. They care about themselves and power. Wake up you Clinton lovers. One good thing is you''ve been dupped by the best, so don''t feel too bad about your stupidity and putting your head in the sand.
Reply to this comment
by p5e0428 March 20, 2008 2:37 AM EDT
Are you kidding me the front page of cbsnews.com should be those crazy comments from the spirtual advisor of BARACK OBAMA. Who also married him and baptised his children. If you can go on Youtube do so. Mr. Wright, of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, referred to the United States as the %u201CU.S. of K.K.K. A.%u201D and said the Sept. 11 attacks were a result of corrupt American foreign policy. Obama even got the name for his second book from this racist pastor. Where are you NAACP and Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. He has been and is being very racist towards all Americans and especially white Americans. OBAMA DOESN''''T KNOW HOW TO KEEP GOOD COMPANY. NO WONDER MICHELLES COMMENTS ABOUT NOT BEING ABLE TO BE PROUD OF AMERICA CAME OUT HER MOUTH. LOOK WHERE THEY GO TO CHURCH.

HILLARY FOR PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by jankebenz March 19, 2008 12:51 AM EDT
The clintons image went opaque years ago back in Arkansas with their "dealings". Millions have been fooled by the illusions of smoke and mirrors.
Reply to this comment
See all 175 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Does dad need a nursing home? Dr. LaPook talks with a geriatrician about navigating a difficult decision.
Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: