Congress Debates Use Of "Downer" Cows

Agriculture Secretary Argues Not All Cattle That Are Unable To Walk Are Unsafe To Eat

(AP)  The agriculture secretary on Thursday resisted calls from Democratic senators for a complete ban on so-called downer cattle - those unable to walk - from entering the food supply.

In the wake of the largest beef recall in U.S. history, Agriculture Secretary Edward T. Schafer announced new steps to ensure the safety of the country's meat supply, including more random inspections of slaughterhouses and immediate audits of the 23 plants that supply meat for federal programs, primarily school lunches.

But Schafer contended downer cattle could occasionally enter the food supply safely, in accordance with USDA rules, after an additional inspection by a veterinarian.

"The rules say if one goes down you call the veterinarian to make a judgment," Schafer told a Senate hearing. "Today I'm convinced the rules in place are such where we are protecting the supply," he said.

Schafer ran into resistance from Sen. Herb Kohl, D-Wis., chairman of the Senate Appropriations agriculture subcommittee.

"We cannot allow a single downer cow to enter our food supply under any circumstances," Kohl insisted in his opening statement. He also urged Schafer to install cameras in slaughterhouses.

It was Schafer's first Capitol Hill appearance since the release in late January of video - shot by the Humane Society of the United States - showing workers at Westland/Hallmark Meat Co. in Chino, Calif., shoving and kicking sick, crippled cattle, forcing them to stand by using electric prods, forklifts and water hoses.

In response, the Agriculture Department shut down the plant and has since ordered the recall of 143 million pounds of the company's beef - the largest recall in U.S. history - because the company broke rules preventing the downer cattle from entering the food supply.

Downers, those too sick or injured to walk, pose a higher risk of E. coli, salmonella contamination, or mad cow disease since they typically wallow in feces and their immune systems are often weak.

Westland/Hallmark was a major supplier to federal school lunch programs.

Schafer insisted his agency is taking the problem seriously and will investigate fully. He tangled with Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, about whether there was actually a safety risk from the recalled beef.

Schafer contended that not all the cattle shown on the Humane Society video ended up passing veterinarian inspections and getting slaughtered. He said others had already passed inspections, and while Westland violated USDA rules by not calling a veterinarian back after the cows fell down again, there was minimal safety risk.

"It is extremely unlikely that the mishandled animals pose a risk to human health," said Schafer.

"If you are there saying absolutely that meat was OK for everyone to eat, then why was it recalled?" Harkin asked. "As I understand it there was not a veterinarian called in to inspect these cattle afterward, so we don't know" whether they were sick or not.

Harkin condemned the USDA rules relying on slaughterhouse officials to call a veterinarian back if a cow falls down after already passing its inspection.

"I think that's a very poor requirement," Harkin said. "Talk about the fox guarding the hen house. This is a classic case of it." After the hearing Kohl said he would consider pursuing legislation to change that rule and enforce a 100 percent ban on downer cattle.

Schafer's testimony came a day after the Humane Society sued USDA over the rule, calling it a loophole.

In 2004, the USDA tightened regulations to prohibit the slaughter of all downer cows after a case of mad cow disease was discovered in Washington state. The agency subsequently decided to allow slaughter of cows that fell down after an initial veterinarian inspection but appeared otherwise healthy and were re-inspected.

Schafer told reporters after the hearing that it was not fair to cattle owners to ban the slaughter of cows that may be perfectly safe to eat and just have a broken leg or hip.

[michellem99-2009]

I have seen this issue on KIRO 7 TV in Seattle WA and it made me sick the way those animals were treated. The humane thing is to put them to sleep and not put meat from them in the food chain. A total ban on dower cows. We demand safe meat not any less just to make a buck. The meat plants yhat do this need to be shut down.

[brianbwb-2009]

"Schafer told reporters after the hearing that it was not fair to cattle owners to ban the slaughter of cows that may be perfectly safe to eat and just have a broken leg or hip."

What he fails to discuss is how it can be determined that a downer cow was simply an injured animal, in light of the insufficient number, and corrupt nature of the meat safety inspectors. The E. coli epidemic is proof that the inspectors are not doing their jobs, but this corruption supporter wants to posit that we ignore the dangers because of the potential lost profit.

[brianbwb-2009]

Two articles in today''s news use the word "fairness", Bush says it is not fair that telecoms be held liable for violating the privacy rights of the users, and this clown saying it is not "fair" that meat companies be held liable for introducing tainted meat into the food supply.

Is this the new neocon strategy, whining about "unfairness" after thirty plus years of profiteering earned not through merit, but through unfair corruption and collusion?

[stephanienym]

I%u2019m so disgusted by this tape that I just can%u2019t eat meat anymore, I can%u2019t stomach it%u2026
This is all about special interest groups in Washington%u2026MONEY, MONEY, MONEY

[grammawhamma]

If a cow is down due to an injury and not an illness there is no reason why it can''t be used for food. Cows that are too "ill" to stand should not be used for food.

[brianbwb-2009]

Posted by GrammaWhamma

But do you trust a proven-corrupt meat packing industry to make that determination by themselves without checks and balances?

[greeneyes222]

I see the agriculture secretary is no better than the heads of other government agencies. Cater to the good for business crowd, and ignore the well-being of the people.

Exactly when did the mission of government agencies change from regulation and protection to paid spokesman for various industries?

[ianlou]

Salad anyone?

[jslepian1]

All I hear about is the safety of the food supply ... does anybody care about the cruelty to these animals ? These are sentient beings ... downer cows should not be processed for food because it''s CRUEL, regardless of the safety of the food supply.
There are so many options for people these days ... meat substitutes, free range beef ... there''s no legitimate reason to support this horrible, horrible agribusiness industry by purchasing factory slaughtered beef.

[sgtrds]

"We cannot allow a single downer cow to enter our food supply under any circumstances," Kohl insisted in his opening statement."

Absolutely! We simply can NOT take the chance that the animal is not sick, just for the sake of a tiny extra profit for the slaughter house.

[noregion5]

Educated with cows, raised on a farm for entire life, same kind of cows as in pic, holsteins. We had several cows that would get injured; due to birth, other cows shoving than a fall, or old age(natural causes.) If the cow is a "downer", does not mean they are contaminated food. If they are not subjected to disease, medication or haven''t layed for long period, there is nothing the matter with the inside of the cows meat. When a human breaks a leg, they are not contagious or diseased. The way they are handled should never be accepted if man is causing the downers.

[hbevis]

I%u2019m so disgusted by this tape that I just can%u2019t eat meat anymore, I can%u2019t stomach it%u2026
This is all about special interest groups in Washington%u2026MONEY, MONEY, MONEY

Posted by stephanienym at 01:54 AM : Feb 29, 2008


I agree 100 percent. This does not apply for just beef, but other products as well. We are relying on China for way to many things. Look at the tainted supply of Heparin and the possible people that have died because of it. These big CEO%u2019S in the United States and around the World, for that matter, need to be brought to task for the underhanded dealings that they do to make more and more money.

The people in the United States are paying through the nose for everything that we buy and it seems that no body cares, PEROID.

[emma915]

Excuse me? . ."downer cattle could OCCASIONALLY enter the food supply safely"????? Who in the devil''s own hell is in charge of running this mess? Why are the cows sick in the first place? And why so MANY sick cows? This wasn''t like one cow that was being fork lifted onto trucks to go off to market. It was practically the whole herd!!!! Watching that video was one of the scariest things I''ve ever seen.

[noregion5]

Another point, do you realize how large/heavy a cow of dead weight is? Not defending the fact we should not consume sick animal meat, ever. The humane issue: how do you suggest to move a heavy downed animal? Can''t quite use a stretcher....so it takes machinary to do so. Not being humane is if the person caused injury or illness. If you haven''t walked the walk you have inaccurate talk.

[emma915]

How sneaky to send this meat to schools! That''s one way of getting it past the public buyer''s inspection. I say set this meat aside and sell it to the families of the ranch owners, the men who run the fork lifts and to the families of the inspectors and government officials who approve it for consumption! And, don''t forget to charge them the outrageously high prices we pay for it at the store. If any of it goes to my supermarket, at least label it DOWNER COW MEAT and see how many consumers put it in their baskets.

[callenfallen]

A downer is not always contaminated. The inspection of beef, that Nadar founded in America by the way, should never allow any contaminated beef through. Slaughter house or ware house shouldn''t matter, just unacceptable. If we need more inspectors, well we need more jobs in America! Not all downer cows are caused by illness, if a simple broken leg occurs, you''ll live folks. If cattle are sick, none of that farms meat should be used. It is not hurting a cow to move it with a hi lo, got a better solution?

[displeased]

Another reason I mostly eat only locally grown produce and meat. Too bad not everyone has that option.

[pburro1]

To think we have to treat anything inhumanely- even something in the foodchain is wrong. We can treat all things humanley.

[ianlou]

This should be a no-brainer; if a cow can''t walk into the slaughter house, it should not become food for people.

[missingamerica]

"additional inspection by a veterinarian"?

That fellow''s name going to appear on the packages of processed beef?

And will we be able to sue Edward Shafer if we lose a family member to - oh, say - mad cow disease?

[cyberus-2009]

Another concept .. if downer cows couldn''t be used perhaps they would take more care to prevent them from becoming downers in the first place.

[Syndicate]

This entire thing is a joke. They got caught. Simple as that. They got caught once! Do you think this is a one time thing? they have been doing this for awhile and no one we know of has gotten sick. Downers are in the food supply rather we like it or not. These animals are to valuable to just throw away. So the slaughter houses are going to use them when no one is looking. The only way to stop this is to have each animal inspected prior to slaughter by the FDA.

[tylenol6]

Since congress is not taking care of the american people''s business, I sincerely hope most of congress got to eat some of that meat since this problem should have
been taken care of a long time ago. Congress is a bunch
of loser''s!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hopefully, they will ALL be voted out of office along with the top IDIOT in charge.

[grammawhamma]

Question for hunters: Who inspects that wild deer and rabbit meat you feed your family?

[hungry1968]

No thanks. I don''t eat road kill, carcasses covered with maggots, or drink from bacteria filled pools.

If you want to eat them, feel free. Just make sure that none of it makes it to my plate.

[hungry1968]

Another concept .. if downer cows couldn''''t be used perhaps they would take more care to prevent them from becoming downers in the first place.

Posted by cyberus at 02:45 PM : Feb 29, 2008





Alter their DNA before birth?

[hungry1968]

No-Brainer = in nature, the Lion first eats the slowest, sickest member of the heard...pass the A-1!

Posted by DaVicar2 at 03:29 PM : Feb 29, 2008





But they won''t eat a disease ridden carcass. I don''t have a problem with selling these cows to zoos so that they can feed the lions.

That sounds like a win / win to me.

[ixoye_02]

Why not prepare specially packaged beef products made from downed cattle and send that to the Agriculture secretary''s family for consumption? And let''s see how fast this person will retract the comment that not all downed or "downer" cattle are unsafe to eat. I am all for eating healthy, moving cattle. I don''t think many of us would voluntarily select cattle who cannot stand as food.

[michellem99-2009]

They are living things and should get the care but if ill keep them out of the food chail.