4 Dead, 10 Injured In NYC Crane Collapse

Crane Tumbles Into Neighboring Block, Crushing One Building Completely

(CBS/AP)  A crane mounted to the side of a skyscraper under construction toppled with a roar Saturday, smashing into a block of apartment buildings, killing at least four people and setting off a scramble for survivors in the rubble.

The crane split into pieces as it fell, pulverizing a four-story brownstone and demolishing parts of three other buildings.

Mayor Michael Bloomberg said at least four people, believed to be construction workers, have died and at least 10 people were injured in one of the city's worst construction accidents in recent memory.

"It is a tragic event," Bloomberg said.

The collapse created a virtual war zone on an affluent block on Manhattan's East Side: Cars were overturned and crushed. A huge dust cloud rose over the neighborhood. Rubble was piled several stories high.

"It's a horrible situation, very gory. There's blood in the street," said Lt. Gov. David Paterson, who takes over as governor for disgraced Eliot Spitzer on Monday.

An intensive rescue operation was under way to find anyone possibly trapped. One man was pulled from a collapsed townhouse 3 1/2 hours after the building was crushed.

Fire Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta said the rescue was "a painstaking hand operation, as we try to remove the rubble so we don't cause further collapse or injure anyone who may still be in that building." He said the operation would continue all night if necessary, including the use of search dogs and thermal-imaging and listening devices.

The accident happened on 51st Street near 2nd Avenue at about 2:20 p.m. at the construction site of a high-rise condominium. It involved a crane that had been the subject of recent safety complaints.

About 19 of the building's 44 planned stories had been erected, and the crane was scheduled to be moved Saturday so workers could start work on a fresh story when a piece of steel fell and sheared off one of the ties holding it to the building, according to Stephen Kaplan, an owner of the Reliance Construction Group, which manages construction at the site.

"It was an absolute freak accident," Kaplan said. "All the piece of steel had to do was fall slightly left or right, and nothing would have happened."

Ben Galati, a 54-year-old doorman a high-rise apartment tower across the street, said he was in the basement when it happened, and ran for his life when he heard the structure smash into his building.

"I heard a rumble outside. I said, 'Let's get out of here! And then the crane came down. A split second later, I heard an explosion," he said.

John LaGreco, who owns Fubar located in the building that was crushed, said he feared one of his employees was dead in the rubble.

"Our bar is done," he said. "The crane crashed the whole building. If I wasn't watching a Yankees game, I would've come to work early and gotten killed."

The crane split into pieces as it fell. Part of it came to rest against an apartment tower, buckling its facade and smashing it upper floors. That building and others in the area were evacuated. Another piece of the crane hit traveled another half a block, ripping away walls and ceilings and crushing a small building.

Maureen Shey, who lives diagonal from the building where the crane collapsed, said she was on the phone laying on her bed when she saw the giant white crane heading straight for her windows.

"I heard a big crash, and I saw dust immediately. Bricks were flying through the air. I saw the whole thing. I thought the crane was coming in my window," she said.

The crane wound up missing her building, but others weren't as lucky.

Video broadcast by television news helicopters showed firefighters clambering through piles of rubble, several stories high, looking for victims.

Witnesses reported a strong smell of gas in the area. Gas utility Consolidated Edison said it shut off service to area buildings.

CBS News affiliate WCBS reports that neighborhood residents said they had complained to the city several times about the construction at the site, saying crews worked illegal hours and the building was going up too fast.

"I used to walk around the block because it was imminently dangerous. They were swinging buckets of concrete over passing cars on 51st Street, and the crane was not properly attached to the building it was constructing," Neighborhood resident Bartle Bull told CBS News correspondent Wendy Gillette.

City Building Department records showed that on March 4, a caller told officials that the upper portions of the crane appeared to lack the proper number of safety ties attaching it to the building.

But, Gillette reports, late today a New York City building commissioner told reporters that the crane had been inspected yesterday and it was considered safe.

Another call questioning the crane's safety was dismissed as unwarranted by another inspector in February.

Kaplan said the company had subcontracted the work to different companies and was not in charge of the crane. He wasn't sure if any workers at the site were among those killed.

Bill Reilly, a retired UPI reporter, said he was in his apartment a block away when it happened.

"First I heard a rumble, and it increased, and then it increased," Reilly said. "It continued building in strength until there was a final vroom! It shook the six story brick building that I live in."

Police blocked traffic in the area. Gawkers crowded the streets, snapping cell phone pictures and stopping to point at the wreckage. Fire trucks filled area streets and chunks of the building littered the ground.

The catastrophe comes amid a building boom in New York City and follows a spate of construction accidents in recent months, including some involving cranes.

At a Donald Trump hotel-condominium tower in SoHo, a worker plummeted 40 stories to his death last month when a concrete form gave way. A month before that, a crane's nylon sling broke away and dropped seven tons of steel onto a construction trailer across from ground zero, injuring an architect.

[jenksmarkymaypo]

I''d like to know where that inspecter really was when he was supposed to be checking that stuff out. Probably in the bar across the street.

[mainemade]

oops....

*so* much for the rush on that job site..

[mainemade]

Sop much for the rush on that job site...

[sumarongi]

Just business as usual in America today.

Not all companies are at fault, but far too many are.

Graft, kickbacks, bribery, cost cutting short cuts and inferior material purchases are rampant.

These "accidents" can be for various reasons ranging from sheer stupidity, criminal negligence or faulty safety protocols.

The oops it was a freak accident theory doesn''t fly in this case. Not when the complaints that had been lodged against this project were so specific. It sounds more like incompetence and/or negligience on several levels from the contractor and the inspectors.

Inspectors who either don''t know their jobs, don''t care, or were ,"$,asked", to overlook problems because of deadlines or costs.

We''ve gone from a country that took pride in doing it to the best of our abilities, to one where the attitude is "that''s good enough"!

It''s a shame people have to die before the problems are brought to light.

My thoughts and prayers go out to the families of the people killed and injured.

[staycalm]

Remember the 70''s movie "Towering Inferno". Developers are a greedy bunch and will cut corners whenever they can but there''s no excuse for city inspectors to rubber stamp them...unless their palms were being greased.

[whatithink-2009]

There goes the $5M profit!

[nothappyatall]

"One positive thing about litigation is that it makes negligence very expensive when one is in the construction business....as it should. It the end it prevents unnecessary deaths."

Sorry Charlie, many states have passed laws limiting the liablitiy for a company when it kills people "

The company doesnt give a krap, like all corporations- they have INSURANCE- the insurance pays the claims, the few thousand bucks additional premium costs are peanuts for a $50 million job.

Corporations exist to make MONEY, and incorporation protects the CEO''s and owners from personal liability in almost every case, the worst that can happens the COMPANY gets sued and the COMPANY assetts along with stock holders are the risk holder- the CEOS walk out of court intact, they can go bankrupt, reorganize with a new corporate name and begin again, real easy, done all the time.
Now, if the laws were changed to make company CEO''s personally, criminally, and civily liable for these ''accidents''- you''d see a big change when its their Lincoln Town car, bank accounts, and $5 million house on the line!

[nothappyatall]

"It was an absolute freak accident," Kaplan said.

Theres no such thing as a ''freak accident'' in construction- someone either cuts corners, doesnt do their JOB or is incompetant to do it, and THIS is the result.

"a New York City building commissioner told reporters that the crane had been inspected yesterday and it was considered safe. "

SO safe that it falls off the building the very next day after inspection, this inspector must have been one of those ''no idiot left behind'' students in school now grown up and workin'' construction.

Like the article said, this is the latest in a string of these ''accidents'' caused by shoddy construction, shoddy workmanship, shoddy materials, rushing, poor planning, poor inspections and people not doing their job.

[alphaa10-2009]

Bloooooooomberg! Bloooooooomberg! Your building inspectors either have outsourced their work, or Someone Has Paid Them To Shut Up.

When ordinary citizens must take the time and trouble to tell you something is wrong, but your own people are silent, then something is very, very wrong in your administration. It may be criminality, it may be incompetence-- or both.

CBS reports, "The accident ... involved a crane that had been the subject of recent safety complaints...

"I used to walk around the block because it was imminently dangerous. They were swinging buckets of concrete over passing cars on 51st Street, and the crane was not properly attached to the building it was constructing," Neighborhood resident Bartle Bull told CBS News correspondent Wendy Gillette...

City Building Department records showed that on March 4, a caller told officials that the upper portions of the crane appeared to lack the proper number of safety ties attaching it to the building.

But, Gillette reports, late today a New York City building commissioner told reporters that the crane had been inspected yesterday and it was considered safe...

[alphaa10-2009]

Yo! Copy Link Editor! Your photo spread features a story about a gas explosion on July 10, 2006-- not a crane collapse on March 15, 2008.

[magoo2u1]

"One positive thing about litigation is that it makes negligence very expensive when one is in the construction business....as it should. It the end it prevents unnecessary deaths."
Sorry Charlie, many states have passed laws limiting the liablitiy for a company when it kills people even if they knowingly violate the law. NC and SC are the worst I know of in this regard. You can kill 24 people and disable 56 more in a chicken plant here by padlocking emergency exits at minimal cost and only 4 years in jail. In SC workers comp pays each family 15000 per dead body and the family can''t sue for a dime. So before everyone jumps on the "people are gonna sue everything that moves and that''s whats wrong with America" band wagon, you better check the law in that state. We make a lot of assumptions when something like this happens and we really are clueless about the real penalties.

[stn_sage]

It sounds like there''s some severe cost and safety cuts happening that may be the cause of this accident.

City inspectors need to be a little tougher on some of these things. Swinging buckets of concrete over moving traffic doesn''t sound very safe to me.

I''m glad I don''t live in NYC, I wish the residents luck in avoiding some of these dangers, though! :)

[cbsblogger]

The people that live there are the elite.....sadly the construction workers who work there are not considered elite. There was a mistake made and it was likely in cutting corners or procedures.

One positive thing about litigation is that it makes negligence very expensive when one is in the construction business....as it should. It the end it prevents unnecessary deaths.

[xraytwonine]

there are more and more sky-scrapers in low-rise neighbourhoods in NYC, which is normal, but accident rates are also rising fast; a worker fell to his death just last month on Varrick St.''s Trump Condo/hotel...

[zootallures2]

Don''t forget to use the word pulverize.

[dbstevens]

You would think that after the similar crane disaster in Times Square several years ago, they would be incredibly strict about safety for these things. This is ridiculous.

[pete_in_az]

guess thats what happens when you name your establishment ''fubar''