FDA Warns Of Botox Death Risk

Anti-Wrinkle Drug Linked To Kids' Deaths In Rare Cases Where Toxin Spread Through Body

(CBS/AP)  The popular anti-wrinkle drug Botox and a competitor have been linked to dangerous botulism symptoms in some users, cases so bad that a few children given the drugs for muscle spasms have died, the U.S. government warned Friday.

The Food and Drug Administration's warning includes both Botox, a wrinkle-specific version called Botox Cosmetic, and its competitor, Myobloc, drugs that all use botulinum toxin to block nerve impulses, causing them to relax.

In rare cases, the toxin can spread beyond the injection site to other parts of the body, paralyzing or weakening the muscles used for breathing and swallowing, a potentially fatal side effect, the FDA said.

Botox is best known for minimizing wrinkles by paralyzing facial muscles - but botulinum toxin also is widely used for a variety of muscle-spasm conditions, such as cervical dystonia or severe neck spasms.

The FDA said the deaths it is investigating so far all involve children, mostly cerebral palsy patients being treated for spasticity in their legs. The FDA has never formally approved that use for the drugs, but some other countries have.

However, the FDA warned that it also is probing reports of illnesses in people of all ages who used the drugs for a variety of conditions, including at least one hospitalization of a woman given Botox for forehead wrinkles.

The FDA would not say exactly how many reports it is probing.

"We're not talking hundreds. It's a relative handful," said Dr. Russell Katz, FDA's neurology chief.

But the agency warned that patients receiving a botulinum toxin injection for any reason - cosmetic or medical - should be told to seek immediate care if they suffer symptoms of botulism, including: difficulty swallowing or breathing, slurred speech, muscle weakness, or difficulty holding up their head.

"I think people should be aware there's a potential for this to happen," Katz said. "People should be on the lookout for it."

Friday's warning came two weeks after the consumer advocacy group Public Citizen petitioned the FDA to strengthen warnings to users of Botox and Myobloc - citing 180 reports of U.S. patients suffering fluid in the lungs, difficulty swallowing or pneumonia, including 16 deaths.

Nor is it the first warning. The drugs' labels do warn about the potential for botulinum toxin to spread beyond the injection site and occasionally kill, but the warnings link that side effect to patients with certain neuromuscular diseases, such as myasthenia gravis.

That's what's different about these latest cases, said FDA's Katz: The botulism toxin seems to be harming people who don't have that particular risk factor. (Cerebral palsy involves a brain injury, not a disease.)

Still, the FDA cautioned that its investigation is in the early stages. It has asked Botox maker Allergan Inc. and Myobloc maker Solstice Neurosciences Inc. to provide additional safety records.

Allergan spokeswoman Caroline Van Hove said children with cerebral palsy receive far larger doses injected into their leg muscles than the doses given adults seeking wrinkle care.

In a statement, Solstice said it supports FDA's probe but stressed that the agency hasn't concluded the drug poses any new risk.

While the FDA said the problems may be related to overdoses, it also has reports of side effects with a variety of doses.

Public Citizen's Dr. Sidney Wolfe criticized FDA's warning as falling short. He asked that the agency order a black-box warning, the FDA's strongest type, be put on the drugs' labels and require that every patient receive a pamphlet outlining the risk before each injection.

"Every doctor needs to notified about this, every patient needs to be notified," Wolfe said. "Children are showing the way, unfortunately some dead children."

He said drug regulators in Britain and Germany last year required that sterner warnings be sent to every doctor in those countries.

"What we're saying is, nobody should be dying of Botox, and they wouldn't be dying if the government and the companies were doing a better job warning people," Wolfe said to CBS Early Show co-anchor Maggie Rodriguez.

[runningralph]

At least they will look good at their funeral. Like a lady friend told me years ago,"It doesn''t matter what you do as long as you look good doing it".

[arowmorg4]

I am surprised vary much at how surprised the F.D.A. was that botox is deadly. right now at my school I am writeing an essay on biological warfare,and I came across some information saying that BOTULINUM TOXIN aka botox is the most deadleast bio weapon because it is so leathal, easy to manufacture, and easiest to weaponize so I think that these facts should have been told to patients and they or the doctors would not have messed up. here is the site http://www.emedicinehealth.com/biological_warfare/page5_em.htm

[alphaa10-2009]

Botox has been a menace ever since it became a fashion accessory to men and women worried about wrinkles.

Public Citizen is right on the money, so to speak, with this warning to the FDA-- "Put the black box warning on the product!"

What kind of thinking ignores the obvious dangers of using one of the world''s deadliest poisons? Not even a black box warning, for fear of losing sales?

Botox as well as curare and other poisons have their uses in responsible medical therapy, but botox parties-- often physician/clinic sponsored-- must go.
Even if it hurts business.

[shanev137]

The FDA rolls up under The Department of Health and Human Services....which rolls up under who?

That''s right, you guessed it....Bush the Butcher.

But hey, feel all warm and fuzzy about people dying at the hands of the FDA....because you voted for him, not once, but twice.

[excoachken]

I never quite understood why infecting yourself with botulism in order to have your face resemble an eggshell was an option for intelligent people, anyway. If you have a new wrinkle, get over it, you,like the rest of the human race, really are getting OLDER!

[drivelphobe]

Individuals who have such defective thoughts and needs as to go to Botox and other such ridiculous measures to change their appearance, have serious problems. All pharmaceuticals have adverse side effects and it''s obvious that these insecure, self-absorbed solipsists are entitled to the consequences of their decisions. I say give them all the Botox they want, and maybe a little extra for insurance.

[xlib]

queen nance and kerry better be careful.

[xlib]

shanev137-so botox just started being used as of 1/20/01?? Is that a fact?? So now, this is Bush''s fault?? So when crappy things happened like,oh say, Waco, that was whose fault??? So when the USS Cole was attacked, whose fault was that? Do you know just how stupid you sound??

[shanev137]

Xlib, you''re probably the only Bush lover left on here. They''re easy to spot because they always blame Clinton for everything that''s gone on in the last 8 years.

By the way, last time I checked, Clinton didn''t run the FDA into the ground the way Bush has. It''s barely safe anymore to eat food you buy at the grocery store.

[ontheleft]

People will do anything to look younger, even if it means risking their lives to do it.

What a surprise! Our FDA which approve this toxic substance is now telling us it can harm us. Just like a bad drug that makes 10 of billions of dollars then it is taken off the market. Refunds do not apply. Corruption at the highest level of health care. Big Pharma marchs on with sky high profits. The FDA needs a massive shake up.

[mdmitchell67]

I am glad that everyone feels so free to comment on all the self-absorbed, egotistical, appearance conscious people who "deserve" to suffer the consequences of using botox! How ignorant you sound. You have completely failed to put yourselves in the shoes of people who have been told by their doctors that botox is the best chance that their child with cerebral palsy will ever walk independently. This is not something that we parents choose to pursue because of vanity. Frankly, none of us want to have to make that decision at all. I did months and months of research regarding botox before deciding that my child might benefit from it. And guess what?? Just two weeks after the injections (from which she suffered absolutely no negative effects), my 3 1/2 year old finally was able to take her first steps. While this new information scares me, and I plan to research much more before I would consider doing it again, I wish people would not be so judgemental about things like botox, shooting their mouths off, when they don''t understand what they are talking about. You don''t know the whole story.

[excoachken]

To mdmitchell67: Since the rest of us are so"judgmental" and ignorant, please inform us on the % of Botox used in the treatment of Cerebral Palsy as compared to that used for cosmetic purposes and simple vanity. If that used for c.p. is over 10% of the total, you have my humble apology for somehow offending you because I was critical of those who just want wrinkles to go away. But, regardless, since nobody complained about it''s legitimate medical use, why are you so defensive? Again, p[lease tell us what the percentages are?

[mdmitchell67]

To exCoachKen,
I do not know the percentage of cases where botox is used for non-cosmetic purposes. That was not part of my research as I was not considering any cosmetic issues, only medical ones. I wonder why 10% was your magic number for issuing an apology. Would you feel any different if it were only 1%? In any case, my concern is that if people can only focus on botox as a cosmetic drug, they will feel free to push the FDA to take it off the market, assuming that only the vain will suffer its loss. Without getting into a political argument (which this issue seems to also be bringing out in these discussions...), I must also say I have concerns with how the FDA makes its decisions, and how easily it might be swayed by public opinion (and, as I have seen here, public opinion is often formed by misconceptions). As we all know, if aspirin were a new drug today, the FDA would never approve it. I am feeling defensive because I fear that a drug that has worked miracles for many children might be banned because of misinformed people.

[underdogus]

_______
_______)~~----gun control
`/
-

[garbosmed]

FDA gives a warning about botox after it affects 180 people total in the whole country. But what about the girls and young women who''ve died from the Gardasil vaccine? Why not put out a warning about that? Or the many many many children who have been vaccine injured and are in the CDC VAERS database? Nope, nothing to see there, just move along. Hello, FDA? WAKE UP!!!

[gce65]

Are you kidding? THIS IS NATURAL SELECTION IN A BOTTLE!

[xlib]

shnev137-I''m not a Bush lover. I just like to point out insanity when I see it. I find it increasinly interesting how bubba got away with everything and anything and the loony left blames Bush for the darndest things. As for Bush "running the FDA into the ground", cite your source. Prove it. I gather from your last paranoid sentence that you grow your own food??
Try taping into reality and you will see that clinton was far from the saint you leemings make him out to be. After all, he is close friends with the chi coms taking millions upon millions and did give us nafta.

[xlib]

shanev-I forgot to mention Waco and the Elian Gonzalez debacle. Still say queen nance better be careful.

[deb82]

I have a traumatic brain injury and have been receiving botox since 2002 for spasticity. I had it to help me walk again. Then in 2005 I hit my head again and I''m back on my walker. I started botox again, however this time around it weakened my entire body and I was choking and have a hard time breathing.
My physiatrist didn''t know anything about this. But after researching my case he found out that it happens but it''s rare. Not sure why it''s all of a sudden happening after so many successful injections. It''s used for several other medical reasons not only cosmetic.

What a surprise! Our FDA which approve this toxic substance is now telling us it can harm us. Just like a bad drug that makes 10 of billions of dollars then it is taken off the market. Refunds do not apply. Corruption at the highest level of health care. Big Pharma marchs on with sky high profits. The FDA needs a massive shake up.

[trevormom]

I usually don''t get involved in any type of "chat"... but I do have to say that this touches very close to home and I feel I need to have a say.

I am with mdmitchell67.... I to had done a lot of research regarding botox injections and no, not for the wrinkles that life so nicely adds to our aging process, but for our 8 yr old son Trevor.... he has CP and thanks to botox injections he can now sit at a 90% angle (like most typical people) and can walk using his a walker standing almost fully straight up and down as apposed to having such tight ham strings he was always bent at the knees and had much more diffuclty with his gate. He has had botox injections every 3-4 months for the past 2 years. We had done the research and found after speaking with several md''s; that like any/all medications there are risks involved. (Have you ever read the insert to any of the medication you are perscribed...makes me just want to swallow that pill... anyone one would run scared if they read all the "possible side effects"...... )the dosage needs to be monitored and administered correctly....

Will these article make us stand up and take a better look after each injection and keep a better eye on the possible side effects.... absolutely...

Will it make us stop having our son treated with botox... I don''t really think so.... it really depends on how much you trust your Dr. and we would have to weigh the consequences of NOT having the treatments...